2011 $55 10.9), wakean Pree Na 10,2011 27 te JOURNAL OF EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTE OF JILIN PROVINCE Vol 27 (8262 5) Total No, 262 ABP Ff 35 25 5s 4 — Bic HE Be Be BY JLB 96D 2 LE Be Behe FRPP (12,3. BASE IPI HF HA RMF A , Hy BOSE 657000) HUE sb THR MUL HG LL SRP HR, LR ATT A AACE LAT T Pe SRE PUM SE; — RU Ha ST PRBIE:021 — LWARIR ANP SMITE) AB — Ae HS AA (ei RII Bh, HY SE LG BELA TL. Saaty F 20 hee 70 AERA LH VATE, Hee RB! TI FL, Oe as 9 3% GE HT BH WEA 1. A BUEBER Saaty BEBE RIC EP CI Awe ~ 2)/( = 1) Agas FD USEF RYT ACORPTEAR ne PUTS RU EAL. RARER FT AE RAG Bl) HOR AE EL CR < 0.1 set FB SERS EAT AE GRE LG RE. HE TIE — BR 5 TST ETE ERS A AREAL BRETT TRH ~ ARRERIAS EA = (45) geq 9 2 BAIS SHE Ta w= (wy 20, SB = (by) ans SEH OG = I Le HG = 12, n) ow MH Ast wy = LE 5, Ye aA i= 12,00 4m) Reb BE PA" EXACT EA = (04) Ren BUIEP PERE AMAT ay = ayay SUA A KE SEHCHIT EPR x2 ey =H stH0, = SO u, = LS tyCind = 1s) SRIF C = (69) 3 SPU Fe St BE RT SE BE SEAS REBT) HUSERE A 56-42 — BEER BRIS MEPE C PIC RI 1, BD ‘Ya -2011—06—07 3: CREB 1671—1580(2011 ) 10014503 bdo e-[ Lo eo HEA Be BT EL A BEB UL, TOAIAEPE A BP ARE C PHO IER Cy HA HELA 1 Ay ANTE AS REL BEL. FETE TB 1 FEM2 Ben BMIUDERE A HONEA 4) nen AL eCINCL a3) SEH eg (if = 1,2, ATA of IAM wb = YY Co, 1)? HAM Ee EI 0? HE SP EES Ben GPUS A BOER C = (64) gay BL eyINC1 03) (Cl BEAM IAPR) ,08 A NBER = SSS ARK BE n? 192 Sr GR oy RABIEPE C TER MADER Hi KE SIF ELE RAED OBI A (k= 1,2, oan). BS 5, 4 = Say 212m, SY 8, J2S ASB AD BE EA HEAL TYLA AF CEA — HENS, ALE AT BLE 8, HE SORE 0 AUIESS A AMT AT F ERE, RELA GBA = (ayn xn) EPUMSE PEW = HERI MDC 1966— ) IN, ZITA. RANE AOR RCE RU, Be, SEE TOM UCR RC ECP IOI 145(uy 105 77° 10,) FCAPS, = lan] = 1,2,-,n) , ELBL8,01N(0,03) (1 si 0 BIR 0 FABLE Di aE PP — BH OE R09 RRs, HAA EE — BE BR 0} KAPPA PE — BE BER BA 0 Mo ALLE PERT A AE FA SURAT FRM PITIE PE of BK — EE, ARTE AY o WAH SLABS Fa FH AY HE BE BARC LICE LHRH ALR T. L. Saaty BE EEA BE a, ATS TLS AT FEST EN EFT HOA 0 FEES HE TS RE 4 ERLE HAE of HES BSE LASER of = FTC NO IAF 0 RK 05,0.1 SLAVE. MAA RSH RI, AIBN FANS — 9 BRITS REZE AFL HEASE TF AOE, 0.01 KA FALSE TIMER 22001 a= 0.05 22010 ZC La (a? = 1) ph (BEE) He caty Lo? = 1) bho 2D) bs cot) Et = 1) feo ED) 3 | 21.666 20.090 ~ 11345 16.919 15. 507 7.815 14, 684 13. 362 6.251 4 [32.00] 30578 | 16.812 [2626] 2.96 | 12.502 [ass] 22307 | i065 s[aszia| 42980 | 23.209 [37.052] 3615 | 18.307 | 34382] 33.196 | 15.987 6 [snoi9| 57.342 | 30.578 [50.98] 49.002 | 24.996 |47.212| 46.059 | 22.307 7 [rie 72.007 | 38.92 [oso] o.032 | 20 [oom] oo | 2.015 8 [92.466] 91.260 | 48278 [ess] eis | 41337 [78.738] 77.026 | 37.916 9 [122.785] 111.602 | 58.619 [102.660] 101.531 | 0.998 [97.506] 96.466 | 47.212 Hes, RATER 6 PPMP WLP ERAS TBE MARE Saaty 1°23 1365 ABLE RASC FH tii. bys AD BARU ER— Hie ee 2 A 3 2 2 na = ant 7 HN eR |xiGP) pCa? ~ 1x3 (AY) 3 2! x3?! &_pro1wc 0.10) 17.508 | 19.76 | e928 3 9 5 A 022( < 0.10)} 8.432 | 7.916 3.25 A, on Doe Ay ). 189( > 0. 10)} 67.968 | 79.480 42.064 eel Oe rT 23 3.5 2 As . 046( < 0. 10)] 19. 