Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
Clearwater Formation shales are heavily overconsolidated clay- and silt-shales encountered within the footprint of several
oil sands mines located in northeastern Alberta, Canada. Their micro- and macro-structures are often associated with very
low shear strengths as demonstrated in this paper by the results of several direct shear tests carried out on Clearwater
shale samples from the Joslyn North lease, located north of Fort McMurray, Alberta. An important structural feature of
these weak rocks is the occurrence of slickensides, i.e. smoothly polished surfaces caused by the frictional movement
along the sides of a fault plane and usually linked with low shear resistance. Identifying these structural discontinuities in
the field is critical for the design of earthen structures founded on these weak materials. At the Joslyn North lease,
slickenside occurrences were identified sparsely throughout the site; however, nearly 98% of the occurrences were
observed in augered test holes. A geotechnical test pit program was implemented in the winter of 2014 to characterize
more accurately the nature of these defects. No evidence of distinct shear zones or slickensides was found, despite their
description in adjacent boreholes, confirming that the slickensides previously described in augered test holes were in fact
drill-induced.
RSUM
Les shales de la formation de Clearwater sont des shales dargile et de silt fortement consolids rencontrs dans
lempreinte de nombreux sites dexploitation ptrolire et gazire du nord-est de lAlberta, au Canada. Leurs micro/macro-
structures sont souvent associes des rsistances au cisaillement trs faibles, tel quil le sera dmontr dans cet article
par les rsultats de nombreux essais de cisaillement effectus sur des chantillons de shale du Clearwater provenant de
la concession ptrolire de Joslyn North, situe au nord de Fort McMurray en Alberta. Un aspect important de ces roches
de faible rsistance est lapparition de surfaces polies par les mouvements de friction le long des plans de faille et
normalement associes une faible rsistance au cisaillement. Lidentification de ces discontinuits structurelles sur le
terrain est cruciale dans la conception de structures en terre fondes sur ces matriaux de faible rsistance. Sur la
concession de Joslyn North, quelques surfaces polies ont t identifies travers le site. Toutefois, 98% dentre elles ont
t retrouves dans des trous de forage. Un programme gotechnique de trous dessais a donc t mis en place durant
lhiver 2014 afin de caractriser de faon plus prcise la nature de ces dfauts. Aucune vidence de zones de cisaillement
distinctes ou de miroirs de faille na t trouve, en dpit de leur description dans les trous de forage adjacents, confirmant
que ces surfaces polies taient en fait induites par le forage.
Facies Symbol
Geological Description
Joslyn CNQ SCL
Kc3 Kce-745 Kce + Greyish-black shale with local low-
+ Kcd- Kcd angle, parallel bedded to cross-
740 bedded, glauconitic sandy silt;
lower contact marked by a dual Figure 2. Frequency distribution of liquid limit for each
indurated bed and bound by a Clearwater facies.
black, fissile, low-density clay cap.
Kc2 Kcc-730, Kcc Dark grey shale with moderate to
725,720, (1 to 6) common silt lenses; thin beds of
710 + Kcb1 low-density clay; thin, locally
indurated beds; lower contact may
be marked by a thin interval of
glauconitic shale.
Kc1 Kcb-700 Kcb2 Black, fissile, low-density clay shale
with rare to moderate silt laminae/
lenses; upper contact commonly
marked by an indurated bed.
Kcw3 Kcb-650 Kcb3 Churned/bioturbated glauconitic
silty sand and dark grey mud
laminae; sharp contact with the
overlying low-density clay; lower
contact marked by induration.
Kcw2 Kca Kca Dark grey silty clay with minor
glauconitic silt laminae/lenses and
rare burrows; locally very dark
grey/black fissile clay.
Kcw1 Kcw Kcw Thinly laminated to churned, Figure 3. Plasticity indexes of several shale formations in
medium to dark grey clay with western Canada, including the Clearwater Formation.
moderate to common glauconitic Atterberg limit data (Liquid Limit and Plasticity Index)
silt and sand lenses/burrows. from Joslyn North added to the original figure modified
Occasional thin indurated beds,
commonly near contacts.
from Wong (1994).
Table 2 lists the across bedding and parallel to 3 GEOTECHNICAL TEST PIT PROGRAM
bedding friction angles selected for design for the MLC
and RWC scenarios. Except for Kc3, which is not quite as A geotechnical test pit program was developed to assess
fine grained as the other Clearwater subunits and also has the presence and nature of structural discontinuities within
a lower liquid limit, all the other subunits exhibit very low the Clearwater units, through examination of the in-situ
residual strengths, with parallel to bedding friction angles stratigraphy, particularly in the top 6 m below ground
as low as 7. Such low values are comparable to those surface. The findings of the test pit campaign would also
reported by other authors (Alencar et al., 1994; Moore et support the development of strength parameters to be used
al., 2006; Martens and Charron, 2007; McRoberts et al., in design.
2008). By comparing the liquid limit values (shown on top The test pit program consisted of ten test pits located
of the circles in Figure 4), one may infer a direct relationship immediately adjacent to existing augered test holes (in
between low shear strength and high plasticity, which in which slickensides had been identified), and within or
turn is associated with clay content and mineralogy. adjacent to the footprint of the planned out-of-pit structures,
The direct shear testing was conducted in accordance as shown in Figure 5. This figure also shows the zero edges
with ASTM D3080. It is very likely that the Clearwater (boundaries) of the Clearwater and Wabiskaw units. Note
that the footprint of the planned out-of-pit structures is smoothly polished, waxy appearance, and is normally
underlain mostly by Clearwater Formation shales. striated in the direction of the shearing movement.
The test pit program was conducted in early February Only small and isolated amounts of centimetre-size,
2014, when temperatures were below -20C. All test pits randomly oriented surfaces were flagged as potentially
were excavated using a backhoe to depths varying from indicative of slickensides. Figures 8 identifies a smooth to
4.1 m to 6.6 m below existing grade. Geotechnical logging slightly rough surface oriented at about 45from horizontal,
was carried out by Thurber personnel soon after the test which was identified in TP5 as a possible occurrence of
pits were opened. Messrs. Sobkowicz, Abraha, Pinheiro slickenside. If it existed, a sheared zone would be expected
and an owner representative mobilized to site to assess the to extend over a length of a few metres to tens of metres,
exposed soils on the open test pit walls. At the time of our as opposed of being located in one or two small, isolated
site visit, the exposed soil on the test pit walls had become spots. Alternatively, less intense shearing could have been
frozen and very hard, making it more challenging to assess indicated by groups of slickensides located in a particular
the presence of structural discontinuities, as shown in soil unit throughout the test pit. Neither of these types of
Figure 6. Whenever possible, a hand pick was used to features was observed in any of the test pits. For this
chop off the outermost frozen layer and re-expose unfrozen reason, it is very likely that these small, polished surfaces
Clearwater shale. Other times, a backhoe was used to were induced by the excavation process and do not
expose larger portions of fresh soils. represent natural structural discontinuities in the
Clearwater deposits.