Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Fellow:
Ajay Kalra, MBBS, PhD
Instructor, World Music
Department of Folk Studies and Anthropology
Western Kentucky University
Project report
Lomax Kentucky Recordings
Berea College Appalachian Sound Archives Fellowship, Summer 2016
This project has been undertaken to help make preliminary sense of the more than 1300 field recordings
of Kentucky musicians that Alan Lomax made in the late 1930s and that are now, for the first time,
available all together in one place. An initiated and dedicated researcher does not need much assistance
and would likely find some of the same resources that I have. My aim here has been to help the less well
initiated researcher interested in this music navigate the substantive collection to gain a quicker
overview of the music contained herein and of the senses that have been made previously of some
sections of it.
Among the major publications, in print or sound or both, through which some of this music has reached
the world are the following. If you have heard this music or popular contemporary renditions of some of
these songs and instrumentals, you might want to explore these as possible sources through which that
specific music was leaked into the larger universe (a world-famous Aaron Copland piece and some
Grateful Dead songs jump to mind here).
I have addressed the first (OSC) in detail at the outset while references to the others appear under the
annotations to individual recordings.
1. Book: Lomax, John and Alan. Our Singing Country: A Second Volume of American Ballads and
Folk Songs. (New York: MacMillan, 1941)
2. Recordings: AFS or AAFS L1-L63 Long Play (LP) records
3. Recordings: Music of Kentucky: Early American Rural Classics 1927-1937 (2 CDs, Yazoo,
1995)
4. Recordings: Kentucky Mountain Music: Classic Recordings of the 1920s & 1930s (7 CDs,
Yazoo, 2003)
The references to Child, Roud, and Laws numbers for ballads and lyric folk songs refer to:
1
Ajay Kalra
Major online indexes referenced herein and recommended for any scholar undertaking further research:
A more extensive list of folk song and recording resources can be found at:
Anyone seeking to dig deeper into the Lomax Kentucky Collection should be familiar with Our Singing
Country (OSC). It was the first significant publication that the Lomaxes released following the 1934
compendium American Ballads and Folk Songs and the subsequent field trips that resulted in most of
these recordings. Within Southern folk music, the regard in which the Lomaxes held Kentucky should
become apparent after considering the prominent place accorded these recordings in this classic book.
Including the widely influential version of Bonapartes Retreat (Bonyparte) by William Stepp, I have
identified twenty-eight recordings from these 1930s field trips that were transcribed and published in
OSC. My own annotations and commentary to these appears below.
In addition, there were at least another fourteen musical pieces published in that volume, variants of
which (in some cases multiple versions) were also recorded in KentuckyI provide commentary on
these next.
Third, across its pages OSC also sprinkled transcriptions of historical contexts offered in the interviews
(which often precede or follow a performance) by the Kentucky musicians in the recordings in this
collection.
List of the recordings from this collection included, transcribed, and annotated in Our Singing
Country (OSC) (Lomax and Lomax, 1941). I supply brief descriptions and analyses here:
Bonyparte (Bonapartes Retreat): William Stepp (2 other versions are also included in this
collection).
o Stepps version and Ruth Seegers transcription from OSC became the basis of
Hoedown in Aaron Coplands ballet Rodeo and later English progressive rock band
Emerson, Lake, and Palmers Rodeo.
2
Ajay Kalra
Callahan (The Last of Callahan): Luther Strong (6 other versions of the piece included):
o Very popular fiddle tune. Strongs version also included in Titons Old-Time Kentucky
Fiddle Tunes, albeit with a different annotation than in OSC. Strong (and Lomaxs
annotation) linked the tune to local KY history, while Titon traces it back to the Old
World.
o Pete Steele learnt about Callahan from his father and Lomax queries him about the
particulars of the story, about which he turns out to be not very clear.
Lynchburg Town: James Mullins (2 other versions included: Pete Steele, George Roark)
o Banjo tune, with melody somewhat similar to Bile Them Cabbage Down. The lyrics
revolve around a master and slave; so African American connections of the tune might be
worth exploring. Tunearch.org traces it back at least to minstrelsy in 1848, when Frank
Spencer, a writer for the Christy Minstrels, copyrighted The Original Lynchburg Town.
Uncle Hardy Lige Morgans Hog Song (Identified as Hog Rogues on the Harricane in OSC):
Theophilus Hoskins.
o Hoskins description of the context at the end of this recording is transcribed in OSC.
3
Ajay Kalra
Lolly Too-Dum: Abner Boggs (2 other recordings in this collection: Nell Hampton and Pine
Mountain Settlement School students)
o OSC category: Courting Song
o Further annotations: see under COMIC SONGS
Where Have You Been My Good Old Man: Hazel Hudson (Another version also included in this
collection: Nancy Stacy)
o OSC category: Courting Song
o Alternate titles/related songs: My Good Old Man, The Best Old Feller in the World
o Roud 240
o Earliest publication: 1885
o Popular versions include an a capella one by Peggy and Mike Seeger, recorded just
before Mikes death, and featured on an album of songs (Fly Down Little Bird, 2008)
they had learnt from their mother, Ruth Crawford Seeger. Ruth has been the transcriber
for OSC.
Ive Rambled this Country both Early and Late: J.M. Mullins
o Roud 1795
o Alternate titles/related songs: Last Friday Evening, Pretty Polly (not the famous
murder ballad), Green Grow the Laurels, I Waited My Hours
o Perhaps a native American narrative song with floating lyrics shared with Green grow
the Laurels/Lilacs and other songs of betrayal by a wife.
o Earliest recording: 1904, Belden, Missouri. Related songs also collected by Cecil Sharpe
and in Nova Scotia.
o Lomax KY Collection also has another version by Eliza Pace.
o Lomax KY also has another recording by Ella D. Sibert titled When I first come to this
country, which is a variant of this song.
