Professional Documents
Culture Documents
LEARNING OBJECTIVE: Readers will recognize that opioid addiction is a chronic condition that requires
ongoing treatment
VANIA MODESTO-LOWE, MD, MPH KATIE SWIEZBIN, BS MARGARET CHAPLIN, MD GABRIELA HOEFER
Connecticut Valley Hospital, Middletown, CT; Quinnipiac University, Hamden, CT University of Connecticut School of Samford University, Birmingham, AL
Quinnipiac University, Hamden, CT; University of Medicine, Farmington, CT; Community
Connecticut School of Medicine, Farmington, CT Mental Health Affiliates, New Britain, CT
one. (Taken orally or sublingually, naloxone Naltrexone has significantly less abuse
is poorly absorbed and has little or no clinical potential, as it provides no euphoria, but pa-
effect.) Buprenorphine-naloxone is available tients do not like it. Even with the long-acting
in tablets, a sublingual film strip, and a buccal formulation (Vivitrol), naltrexone treatment
film strip. Buprenorphine is also available by is significantly less effective than methadone
itself in a sublingual formulation. or buprenorphine.2325 Further, although nal-
The US Food and Drug Administration trexone is not a controlled substance and so
has approved a buprenorphine subdermal im- does not face the same scrutiny as the agonist
plant, Probuphine. Four rods, about 1 inch therapies, there are other significant barriers.
long, are placed under the skin in the in- Additional information on naltrexone is pre-
ner aspect of the upper arm and provide the sented in reviews by Modesto-Lowe and Van
equivalent of 8 mg of buprenorphine daily Kirk24 and Woody.25
for 6 months.17 However, this method is for-
mulated only for maintenance treatment and OBSTACLES TO TREATMENT
cannot be used for induction. Additionally, it People hold conflicting views about opioid ag-
is recommended that the implants be surgi- onist therapy. Some believe that trading one
cally removed at the end of 6 months, after drug for another is not a legitimate therapeu-
which another set of implants can be inserted tic strategy, and they may feel ashamed of be-
in the other arm or the patient can switch to ing on maintenance therapy.26 Similarly, some
sublingual therapy, depending on the clinical argue that the answer to establishing stable
situation and patient preference.17 abstinence does not lie simply in prescribing
Generally safer than methadone medications.
Buprenorphine works on the same receptor The contrary argument is that these medi-
as methadone and therefore has a similar side cations, if used appropriately, confer many
effect profile. However, buprenorphine has a benefits such as reducing the medical and psy-
ceiling effect, which greatly reduces the risk of chosocial sequelae of opioid addiction.18 In
fatal respiratory depression.18 It also does not fact, properly treated patients no longer meet
the diagnostic criteria of opioid use disorder, Heroin
cause clinically significant QTc prolongation
and is preferable in patients who have cardiac and both methadone and buprenorphine are is typically
risk factors.18 on the World Health Organizations (WHO) less expensive
Another advantage is that buprenorphine list of essential medicines.27
has fewer identified medication interactions Despite endorsement by the WHO, the and easier
than methadone.18 Further, induction of bu- stigma attached to the opioid agonists has to obtain than
prenorphine in patients with opioid use dis- been difficult to overcome. Patients with opi-
oid use disorder may be viewed with distrust prescription
order has been shown to be safer than metha-
done.19 by healthcare providers and often do not feel opioids
Although buprenorphine has been found welcome in healthcare settings or in self-help
to be 6 times safer than methadone with re- recovery groups.28
gard to overdose among the general popula- Barriers to methadone therapy
tion,20 it can still cause fatal intoxication if Federal regulations on methadone prescrib-
used in combination with central nervous sys- ing and use were established to promote pa-
tem depressants.21 tient safety and decrease diversion, but they
Buprenorphine has been also associated may also complicate access to care.29 They
with hepatotoxicity, though the risk of new- stipulate that to qualify for methadone main-
onset liver disease appears to be low.22 tenance, patients need to demonstrate opioid
addiction for 1 year, except for pregnant wom-
NALTREXONE IS LESS EFFECTIVE en and those who have been incarcerated in
THAN METHADONE, BUPRENORPHINE the past 6 months. Patients under the age of
Besides methadone and buprenorphine, the 18 must have 2 documented failed treatment
only other approved option for treating opioid episodes as well as approval by a guardian to
use disorder is the opioid antagonist naltrexone. receive treatment.
