You are on page 1of 20

FORESTRY COMMISSION

BOOKLET No. 13

PRINCIPAL
BUTT ROTS OF
CONIFERS
by
R. J. GLADMAN and B. J. W. GREIG
Forestry Commission

LONDON
H E R M A J E S T Y S S T A T I O N E R Y O F F IC E
PRICE 2s. 3d. NET
Forestry Commission

ARCHIVE
FORESTRY COMMISSION
BOOKLET No. 13

Principal
Butt Rots of
Conifers
by
R. J. GLADMAN and B. J. W. GREIG
Forestry Commission

LONDON
HER M A J E S T Y S S T A T I O N E R Y O F F IC E

1965
PRINCIPAL BUTT ROTS OF CONIFERS
This booklet is planned as a foresters guide those of nearby living trees where they are
to the recognition of the three m ost common in contact. The highest incidence of the
and damaging decays of standing conifers disease is therefore found in second or
in G reat Britain. The fungi that cause these subsequent-rotation conifer crops, in which
rots are the basidiomycetes Fomes annosus infected stumps are most likely to occur,
(Fr.) Cooke, Armillaria mellea (Vahl. ex Fr.) whereas the fungus is absent from first-
Kummer and Polyporus schweinilzii Fr. They rotation woods until thinning is commenced.
are primary root rotting organisms, infection Rhizomorphs like those of Armillaria mellea
usually beginning in the root system and (described below) are not formed and the
developing there before proceeding into the fungus does not exist freely in the soil.
stem, where more extensive damage is caused. Many of the conifer species in use today
In addition, however, they may all sometimes in this country are susceptible to butt-rot
enter the stem by other means, for example attack by Fomes annosus, and although the
through stem wounds. degree of attack varies according to sites
A relationship normally exists between and soils, species susceptibility can be broadly
the age of the crop attacked and the state classified as follows: Western hemlock (Tsuga
and extent of the decay within it. Younger heterophylla) and Western red cedar (Thuja
crops thus often show only incipient decay, plicata) are probably the two worst-affected
whereas m ature trees are often well rotted, species when planted on an already-infected
and a large proportion of their timber may site, and often, when early thinnings are
be lost. This booklet therefore includes carried out, show as much as 50% crop
illustrations and descriptions of both the infection. Sitka and Norway spruces (Picea
early and the more characteristic advanced sitchensis and P. abies) and the larches (Larix
stages of ro t caused by each of the fungi spp.) are also susceptible, and when they are
concerned. Brief notes on the occurrence growing on previously-infected sites, crops
and relative importance of each butt rot of these species will often contain 30% of
are also given. diseased trees by the time pole stage has
The descriptions and illustrations that been reached.
follow refer to the gross characteristics of the Douglas fir (Pseudotsuga taxifolia) is more
fungi and the rots they cause, and microscopic resistant, but is not comparable with the
details are not included. pines and Silver firs (Abies spp.), which show
excellent resistance to heart-rot caused by
FOMES ANNOSUS this fungus. In the case of Douglas fir, severe
root rot (as opposed to decay within the
A White Pocket Rot
butt) is often caused by Fomes infection.
This is the most widespread and damaging When susceptible species are planted on
of these butt-rot fungi. Infection is carried alkaline sites, root and butt rot is particularly
from plantation to plantation, and from forest severe and in mature trees decay sometimes
to forest, by airborne spores of the fungus, extends for fifteen or twenty feet up the stem.
which are generally available throughout It must be noted here, moreover, that
the country for most of the year, and which F. annosus may cause death as well as heart
readily germinate on freshly-cut conifer ro t in conifers, and although pines are
stumps. Colonisation of whole stumps and resistant to heart rot, they are often killed
their roots then takes place, and the fungus then by the fungus. On infested sites, killing may
spreads from the infested stumps roots to take place from about two years after plant