East Virginia: Walter Williams (An outstanding banjo player! And a classic mountain singer!)
o Other versions included in this collection: Dorothy and Ellen Wilson (2 voices with
guitar accompaniment)
4
Ajay Kalra
The Lady of Carlisle: Basil May (Key: C major; transcription key: G major)
o Vocal with guitar accompaniment
o Roud 396, Laws O25
o Old English Ballad, not included in Child
o Alternate titles/related songs: The Lions Den, The Fan, The Ladys Fan, The Glove,
Two Brothers in the Army
o Earliest publication: 1807, broadside, National Library of Ireland
o Further information: fresnostate.edu
o Lomax KY also has an a capella version by Clay Walters (Key: C major, sounds slightly
flat on the recording)
o This particular recording was included on AAFS L1 and on Yazoos The Music of
Kentucky, CD 2. Kentucky fiddle music aficionado Guthrie Meades liner notes mention
that according to his wife Ethel May, Basil Mays shyness might have been the reason
that despite his singing talent, he made only one recording for Lomax.
5
Ajay Kalra
Texas Rangers:
o A song (may be considered a native American ballad) from after the Civil War. The LP
record AFS L28 with liner notes by Duncan Emrich featured a version from 1942 from
Alpine, Texas, collected by John Lomax. Emrich describes it as presumably written
during or immediately after the Civil War by a fifteen-year old soldier in the Arizona
brigade. The liner notes are also available here:
https://www.loc.gov/folklife/LP/CowboySongs_opt.pdf
o Lomax KY Collection features two versions: Aunt Molly Jackson singing a capella and a
vocal trio with guitar featuring Pauline Fannin, Gladys Wilder, and Dawn Leda Lewis.
OSC features the latters transcription (Key: C major, which is also the sounded
key on the recording) with the spelling Pauline Ferris.
6
Ajay Kalra
o Key: G major
Darling Corey/Cora
o Roud 5723
o Famous Appalachian song first collected and published by Cecil Sharp in 1918 in NC and
first released commercially in 1927 by Kentuckians Buell Kazee and B.F. Shelton, the
latter as part of the famous Bristol Sessions.
o OSC features a transcription ascribed to Aunt Molly Jackson, but the recording featured
on Lomax KY collection under that title is another song, sung in A major. From the
discernible lyrics, I am unable to place that song. Its melody invokes a major key version
of Reubens Train/ Train 45.
o Lomax KY also features 4 other versions:
Maynard Britton (Gb): Vocal with guitar accompaniment.
Clay Begley (Gb): A capella.
Bill Atkins (Db): Vocal with chorus (unidentified singers) and guitar.
Pete Steele (Db): Vocal with banjo.
o A version by Pleaz Mobley of Manchester, KY, recorded at Renfro Valley, KY, appeared
on AAS L14 LP, and the liner notes by Duncan Emrich call it a white blues of the
hills, a genre in which considerable study remains to be done. Mobley clarifies that
the pronunciation is cory and not cora.
7
Ajay Kalra
List of the pieces included, transcribed, and annotated in Our Singing Country (Lomax and
Lomax, 1941) versions of which Lomax et al also recorded from informants in KY in the 1930s
(and now included in this collection). (The versions in this collection might be compared those
largely contemporaneous versions collected from elsewhere by Lomax et al.)
The Romish Lady (Composer and source: William Walker, The Southern Harmony) (Artist: Mrs.
Minnie Floyd, SC, 1937)
o The two versions in Lomax KY collection are by Boyd Hoskins and Monroe Gevedon.
The piece should perhaps be (cross)-listed under Religious Songs.
Old Shoes and Leggins (Artist: Alex Dunsford, Galax, VA, 1937, and Angie Clark, Mullins, SC)
o The KY collections includes versions by May Feltner, Nancy Boggs, and Aunt Molly
Jackson. OSC transcribes Jacksons discussion of the song from the recording included
here.
Devilish Mary (Artist: Jesse Staffod, Crowley, LA, 1934, and Mrs. S.P. Griffin, Newberry, FL)
o The Lomax KY Collection includes a version by George Roark, accompanying himself
on banjo.
o OSC includes transcription of Aunt Molly Jackson explaining a specific domestic fight
context of the song in coal mining Kentucky (the recorded source of which is not clear,
nor is the exact relation to this lyric).
o A version by Paul Rogers of Paint Lick, KY, recorded in 1946 at Renfro Valley Folk
Festival, appeared on the AFS L14 LP Anglo-American Songs and Ballads. The liner
notes explain the domestic spat context.
o Clearly a very popular song in early hillbilly (Skillet Lickers) and folk and old-time
revival (Burl Ives, Pete Seeger, Odetta, Cisco Houston, Bob Dylan, Highwoods String
Band, Grandpa Jones) circles.
8
Ajay Kalra
My Old True Love (Artists: Mrs. Gladys Helen Davis and Mrs. Flossie Ellen Evans, Galax, VA,
1937) and Fare Ye Well, My Darlin (Artist: Mrs. Minne Floyd, Murrells Inlet, SC, 1937)
o The Lomax KY Collection includes a version by J.M. Mullins under the title, Fare You
Well, My Own True Love.
o The lyric here is somewhat related to songs later popularized by Bob Dylan as Farewell
and Tony Rice as Fare Thee Well.
Ive Rambled this Country Both Earlye and Late (Artist: James Mullins, Morgan County, KY,
1939)
o The Lomax KY collection does not seem to include this 1939 recording but features a
1937 a capella recording by Eliza Pace.
Tee Roo
o A song related to The Farmers Curst Wife (Child 278, Roud 160) sung on Lomax KY
by Aunt Molly. OSC added to the transcription of Tee Roo a transcription of Jackson
describing the context of farmer scaring his wife that is featured at the end of this
particular recording of The Farmers Curst Wife.
o Further notes: fresnostate.edu.
