Professional Documents
Culture Documents
352,, .
$PPRQLD6\QWKHVLV3ODQW
&DVHERRN
May 2014
All rights reserved. No part of this documentation shall be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or
transmitted by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without the
prior written permission of Invensys Systems, Inc. No copyright or patent liability is assumed with
respect to the use of the information contained herein. Although every precaution has been taken in the
preparation of this documentation, the publisher and the author assume no responsibility for errors or
omissions. Neither is any liability assumed for damages resulting from the use of the information
contained herein.
The information in this documentation is subject to change without notice and does not represent a
commitment on the part of Invensys Systems, Inc. The software described in this documentation is
furnished under a license or nondisclosure agreement. This software may be used or copied only in
accordance with the terms of these agreements.
For comments or suggestions about the product documentation, send an e-mail message to
ProductDocumentationComments@invensys.com.
All terms mentioned in this documentation that are known to be trademarks or service marks have been
appropriately capitalized. Invensys Systems, Inc. cannot attest to the accuracy of this
information. Use of a term in this documentation should not be regarded as affecting the validity of any
trademark or service mark. Invensys, Invensys logo, PRO/II, and SimSci are trademarks of Invensys
plc, its subsidiaries and affiliates.
Case 2:
Ammonia Synthesis Plant
Abstract
Over 140 million tons of ammonia is produced worldwide each
year. The rewards for reducing costs, increasing efficiency and
improving the profitability of ammonia plants are enormous.
Computer simulation of the plant is the first step towards
identifying which parameters control the conversion rate, product
purity, energy usage, and the production rate of an existing facility.
This casebook demonstrates the use of PRO/II in the simulation of
an ammonia synthesis process. The entire plant is modeled, from
the reforming of the hydrocarbon feedstream to synthesis gas
through its purification to its conversion to ammonia in a synthesis
reactor. This casebook also outlines the use of the simulation for
parametric studies in the evolution of a control strategy.
The ammonia synthesis loop involves a large recycle compared to
the feed and product rates. In addition there are several thermal
recycles and two control loops. Special thermodynamics are used to
ensure the accurate prediction of the separation of ammonia from
the other materials.
Introduction
Chemically combined nitrogen is essential for the growth of all
living organisms. Animals and plants (with one or two exceptions)
are unable to assimilate free nitrogen from the air, so they depend
upon nitrates, ammonium salts or other nitrogen compounds found
in the soil.
The natural supplies of fixed nitrogen were adequate for many
centuries to satisfy the normal processes of nature. However, by the
Process Overview
The Kellogg Ammonia process is a single train process, divisible
into four stages, which operate sequentially. In stage 1 the natural
gas undergoes catalytic reforming to produce hydrogen from
methane and steam. The nitrogen required for the ammonia is
introduced at this stage. In stage 2, the resulting syngas is purified
by the removal of carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide in a MEA
plant or similar process. Stage 3 consists of compression of the
syngas up to the pressure required in stage 4, the ammonia loop.
Products
The main product of an ammonia plant is, of course, ammonia. The
ammonia product stream must have a purity greater than 99.5%.
The major impurities are hydrogen, nitrogen, argon and methane.
The other product streams are:
letdown gas from the final separator consisting of
approximately 45% ammonia, 30% hydrogen with the rest
being nitrogen, argon and methane
purge gas from the ammonia loop consisting of approximately
8% ammonia, 57% hydrogen plus nitrogen, argon and methane
Ammonia is recovered from the letdown and purge gases in an
absorber.
Detailed descriptions of the product streams may be found at the
end of the Simulation section in Table 2-5.
Stage 3: Compression
Figure 2-3: Schematic of Compression Section
In the Reformer
The primary reformer passes the natural gas and steam mixture
through catalyst-packed tubes in a furnace. The furnace exhaust
gases are used to generate steam in a series of boilers. This steam is
then used to drive the compressors.
The effluent from the secondary reformer is used in a waste heat
boiler and then to preheat the feed to the desulfurizer.
In the Conversion
The products from the ammonia converter are mixed with the
synthesis gas from the compressors and cooled for ammonia
separation by exchange with the converter feed. The converter feed
is preheated by the products inside the converter vessel.
Material Recycle
The final stage, the Synthesis Loop, is a recycle operation. The
conversion of nitrogen and hydrogen to ammonia in the converter is
very low - less than 30% of the hydrogen is converted per pass.
Therefore there has to be a large recycle in order to convert all the
feed and ensure that the final ammonia product reaches the required
purity.