3
ing, though on first-rotation areas deaths and roughly circular, usually an inch
do not usually occur until after cultural in diameter, and of a rubbery consistency.
operations such as thinning, rack cutting or Partially formed pores are sometimes seen
brashing have been initiated. These operations on their exposed surfaces. The mycelium
give rise to infection centres, around which (spawn) of Fomes does not form strands,
dead trees tend to appear in groups some but is thin and tissue-like. It can be found
five years later. Normally deaths are sufficient only occasionally under the bark of killed
ly numerous to be of economic importance roots and is of little value in identification.
only on alkaline sites with a pH higher than
6-0, and on ex-agricultural land that has
been tilled and limed, elsewhere, they are
The Decay
infrequent. (1) Stain Stage
Forestry Commission Leaflet No. 5, The very early stage of butt-rot infection
entitled: Fomes annosus, (In preparation), de shows only as stain in the stem cross-section
scribes the fungus more fully. when trees are felled, and is often positioned
eccentrically to coincide with the original
The Fructification
root infection. The appearance of the stain
This is normally bracket shaped, measuring varies between species. In Western hemlock,
between two and ten inches across, and Western red cedar, and Lawson cypress
appears particularly on the sides of infected (Chamaecyparis lawsoniana) it shows as a
stumps in sheltered positions. It is perennial, dark brown area, contrasting with the light-
tough and leathery, with an upper surface coloured wood, especially in juvenile timber.
that is often concentrically zoned. The colour In the larches, a brownish-grey stain first
of the upper surface varies from a rich, appears, often in the sap wood, and becomes
chestnut-brown in young specimens to dull darker brown or reddish-brown as infection
slate-grey in old ones, and it has a white develops (Plate 4e). It is darker brown in
outer rim which may be either thick or thin, colour than that produced by early heartwood
according to the vigour of growth of the formation in larch (Plate 4d), although both
fruit-body (Plate 1). The underside (Plate 2) may appear as irregular areas.
which may be white or biscuit-coloured, is In spruces, (especially Sitka) staining due
perforated by very numerous minute pores, to Fomes is also brown in colour (Plate 4b),
from which spores are released at most times but is commonly associated with a pink, lilac,
of the year. Fomes fructifications vary con or bluish discolouration. Unattacked wood
siderably in shape and size, and are often of Sitka spruce has been found to develop
hidden beneath litter and vegetation. They a natural pinkish hue when growing in
are commonly produced on infected roots certain conditions, e.g. sometimes on peat,
in the cavities formed by the root plates of but in this case no brown stain is present.
wind-blown trees. In this case, they are not In Plate 4a, a cross-section of a stem of
bracket-shaped, but flattened to the contour Sitka spruce shows natural brown staining,
of the root, and form only a pore surface. n ot associated with fungal infection.
During development of the fructifications,
twigs, grass, and other small objects are (2) Incipient Decay
often encircled and enclosed within them Incipient decay is a term that refers to the
(Plate 1). stage of rot infection which has advanced
Pustules, or imperfectly-formed sporo- beyond the staining of tissues but which
phores, are sometimes found on the surfaces has not produced actual rot. It is illustrated
of infected stumps under a covering of fallen in Plate 4b, in the centre of the Sitka spruce
needles. They are small flattish bodies, white specimen.
4
P L A T E i . F R U C T IF IC A T IO N S O F FO M ES A N N O S U S, U P P E R S U R F A C E S .
N o te the w id e variation in size and form . T he concentric zoning is clearly visible
in the top right-hand sporoph ore, and the ch aracteristic habit o f en circlin g small
objects is seen in the centre (top) specim en (scale shown).