John Henry (Note: needs to be identified across all versions as blues ballad and African
American ballad, irrespective of whether it is played as a fiddle tune or banjo tune or guitar
instrumental. Originally, it was also not a lyric song, as we have identified on many
versions, but a narrative folk song or ballad. In some versions, however, the linearity of the
narrative might be altered.)
o OSC featured a transcription of Leadbellys talk about John Henry as a double-jointed
man. It next features a distinct Western variant of the African American ballad sung by
Arthur Blunt of Pine Bluff, Arkansas.
o Lomax KY Collection features a slide guitar version (without vocals) by famous banjoist
Pete Steele, recorded in Ohio. The sounding key is F# or Gb, likely in an open chordal
tuning with the melody played on the highest string.
9
Ajay Kalra
o J.F. Collett also sings a version accompanied on slide guitar in the key of E, the more
common key for the song.
o Theophilus G. Hoskins plays a fiddle version (Key: F)
o Winnie Pratter offers a banjo instrumental version (Key: E)
o J.M. Mullins sings a version self-accompanied on banjo. (Key: Bb)
o Bill Atkins sings a version self-accompanied on the guitar (Key: Ab)
o George Roark sings a version self-accompanied on the banjo (Key: Ab)
o One version by Aunt Molly Jackson (AFS0828A3), in fact, is a rendition of Rye
Whiskey
Harvey Logan:
o (note: This is credited to Walt Gibson on the website. On the copy of the original LOC
card, the same number AFS 1548A2 credits the singer as Jimmie Morris, which seems to
be the accurate ascription.)
o A native American outlaw ballad about a Western outlaw associated with both Jesse
James and Butch Cassidy.
o There are many interesting aspects to the recording, the topic, and its relationship to KY.
o Not enough information about Harvey Logan was available before the recent publication
of a monograph by Mark T. Smokov, He Rode with Butch and Sundance: The Story of
Harvey Kid Curry Logan (University of North Texas Press, 2012).
10
Ajay Kalra
o The Lomax recording of Jimmie Morris in Hazard, KY, in Oct 1937 could be the first
recording of this song.
o It was popular during the folk revival and Paul Clayton and a rediscovered Dock Boggs
recorded versions.
o It is worth noting that both the a capella version here (likely Morriss and not Gibsons)
and the instrumentally accompanied folk revival versions feature the I-vi-II-V chord
progressionin this recording the chords are implied by the melody, and it is not very
usual to have such a ragtime-associated progression to feature in folk field recordings.
Its appearance on an a capella vocal evidences the influence of popular music and
African American music on rural Kentucky music.
o Note: this is the chord progression most famously associated in white rural Southern
music with the song Salty Dog (Blues), which also has a ragtime and early jazz
provenance through Papa Charlie Jackson (1924) and Clara Smith (1926).
Po Lazus
o The song transcribed in OSC was sung as a work song, including by (presumably African
American) prison gangs at the Tucker Farm in Little Rock, Arkansas. It is neither the
latterly famous version featured in O Brother! Where Art Thou? nor is it the version of
Dives and Lazarus (Child 56) that appears in the present Lomax Kentucky Collection, as
sung by Aunt Molly Jackson.
o The connections between the three might be further explored.
The Music of Kentucky: Early American Rural Classics 1927-1937 (2CDs, Yazoo, 1995)
Volume 1
Volume 2
11
Ajay Kalra
Kentucky Mountain Music: Classic Recordings of the 1920s and 1930s. Yazoo, 2003.
Includes:
CD 1
4. Shortbuckle Roark & Family: I Truly Understand You Love Another Man (Commercial version
from 1928)
8. Robert L. Day (J.W.s brother): The Rowan County Crew
17. J.W. Day: Grand Hornpipe
18. Walter Williams: East Virginia
20. Pete Steele: Pretty Polly
21. Justus Begley: Run Banjo
CD 2
CD 3
CD 4
12
Ajay Kalra
CD 5
CD 6
CD 7
BANJO
13
Ajay Kalra
14
Ajay Kalra
AlabamMullins, J.M.
Banjo and vocal
Sounds in Eb major
15
Ajay Kalra
CallahanPrater, Winnie
Banjo instrumental
Key: Sounds between G# and A major
Tune bears resemblance to McKinley Ashers recording of the same title in collection, albeit
Praters version proceeds to higher notes.
DinahMullins, J.M.
Vocal with banjo accompaniment
Key: D major.
16
Ajay Kalra
17
Ajay Kalra
HornpipeBegley, Justus
Banjo instrumental
Key: C# major
A distinctive tune with a melody that, in the A part, descends diatonically from the fifth degree
on the high strings and guides the chord progression.
18
Ajay Kalra
Hook and Line/I Wish to the Lord Id Never Been BornAsher, McKinley
Banjo instrumental(s)
Key: A# major
Compare with other instrumental titled Hook and Line in D minor by Justus Begley in this
collection.
CallahanAsher, McKinley
Banjo instrumental
Key: G# major
Compare with Winnie Praters recording with same title in this collection.
19
Ajay Kalra
20
Ajay Kalra
Very popular number since 1800s. In some versions, it seems related in melody and lyrical
motifs to Dan Emmetts Old Dan Tucker, a minstrelsy song from 1848.
The Dictionary of African American Slavery (Miller and Smith: 255) mentions this among tunes,
including Old Dan Tucker, which African American slave musicianers used to play.
In recent years, covered by Ralph Stanley, Ricky Skaggs, and the Old Crow Medicine Show.
ReubenRoark, George
Vocal with banjo
Key: D# major
Archie Green edited and furnished liner notes for AFS recording (AFS L61, 1968) Railroad
Songs and Ballads.