CL E V E L AND CL I NI C J O URNAL O F M E DI CI NE V O L UM E 84 NUM BE R 5 M AY 2 0 1 7 379
OPIOID AGONISTS
Inconvenience. Methadone can be pre- (DATA) of 2000, any physician can apply for
scribed for opioid dependence only by an ac- a waiver to prescribe and dispense buprenor-
credited treatment program. Patients must phine in his or her office. To qualify for an ini-
therefore travel to the clinic and wait to be tial waiver, physicians must either obtain cer-
evaluated on a daily basis for a minimum of 90 tification in the fields of addiction medicine or
days. Only after they demonstrate consistent addiction psychiatry or complete an approved
responsible behavior and negative results on 8-hour training session.32 Each physician starts
urine testing do they become eligible to take with a maximum of 30 patients, but can ap-
methadone home.29 If a patient is to travel ply to treat up to 100 patients after 1 year and
out of the area during the initial 90 days of eventually up to 275 patients. Physicians must
treatment, he or she must make arrangements document every buprenorphine prescription
in advance to find a clinic that will provide a they write and be able to refer patients for
guest dose. counseling.31
The inconvenience arising from the regu- As of February 2017, nurse practitioners
lations may deter some patients from seek- and physician assistants can also apply for a
ing methadone therapy. In spite of this, once DATA 2000 waiver. All waivered providers
patients are started on methadone, more of are subject to unannounced visits from the
them continue treatment than with buprenor- Drug Enforcement Administration once every
phine.18 A proposed reason is that methadone 5 years.32
is a potent full opioid agonist and therefore While there are no federal restrictions on
relieves withdrawal symptoms and craving the amount of buprenorphine that can be
more effectively than buprenorphine, which dispensed, some states and some insurance
is a partial agonist.30 Another possible reason companies have placed restrictions on dose
is the higher level of supervision afforded by or length of treatment.33 Buprenorphine
methadone clinics, which require daily con- patients can fill their prescriptions at any
tact for at least 90 days. pharmacy and are permitted to bring their
Safety concerns arise from methadone medication home, which improves access
Buprenorphine diversion, as illicit use may have lethal con- to care. However, office-based outpatient
is safer than sequences. In the past decade, deaths from treatment is not without risk, and prevent-
methadone overdose have risen significantly, ing buprenorphine diversion remains a chal-
methadone most of them due to respiratory depression or lenge.34
but can still torsade de pointes.13 However, most cases of
Lending buprenorphine is a felony
kill if used diversion and overdose involve methadone
Addicts have illegally used buprenorphine to
that is prescribed for pain by individual practi-
with central self-treat opioid withdrawal, craving, and de-
tioners and not from maintenance programs.13
pendence.35 Its misuse has also been coupled
nervous system Advantages of buprenorphine with self-treatment of conditions that include
depressants Together, methadones lethality, stigma, and depression and pain.36
inconvenience may contribute to patients A survey found that 83.7% of patients
preferring buprenorphine.31 deem buprenorphine diversion to be appropri-
The regulations governing buprenor- ate; further, most patients said they consider
phines use are less restrictive than those with it unethical to withhold prescribed buprenor-
methadone. For example, patients must have phine from individuals showing symptoms of
a diagnosis of opioid addiction to be pre- withdrawal.34 Physicians who prescribe bu-
scribed buprenorphine, but they are not re- prenorphine must inform their patients that
quired to carry the diagnosis for a year before even lending or giving away their medica-
treatment.31 Additionally, they do not need tion is a felony.
to travel to a federally approved opioid treat- Prescribing physicians must also be dili-
ment center daily and can receive buprenor- gent about monitoring for signs of diversion
phine directly from a physician in an outpa- such as inconsistent urine toxicology screens,
tient setting. lost medication, and requests for early refills
Under the Drug Abuse Treatment Act or escalating doses.37
380 C LEV ELA N D C L INIC J OURNAL OF MEDICINE VOL UME 84 NUM BE R 5 M AY 2017
MODESTO-LOWE AND COLLEAGUES
tisocial personality disorder display disruptive aware of or unwilling to consider the risks as-
and maladaptive behaviors. sociated with their opioid use and resistant to
Identify any psychotropic medication that the idea of quitting. Engagement with opioid
is prescribed and check carefully for drug in- agonists for individuals in this stage is low and
teractions. This applies especially to metha- dropout rates are likely high.
done, as many psychiatric medications also Thus, the proper approach for precon-
prolong the QT interval. Moreover, patients templators is to help them develop some am-
may not be forthcoming about the use of psy- bivalence about their opioid use. One tactic
chiatric medication. is to involve the patient in a discussion of the
Find out whether the patient is using personal benefits and risks of opioid use.
any other addictive substances, particularly Contemplation. Individuals in the con-
those that affect the central nervous system, templation stage have begun to weigh the
as those who use fentanyl, benzodiazepines, costs and benefits of opioid use and express
or alcohol are at the highest risk of over- ambivalence about it.44 Because the patient is
dose.31 Often the best option for those with willing to explore the risks of ongoing use and
concurrent substance use disorders is inpa- consider the benefits of treatment, the goal in
tient detoxification followed by residential this stage is to elicit a commitment from the
rehabilitation care. Either buprenorphine or individual to seek treatment.
methadone can then be initiated upon return Preparation. The person in this stage
to an outpatient setting. moves from thinking about treatment to plan-
Step 3: Assess psychosocial status ning what action to take.45 As the individual
To what extent do the patients home envi- prepares to enter treatment, indecision tends
ronment and support systems promote a drug- to resurface, as well as self-doubt about his or
free lifestyle? Unfortunately, the psychosocial her ability to change. During this stage, it is im-
status of many of these patients is fragile, and portant for the provider to spell out goals (ab-
they may live in areas where illicit drugs are stinence) and strategies (eg, counseling, medi-
readily available (which can be urban, subur- cation) and enhance a sense of self-efficacy.