P L A T E 2. U N D E R SID E O F FO M ES A N N O SU S F R U C T IF IC A T IO N .
Show ing the tube surfaces (x i i ) .
FOMES

P L A T E 3. D E C A Y C A U S E D BY FO M E S A N N O S U S.
European larch. Longitudinal, radial section. The dry fibrous nature o f the
advanced decay is seen at the bottom o f the photograph in the cen tral p ortio n ol
the specim en. A bove this the ch aracteristic sm all w h ite p ockets are visib le (x pj).
ANNOSUS

P L A T E 4. ST A IN A N D D E C A Y C A U SE D BY FO M ES A N N O SU S
(W IT H E X A M P L E S O F N A T U R A L S T A IN IN G ).
Transverse sections from butts o f newly- felled trees ( x Wo ) -
(a) Sitka spruce. (d) European larch.
Natural staining. Natural staining w hich is due to the
(b) Sitka spruce. form ation of early (false) heartw ood.
Staining and incipient decay (e) European larch.
(the ligh t y e llo w central region) Staining due to inlection by
caused by Fomes annosus. Fomcs annosus.
(c) Sitka spruce. (f) European larch.
A dvanced decay. Advanced decay.
ARMILLARIA

PLATE s . D E C A Y C A U S E D BY A R M IL L A R IA M E L L E A .
N o rw a y spruce. Lon gitudinal radial sectio n . This photograph show s the very lim ited
ex te n t o f the decay up the stem when com pared w ith that caused b y Fomes annosus
and Folyporus schweinitzii (Plates 3 and 8). T he central w e ll-ro tte d p o rtio n contains
m any black skins o f Arm illaria tissue and has been invaded b y o th er fungi and
bacteria. A dvanced decay caused by Arm illaria alone can be seen surrounding this as
areas o f soft orange-brow n ro t in w h ich w h itish regions occu r. Incipient A rm illaria
decay is clea rly visible at the b o ttom -righ t o f the infected area, and contains
irregu lar cream colo u red flecks (scale show n).
MELLEA

P L A T E 6. ST A IN A N D D E C A Y C A U S E D BY A R M IL L A R IA M E L L E A .
N o rw a y spru ce. Transverse sections. The top specim en shows the early stage o f
in fectio n indicated by the ou ter, pale, inky stain, and the central w atery-b ro w n
stain. T h e lo w e r specim en shows advanced decay. The very dark bro w n stain
im m ed iately surrounding the area o f ro t is ch aracteristic (scale show n).
POLYPORUS

P L A T E 7. D E C A Y C A U S E D BY P O L Y P O R U S S C H W E IN IT Z II.
D ouglas fir (top) and Sitka spruce (bottom ). T ransverse sections. Incipient decay is
show n in the top specim en, w h ere the radial cracks and flaking o f tissue in the affected
area arc apparent, as is the red -brow n staining surrounding it. T he crack on the right
o f the specim en, extending to the bark, resulted from felling. A dvanced decay is
show n in the lo w e r specim en. C h aracteristic features are the dry, crum bly nature ol
the ro t ; the radial fissures, and the cream y-w h ite m yceliu m w ith in them . The very
dark ring o f tissue w hich appears tow ards the outside of the decay is filled w ith
resin and is not always present (scale show n).
SCHWEINITZII

P L A T E 8. D E C A Y C A U S E D BY P O L Y P O R U S S C H W E IN IT Z II.
Sitka sp ru ce. Longitudinal, radial section. The radial cracking w h ich tends to
produce cubes o f decay is illu strated . The narrow darker colum n to the right o f the
specim en is filled w ith resin (x >,).
P L A T E 9. F R U C T IF IC A T IO N S O F P O L Y P O R U S S C H W E IN IT Z II.
T h e specim en in the foreground is a cu rren t active fru ctification, w h ile in the
background is an old er dead one. The fructification is also often o f the b rack et form
grow in g out from the tree stem (xg).