The ratio of recycle to ammonia product is of the order of 3:1
General Data
Because stage 4 of this process involves a loop which has a large
recycle rate in comparison to the product rates, it is essential that
the flowsheet is in mass balance. The normal stream component
recycle convergence tolerance must therefore be tightened - in this
case to 0.05%. The stream Temperature and Pressure recycle
tolerances were also tightened to 0.1 and 0.001 respectively. The
Wegstein acceleration option is used to help speed up convergence.
The graphic below shows the data entry window for the recycle
convergence and acceleration options. .
Thermodynamic Data
For most of the units in the flowsheet the Soave-Redlich-Kwong
(SRK) equation of state is an excellent predictor of phase
equilibrium and thermal properties. However, in stage 4 where the
ammonia is being separated from the recycle gas in flash units, a
more accurate prediction is needed to represent the interaction
between ammonia and the other components in the streams. For
this, a second method is used with user-defined SRK binary
interaction parameters. Figure 2-5 illustrates the Data Entry
Window.
Figure 2-5: Entering Binary Interaction Data
The data used in this case study is defined in Table 2-3 below.
Recycle Streams
There is a recycle stream in stage 4. The large flowrate of this
recycle stream relative to the flowsheet feeds and products along
with the fact that the ammonia species is created in the recycle,
necessitates an initial estimate of the rate and composition of the
recycle stream. The stream initial estimates are entered into stream
31R below:
This means that stream 38B takes its composition and rate at all
times from stream 38 but its temperature and pressure are calculated
by the heat exchanger from which it is a product.
Results
The compressor work for the three stages is 1752, 1831 and 1776
HP respectively. The corresponding aftercooler duties are 4.73, 4.70
and 4.35 MM Btu/hr.
Most of the water is removed after the first compressor with a small
amount removed after the second compressor. The final separator
removes all remaining water from the synthesis loop feed.
Input
The fourth compressor (CP-4) is in the ammonia recycle loop. The
loop starts at that unit, stream 31R being the main recycle stream.
An initial estimate for this stream is needed, as discussed in the
Stream Data Section above.
The Ammonia Converter feed is preheated by exchanging inside the
converter with its product stream. This exchanger is modeled
separately in the flowsheet as FDEF. The exchangers before the
separators do not appear on the simulation flowsheet as they are
combined with the separators.
There are two thermal recycles in the loop. The loop involving the
convertor and feed preheater is split by referencing the convertor
feed (stream 38B) to the product from exchanger X-4 (stream 38) in
the Stream Data Section. FDEF is then solved after the convertor
when both feed streams have been calculated.
The loop involving exchanger X-4 is solved explicitly as it appears
in the flowsheet. This involves introducing an inner loop within the
ammonia recycle loop. This loop could also be eliminated by using
the devices mentioned above.
The chart below was taken from the PRO/II output file. This depicts
the overall plant mass balance as calculated by PRO/II:
Table 2-5: Product Stream Summary t
Overall Plant Mass
Balance lb/hr lb/hr
Component Feed +Reaction -Product =Deviation % dev
The chart below was taken from the PRO/II output file. This depicts
the summary of RX-7,7, the ammonia converter.
6 n2 1 787.0843 0.2737
Reactor Mass Balance Fraction
Converted
Rates, lb_mole/hr
2 o2 1.96663E-07 0.0000 1.96663E-07
3 co 2.91756E-04 0.0000 2.91756E-04
4 co2 4.25713E-06 0.0000 4.25713E-06
5 h2 17167.3105 -4760.0030 12407.3075 0.2773
6 n2 80546.5254 -22048.9708 58497.5546 0.2737
7 a 28892.6554 0.0000 28892.6554
8 c1 14311.1818 0.0000 14311.1818
9 c2 0.0372 0.0000 0.0372
10 c3 5.35374E-07 0.0000 5.35374E-07
11 nc4 2.69157E-07 0.0000 2.69157E-07
12 nc5 2.18500E-07 0.0000 2.18500E-07
13 nh3 8941.8560 26808.9734 35750.8294
Component Rates
Stream ID nat gas 5 7 3IP 39 40
Description nat gas steam air purge LetDwn NH3Prod
Phase vapor vapor vapor vapor vapor liquid
Temperature, F 60.00 950.00 330.00 85.00 79.42 79.42
Pressure, psig 340.00 334.00 289.00 4660.00 350.00 350.00
Molecular Wt. 20.30 18.02 28.96 12.03 14.70 17.00