Professional Documents
Culture Documents
While the thesis of the essay suggest that this turmoil is due to U.S. policy, one could argue that
the author uses his dominant discourse to portray his underlying intent. This intent is to degrade
the idea of illegal immigrants and this can be seen in the authors diction as he depicts these
individuals in a negative light through his argument on U.S. policy. Many who have nomadized
to the United States have failed to follow these laws. Currently there are approximately 12
million undocumented residents in the United States. This means there are possibly 12 million
individuals who are present in the United States that are dependent upon its resources without
contributing to the system. This form of writing denotes the idea and argument the author is
trying to make, yet it does highlight his way of thinking and how he feels towards the people
instead of U.S. policy. In the excerpt, the writer stresses the number of illegal immigrants that
live within the country. Although there could possibly be some truth to the statement, this is more
of a focus on the people rather than the overall issue the writer intends to get across. This form of
literacy The author uses informal language in reference to illegal immigrants such as aliens
and these people. If one chooses to argue that U.S policy is the reason for the devastation that
we see financially in terms of illegal immigration, then ones argument should show that and
depict that idea. Yet, here in this situation one can see that the author stems away from his
thesis in an attempt to attack people and not policy. This can be seen in todays society with
President Trump. He talks about building a wall to help enforce the deportation and stabilization
of the number of illegal immigrants entering the United States. Much like the author, President
Trump sees U.S. policy as an issue as to why our resources are so easily accessible, slowly
depleting and why there are financial struggles throughout the country in reference to the topic
of illegal immigrants. President Trump then goes on to modify or amend U.S policy to enforce
evidence that do not in any way support the authors idea, but creates a false sense of urgency
that many people have on the situation. One could raise the question on how could illegal
immigrants deplete education resources when there are set standard procedures for
background checks for registration in most schools. The forms of identification that is collected
during registration such as social security numbers, birth certificates, and proof of state
residency refutes that idea of secretly getting through the system. The author creates a
discourse in which the formality of his argument seems more of a personal matter and belief. It
makes the reader question if this is a connection with the authors primary discourse? What
influences or inspirations did the author have to write on such a topic? Is this this a result of