P L A T E 10 . F R U C T IF IC A T IO N S O F A R M IL L A R IA M E L L E A .
G roup o f young fructifications grow in g on the stem o f an attacked trees. The
photograph shows several ch aracteristic features o f the fungus including the gills, the
annulus o r ring, and the scales on the caps (x-J-).
At this stage the wood shows loss of weight, As a butt-rot organism in conifer crops,
but it remains relatively firm and sound in it is virtually limited to ex-hardwood sites,
structure. It is usually lighter in colour than or to mixtures of hardwoods and conifers,
the surrounding wood, from pale yellow to where attacks to the growing conifers develop
cork-coloured, and in a longitudinal section from infection sources contained in the
of an infected butt occasional black flecks hardwood stumps. Movement of the fungus
can be seen. The area of incipient decay is from stump to tree is largely by means of
almost always surrounded by an irregularly- rhizomorphs. These are black, bootlace-like
shaped band of darker stained wood. strands which spread out from infected
The small, narrow, white pockets that are stumps, etc., move freely through the soil,
the most characteristic feature of Fomes and infect roots of live trees which they
annosus heart ro t begin to appear at this encounter. These black rhizomorphs vary
stage. They are regularly shaped and clearly considerably in size and form. In the soil
defined, and are filled with a soft, white they are cord-like and may be from 1/16 to
material which gives the decay the name i of an inch in diameter, but when they grow
White Pocket R o t . These pockets are under the bark of killed roots or stems, they
readily seen in a longitudinal section of a are flattened and forked and often anastomose
decaying stem (Plate 3), and are believed to to form extensive networks. When young
be formed by the intensified activity of the and active they are not black, but light tan
fungus around the black specks, which later to reddish-brown, and have conical growing
disappear. tips.
(3) Advanced Decay In young conifers, root attack by Armillaria
often results in death of the whole tree.
W ood in an advanced state of decay in the
In older trees, however, only one or two
standing tree varies little between different
roots may be killed, and in butt-rot-susceptible
conifer species. The tissues are well broken
species this allows entry of the fungus to
down, and the wood is dry, very light in
the heartwood in the butt, where decay
weight, of a soft fibrous nature, and can
readily be pulled out from the butts of develops slowly. Affected roots (often tap
infected felled trees in long strands. It is roots or secondary sinkers) may exude
copious resin, and under their bark character
illustrated in the centre of the specimen shown
istic sheets of white or cream-coloured
in Plate 3, and in Plates 4c and 4f. In the
mycelium are found. These mycelial sheets
final stages the individual pockets often
are often fan-shaped, with much-branched
coalesce and their white contents disappear,
tongues extending radially outwards from the
so that empty spaces then occur in the rotten
source. Occasionally they are quite thick,
wood.
and then closely resemble the inner peel of
an orange.
ARMILLARIA MELLEA
Although the abundant airborne spores of
A Wet Stringy Rot the fungus are likely to play a part in its
Armillaria mellea, the Honey fungus, is pro general dissemination and spread, there is
bably best known to British foresters as a no evidence that they readily colonise conifer
common cause of deaths of trees in young stumps. This fact is supported by the repeated
plantations. However, it also acts as a conifer scarcity of the fungus in thinned conifer
root and butt rot, although this type of plantations growing on ground that was
damage is not nearly as frequent as that previously treeless.
caused by Fomes annosus, nor does it cause As distinct from tree killing, root and butt-
such severe losses in the stems and stands rot attacks by Armillaria mellea are found
attacked. more frequently on Norway and Sitka spruce
5
