Professional Documents
Culture Documents
NEWSLETTER
OF THE
MADISON
AUDUBON
SOCIETY
JOIN MADISON AUDUBON MADISON AUDUBON SOCIETY THE AUDUBON CAWS is published
A Chapter of National Audubon President: Joanne Herfel, 241-8009 September through July by:
Vice-president: Debra Weitzel, 836-4051 Madison Audubon Society,
Introductory New membership - $20 Goose Pond Resident Naturalists: 222 S. Hamilton St.,
Membership Renewal - $35 Mark and Sue Martin, 635-4160 Madison, WI 53703,
Student/Senior Membership - $15 Editor: Abbie Kurtz, 245-1758 (608) 255-BIRD (2473).
Foreign - Add $10 in US funds abbiejkurtz@yahoo.com Birding hotline, 255-BIRM
Graphic design: Paul Capobianco Madison Audubon Web Page:
Make check payable to Printed by Roemer Printing http://madisonaudubon.org
National Audubon Society E-mail: masoffice@mailbag.com
Mail check to Madison Audubon Society, The mission of the Madison Audubon E-mail services donated by Berbee
222 S. Hamilton St. Suite 1, Society is to educate our members and the Contribution deadline is January 13
Madison, WI 53703 public about the natural world and the for the February issue, for which items
threats that natural systems are facing, to may be sent to Abbie Kurtz, 313
Name engage in advocacy to preserve and protect Moulton Ct., Madison, WI 53704.
Address these systems, and to develop and maintain abbiejkurtz@yahoo.com
City sanctuaries to save and restore natural habi-
State Zip tat.
January 2003 3
WBCI Statewide who should protect them. This report is cared deeply about, but which we have
meant to foster those discussions over also taken for granted - but no longer.
Conference - time at the local and state level among In October, over 700 people came
February 4-5, 2003 citizens, government agencies, nonprof- together at a "Waters of Wisconsin"
by Karen Etter Hale, WBCI Chair it groups, businesses and many other conference, the culmination of a two-
organizations with a stake in these spe- year statewide effort by the Wisconsin
A statewide Wisconsin Bird cial places." Academy of Sciences, Arts and Letters
Conservation Initiative (WBCI) meeting I attended the "unveiling" ceremony that involved hundreds of people in
has been set for Tuesday and November 20, representing Audubon examining the status and sustainability
Wednesday, February 4-5, 2003 at the as well as the Wisconsin Bird of Wisconsin's aquatic ecosystems and
Westwood Center in Wausau. This will Conservation Initiative. It is an impres- resources. The conference brought
be a working meeting that will kick off sive report, loaded with great maps, diverse people together to start laying
development of a State Action Plan for data, and information. Many organiza- the groundwork for "a comprehensive
"all-bird" conservation by focusing on tions, including ours, will be taking a long-term policy for sustaining
identifying Important Bird Areas (IBAs) close look at this tremendous resource Wisconsin's waters." As Luna Leopold,
in Wisconsin's major habitats: wetlands to see how it fits in with our land one of Aldo Leopold's sons, states
and shorelines; forests and barrens; preservation priorities, and how we "Water is the most critical resource
prairies, savannas, and agricultural might help protect some of the "Legacy issue of our lifetime and our children's
lands; and urban habitats. Places" described in the study. lifetimes. The health of our waters is the
WBCI has been progressing rapidly I encourage anyone who is interested principal measure of how we live on
on several fronts as all ten committees in commenting on the draft report to the land."
(Research and Monitoring, Habitat obtain a copy. It is available in two for- We were asked to consider many
Assessment and Management along mats: black-and-white hard copy and questions: Can you imagine
with 4 habitat subcommittees, compact disk (CD). The report has Wisconsin's waters in the year 2075?