Green confirms the relationship, lyrically and melodically, between Reubens Train, Train
45, and Reuben.
A number of commercial recordings in early hillbilly music might have added to the numbers
popularity. These include recordings by Fiddlin John Carson (Im Nine Hundred Miles Away
from Home), Wade Mainer (Old Reuben)
Roark calls the song Crazy (train) while the mentioned AFS collection featured a field
recording from VA titled The Train is Off the Track.
CallahanSteele, Pete
Banjo instrumental
Key: A major
See notes under OSC
21
Ajay Kalra
open D major tuning and follows from the The Siege of Sebastopol. The Open G major tuning
is called the Spanish tuning and is descended from its use in the sheet music for Spanish
Fandango. Thus, on the guitar it is largely played in G major. It is also commonly in time and
played at a much slower tempo.
Nonetheless, Steeles melody and playing is beautiful.
HoedownSteele, Pete
Banjo instrumental
Key: G# major
Discussion at 2:23
BAWDY SONGS
22
Ajay Kalra
Melody and functional harmony close to a number of hillbilly 16-bar blues-related songs such as
"Crawdad Song," "New River Train," "Lay Down this Old Guitar," and "Going Down the Road
Feeling Bad."
23
Ajay Kalra
BLUES
COMIC SONG
24
Ajay Kalra
The Farmers Curst Wife (The Devil and the Farmers Wife)Jackson, Aunt Molly
A capella
Key: G# major.
3:00: Lomax asks, Molly, who sung that song, man or woman? Jackson responds.
25
Ajay Kalra
26
Ajay Kalra
27
Ajay Kalra
28
Ajay Kalra
Other recordings in LKC include those by Abner Boggs (mentioned above) and Nell Hampton
A version titled Rolly Trudum collected from Mrs. May K. Springfield at Springfield,
Missouri, in 1941, was included on AAFS L12, and the brief liner notes refer the reader to: H.M.
Belden, Ballads and Songs Collected by the Missouri Folk-Lore Society, University of Missouri
Studies, vol. xv, no. 1, 1940.
29
Ajay Kalra
30
Ajay Kalra
The song was popular and inspired sequels and answer songs: Uncle Quit Work Too and
Fathers got a Job.
In country music, it was recorded by Riley Puckett in 1926.
Covered later by comedian Groucho Marx.
Also covered in other countries and languages.
31
Ajay Kalra
I Was Born about Four Thousand Years Ago (or Ten Thousand)Jackson, Aunt Molly
A capella vocal
Key: D major
Popular song, sung to a melody similar to that of Shell be coming round the Mountain.
Song has appeared in other folk song collections (for instance Carl Sandburgs The American
Songbag) and field recordings (Max Hunter Collection at Missouri State University) while also
being popular in commercial music (recorded by Elvis Presley and Tommy Makem, the latter
titling it The Liar.)
Humorous tall tale song
32
Ajay Kalra
INSTRUMENTAL
5 recordings by Ambrose Deaton on the Appalachian dulcimer: Wreck of the Old 97, Red Wing,
Goo Goo Eyes, Casey Jones, The Girl I Left Behind
o All in the Key of F majorlikely the open tuning of the dulcimer
o The last tune is titled unidentified dulcimer tune, but was originally identified on AFS
card as The Girl I Left Behind. It does have elements of that melody and we should
restore the title with a cautionary note.
33
Ajay Kalra
34
Ajay Kalra
35
Ajay Kalra
Key: A
Also see another version categorized under BANJO: Fair You Well My Blue Eyed Girl
Begley, Justus
36
Ajay Kalra
SENTIMENTAL SONGS
37
Ajay Kalra
38
Ajay Kalra
39
Ajay Kalra
Both blues-influenced
Key: F
40
Ajay Kalra
41
Ajay Kalra
AlabamMullins, J.M.
Key: D# major
Vocal with banjo
TennesseeMullins, J.M.
See under BANJO
42
Ajay Kalra
Song unrelated to the famous song and tune with that title
Mullins seems extremely prolific at inventing song titles and lyrics and weaving them in with
floating lyrics while playing a rhythm-oriented banjo style that would serve almost any melody.
His vocal melodies, in any case, have much fewer variations than one would expect from such a
vast repertoire of songs. A curiosity, at the very least.
43
Ajay Kalra
Down in Tennessee ValleyLewis, Henrietta and Roberta (Girls aged 11 and 12)
See POPULAR COUNTRY SONGS
44
Ajay Kalra
45
Ajay Kalra
I Am a Man of Constant Sorrow (2 parts AFS 1522B1 and B2; not specifically identified as #1 and 2
in the title)Britton, Maynard
Roud 499
Key: B major (likely intended in C major)
Vocal with guitar
Sung in a relaxed baritone voice, reminiscent more of cowboy songs than hillbilly
Now the most widely recognized mountain song across the world, after the success of Dan
Tyminskis version with the Union Station featured on the soundtrack of O Brother! Where Art
Thou? Also one of the most famous songs to mention Kentucky in the lyrics. The most popular
bluegrass arrangement, and the one that inspired the contemporary one, was the Stanley
Brothers.
Earliest publication dates from 1913 in Richard Burnetts songbook; earliest recording from
Emry Arthur in 1928.
DinahHoskins, Theophilus
Vocal with banjo
Key: Bb major
Major genre designation should match the one used for J.M. Mullinss version (BANJO) in this
collection.
46
Ajay Kalra
The song has a 16-bar blues form common to a number of early hillbilly songs, including
Worried (Man) Blues, New River Train, and Lay Down My Old Guitar
47
Ajay Kalra
Among the most legendary songs collected in Appalachia from white Americans, while redolent
of African American tradition. I am not sure, if any African American source has been
specifically nailed, although much has been written about this song.