Patients with ban, or rural), making it difficult to stay sub- Action and maintenance. Patients in
active suicidal stance-free.38 these stages engage in treatment and employ
or homicidal Generally, lifestyle modifications are need- new strategies to abstain from opioid use.
ed to transform maladaptive behaviors and Maintaining these behaviors can be a daily
ideation promote an environment conducive to long- struggle. Expressing confidence in the pa-
should term recovery. Referrals to social services to tients ability to abstain from use will support
address housing, vocational needs, and enti- his or her progress. Behavioral interventions
be assessed tlements may be helpful.39 such as strategic avoidance of triggers and en-
for need gagement in alternative activities (eg, support
Step 4: Assess readiness to change groups, exercise, faith-based practices) will
of immediate According to one model, people go through help to maintain abstinence.
hospitalization 5 stages when changing a behavior: precon-
templation, contemplation, preparation for A CHRONIC CONDITION
action, action, and maintenance.43 In general,
the further along the stages a patient is, the Opioid use disorder, like many chronic ill-
more appropriate he or she is for office-based nesses, requires long-term attention to attain
treatment with buprenorphine.39 successful patient outcomes. The opioid ago-
The level of change can be assessed with nists methadone and buprenorphine are the
tools such as Stages of Change Readiness and mainstay of treatment for it, conferring ben-
Treatment Eagerness Scale (SOCRATES). efits such as reducing opioid use and prevent-
Use of stage-specific strategies may enhance a ing relapse.
patients readiness to cease opioid use.43 Candidates for opioid agonist therapy
Precontemplation. Those in the precon- should undergo a multidisciplinary assessment,
templation stage are not ready to think about including an evaluation on the patients readi-
changing their behavior.43 They may be un- ness to change his or her opioid use.
382 C LEV ELA N D C L INIC J OURNAL OF MEDICINE VOL UME 84 NUM BE R 5 M AY 2017
MODESTO-LOWE AND COLLEAGUES
Patient education should include a discus- Despite the difficulties inherent in treat-
sion of the risks of methadone (eg, respiratory ing patients with opioid use disorder, when
depression, fatal overdose, and QTc prolonga- used appropriately, opioid agonist therapy can
tion) and buprenorphine (eg hepatotoxicity) be lifesaving for patients struggling with long-
term opioid addiction.
and their benefits (eg, controlling craving,
decreasing the risk of relapse). Patients should ACKNOWLEDGMENT: We thank Katelyn Colosi, BS, and Drs.
Susan Wolfe, Dennis Bouffard, and Sinha Shirshendu for their
also be educated about overdose and diversion. helpful comments.
the treatment of opioid addiction. Rockville, MD: US Department focus on heroin and cocaine dependence. Am J Psychiatry 1985;
of Health and Human Services, Substance Abuse and Mental Health 142:12591264.
Service Administration; 2004. 43. Belding MA, Iguchi MY, Lamb RJ, Lakin M, Terry R. Stages and pro-
39. Center for Substance Abuse Treatment. Clinical guidelines for the cesses of change among polydrug users in methadone maintenance
use of buprenorphine in the treatment of opioid addiction. Rockville treatment. Drug Alcohol Depend 1995; 39:4553. 44. Peteet
(MD): Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration JR, Brenner S, Curtiss D, Ferrigno M, Kauffman J. A stage of change
(US); 2004. (Treatment Improvement Protocol (TIP) Series, No. 40.) approach to addiction in the medical setting. Gen Hosp Psychiatry
www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK64245/. Accessed April 6, 2017. 1998; 20:267273.
40. Zippel-Schultz B, Specka M, Cimander K, et al. Outcomes of patients 45. Vijay A, Bazazi AR, Yee I, Kamarulzaman A, Altice FL. Treatment
in long-term opioid maintenance treatment. Subst Use Misuse 2016; readiness, attitudes toward, and experiences with methadone and
51:14931503. buprenorphine maintenance therapy among people who inject
41. Martins SS, Keyes KM, Storr CL, Zhu H, Chilcoat HD. Pathways be- drugs in Malaysia. J Subst Abuse Treat 2015; 54:2936.
tween nonmedical opioid use/dependence and psychiatric disorders:
results from the National Epidemiologic Survey on Alcohol and ADDRESS: Vania Modesto-Lowe, MD, MPH, Connecticut Valley Hospital,
Related Conditions. Drug Alcohol Depend 2009; 103:1624. PO Box 351, Silver Street, Middletown, CT 06457;
42. Khantzian EJ. The self-medication hypothesis of addictive disorders: vania.modesto-lowe@ct.gov
384 C LEV ELA N D C L INIC J OURNAL OF MEDICINE VOL UME 84 NUM BE R 5 M AY 2017