Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Contributors of Punching
Forces in Combat Sports
Athletes: Implications for
Strength and Conditioning
Seth Lenetsky, Nigel Harris, PhD, and Matt Brughelli, PhD
Sport Performance Research Institute New Zealand, AUT University, Auckland, New Zealand
ABSTRACT (25). Punching is a complex motion so-called straight rear hand punch,
that involves movement of the arm, also known as the cross.
PUNCHING IS A KEY COMPONENT
trunk, and legs (29), but the lower body
OF STRIKING-BASED COMBAT MEASUREMENT AND ANALYSIS
is considered a primary contributor to
SPORTS. IT HAS BEEN ESTABLISHED OF PUNCHING FORCES
an effective punch (8). Although speed
IN BOXING THAT THE ABILITY TO Punching forces can be measured and
and accuracy are needed for a punch to
APPLY FORCE VIA PUNCHING TO AN be effective (22), several studies have analyzed to provide diagnostic infor-
OPPONENT IS PARAMOUNT TO VIC- shown that punching force is para- mation for programming and prognos-
TORY. AS SUCH, IT BEHOOVES mount to a fighters victory (21,25). tic information for talent identification
STRENGTH AND CONDITIONING Research into punching has focused and team selection. As one of the key
PROFESSIONALS TO IMPROVE THE primarily on observing forces, with indicators of performance, monitoring
PUNCHING FORCE OF COMBAT only one study of note focusing on changes in punching force can be used
SPORTS ATHLETES IN GENERAL. potential training strategies for improv- as a diagnostic tool for the design and
THIS REVIEW EXPLORES CURRENT ing punching force (29). Using research efficacy of strength and conditioning
RESEARCH INTO THE ASSESSMENT interventions. Furthermore, the mea-
into the lower limbs involvement in
OF PUNCHING FORCES AND CON- surement and analysis of punching
punching and other similar move-
TRIBUTORS OF PUNCHING FORCES, forces can be used as a prognostic tool
ments, this review will examine the
for categorizing combat sport athletes
SPECIFICALLY GROUND REACTION assessment of punching forces and will
according to their punching forces for
FORCES. SUCH INFORMATION IS further explore potential strength and
a potential aid in team or program
VITAL FOR ENHANCING THE SCIEN- conditioning strategies for improving
selection. Combat sports are in a unique
TIFIC UNDERSTANDING OF PUNCH- punching force.
position, lacking this important moni-
ING AND THUS THE DEVELOPMENT The databases Google Scholar, Pro toring tool in common practice.
OF OPTIMUM STRENGTH AND Quest, and SportDiscus were explored
CONDITIONING STRATEGIES. Throughout the literature, a variety of
for relevant research with the trun-
devices have been used to monitor
cated keywords punch and strike
punching forces. Although several
INTRODUCTION and combined with sport, combat
unique designs have been used, such
he punch is a key component sport, and force. Of the 43 articles
Copyright National Strength and Conditioning Association Strength and Conditioning Journal | www.nsca-scj.com 1
Assessment and Contributors of Punching Forces
as pressure transducer submerged in In a distinctive study design, Pierce et al. mounted triaxial piezoelectric force
water-filled heavy bag (9), and load cells (21) measured punching force from the transducers used by Smith et al. (26).
in the neck of a dummy (31), the most fist of the fighter rather than from the A key finding by Pierce et al. (21) was
common design used to record punch- target of a punch. Using the Bestshot that peak and mean force outputs in the
ing forces is piezoelectric force trans- system, Pierce et al. (21) were able to ring were substantially lower than those
ducers embedded in a target (Table 1) have a force sensor placed inside of the assessed in the laboratory. The authors
(3,10,26). The preferential choice of gloves of boxers and have the resulting note that the hardest punch recorded by
using piezoelectric force transducers impacts transmitted via radio frequency a heavy weight boxer registered 3,554 N
could be because of their accuracy, ease, telemetry to a computer during 6 pro- of peak force. This result was substan-
and proven reliability (coefficient of var- fessional boxing matches across multi- tially lower than the 4,800 N 6 227
iation 5 1.8%3.6%) (12). The piezo- ple weight classes. This advancement in found by Smith et al. (26) and the result
electric force transducers have been technology allowed for a flexibility of of Atha et al. (3) 4,096 N. This discrep-
used to explore injury and health issues punch selection and, more importantly, ancy raises a potentially important issue.
in boxers (3,31) and to correctly identify the ability to record actual fight data. Laboratory and competition punching
boxers experience levels through their In addition, the system was found to assessments may differ because of the
punching forces (26). be reliable and comparable with the dynamic nature of combat sports and
Table 1
Dynamometry in punching force literature
Study Subjects Force measuring equipment Punches tested Punching forces, N
Atha et al. (3) Professional heavy weight Padded pendulum equipped Unidentified 4,096 (PF)
boxer (n 5 1) with piezoelectric force
transducer
Fortin et al. (9) Unidentified Water-filled bag with pressure Unidentified Not included
transducer
Smith et al. (26) Elite (n 5 7), intermediate Wall-mounted force plate Elite rear hand mean 4,800 6 227
(n 5 8), and novice (n 5 8) (4 triaxial piezoelectric force force
boxers transducers) with a boxing
manikin cover Elite front hand mean 2,874 6 225
force
Intermediate rear hand 3,722 6 133
mean force
Intermediate front 2,283 6 126
hand mean force
Novice rear hand mean 2,381 6 116
force
Novice front hand 1,604 6 97
mean force
Girodet et al. (10) Karateka (n 5 1) Makiware equipped with 2 Straight punch Peak force 1,745
single-axis force sensors
Walilko et al. (31) Olympic boxers weighing Hybrid III dummy equipped Straight punch 1,9904,741 (PF)
from 48 to 109 kg (n 5 7) with a 6 axis load cell in the
neck, a Tekscans pressure 3,427 N 6 811 (MF)
sensor in the dummys face,
and Endevco
accelerometers on the
boxers hands
Pierce et al. (21) Professional boxers weighing Bestshot force sensor NA 866.61,149.2 (MF)
59.098.9 kg (n 5 12) imbedded in boxing gloves
5,358 (PF)
MF 5 mean force; PF 5 peak force.