The earliest recording in white tradition is Clarence Ashleys from 1933. Other early recordings
include: The Callahan Brothers Rounders Luck (1935)
Appalachian versions, into the folk revival with Doc Watson, would continue to be in major
keys. (Ashleys was an 8- or 16-bar blues variant in E major, with a I-V-I-I blue yodel-like tag,
albeit without a sung yodel. The Callahans was in F major.)
Texas Alexanders 1928 recording Rising Sun is an unrelated 12-bar blues; Darby and
Tarltons 1931 recording Rising Sun Blues is a 12-bar blues with a yodel tag a la Jimmie
Rodgerss blue yodels, but is not related to Ashleys song.
Paul J Stamler at fresnostate states that Ashley learned his version from his grandmother
(original source unspecified).
48
Ajay Kalra
dandy cartoon, was published by Ashbel Stoddard publishers in 1827 in Hudson, NY, and is
available online through the Duke University Library.
o For further scholarly consideration, please check: Barbara Lewis, Daddy Blue: The
Evolution of the Dark Daddy, in Inside the Minstrel Mask: Readings in Nineteenth-
Century Minstrelsy, ed. Annemarie Bean, James V. Hatch, and Brooks McNamara
(Middletown: Wesleyan University Press, 1996), 257.
Garrisons whistling also suggests a popular novelty genre source
49
Ajay Kalra
50
Ajay Kalra
StagoleeMartin, Bert
Vocal with guitar
Key: B major
Laws I15, Roud 4183
Features a I-VI-II-V chord progression typical of ragtime influenced music (especially guitar
music) of the 1910s through 1930s. It might be worthwhile to investigate which (if any)
commercial version first set the song to this chord progression and might be the proximate
influence here.
The song is among the best known blues ballads from the turn of the century, alongside John
Hardy and Frankie and Johnny and the older John Henry. The event that inspired the lyric
is from 1895 and Waltz et al put the earliest publication in 1903. It was first recorded as an
instrumental by (proto-jazz) orchestras in 1923 and 1924 including Fred Warings
Pennsylvanians, Frank Westphal and his Orchestra, and Herb Weidoefts Cinderella Orchestra.
Ma Raineys 1925 version might be the first vocal recording
Sol Hoopii recorded a Hawaiian version in 1926
The rural blues and hillbilly versions were recorded later.
o Frank Hutchisons (recorded Sep 28, 1926) and David Millers 1927 record releases are
among the first hillbilly pressings.
o A number of African American rural blues/jug band versions were recorded from 1927
starting with Furry Lewis, Clive Reed
It might be noted that while John Hardy features a 16-bar blues structure and Frankie and
Johnny features a 12-bar blues structure, both predating the popularity of blues in popular
music, Staggerlee has been recorded with varying structure and chord progressions. A slightly
modified I-IV-V 12-bar blues chord progression is still the commonest.
For other recordings in this collection with a popular, ragtime-influenced chord progression, see
Harvey Logan and Candy Man
A better categorization would be: blues ballad, African American ballad, popular song (not lyric
song)
A monograph by Cecil Brown, Stagolee Shot Billy (Harvard University Press, 2003), delves
deeper. Among other aspects, it examines the fascination of white rural musicians with badman
figures of African American blues ballads. Robert Gordon, a UC Berkley English professor (and
later founder of Archive of American Folk Song at LOC), was so taken with this fascination that
he specifically called out to readers of the cowboy Western magazine, Adventure, to collect
versions of Stagolee in the West.
51
Ajay Kalra
52
Ajay Kalra
The song has long been very popular and has inspired not only many versions but also many
other songs, including songs for three US presidential campaigns.
Earliest publication dates to 1838 in P
The meter suggests British Isles, perhaps Irish, origin
53
Ajay Kalra
It might be noted that Coal Creek later became Lake City and is now Rocky Top, TN.
The Mud FenceStepp, William Hamilton (fiddle) and Walter Williams (banjo)
Key: Major. Sounds slightly higher than C major on the recording. Might have been played in
the intended key of D. Possibly in an altered (or cross) tuning.
Alternate titles and related tunes: Drunken Billy Goat, Rocky Mountain Goat, Cricket on
the Hearth, Railroad Through the Rocky Mountains, Ride the Goat Over the Mountain,
Marmadukes Horpipe.
54
Ajay Kalra
FIDDLE (Overview)
I am not a fiddle player, although for two decades I have been attempting to play what were originally
American fiddle tunes transposed to the guitar, mandolin, and dobro. What I have attempted here is to
help a fiddle tune researcher to make quicker sense of what all treasures might await their more focused
and better informed scrutiny.
List of Fiddle Tunes or rather of recordings classified or cross-listed under the rubric Fiddle Tunes.