Outreach, Issues, IBAs, and Bird-related many full-color maps and figures, How healthy will our aquatic ecosys-
Recreation) are now up and running. which are more difficult to interpret in tems be? Are our water policies ade-
Since August, we have also had a full- black-and-white. The CD has all the quate to meet the needs of the future?
time coordinator, Andy Paulios, on maps and figures in color. Given the What is the current status of our
board, working through WDNR. size of the report (approximately 230 waters? Do our decisions and policies
This will be an excellent chance for pages, 11"x17"), it will be much less recognize the value of our waters for
the 108 WBCI partners, and others who expensive for WDNR to send you a CD, both humans and the diversity of
care about birds, to come together to plus the final report will be published native species, communities and land-
work on enhancing Wisconsin's bird in color. If you are interested, you can scapes they support? Is there equitable
life. For more information, contact request a copy (be sure to specify CD or access to water? What do we need to do
Karen Etter Hale, black-and-white hard copy) via e-mail to make sure our waters are sustain-
masoffice@mailbag.com, or (Land.Legacy@dnr.state.wi.us), phone able? Another intriguing question was
608/255-BIRD. (608/266-0823), or letter (Land Legacy - whether we know what our "water-
LF/4, WI Dept. of Natural Resources, shed" address is.
PO Box 7921, Madison, WI 53707- The year 2002 marked the 30th
Wisconsin Land Legacy 7921). anniversary of the Clean Water Act.
Report Draft Unveiled The deadline for sending comments The year 2003 has been proclaimed the
by Karen Etter Hale, to WDNR is January 24, 2003. Specific "Year of Water" in Wisconsin and the
Executive Secretary questions can be directed to John "International Year of Freshwater" by
Pohlman, WDNR, 608/264-6263 or the United Nations. Not only will there
The Wisconsin DNR (WDNR) has John.Pohlman@dnr.state.wi.us be many efforts over the next year to
completed a draft of the Wisconsin preserve and protect Wisconsin's
Land Legacy Report, which identifies Wisconsin - Land of Waters waters, but there will be numerous
228 "Legacy Places." These are the spe- by Karen Etter Hale, events held to, in the words of the
cial lands and waters, identified over Executive Secretary Academy, "celebrate, through art, poet-
the past three years with extensive ry, and music, the importance and
input from the public and WDNR staff, Wisconsin is blessed by an abun- beauty of water in our lives, to remind
that make Wisconsin "Wisconsin." dance of water: we sit at the headwa- ourselves why this precious and endan-
These are the places that will be critical ters of both the Mississippi River and gered resource must be protected - now
in meeting Wisconsin's conservation the Great Lakes systems, we have over and in the future."
and recreation needs over the next 50 15,000 lakes, 12,600 rivers and streams What will you be doing for
years. Steve Miller, WDNR Land totaling 44,000 miles, 5.3 million acres Wisconsin's waters in the coming year?
Division Administrator, writes "While of wetlands, and an estimate 2
the report describes each place in detail, quadrillion gallons of groundwater.
it does not identify how or when These are resources we have always
Legacy Places should be protected or
4 The Audubon Caws
Population & Habitat enced for the last 65 million years," how many pieces we can remove until
reported Dr Peter Raven, Director of it collapses.
Living in the the Missouri Botanical Gardens. We The current rate of species extinction
Sixth Extinction find ourselves living in a sixth extinc- is so fast that turning a few hundred
Reprinted with permission tion period. acres into conservation reserves will not
from Population Press, vol. 8 #4, This Sixth Extinction is being caused solve the problem, important as those
October 2002 by the activities of a single species: reserves are. To avoid bringing our
Humans. Human overpopulation and entire house down, we have to stop
What does it mean to be living in the overconsumption are the culprits of this burning the boards. While we huddle
sixth extinction? Over the last two gen- current catastrophe. We are cutting around the fire, this reasoning may
erations, America has lost 50% of its down the temperate and tropical forests seem illogical. But tearing down our
wetlands, 85% of its old growth forests, faster than they can regenerate. We are walls can in no way be considered sus-
and 99% of its prairie. That means there releasing carbon dioxide and other tainable. We must remember, it is the
were landscapes and animals my greenhouse gasses into the atmosphere, house that protects us.
grandparents saw that my parents causing a rise in global temperatures, Extinction is forever. Biodiversity is
could not, ones that my parents saw melting of the polar ice caps, and pro- not a house we can rebuild. However, if
that I cannot, and ones that I have seen found changes in the climate. With we act quickly to stem the future dam-
that my son will not. What do I tell my human population still growing, along age of this extinction period, then we
son about the world he inherits? I can with demand for water, food and will give our children a chance to sur-
tell him there were once sparrows that goods, we are destroying more and vive it, and the world a chance to heal.
