4/27/2017 PhilippineLawsandCases.:EffectofnoncompliancewithSec.21,RA9165drugcaseG.R.No.

184808

0 HigitPa SusunodnaBlog BumuongBlog Magsignin

PhilippineLawsandCases.
ManuelJ.LasernaJr.,LasernaCuevaMercaderLawOffices,LasPinasCity,Philippines.

FollowbyEmail Tuesday,November29,2011 SearchThisBlog

Emailaddress...Submit Search
EffectofnoncompliancewithSec.
AboutMe 21,RA9165drugcaseG.R.No. BlogArchive
184808 2017(293)

G.R.No.184808 2016(712)

2015(778)
PhilippineLaws "xxx.
andCasesManuel 2014(339)
J.LasernaJr.
At any rate, noncompliance by the police with the 2013(468)
LasPinasCity,Metro
directive of Section 21, Article 11 of R.A. No. 9165 is not 2012(670)
Manila,Philippines
necessarily fatal to a prosecutions case, in light of the last
MANUELJ.LASERNA 2011(489)
sentence of its implementing rules expressly stating that non
JR.Email:
compliancewiththeserequirementsunderjustifiablegrounds,as December
lcmlaw@gmail.com. (70)
Tel/Fax..+632 longastheintegrityandtheevidentiaryvalueoftheseizeditems
8462539and8725443. are properly preserved by the apprehending officer/team, shall November
not render void and invalid such seizures of and custody over (62)
SeeGoogleMapsfor
directionsLaserna said items[.] Simply put, mere lapses in procedures need not CoronaCourt
CuevaMercaderLaw damaged
invalidate a seizure if the integrity and evidentiary value of the badly|
Offices.PROFILE: seizeditemscanbeshowntohavebeenproperlypreservedand BusinessWo
Partner,Laserna rldOnline...
[15]
CuevaMercaderLaw safeguarded. Theproceduresaretheretoensuretheintegrity
Offices.Admittedtothe Whenjudge
and evidentiary value of seized items, and can liberally be
actsingood
Barin1985(3rdplacer, viewediftheattainmentoftheseobjectivesisnotindoubt. faith
1984barexam).Law Panganvs
Jurisprudence teems with pronouncements that failure to
professorofFEU, Ganay:...
strictlycomplywithSection21,ArticleIIofR.A.No.9165does
Manila,1985to2006
not necessarily render an accused's arrest illegal or the items Detention
(ret.).Educ.:ABJourn.,
seized or confiscated from him inadmissible. To reiterate, what house
UP,Diliman,QC,1975 arrestG.R.
BachelorofLaws assumes utmost importance is the preservation of the integrity No.179817
(LL.B.),cumlaude, and the evidentiary value of the seized items, as these are the
FEU,1984Masterof HowMany
critical pieces of evidence in the determination of the guilt or
TimesDid
Laws(LL.M.),UST, [16] Chief
(cand.),Manila[asFEU innocence of the accused. In this case, as discussed, the
Justice
fellow,19982000]. integrityandtheevidentiaryvalueofthedangerousdrugseized Corona
Honors:3rdplacer, from the appellant were duly proven to have been properly VoteinFa...
1984BarExams preserved its identity, quantity and quality remained Fresh
(90.95%only22% untarnished. We thus see sufficient compliance by the police Perspective
passed)Meralcopre son
with the required procedure in the custody and control of the
lawscholarCocofed Managing
confiscateditems.InthesimilarcaseofPeoplev.Campomanes, Reputationa
lawscholarCocofed
[17] lCorpor...
managementscholar weheld:
(AIM,Makati)FEU Although Section 21(1) of R.A. No. 9165 Shakenbaby
fellow(LLM,UST).Bar syndrome
mandates that the apprehending team must
leaderinsouthern andthe
immediately conduct a physical inventory of the Supreme
MetroManilaarea
seized items and photograph them, noncompliance Court.
since1995.Founded Slat...
with said section 21 is not fatal as long as there is a
LasPinasCityBar

http://attylaserna.blogspot.com/2011/11/effectofnoncompliancewithsec21ra.html 1/7
4/27/2017 PhilippineLawsandCases.:EffectofnoncompliancewithSec.21,RA9165drugcaseG.R.No.184808

