Attachment: SLT4/NKC/EMP-4/DGN/GEN/2017/1--
ANNEXURE - 1
Item wise reply to Engineer's comments on Control Room Building Layout for SP and
SSP - A received vide letter no. L-NKC-SLT4-PMC-1702-05 dated 01-02-2017
Sl. No Engineer's Comments
Control Room Building Layout for SP
(Drawing No: 5/TP/TD/0055 Sheet 1)
Control and Relay Panel: The size of
control and Relay Panel has been taken
from the vendor M/S Ashida Electronics
AE 15BSP01-04. From dimensions, it is
not feasible to conclude that the panel
also provides for Circuit breakers and
2.1 relays required for protection
arrangement of Auto-Transformer and fire
protection system including SCADA links.
Confirm the same with vendor. The
Circuit breaker, associated relays are not
part of Supply from M/S CTR, or Auto-
transformer supplier and are not included
in any equipment provided by them in
the Equipment room.
The SLT 4 Contractor should finalize
protection linked to auto-transformer and
PNT Fire system and integrate all
requirements inside the equipment room.
The Vendor drawing need contain details
2.2 provided for in their control panel.
Control Room Building Layout for
SSP A (Drawing No 5/TP/TD/0055
Sheet 2)
Control and Relay Panel: The proposal
contains wall mounted Terminal Board
based on RDSO drawing. There is no
provision of Control and relay panel in
equipment room. SSP type A has
provision of 2 Nos Auto-transformers and
revised CAD submitted has provided for
3
CB and CT. The provision of control and
relay panel is essential and wall mounted
terminal board is not suitable. In view of
the new requirement equipment room
and battery room size may be identical to
room sizes proposed for SP.
4.1 Items of STP5 as interface like Telephone As per the discussions held between
(including Battery/ battery charger) may EMP-4 and STP5 during the interface
SLT4's Response
The Dimensions of C&R Panel will
remain same as per M/s Ashida
Electronics AE 15BSP01-04 since, the
relays required for opening of
associated Circuit Breakers before
actuating the NIFPS will be mounted
on/near the Auto Transformer.
There is no requirement of additional
panel/control box for the PNT fire
system other than those shown in the
drawing attached.
The relays (Over Current and
RPRR/PRV) required for operation of
associated Circuit Breakers before
actuating the NIFPS will be mounted
on/near the Auto Transformer.
Agreed.
The drawing 5/TP/TD/0055 Sheet 2 as
referred to in Sl. No. 4 was submitted in
support of the GAD without the
provision of CBs and CTs and hence the
Control Room did not entertain the
need of any C&R Panel in its Equipment
Room.
The revised GAD, as submitted vide
Submittal SUBM/SLT4/NKC/EMP-
4/DGN/274 dated 3rd Feb'17, however
had a provision of CB in front of each
AT.
The relays (Over Current and
RPRR/PRV) required for operation of
associated Circuit Breakers before
actuating the NIFPS will be mounted
on/near the Auto Transformer.

be concluded.
AC Control Board has to be provided with
Automatic changeover as supplies from
4.2
both auxiliary transformers are brought
to AC DB. Provide for the same.
meeting it was concluded to
incorporate a wall mounted S&T
Equipment in the Equipment Room to
cater the need of signalling,
telecommunication and fibre optics
cable. Also this has been added in the
notes to cater the need.
These items, however, do not demand
the increment in room dimensions as
they can be well
adjusted/accommodated in the spaces
available inside the room. Hence the
Control Room dimensions are not
expected to alter on addition/deletion of
these items and thus may be
considered for the approval.
Note no. 12 has been added to cater
the need of Automatic Change Over
switch in the ACDB. The attachment no.
4 having the vendor drawing of ACDB
panel clearly indicated this switch.