sang in London's Hyde Park, but now more habitats vital for other species, as The most important and most difficult
the park is quiet. I can tell him there well as overfarming and overgrazing tasks will be to stop population growth
were once frogs croaking in the moun- once fertile land into wasteland. and unsustainable use of natural
tains above our house, but now they are Species we thought were not threat- resources.
gone forever. I am saddened to have to ened are disappearing at alarming We must realize that for all our tech-
tell him that his world is ecologically rates. For example, just this year, sever- nological prowess, humans rely upon
poorer than it was for me, my parents, al species of sparrows that populated the house we call Earth to survive. We
my grandparents. towns and the countryside of Great need specific environmental conditions
Life on Earth has ebbed and flowed Britain have nearly vanished. Residents to survive, and if we destroy those con-
throughout the history of our planet. of London didn't realize the birds were ditions, we will go the way of the
Mostly life has flourished over the last in trouble until people started noticing dinosaurs. Extinction periods only
500 million years in fantastic diversity that Hyde Park was silent of bird songs. end when the cataclysm causing the
and profusion. However, there have North Atlantic fishing industries have damage is gone. We are the cataclysm.
also been times of great destruction, collapsed in recent years, as once plenti- As Virginia Morell of National
what are called Extinction Periods, ful cod and wild salmon are nearly Geographic points out, "the sixth
when large portions of life have died. gone. The North Atlantic bottlenose extinction is not inevitable. If humans
There have been five such periods in dolphin and the Atlantic Pilot Whale are the cause, they can also be the solu-
the history of Earth, and each was are also near extinction. Wild pandas tion."
caused by catastrophic events that dis- are barely hanging on. All great cat
rupted the fragile balance of the global species are either threatened or endan-
ecosystem -- an asteroid collision or gered. Amphibian populations around
massive volcanic activity. Extinction the world in a state of total collapse.
Periods are marked by sharp declines The list goes on and on.
in oxygen-producing plants, such as Why should we care about sparrows,
trees in tropical and temperate forests, dolphins and lions, much less lowly
and ocean-based phytoplanktons and plants and phytoplankton? Mohamed
kelp. They are also marked by the El-Ashry, the CEO of the U.N. Global
death of large percentages of animals Environment Facility, describes biodi-
living in various ecosystems. versity as being like a wooden house
Scientists have recently had a star- we live in. We have been pulling pieces
Courtesy of U.S. Fish & Wildlife
tling revelation about the state of our out here and there and burning them to
world today. Over the last century, the stay comfortable. We can continue this
biodiversity of the entire planet has for some time without a noticeable
decreased by 20% in the oceans and change, but gradually the cold seeps in
15% on the land. Rain forests have and we need more wood to maintain
decreased in size by 85% and temperate our comfort level. However, we do not
forests by 80%. "We are confronting an fully understand the design of the
episode of species extinction greater house, so we may one day remove a The California Condor is one of the most
piece that brings the whole structure famous birds listed on the U.S. Fish &
than anything the world has experi-
down on our heads. We don't know Wildlife Service’s Endangered Species List.
January 2003 5
Photo by Mark Martin
Ethanol Plant
Threat Loses Steam:
Proposal Tabled
Indefinitely
by Marsha Cannon
Photo shows
On December 9, 2002 the Arlington the Jackson
Village Board took no action on the vil- Family. The
lage Plan Commission's unanimous ethanol plant
recommendation to "indefinitely table was proposed
the application by United Wisconsin to be in line
Grain Producers (UWGP) to locate an with the water
ethanol plant in the village industrial tower, half way
between the
park until such time as UWGP obtains
water tower and
all state and federal permits to operate Goose Pond.
on the proposed site." This leaves the
application tabled indefinitely at the both Arlington and Madison Audubon. public records, learning about ethanol
Plan Commission level. Village residents and elected officials production and its effects, attending
Thus, after more than seven months became polarized during the debate, meetings of the Plan Commission,
of legal wrangling, the ethanol plant and the wounds will take time to heal. meetings of the Village Board, meetings
conditional use permit application The MAS Board committed immedi- with UWGP representatives and con-
review process initiated on April 22, ately to protecting Goose Pond, and we sulting with our legal team at Solheim,
2002 came to a quiet but very happy are proud to have staved off a plant Billing and Grimmer. Special thanks go
ending. that would change forever the neigh- to Attorneys Jeanette Lytle and David
boring community and our sanctuary. Billing for orchestrating Madison
A costly lesson Madison Audubon's cost for open Audubon's strategy.