Assn(2001).Servedas justifiablegroundtherefor,andaslongastheintegrity Laurence

director/sec./vicepres., and the evidentiary value of the confiscated/seized Watts:Gay
IBPPPLMCh.,1995 items are properly preserved by the apprehending Rightsand
2007. theU.S.
team.Thus,theprosecutionmustdemonstratethatthe Supreme
Viewmycomplete integrityandevidentiaryvalueoftheevidenceseized Co...
profile havebeenpreserved.
Supreme
We note that nowhere in the prosecution CourtTV?
PopularPosts evidencedoesitshowthe"justifiableground"which NiceIdea,
mayexcusethepoliceoperativesinvolvedinthebuy butStillNot
"Condemn Likely...
DuterteEvenIf bustoperationinthecaseatbarfromcomplyingwith
YoureA Section21ofRepublicActNo.9165,particularlythe WhiteHouse
Supporter.Yourman makingoftheinventoryandthephotographingofthe looksto
maywinandbecome beefup
drugs and drug paraphernalia confiscated and/or manageme
presidentbutinthe
processyouhavelost. seized. However, such omission shall not render ntof
Inmakinghimawinner accusedappellant's arrest illegal or the items electro...
youhavemade seized/confiscated from him as inadmissible in
yourselfaloser." Accidental
evidence. In People v. Naelga [G.R. No. 171018, dischargeof
SeeXCondemn
September 11, 2009, 599 SCRA 477], We have firearmby
DuterteEvenIfYoure security
ASupporter"xxx.By: explained that what is of utmost importance is the
guard...
CarlosS.Hernandez preservationoftheintegrityandtheevidentiaryvalue
Jr.Whenheadvocated Command
oftheseizeditemsbecausethesamewillbeutilized
forextrajudicialkillings responsibilit
,... inascertainingtheguiltorinnocenceoftheaccused. yscope
It must be stressed that said "justifiable and
Qualifiedtheftdefined ground" will remain unknown in the light of the limitation
properpenalty expl...
apparentfailureoftheaccusedappellanttochallenge
explained
the custody and safekeeping or the issue of Command
ItemNo"xxx.The
elementsofthecrime dispositionandpreservationofthesubjectdrugsand responsibilit
oftheftasprovidedfor yscope
drugparaphernaliabeforetheRTC.
inArticle3089ofthe and
Finally, we find the penalty imposed to be within the range limitation
RevisedPenalCode
areasfollows:(1)t... [18] exp...
provided by law, and was, therefore, correctly imposed by
theRTCandaffirmedbytheCA. Presidential
Oraldefamation, immunity
slanderG.R.No. xxx." fromsuit
160351 scopeof
SeeG.R.No.160351 G.R.N...
"xxx.Theissuesare: PostedbyPhilippineLawsandCasesManuelJ.Laserna
(1)whethertheCourt Writof
ofAppealserredin Jr.at1:34AM amparowrit
sustainingthe ofhabeas
Recommend this on Google data
convictionofpetitioner
... provisional
...
Estafa
Linkstothispost
Effectof
(deceit/swindling) CreateaLink
noncomplia
underArt.315,Rev.
ncewith
PenalCode Sec.21,RA
Forlegalresearch 9165dru...
purposesofmy
readers,mayIshare Unauthorized
thejurisprudentialpart practiceof
ofamotionfor lawA.C.
reconsiderationIhave No.7269
justfiledwiththe...
Quantumof
Estafasample proof
counteraffidavit requiredin
laborcases
Belowisasample
Abandonm..
counteraffidavit
.
preparedbyAtty.
ManuelJ.LAsernaJr. Administrative
involvingEstafa cases
http://attylaserna.blogspot.com/2011/11/effectofnoncompliancewithsec21ra.html quantumof 2/7
4/27/2017 PhilippineLawsandCases.:EffectofnoncompliancewithSec.21,RA9165drugcaseG.R.No.184808
undergoingpreliminary NewerPost Home OlderPost quantumof
investigationbef... proofA.M.
No....
Titlingofpubliclands
Lawyers
Forpurposesoflegal suspended
researchofforeign forneglect
readersvisitingthis ofduty
blog,onthesubjectof A.C.No.6...
thelegalsystem
involvingthetitlingof Attorney's
publicla... fees
ordinaryvs.
Jurisdictionof extraordinar
Philippinecourts yG.R....
Iampresentingbelow
abriefdigestofthe Limitsofa
Rule65
jurisdictionofPhilippine
petitionin
courtsascontainedin
laborcases
BATASPAMBANSA
G.R....
Blg.129,asamended.
forthe... Civilaspectof
crimes
Contracttosellvs.
contractofsale Whatwillsave
explainedG.R.No. SCfrom
188064 intense
G.R.No.188064(click assault?
link)"xxx.TheCourts POSTSCRI.
RulingThepetition ..
lacksmerit.TheCourt
agreeswiththeruling Demanding
of... justice|
BusinessWo
rldOnline
CRIMINAL Edition
NEGLIGENCEOF
DRIVERSAND Criminal
OPERATORS Justice
applicablelaws Degrees
penaltiescivil Guide|9
liabilities. Judges
Recklessimprudence WhoDisg...
visvissimple
negligence.Art. Maguindanao
365oftheRevised massacre
PenalCodeprovides (Year2)|
thatreckless Inquirer
imprudencecons... Opinion