Table 2
Training recommendations
hit tennis balls. This may be applicable suggested by Filimonov et al. (8) and development of punching force in
to understand GRF during punching as Turner et al. (29). combat sports athletes. First and fore-
part of the tennis players backhand A third theory in regard to the speci- most, it is recommended that lower
technique used rotation of the pelvis ficity of GRF in the punch may be pro- limb strength and power are consid-
in a similar manner to that found in posed. There may be no singular GRF ered for improving punching force,
many forms of punching. direction that is optimum for improved seen in Table 3. Although strength
In contrast, support for horizontal GRF force production. As a movement that and power are also important for both
as the primary factor in punching force involves rotation of the pelvis, trunk, the upper body and the core in a more
is found in Cesari and Bertucco (7), and shoulder (29), both vertical and general sense, this section will focus on
who observed large changes in the cen- horizontal force may contribute near specifics for improving punching force
ter of pressure (COP) anteriorly/poste- equally to the punch in a rotary move- as currently understood from the liter-
riorly as karatekas (karate practitioners) ment. Until further research exploring ature. That is, the development of
punched a target. The study also com- the directional application of leg drive lower-body strength and power, core
pared experienced with less experi- is conducted, current strength and con- stability, and upper limb velocity. In
enced karatekas and found that with ditioning practitioners are reliant on an regard to training the lower limbs for
experience there was a greater COP incomplete picture of punching and the punching, there is currently a paucity
movement anteriorly and less posteri- components that affect it. of research exploring the specificity of
orly. Although Cesari and Bertucco (7) GRF direction. It is the view of the
focused their results on the karatekas PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS authors to focus equally on axial loaded
ability to maintain dynamic stability, Using the literature reviewed in this movements (e.g., squats) and longitu-
this study still helps to illustrate the article, basic strength and conditioning dinally loaded movements (e.g., sled
directionality of the force during suggestions can be provided for the pulls).
a punch. Similarly, Gulledge and Dape-
na (11) found high levels of horizontal
force in rear hand punches recorded on Table 3
a force plate but unfortunately did not Strength and power guidelines (4)
examine vertical forces. The strength of
Training goal Goal repetitions Sets Rest period lengths
both studies was the inclusion of a force
plate to assess the participants. If future Strength #6 26 25 min
research corroborates these findings,
Power
a strength and conditioning practitioner
would be well served to focus on lon- Single effort 12 35 25 min
gitudinally loaded movements to com-
Multiple effort 35 35 25 min
plement the axial loaded movements
7. Cesari P and Bertucco M. Coupling 21. Pierce JD, Reinbold KA, Lyngard BC,
Seth Lenetsky between punch efficacy and body stability Goldman RJ, and Pastore CM. Direct
is a masters stu- for elite karate. J Sci Med Sport 11: 353 measurement of punch force during six
dent of Sport and 356, 2008. professional boxing matches. J Quant Anal
Sports 2: 2006.
Exercise Science 8. Filimonov VI, Koptsev KN, Husyanov ZM,
with AUT Uni- and Nazarov SS. Means of increasing 22. Piorkowski BA, Lees A, and Barton GJ.
strength of the punch. Natl Strength Cond Single maximal versus combination punch
versitys School of
Assoc J 7: 6566, 1983. kinematics. Sports Biomech 10: 111,
Sport and Recre-
2011.
ation in Auck- 9. Fortin Y, Lamontagne M, and Gadouas A.
Punching bag dynamometer. J Biomech 23. Schick MG, Brown LE, and Schick EE.
land, New
27: 758759, 1995. Strength and conditioning considerations
Zealand, and for female mixed martial artists Strength
a strength and conditioning coach spe- 10. Girodet P, Vaslin P, Dabonneville M, and
Cond J 34: 6675, 2012.
cializing in combat sports athletes. Lacouture P. Two-dimensional kinematic
and dynamic analysis of a karate straight 24. Siff MC. Supertraining. Denver, CO:
punch. Comput Method Biomech Biomed Supertraining Institute, 2004.
Eng 8: 117118, 2005. 25. Smith MS. Physiological profile of
Nigel Harris is
11. Gulledge JK and Dapena J. A comparison of senior and junior England international
a senior lecturer in amateur boxers. J Sport Sci Med 5: 7489,
the reverse and power punches in oriental
Sport and Exer- martial arts. J Sport Sci 26: 189196, 2008. 2006.
cise Science at
12. Harris NK, Cronin J, Taylor K, Boris J, and 26. Smith MS, Dyson RJ, Hale T, and
AUT University Sheppard J. Understanding position Janaway L. Development of a boxing
and a strength transducer technology for strength and dynamometer and its punch force
and conditioning conditioning practitioners. Strength Cond J discrimination efficacy. J Sport Sci 18:
coach. 32: 6679, 2010. 445450, 2000.