The order is the same as the one in which they appear in the search results under Genre: Fiddle.:
55
Ajay Kalra
Lost Girl
Bonapartes Retreat
Pretty Polly
Flop Eared Mule (and #1)
Waynesborough
Sourwood Mountain
The Last of Sizemore
The Last of Callahan
Ricketts Hornpipe
Leather Breeches
Billy in the Low Ground
Jack of Diamonds
Wagoner
Glory in the Meeting House (X2)
The Ways of the World
Cacklin Hen
Soldiers Joy
The Old Hen Cackled
The Hog Wet through the Fence, Yoke and all
The Hog-Eyed Man
Black-eyed Susie
Give the Fiddler a Dram
Hickory Jack
Roll on Buddy
Arkansas Traveler
Slidin Jenny
Adeline
Nig Inch Along
Old Joe Clark
Sally Goodin
Leather Breeches
Hog-Eyed Man
Pretty Polly
Bonapartes Retreat
Billy in the Low Ground
Glory in the Meeting House
Hickory Jack
Cacklin Hen
Leather Breeches
Sally Goodin
Billy in the Low Ground
I Love Somebody
Callahan
Leather Breeches
56
Ajay Kalra
57
Ajay Kalra
Cumberland Gap
Groundhog
The Hog-eyed Man
The Niggers Wedding
Dr. Humphreys Jig
No Corn on Tygarts
Sweet Susan
The Devils Dream
Hell and Scissors
Billy in the Low Ground
Cindy
Old Joe Clark
Sourwood Mountain
The above list of Fiddle Tunes, with artist (largely retaining the order in which they appear on the
website with a few minor adjustments where two listed primary artists appear alternatingly in the above
list):
58
Ajay Kalra
Strong, Luther
Cripple Creek
Liza Jane
Cumberland Gap
Lost Girl
Bonapartes Retreat
Pretty Polly
Baker, Bev
Flop Eared Mule (and #1)
Waynesborough
Strong, Luther
Sourwood Mountain
The Last of Sizemore
The Last of Callahan
Ricketts Hornpipe
Leather Breeches
Billy in the Low Ground
Baker, Bev
Jack of Diamonds
Wagoner
Glory in the Meeting House
Strong, Luther
Glory in the Meeting House
The Ways of the World
Cacklin Hen
Soldiers Joy
The Old Hen Cackled
The Hog Wet through the Fence, Yoke and all
The Hog-Eyed Man
Black-eyed Susie
Give the Fiddler a Dram
Hickory Jack
Roll on Buddy
Arkansas Traveler
Slidin Jenny
Adeline
Nig Inch Along
59
Ajay Kalra
Asher, Boyd
Leather Breeches
Hog-Eyed Man
Pretty Polly
Bonapartes Retreat
Billy in the Low Ground
Glory in the Meeting House
Hickory Jack
Cacklin Hen
Leather Breeches
Hammock, Jimmie
Sally Goodin
Billy in the Low Ground
I Love Somebody
Asher, Boyd
Callahan
Leather Breeches
Nigger Inch Along
Old Joe Clark
Sourwood Mountain
Youve Got to Walk that Lonesome Valley
Old Christmas
The Last of Sizemore
Give the Fiddler a Dram
Sally Goodin (#2 and #1)
Asher, McKinley
Cripple Creek
Hoskins, Theophilus G.
Natchez Under the Hill
Unidentified Fiddle Tune
Going Down the Road Feeling Bad
John Henry
Pretty Polly
Nigger Inch Along
Lost Girl
Wagoner (_ and #1)
Fly Around My Blue Eyed Girl
60
Ajay Kalra
Sourwood Mountain
Pace, Eliza
I Wonder Where My True Love is
Nicholson, George C.
Prettiest Little Girl in the Country-O
Sourwood Mountain
Callahan
Old Christmas
Old Mr. Moore
Sally Goodin
Blue Bonnet
Old Joe Clark
Nicholson, George N.
Bonapartes Retreat
Skeens, Ray
The Little Stream of Whiskey
Skeens, Lee
Cluck Old Hen
Dance All Night with a Bottle in Your Hand (Give the Fiddler a Dram)
Rye Whiskey (Drunken Hiccups/Way Up on Cinch Mountain)
Pretty Polly
The Cherry Tree Carol
Hoskins, Theophilus G.
Sourwood Mountain
Glory in the Meeting House
Arkansas Traveler (Part 1 and 2)
Cumberland Gap/Buck Creek Girls
Charming Betsy
Cumberland Gap
Groundhog
The Hog-eyed Man
61
Ajay Kalra
FREQUENCY: Among the 133 recordings listed under fiddle tunes (a few would actually be better
described as lyric songs or ballads with fiddle accompaniment), the following appear with greatest
frequency. Most of these are widely known titles:
Sourwood Mountain: 6 versions (Strong, B. Asher, Hoskins, L.N. Garrison, G.C. Nicholson,
Howard)
Sally Goodin: 5 (Stepp, Strong, Hammock, B. Asher, G.C. Nicholson)
Billy in the Low Ground: 4 (Strong, B. Asher, Hammock, Setters)
Bonapartes Retreat: 4 (Stepp, Strong, B. Asher, G.N. Nicholson)
Old Joe Clark: 4 (Strong, B. Asher, G.C. Nicholson, Howard)
(The Last of) Callahan: 4 (Stepp, Strong, B. Asher, G.C. Nicholson)
Pretty Polly: 4 (Strong, B. Asher, Hoskins, L.Skeens)
Glory in the Meeting House: 4 (Baker, Strong, B. Asher, Hoskins)
Drunken Hiccups/Rye Whiskey/Jack of Diamonds: 3
Arkansas Traveler: 3 (Strong, L N Garrison, Hoskins)
Give the Fiddler a Dram: 3 (Strong, B. Asher, L. Skeens)
Cacklin Hen: 3 (Stepp, Strong, B. Asher)
Hog-eyed Man: 3 (Strong, B. Asher, Hoskins)
Nigger Inch Along: 3 (Strong, B. Asher, Hoskins)
The Ways of the World: 2 (Stepp, Strong)
Cripple Creek: 2 (Strong, M. Asher)
Cumberland Gap: 2 (Strong, Hoskins)
Leather Breeches: 2 (Strong, B. Asher)
Wagoner: 2 (Baker, Hoskins)
Hickory Jack: 2 (Strong, B. Asher)
The Last of Sizemore: 2 (Strong, B. Asher)
62
Ajay Kalra
A number of other popular titles, at least now widely known, appear once, including:
Jeff Titons aforementioned book, Old-Time Kentucky Fiddle Tunes, is the best existing treatment of
Kentucky fiddle tunes and features transcriptions and historical plus analytical annotations of the
following tunes from this very collection. I have added here some observations to some of the titles,
based on my preliminary listening and research on these tunes:
Bonyparte (Bonapartes Retreat): Stepp (Key: D major) (The best known of this whole batch
of recordings as Stepps performance was deemed stellar, transcribed by Ruth Seeger and
included in the Lomaxes Our Singing Country, picked up by Aaron Copland as the melodic
basis of his Hoedown in the famous ballet Rodeo. The tune was later also used by the British
progressive rock band Emerson, Lake, and Palmer in their tune Hoedown and used a number
of time on TV commercials. Interestingly, this very popular tune is also played by three other
fiddlers in this collection, each sounding like the familiar versions of this famous melody, even if
sped up by two of the other fiddlersStrong and Asherto a tempo similar to Stepps. The
distinctiveness of Stepps interpretation is most remarkable in the two different interpretations of
the B part, especially in the second go around where he plays the melody an octave higher
against lower string drones, emulating the sound of highland bagpipes. The high melody in that
63
Ajay Kalra
part, in Stepps recording, is redolent of the B part melody of Soldiers Joy. It might be noted
that while the tune is often played in D major, this is not the key in which it sounds in these
recordings, where the sounding key in different versions is thusStepp: C major, Strong: D#
major, Asher: Db major; Nicholson: G# major) (Just his one relatively well-scrutinized tune from
this collection suggests there is much more to be gained by digging in deeper.)