Credibilityvs.
EstafaandBlg.22 legalism|
Complaintw/lawsand BusinessWo
jurisprudence.
rldOnline
Iwishtosharea Ed...
criminalcomplaintfor
EstafaandBP22thatI Executive,
preparedrecently,with legislative
focusonthelegal branches
researchaspect urgedto
thereof,fort... oppose
SC...

Links Deportationof
Aliens
Ltigation,Appeals, grounds
JusticeSystem Sec.37,CA
LasernaCueva 613,P...
MercaderLawOffices
Checkmate|
Inquirer
Followers Opinion

http://attylaserna.blogspot.com/2011/11/effectofnoncompliancewithsec21ra.html 3/7
4/27/2017 PhilippineLawsandCases.:EffectofnoncompliancewithSec.21,RA9165drugcaseG.R.No.184808
Mgasumusubaybay Unfinished
(180)Susunod legal
business|
Inquirer
Opinion

Lawmakers
wantMidas
Marquez
disciplined|
Inquire...

Allrightsare
Sundin limitedby
therightsof
others|I...

Justice
Sereno
warnsSC
spokesman
andclerken
ban...

Japan
develops
jurysystem:
Layjudge
system
ruled...

Istime
running
out?The
Philippine
StarNews
...

Revolutionary
gov'tan
optionfor
NoyDND
The...

Ruleoflaw
andpublic
esteem|
Inquirer
Opinion

Demurrerto
evidence
remedies
G.R.No.
189365

Malversation
modesof
commission
G.R.No.
18936...

Rightsof
illegitimate
children|
Inquirer
Opinion...

CHR:Rightto
travelnot
applicable
inGMA
case...
http://attylaserna.blogspot.com/2011/11/effectofnoncompliancewithsec21ra.html 4/7
4/27/2017 PhilippineLawsandCases.:EffectofnoncompliancewithSec.21,RA9165drugcaseG.R.No.184808

Execution
pending
appeal
when
allowed.
G.R.No....

Liabilityof
corporate
directors
andofficers
G....

Attorney's
FeesG.R.
No.145817

Internetkeeps
government
honest:
Google
chief|I...

Privacy
issues:
Austrian
student
takeson
Facebook...

Violent
Negros
Oriental.
Lawyers
killed.
DAILYS...

SisterRaquel
Blog
eastwind
journals03
OPENL...

PALrow,
Occupy
WallStreet
Prof.R.
Ofreneo

Flightand
plight

TheBar
exams
redux|
Columnist

SCjustices
underfire
forfraud,
coverup|
Top...

Unduedelay
inrendering
decision
judgefined
...

Judicial
ethics
judgefined

http://attylaserna.blogspot.com/2011/11/effectofnoncompliancewithsec21ra.html forviolation 5/7

4/27/2017 PhilippineLawsandCases.:EffectofnoncompliancewithSec.21,RA9165drugcaseG.R.No.184808
forviolation
oflaw...

Qualifiedtheft
G.R.No.
193479

Illegalstrike
G.R.Nos.
19113839

Temperate
damages
when
awarded
G.R.No.
188072

Taxrefund
valueadded
taxG.R.
No.179632

How
jurisdiction
is
determined
G.R.No.
175497

Certiorariand
double
jeopardy
G.R.No.
172777

Factbox:Key
political
risksto
watchinthe
Phili...

October(67)

September
(84)

August(53)

July(48)

June(18)

May(6)

April(3)

March(33)

February(37)

January(8)

2010(285)

2009(235)

2008(182)

2007(114)

TotalPageviews

http://attylaserna.blogspot.com/2011/11/effectofnoncompliancewithsec21ra.html 6/7
4/27/2017 PhilippineLawsandCases.:EffectofnoncompliancewithSec.21,RA9165drugcaseG.R.No.184808

5,271,543

Watermarktheme.PoweredbyBlogger.

http://attylaserna.blogspot.com/2011/11/effectofnoncompliancewithsec21ra.html 7/7