Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chloe Page
Ms. Gigliello
AP Literature
1 January 2017
in combat too intense for soldiers? Does combat impact women more severely than
men? The recent decision to integrate women into all aspects of the military has
been challenged and questioned by people who see there only being negative
positive and negative outcomes that need to be considered. Women who are
involved in any branch of the United States Armed Forces struggle with mental
health needs that outweigh men and women from the general public. The need for
readily available support and education on mental health post combat deployment
is essential for the success of the careers of the women in the military. Sexual
assault, fraternization, physical capabilities, and equal treatment are all topics for
combat. Recently, women have been involved in wars and combat scenarios just as
often as men resulting in frequent and increasing reports of females suffering from
Page 2
posttraumatic stress disorder, depression, suicidal thoughts, and many other mental
health struggles. Although there are differences between military men and women
that are physical and mental, their overall reasons for serving are similar.
will encounter, military women are not different from military men: they are just as
likely to be officers, they joined the armed services for similar reasons, and veterans
of both sexes experience similar struggles and rewards upon returning to civilian
life. Women can enhance the combat capabilities of the military due to the
possibility for diverse problem solving and critical thinking without directly causing
cohesion to suffer. Cohesion is not just linked to common traits such as race,
ethnicity, or gender but is based on similar collective goals and mindsets. Task
cohesion is far more important to a unit than social cohesion. Social cohesion can
the purpose of the mission and making the sacrifices needed. Women have shown to
have success throughout other jobs within the military, but upfront combat has no
room for any sort of set back or mistake. A weak link will become the difference
One positive aspect to having women in combat is the general statistic that
women may have cultural differences that give advantages. As explained by the,
than men. Allowing women to serve doubles the talent pool for delicate and
sensitive jobs that require interpersonal skills not every soldier has. Having a wider
personnel base allows militaries to have the best and most diplomatic soldiers
working to end conflict quickly(Women). The diversity that many women will bring
to the military with the opening of all jobs, is one of the main things that is argued as
the strengthening aspect. Cultural change needs to start in the training base to set
the conditions for successful future service for females entering these combat jobs.
If women are allowed to have the opportunity to complete whatever job that is fit
for them, this will allow head officers to be able to make the best choice when
Military women have played many different roles within the United States
armed forces. Women have been a part of the military since the Revolutionary War,
but the term military women has developed a different meaning over the years.
Women were used as nurses and were usually correlated with being a wife to
someone in the military, they were not thought of upfront combat soldiers.
Recently, around the time of Desert Storms in the early 1990s, women were then
given the right to fight in combat and have few restrictions on their job choices. This
does also depend on the branch that the woman is apart of. According to the San
Diego Union-Tribune, The marines for example, have the most restrictions on
women involvement compared to all other branches. This then affects how a
Page 4
womans health status may be post deployment due to the smaller chance of combat
of these military womens experiences and unique mental health challenges in order
differences between men and women, and the success women are experiencing in
other physically and mentally stressful occupations. Due to the fact that women do
not meet the same physical fitness levels as the majority of men, when a woman
takes on a leadership role her authority and success may suffer. Success in the
military starts with physical fitness and if a woman who is leading is asking her
soldiers to complete a task that she herself could not even do, it may be hard for
them to trust and look up to her leadership. This will dilute the development of
numbers. According to recent data from the the online magazine, Time Labs,
Currently, women account for 15.3% of active-duty personnel in the U.S. military
(Johnson). In addition, 200,000 out of the 1.6 million that have deployed to
Afghanistan and Iraq since 2001, have been women. Although, men do also suffer
from PTSD and other mental struggles, women do not have as much support due to
Page 5
how new their part in combat is. Women who enter the military life already have a
disadvantage mentally according to data. For example, nearly twice as many civilian
Psychological Bulletin (Munsey). There are many reasons why women seem to
struggle with mental health issues more than men. According to the U.S. Department
of Veterans Affairs, Women with PTSD are more likely to feel depressed and
anxious, while men with PTSD are more likely to have problems with alcohol or
drugs (Trauma). Men will find ways to avoid and cope with their struggles, while
the majority of women let it consume their minds causing more mental issues. Jobs
and ranks within the military have now been made available to women. Despite
stereotypes and assumptions, military women do in fact see upfront combat, which
is something that not many people realize. With society and technological advances
in many different aspects, the military is advancing as well in those areas and on
gender stereotypes and standards. In result from how new the presence of women
in certain occupations are, there are many flaws that have occurred.
Women who deploy with the reserves or national guard, are at a disadvantage
and at more of a risk due to the lack of attention and resources post deployment.