Dolly: Stepp (Key: E major) (Interestingly, Titon describes and transcribes it in G major, from
this very recording.)
Glory in the Meeting House: Strong (Key: E major) (Titon describes this as a local tune from
the Kentucky River basin. He describes and transcribes this version in D major.) (The three other
recordings of this title in this collection are: Boyd Asher: Db major; Bev Baker: E major. Titon
mentions that the tune was played in 1919 by Bev Baker at the Berea College fiddle contest.)
Hickory Jack: Strong (Key: E Dorian) (Titon identifies it as a local tune from southeastern KY
coal fields, closely related to another Appalachian tune, The Route)
The Hog Went Through the Fence, Yoke and All: Strong
Titons notes on some other tunes (transcribed in his book from versions from other recorded
collections) that do also appear in this collection are also useful. These include
64
Ajay Kalra
Titon also gives brief biographies of three of the fiddlers included here:
Day, James W.
Stepp, William
Strong, Luther
Any researcher interested in local and rarer fiddle tunes and titles may further investigate the remaining
titles in this collection.
BALLAD
Ballads are the best known of Appalachian traditional music genres as well as being historically the
most sought by collectors. Not surprisingly, the ballad rubric subsumes the greatest number of
recordings in the Lomax Collection398 recordings in all.
Following is a list of all the recordings in the order they appear on the website under Browse by Genre:
Ballads. The initial ones by Aunt Molly Jackson feature annotations here that supply some ideas for
perhaps a more elaborate future project focusing on ballads in Depression-era Kentucky.
65
Ajay Kalra
66
Ajay Kalra
o Other versions in this collection: Hulda Roberts, Arthur Williams, Mrs. Cottongim/Bill
Bundy, Nancy Boggs, and Alan Lomax himself.
o Inside Bluegrass, October 1997, published a history by Lyle Lofgren, available online at:
http://www.lizlyle.lofgrens.org/RmOlSngs/RTOS-ThreeBabes.html
o Other field recorded versions can be found online at Missouri State Universitys Max
Hunter Collection.
Dog and Gun (2 parts; with commentary on ballads in the mountains)Aunt Molly Jackson
o Alternate titles and related songs: The Golden Glove
o Roud 141; Laws N20
o Lomax asks about why mountain singers sang about lords and ladies, and Jackson talks
about a preference for local lyrics. She also talks about English themes and Old World
texts.
67
Ajay Kalra
68
Ajay Kalra
Lord Bateman
Golden Glove (#1 and 2)
Since you have Disdained me, Ill Cross the Briny Sea
Lord Bateman (2 parts)
Loving Henry (2 parts)
The Cherry Tree Carol
The Butchers Boy
I First came to this Country in 1865
Harvey Logan
The Brown Girl
Fair Florella
The Weeping Willow Tree (2 parts)
The Murder of Virgil Gibson
The Butchers Boy (2 parts)
Hiram Hubbard
Fair Florella
Hiram Hubbard (#1 and 2)
Lady Gay
John McCardner
As I Went Out for a Ramble
The Knoxville Girl
Barbara Allen
Henry of Knoxville
The Bailiffs Daughter of Islington
The Wreck on the Somerset Road (2 parts)
The Golden Willow Tree (2 parts)
The Harlan County Blues
Jake Leg Blues
Darling Cora (2 parts)
The Gambling Man
The J.B. Marcum Song (#1 and 2)
When I First Came to this Country in 1865
The Wife Wrapt in Wethers Skin
Lovely Nancy
Spruce Pine Hog Song
Uncle Hardy Lige Morgans Hog Song
The Wife Wrapt in Wehters Skin
Ive Rambled this Country Both Early and Late
The Brown Girl
Johnnys on the Sea (2 parts) (#1 and 2) (Total=3)
Sweet Islands Hill (2 parts)
Lady Margaret and Sweet William (2 parts)
The Blind Child
Lady Gay
69
Ajay Kalra
Loving Henry
Poison in a Glass of Wine
The Brisk Young Soldier
Lord Thomas and Fair Eleanor
The Two Sisters
The Two Sisters (2 parts)
John Reilly
Lady Margaret and Sweet William
The Murder of George Thompson
Swafford Branch Stills
The Peanut Farm
The Death of Mary Jane Martin
Six Kings Daughters
Rowan County Trouble
The Romish Lady
The Knoxville Girl (2 parts)
Barbara Allen (2 parts)
The Little Mohee (2 parts)
Poison in a Glass of Wine
Omie Wise
Charming Beauty Bright
Loving Henry
The Cruel Mother (2 parts)
The Lady Leroy (2 fragments)
Poison in a Glass of Wine
Pretty Polly
The Cowgirl
The Wreck of Old Number Nine
Bert Martin, Moonshiner
The Little Mohee
The Silver Dagger
Im Going Out to the City
Poor Little Joe
Pearl Bryant
Lady Gay
When I First Came to this Country
Lady Margaret and Sweet Williams (3 parts)
Lord Daniel (2 parts)
Pretty Fair Maid in the Garden
The Wife Wrapt in Wehthers Skin
Pretty Saro
Lady Margaret and Sweet William
Green Grows the Laurel
Loving Nancy (2 parts)
70
Ajay Kalra
71
Ajay Kalra