Unfortunately, the ethanol plant records requests, copying complex doc-
debate proved to be a costly lesson for uments, assembling a team of expert New developments
witnesses and documenting their testi- Recently Margaret Ruesch of
mony, and a myriad of other legal ser- MeggPro Solutions, LLC of Sun Prairie
What you can do! vices amounts to over $60,000. applied for a permit to operate a metal
Contribute to the In spite of the cost, by becoming recycling facility in the old DelMonte
MAS Legal Defense Fund involved at the beginning of the headquarters building. Another payoff
process, we found a large core of of the ethanol debate is that a more
_____ Yes! I want to help cover legal friends in the village, appear to have knowledgeable Village Board gave the
costs of defeating the Arlington defeated the project, and saved the application fairly close scrutiny, asking
ethanol plant proposal. Here is my even greater expense of fighting the about heavy metal contamination,
donation to ensure expert legal project in court. It is significantly more smelting, dust and traffic aspect of the
advice is available to protect Madison difficult, if not impossible, to overturn operation. MeggPro described the recy-
Audubon wildlife sanctuaries, now municipal action after it has been taken. cling process as a "closed system" using
and in the future. It is unlikely that UWGP will come only 170-degree water.
back to Arlington. Obtaining federal Although the Board failed to seek
Name___________________________ and state permits for an ethanol plant outside expert advice about the pro-
Address_________________________ can cost $150,000 or more. posed MeggPro operation, they did
City__________________State ______ Madison Audubon appreciates that insist on four conditions: (1) no water
Zip_________ Phone______________ Village of Arlington officials came to a discharge except bathroom waste into
logical conclusion and opted to protect the village wastewater treatment plant;
$50______ $100______ $250______ their community. We are grateful to (2) the village will consider other waste-
$500_____ Other_____ residents who formed Concerned water discharge, but requires testing at
Citizens of Arlington to oppose siting the business's expense, to protect the
Please make check payable to the plant within the village limits. We village treatment plant; (3) operations
Madison Audubon Society Legal also wish to thank expert witnesses are limited to metal washing, "densify-
Defense Fund. Mail to: Madison who testified about procedural options ing" (compacting) and briquetting
Audubon Society, 222 S. Hamilton- available to the Village and the effects (forming into small bricks); and (4)
Suite #1, Madison, WI 53703. the plant would have on Goose Pond. MeggPro must pay the cost of profes-
Donations are tax deductible to the MAS board and chapter members sional fees incurred by the Village from
extent provided by law. spent countless hours reading through the date of application through issuing
ed the existing wastewater treatment In Memory of John Smail [ ] Land acquisition at Goose Pond
plant. The remaining land and build- Helen Ranney [ ] MAS Program Support
ings were sold to MR/BK. The village Marilyn & Edward Schten
also established a 200-acre Tax Name
Margaret & Kurt Stege
Incremental Financing (TIF) district, Diana & Thompson Webb Address
including the DelMonte site and adja-
cent farmland. In Memory of Ruth Wynn
Shall we breathe a sigh of relief now In Memory of
Karen & Austin McNey
that the ethanol threat appears to have In Honor of
passed? For awhile. But Madison GIFTS IN HONOR OF A PERSON
Audubon and local residents must In Honor of Carol Liddle For Gifts Honoring Another, send acknowledge-
remain vigilant. Future industrial Margaret Leslie Demuth ment to (name and address)
development could bring air and water In Honor of Nancy Ludwig
pollution as well as increased runoff Harry Ludwig
from roofs and pavement. Goose Pond Susan Pirocanac
resident manager Mark Martin and the In Honor of Mark & Sue Martin Contributions will be acknowledged near the
industrial park owner have begun dis- Arlys Caslavka Madison Audubon Information Board at Goose
cussions about a plan to protect Goose Pond as follows: $1,000 or more-name will appear
Pond from industrial park runoff. Stay on a permanent plaque; $250-$999-name will
tuned! appear on engraved paving brick.
January 2003 7
Madison Audubon Society, Inc. Non-profit organization
Joanne Herfel, President U.S. Postage Paid
222 S. Hamilton St. Suite #1 Permit No. 1831
Madison, WI 53703 Madison, Wisconsin
Timely Topics
See page 1 1/03