Active duty women that are enlisted and officers, usually go back to their unit full
people to support them. Women and even men who do not return to a unit or
Page 6
military setting are not surrounded with the support that is helpful for someone
who may be experiencing PTSD. There is little research that has been done to
investigate the impact military service has on women specifically in the reserves or
National guard. The situation needs to be invested into and proactively dealt with.
Everyday veterans suffer from PTSD and do not receive the help they need.
more common due to the increase in female deployment to combat zones. Female
soldiers may experience challenges when it comes to reporting incidents and getting
the proper legal and emotional support. It is also important to realize many times in
military setting, the offender may out rank the victim, leaving the offender with
more control and equity in the situation. That may be another fear that the female
faces, is losing her career due to being attacked by someone who is in charge of her.
The offender can range from a citizen of the deployment zone, a colleague, or even
an out ranking officer. Also, there have been scenarios when women have said they
did not know how to report the incident. One of the major reasons why it is an issue
for women serving in some roles is the need for separate sleeping quarters, and
particularly the worries about women being subject to sexual crimes. Unfortunately,
these worries do occur. Many times when a female reports an incident, she is not
given the opportunity to leave her duty station. In some cases her offender may or
may not be removed from the scene as well. It has been shown that the amount of
Page 7
PTSD from sexual trauma for women is equal in amount to PTSD for men with
combat exposure. Recent reports show ranges of sexual assault from 4.2% to 7.3%
for active duty women and 11% to 48% for female veterans; sexual harassment
rates ranged from 55% to 79%, based on reported events (Batuman). For military
women, sexual trauma can result in many disorders such as, depression, anxiety,
Men deploy for many months at a time, and live in extremely tight conditions,
while being involved in violent attacks. Sexual intimacy is not appropriate for that
type of environment, but when there is women around and possible gay people, sex
will be found. Another issue will be the fact that rape is known to be used as
psychological warfare.
The top concerns listed by female Marines were enemy forces targeting
The enemy would take full advantage of capturing female soldiers in combat to use
this method of warfare. When these events take place, soldiers that are affected
mentally or physically, cannot just quit their job like a civilian job. The chain of
command is what controls where and when you go somewhere. A huge issue and
flaw in the military system is these people of authority could also be the people who
are doing the abusing when it comes to scenarios such as sexual harassment.
Page 8
One realistic and debatable issue with women being a part of critical
deployments and missions is allowing human nature to take over priorities. There is
always the possibility of a man and woman being attracted to each other, which
Post, Sexual tension is a most delightful distraction in civilian life. But in close
quarters, where men likely would vastly outnumber the few women who qualify for
combat, other human emotions envy, jealousy and resentment enter into a
fault that a man is attracted to her, but it is something that may become an issue
with women being in certain units. In combat units sleeping quarters may be tight
and there will be a lack of gender separation because that is not the priority at hand
in combat. In human nature men naturally feel protective over women. An argument
that many have brought up is would men end up putting themselves or their fellow
soldiers in unnecessary danger in order to protect a woman who has been captured
or killed? This is a valid argument that may be resolved by possibly changing certain
initial training in order to prepare men for these scenarios. Disruption in a unit, in
combat, can cost lives and prevent the completion of the mission at hand.
Training will not completely change the genetic makeup of a human so there
is not a way around completely avoiding these issues that will arise. To help avoid
some of these conflicts units discourage having relations that are sexual due to the
Page 9
chances of pregnancy and distractions. Despite these set standards, due to human
nature and the fact that women are now apart of combat units full of men who have
been away from freedom for a long time, women are getting pregnant during
experienced issues with women getting pregnant from other men on the ship which
ends up causing the ship to completely change route in order to get the woman off
the ship. (Eden) Although being on a Navy ship is not a combat job, it reassures that
there is time and money wasted due to these scenarios regarding sexual relations.
One of the main concerns that is voiced by many civilians and military
women attempting to qualify for these jobs. With the change of allowing women to
be in combat comes with the negative opinions on the idea and people who do not
agree with it. An honest and common outlook opinion on the topic of women in
Putting women into close combat roles isnt fair to the men who will be
relying on them, and isnt fair to the women who will find themselves
combat we should be giving them the best possible chance of succeeding and
surviving. While women are equal to or better than men at many tasks, they
simply arent when it comes to combat. Substituting men with far less
Page 10
unnecessary.(Putting)
On the opposite side of this argument, many feel as though if women do meet these
standards, they should be allowed to be apart of the combat job. People now believe
that the military is becoming something else due to womens newly extensive
involvement. Secretary of the Navy Ray Mabus argued that lifting the ban is not
going to make the U.S. military any less fighting effective. In fact I think they will be a
stronger force, because a more diverse force is a stronger force. There have been
many arguments that show there will be some positive and negative outcomes due
to the involvement of women. It is a debate that has many aspects that need to be
considered. Women will most likely struggle with combat missions that entail
marching many miles. Although that is not a set standard, it is a possible task these
women may face while completing a combat mission. The biggest aspect to consider
is, they may be able to complete it, but the real consequence may be that they will
not be as efficient as men. There will be women that will be able to add positive
aspects to the military, but there will also be women who will not be able to keep up.