72
Ajay Kalra
Henry Lee
Floyd Frazier
The Burglar and the Old Maid
George Collins
The Maid Freed from the Gallows (2 parts)
True and Faithful Brakeman
Scott Jackson and Pearl Bryant
Jackie Frazier
The False Young Man (2 parts)
Barbara Allen
John Reilly
Sweetheart in the Army
Barbara Allen
Mary on the Wild Moor
The Quakers Courtship
Pretty Fair Miss All in Her Garden
Omie Wise
The Dying Cowboy
Fair Lander
The Little Pig
Jimmy Randall
Sidney Allen
Kenny Wagners Surrender
John de Troy
The Little Mohee
Wild Bill Jones
Silver Dagger
Bobby Shaftoe
The Ship that Never Returned
The Dying Cowboy
Two Little Orphans
Dream of the Miners Child
Barbara Allen
Waiting for a Train
Wild and Reckless Hobo (2 parts)
Rowan County Crew
The California Earthquake
The Drunken Driver
Lady Gay
The White Slave
One More Trip, Said the Sleepy-headed Driver
The Ballad of John Catchings (2 parts)
The Death of Harry Simms
East Ohio Miners Strike
73
Ajay Kalra
74
Ajay Kalra
Folk Music of the United States. A multi-record anthology from the Archive of Folk Song at the Library
of Congress, compiled from various field recordings and issued by genre. The following LPs available at
Berea College feature recordings from the 1930s Lomax recordings in Kentucky.
AAFS L1. Folk Music of the United States: Anglo-American Ballads from the Archive of American Folk
Song. Edited by Alan Lomax. Includes The Lady of Carlisle by Basil May from the Lomax KY
Collection. It features extensive liner notes on the origins of the ballad, adapted from the writing of
folklorists H.G. Shearing and G.L. Kittredge. The notes also feature a brief discussion of the effect of
the introduction of the guitar and of basic tonal harmony on the previously unaccompanied ballads. I
also had found this effect one of the most striking elements, even of the a capella singing in this
collectionvocal melodies largely align with guiding chordal harmony, even when no instrument is
present.
AAFS L2. Anglo American Shanties, Lyric Songs, Dance Tunes and Spirituals, From the Archive of
Folk Song. Edited by Alan Lomax. Includes Pay Day at Coal Creek and Coal Creek March by Pete
Steele, both part of the Lomax KY Collection. Also from LKC, includes Little Dove and Ten
Thousand Miles by Aunt Molly Jackson and three fiddle tunes by Luther StrongThe Last of
Callahan, The Ways of the World, and Glory in the Meeting House.
AAFS L12. Folk Music of the United States: Anglo-American Songs and Ballads from the Archive of
American Folk Song. Edited by Duncan B.M. Emrich. Includes later versions of some songs also
included in LKC. These include Lord Bateman, Naomi Wise, Froggie Went A-Courtin, Rolly
Trudum, Sourwood Mountain, and Our Goodman.
AFS L57. Folk Music of the United States: Child Ballads Traditional in the United States (I) from the
Archive of Folk Song. Edited by Bertrand H. Bronson. Includes Bangum and the Boar (Child No. 18)
sung by G.D. Vowell; Lord Bateman (Child No. 53) and (The Ballad of) Lazarus sung by Aunt
Molly Jackson; and The Cherry Tree Carol (Child No. 54) sung by Mrs. Lee Skeens. (Note: The
Lomaxky.omeka website has a fiddle instrumental under that title, date, and performer. Perhaps an
erroneous annotation?) LP comes with liner notes booklet with lyrics and commentary on each ballad
included.
AFS L58. Folk Music of the United States: Child Ballads Traditional in the United States (II) from the
Archive of Folk Song. Edited by Bertrand H. Bronson. Includes The Ship Carpenter (Child No 243)
(the title of the same recording on Lomaxky website is The House Carpenter) by Clay Walters and
The Golden Willow Tree (Child No. 286) by Jimmy Morris.
75
Ajay Kalra
AFS L62. Folk Music of the United States: American Fiddle Tunes from the Archive of Folk Song.
Edited by Alan Jabbour. Includes W. M. Stepps Bonapartes Retreat, The Drunken Hiccups, Run,
Nigger, Run, and The Ways of the World; and Luther Strongs The Hog-Eyed Man, Ricketts
Hornpipe, and Cumberland Gap. LP does not include a booklet of liner notes.
Harrod, John. Kentucky Muse: Where the Fiddle Reigns Supreme. One Music Lovers Perspective on
the Mountain Music Gatherin. Available at www.ket.org/muse/mountainmusic/music.htm.
Fiddler and Rhodes scholar Herrods brief essay on Kentucky Fiddling and Old Time music
revival, specifically in relation to the J.P Fraley Family Mountain Music Festival, held since early 1970s
in Carter Caves State Park in Northeastern KY. The page also provides a short list of renowned KY old-
time musicians.
Other Resources:
http://traildriver.com/web%20content/projects/folklore/loc%201940%20checklists/kentucky%20checkli
st.pdf
APPENDIX
Abbreviations:
76