than on any other conifer species planted in or on the surface of the soil immediately above
this country. Lawson cypress, Western red stump roots.
cedar and Western hemlock are also suscept
ible to this form of attack. In addition, The Decay
Western red cedar seems especially susceptible (1) Stain Stage
to this decay entering through wounds on In the susceptible species mentioned, cross
roots and stem bases. The larches and Silver sections of infected stems first show a pale
firs are more resistant than any of these stain. Initially this is pale brown, grey or
species, while Douglas fir and the pines are bluish, and it later darkens to a deep brown
very resistant to heart ro t by Armillaria. In or blue-black (Plate 6, upper specimen). It
all of these species, even in m ature trees, often has a water-soaked appearance.
heart ro t caused by Honey fungus is confined
(2) Incipient Decay
to the lower trunk, seldom extending up the
tree more than two feet (Plate 5). In pole- This varies little. It is mid-brown to orange-
stage crops it is common to find that only brown in colour, and again has a water-
small pockets of decay occur in the butt soaked appearance, thus contrasting with the
cross-section, i.e. considerably less than that dry, incipient decay caused by Fomes annosus.
shown in Plate 6, lower specimen. In longitudinal sections, early Armillaria
Little association has been found between decay contains scattered white or cream-
general site factors and degree of attack, coloured flecks (Plate 5, lower right-hand
except th at the frequency of the disease in side). These are irregularly-shaped and are
creases if the crop, or any part of it, is unsuited therefore unlike the Fomes pockets, although
silviculturally to the site, e.g. spruce on dry some of them may be of the same size. Black
knolls. zone lines may sometimes be found on the
Forestry Commission Leaflet No. 6, butt-end of an infected felled tree within,
entitled Honey Fungus (H.M.S.O. 6d.) gives or at the margin of, the incipient decay.
a description of the fungus, its characteristics, These lines are very fine, as though drawn
incidence and importance in this country. with a pen, and often form apices in outline,
pointing in the direction of fungal extension,
The Fructification i.e. generally towards the outside of the stem.
This is of the toadstool type, and appears (3) Advanced Decay
from September to late autumn, usually In the field, it has been found that Armillaria
growing in clusters from the sides of infested decay in the advanced stages is seldom
stumps. They are pale honey-coloured at first, pure , and that commonly there are other
and have numerous brown scales on their organisms present, e.g. bacteria, so th at the
rounded caps, but soon acquire a deeper, appearance of the gross rot is not characteri
tawny-brown colour, and the scales then stic of Armillaria alone. In Plate 5, the darker
gradually disappear. They are usually three central portion of the rot is a good example
to six inches in height, with caps two to of this complex condition. Advanced decay
four inches across. A white ring, or annulus, due to Honey fungus alone can be seen
is situated on the stem just below the pale surrounding this as areas of soft, orange-
coloured gills, which are slightly decurrent, brown decay, in which whitish regions occur.
i.e. they extend a little way down the stem These white regions consist of remnants of
(Plate 10). Spores are produced in very large wood tissue mixed with Armillaria mycelium.
quantities on the surfaces of these gills. It is Two further features, typical of the rot at
unusual to find these fructifications growing this stage, help in identification. These are
on standing trees that have Armillaria butt the occurrence o f irregular black skins of
rot: characteristically they occur on stumps fungal tissue which often border areas of
6
soft white ro t; and the wet, mushy nature spruce or Silver firs, and none are known for
o f the orange-brown stringy decay which Western hemlock, Lawson cypress, Western
precedes it. Both can be seen in Plate 5. red cedar or for pines other than Scots pine.