251 | 15.831 8.319 14 1 As 136( > 0.10)] 50.751] s1.408 | 30.222 zai 5 721 2 3 ZI HER AUR 2 RAR. 13°23 ees SAC SE HOH SEAM LEBER TRACT AB AE +5234 Sue WLAS: 3 asi1itid 1. PRU RRR 0} VTL jt 4.1 23 dala 4 17 5) Lex tiitiiet— set Rt, ARR REO Acj2 2 - 1 | ROLE AUTRE os HIER A HREA Adz cal fs 2 51 4) Fete mato naire Rim en 7 Eth A, HOARE oLCdN, 2M a = 0.01 une S4GG 5) (2 4 5 1) emincoemverueee sama —aet, my « 5 = 0.050. 10 Bt, =e} ARH AAD ABE I IPe Sm — et ing, ALU PAGER SUA REI 2. Pen 0} Dk AEC. =A OIF UAN Soaty ff) — BE He BN LEC — 2 MSE PERE A AE SUAT EINE, EAR SUT HEH ELE, 3. ARSC A 6 APERERETITES a CoP) HA SayiGe? = 1) ebfteneaitean yg (2D) oe APA FAI SSS — SE Ba A 1 IE ARAMA, ATER MIC ATEN 4. SRY TT RO Ma A BEE He ET TE LES MRRAS , HFb,Saaty 32 CR < 0.10 He a NA SE SA BH EE — BE OY ERS HE AR HE RADHA SHEEP 0} Alo (i TR EEE AA RE , AAR AD SEARS CEN I HF — BHI I SG AE 5 AS AA RRA LAP RRA ane a aoe f ra CR Bin) B08 dy ni) TE Ts TeuviPa-nes|aoovey acoat fates | axaio] Boom 879 a, | Seuaco | Siete | Sion | Snear| Soo | Gesor | sine | Suse oon cies) | FEES [aoa Raw | Ral awe la em] RHm| Ra Ram te ee eee an fe |p lave [ee [me [me | ae ite Te oa seoxn | 55ST] 2-908] S=8TO] Z=UHT| secs | S=OID] S=TAT] a =ooF | S=OTH A, | 4eeRID | Sree | Seats | Sesser | Saos | Sssor | Saaes | aes | Seats, | Seas TRORE | aia dan | aun | tan | san | Ram | Paw | hae zo wan | 25- | wen | Ren [RO | Ree) Re ee Pret | “oe | Sie | Sa [see | ata | Sie 0 ia coro) | aeeat ‘euis| e=oaH] aeves | avoio] aoa [aco | wea Ay | RO | Eom Shan | Ses | Seo | Saser | Sgn | Sie | aoe cactay | PRBS? | aa ana |nua[Ram|ARR| Ram RH] RA a0 ah-jan-|ee|en-| eo |e | aa ae Se lee [se loe jee [ke | ae eo oa rai zane wzUTP eas] wea STEP Ssts Pasa Ay | SERIO | Sor Spa | Sass | Seuss] Souter | hese | Faye | Soe cnciay| SARRR | Bae Fan |Paa| tan |san|tan| caa| TAR ma sen lean |aao|aen| aes |e mee Sr | Pee | Sie | Se | Sore | Pane | Bae a = Feuioy FGA pasows] Taos] aevaT] ty Paso spun) Site | 25500 [Salts | Save | Sham | San | Siow oa Rum | Rum |Awm| Raw) RAR) RH m| RAH ap |eh—|ea-|eo-|z0-|e8—| ea aie [me [ae | sue [ee | mo | are aa So oe z=oys| Beda a cass] anos] aoe Pastas [asa aseooam | Saat Sales | Sate | Seats | Se | Sadie | Siesor [San TANS | aH wan |Fan|tan| ean ean | tag) tae ne men |Ran|#an| aan) Ren mee | Re aaa Shiv | “wie | eae | Mau | ae | Sate | ae (4)4b20b CERRO. PLATE Se mL Maa (J). ET (sax) #11997 15(3) 46 ~49 CADE MU MLA. BUM Ponzy) BeeF DEFENCE a LATERAL, 2002. (214266. SEP: SHRM MARAT). RT, 453288, 1998(6) 102 - 104, (3) SSFR599. AMP of 25 AP — Rete fad AMET BST (2). YET FE, 2002,20(3) 68 -71 (S198, San PH EBA). AEA ‘BYAHE,2002(4) 92 ~94 (6) 2:509%. ANP YAMA — Se HEH TEL J]. EAT %e 2007(-4) ,29 -30, C71 cA PHS ORBEA) AN ETT CS RGAE, 1996. Comparisons Between Several Statistical Methods of Checking the Consistency of a Judgment Matrix in AHP KANG Daokun', CHEN Jin’, HUANG Yong? (1.2.3. Department of Mathematics, Zhaotong Teecher’» College, Yunnan Zhactong 657000 china ) Abstract: Now there exist some statistical hypothesis testing methods in checking the consistency of a judgment matrix, In this pa- Per «e make some comparisons between several representative methods by analyzing actual examples. Key words; Judgment matrix; consistoney testing staistieal hypothesis testing; comparison 147