POLYPORUS SCHWEINITZII The Fructification


A Dry Crumbly Rot This is usually a bracket, and grows from
This fungus has a widespread but sporadic the sides o f infected stumps or roots, or
distribution in the British Isles, and overall from the bases of infected, growing trees.
decay losses from it are small. This is due to Occasionally it is seen growing apparently
its limited incidence and not to the degree on the litter surface, when it has a short
of damage in individual trees, which is central stalk or stipe, but in these cases
commonly severe. it is always connected to an underground
In Britain, heart ro t damage by P. schwein root. The fructification, which is fleshy and
itzii in conifer plantations is most prevalent easily broken, is annual, first appearing in
on sites which have carried previous crops late summer or early autum n; it remains
o f either pines or hardwoods, but even on active for approximately two months. An
these sites it is not commonly found. In these average specimen, fully-grown, measures
plantations infection develops first in the tree about twelve inches across, and has a deep,
roots. The relationship between this fungus rusty-brown upper surface with a contrasting
and the previous crop history is not clearly yellow rim. This surface resembles coarse
understood, because o f a general lack of brown velvet, and in the United States of
knowledge of the infection biology of P. America it is known as The Velvet Top
schweinitzii. It appears that spores are capable Fungus . The yellow rim, which is broad
of infecting woody tissues on conifers, e.g. on young, growing specimens, becomes
stem wounds, but observations and experi narrower with age, and gradually disappears
mental evidence suggest that spore infection as the mature sporophore dies. The underside
o f conifer stumps does not occur as readily is pale greyish-green and is easily bruised,
as with Fomes annosus. and when active, exudes moisture droplets.
In Britain a num ber of conifer species are It is broken by numerous, small, irregular
susceptible to root and heart ro t attacks by channels, and is maze-like in appearance. The
P. schweinitzii, especially Sitka spruce. In fructifications gradually die as winter
this tree, decay to eight feet and more is approaches, but they remain in situ and can
frequently recorded in semi-mature stands still be readily recognised in the following
thirty to forty years old, where they are year, when they are much-dried and dark
growing on the site-types previously mention brown all over. On the litter surface in this
ed. It is commonly found that, in an attacked state, they closely resemble old cow-pats.
Sitka spruce, a large proportion of its cross- Plate 9 shows two specimens, one active
sectional area at the b u tt is decayed (Plate 7, (foreground), and the other an old specimen.
lower specimen). Other species attacked are
Douglas fir, Scots pine and the larches. In The Decay
all of these it is more common to find the (1) Stain Stage
decay in m ature or near-m ature trees than In Sitka spruce this is usually detected as a
in pole-stage crops, in which damage is seldom yellowish discolouration in the sapwood or
severe. Because of the general low incidence early heartwood of newly-felled trees. A
of P. schweinitzii in the British Isles, suscepti pinkish stain may also be present. In Douglas
bility of the other commonly-planted conifer fir, a pinkish-brown area in the butt, darker
species is n o t fully known. To date, very than the natural heartwood colour, is the
few attacks have been recorded in Norway first indication o f root infection. It is seldom
7
clearly defined in either species, and can be are considerably shrunken, it becomes much
seen in Plate 7, in both specimens, surrounding darker in all species, and resembles mahogany
the area of decay. in colour.
(2) Incipient Decay SUMMARY OF MAIN FEATURES
This is well illustrated in Plate 7, in the OF THE DECAYS
central area of the top specimen. In all Fomes annosus
species the affected wood appears dry, and M ost often found in second rotation conifer
there may be numerous, small, radial cracks crops. Dry, fibrous, yellow-brown to tan-
when stems are seen in cross-section. Again, brown. Small, regularly shaped, white oval
the infected area is often ill-defined, and the pockets in longitudinal sections. No character
colour and texture of the rot do not differ istic smell. Commonly found in larches,
greatly from normal wood. The m ost constant spruces, Western hemlock and Western red
feature is the radial pattern of minute ridges cedar.
or flakes of wood that result from the partial
decay. These are more easily seen in Douglas Armillaria mellea
fir than in Sitka spruce. N o pockets are Generally found on old hardwood sites. Wet
formed. A t this stage a strong, sweetish smell stringy rot, yellow-brown to orange-brown.
is readily apparent on fresh-cut decayed Irregularly-shaped cream flecks in incipient
specimens of all species. It has been likened stage. Thin black zone lines and/or black
to turpentine and to anise, and is at one skins present. No distinctive smell. Commonly
and the same time sweet, sour, and resinous. found in spruces, Western hemlock, and
It is a valuable diagnostic characteristic. Western red cedar.
(3) Advanced Decay Polyporus schweinitzii
In this stage it is readily recognised, and the M ost often found on ex-pine or ex-hardwood
term Crumbly R o t is an apt description sites. Dry, crumbly, pale yellow-brown,
for it, especially in Sitka spruce (Plate 7, becoming much darker in final stages. Cubical
bottom specimen). It is dry, very light in decay, no pockets formed. Whitish-yellow
weight, and granular or crumbly in texture, mycelium in cracks. Strong sweet-sour smell.
not at all fibrous. In Sitka spruce it is light- Commonly found on Sitka spruce and Douglas
yellow-brown in colour, but in Douglas fir fir.
it is darker brown or pinkish-brown. It can
be easily dug out with the blade of a pocket This booklet has described the three most
knife and quickly crumbles when rubbed common and most damaging decays of
between the fingers. Radial cracks are large standing conifers in G reat Britain. The three
and often numerous, and are sometimes filled fungi discussed account for nearly all of the
with pale yellow or creamish-white mycelial softwood decay in British forests, but occasion
growths (Plate 7, lower specimen). These ally rot caused by other organisms will be
radial cracks tend to break up the wood into encountered. Reference should then be made
roughly cubical blocks (Plate 8), and in the to the textbook entitled Decay o f Timber
final stage of decay these will sometimes fall and its Prevention, written by K. St. G.
out from the butt of a tree when it is felled. Cartwright and W. P. K. Findlay, of the
The characteristic sweet-sour smell remains Forest Products Research Laboratory, D epart
apparent. In late stages of decay, when the ment of Scientific and Industrial Research
wood is dust-dry and brittle, and the cubes (H.M.S.O. 27s. 6d.) (by Post 30s. 6d.).

Printed in England for Her Majestys Stationery Office


by James Townsend & Sons, Ltd., Exeter
(B59211) 405347. W t 2206/3209 5,000 6/65. G p. 466
Crown copyright 1965
Published by
H er M a j e s t y s Stationery O ffice

To be purchased from
York House, Kingsway, London, w.c.2
423 Oxford Street, London, w.l
13 a Castle Street, Edinburgh 2
109 St. Mary Street, Cardiff
39 King Street, Manchester 2
50 Fairfax Street, Bristol 1
35 Smallbrook, Ringway, Birmingham 5
80 Chichester Street, Belfast 1
or through any bookseller

You might also like