This can be prevented by making sure the standards do not change just because
women are now involved in combat. According to Elaine Donnelly, president of the
Center for Military Readiness, There is no way women can be accommodated in the
Page 11
justified. Theres no trade-off. Many people are concerned that Congress is not
asking enough questions or having qualitative hearing to really justify this choice.
According to the Ledger Enquirer, The eight women remaining in the first
U.S. Army Ranger School class to accept females were dropped on Friday after
failing to pass the Camp Darby phase for a second time, according to the Army. The
is an extensive schooling that has requirements that not many men can even
complete. There have been some women recently that have completed Ranger
school, but there have also been many that have failed. This shows that there are
requirements and standards and not all women are being allowed to just make their
way through.
It requires intense work that will weed out the female soldiers that will not be
suited for certain positions. These requirements help to make sure these women
the truth to her experience and takes a stand against women in combat. Women are
often great shooters but cant run in 50-80 lbs of gear as long, hard, or fast as men.
Military training is hard enough on mens bodies; its harder on womens. And until
women stop menstruating, there will always be an uphill battle for staying level and
strong at all times (Eden). Something that is not spoken of much is the fact that
Page 12
said by Womens Running, that many women report that days before their
menstrual cycle begins they experience fatigue and are not feeling like they are able
to perform their best. 5 to 7 days before you begin to bleed that female athletes are
most affected by their cycles and thus may underperform in races and workouts
(Lauretta). Women are put at an undeniable disadvantage due to the makeup and
the field, but their body does become fragile and is put at risk for possible injury.
Women will be more susceptible to acute short term injury than men, which is
periods are likely to be the most damaging. Screening and testing may
injury. The current physical training regime for ground close combat
roles is optimised for a male cohort; the training has been proven to be
Page 13
(WOMEN)
To have the most successful outcome for females in combat, research will need to
be continued in order to identify the most effective ways to achieve the same
physicality that men tolerate, but in a way that will not put a female at risk for
injury. As supported by the research that was conducted by the Army, women have
a higher rate of hip and stress fracture injury due to the biological makeup if their
bone strength (WOMEN). Women need more nutrients and attention in order to
maintain a quality physical health. Many of these needs will most likely become
inconveniences in the field due to the raw living conditions. The current physical
training programs for combat is designed for a male soldier. Although, changing
may be able to identify a program that results in the same physical outcome but
When restrictions are put on the jobs and skills that women are willing to get,
it also restricts their ability to advance and get the most out of their career. When it
comes to awards and promotions, women are put at a set back when they do not
have the opportunities to advance their careers. If a woman deserves a certain title
or opportunity and it is fairly earned and given, then this should be acceptable. In
order to fully move away from limitations on genders, there needs to be willingness
Page 14
to be adaptable to negative and positive outcomes. There will be very few women
within these physically rigorous positions if the military stays true to old standards.
The old standards should be kept in order to keep the men and women in combat
zones safe. Training requirements are the way they are for a reason and to change
While moving through this research, a debate topic that is making a strong
stand for both opinions is, should women be allowed in combat jobs at all. The
average military woman may fall short of combat skills and generally all male units
perform proficiently due to the lack of problems that occur. Most people may agree
to the fact that a woman would not have a fitness level that is comparable to a fit
man due to uncontrollable biological makeup. Despite the physical back sets a
woman in combat will encounter, being blocked from combat jobs does prevent
women from being able to attain higher ranks. A solution that many people have
suggested would be rather change the rules of promotion, than put the effectiveness
Works Cited
Eden, Jude. "The Problems of Women in Combat - From a Female Combat Vet."
Johnson, David. See Womens Progress in the U.S. Military. 8 Sept. 2015. Time Labs,
Kovach, Gretchel. Why Marines Have a Problem With Women in Combat. The San
Diego Union,
www.sandiegouniontribune.com/military/sdut-marine-women-in-combat-ka
Lamothe, Dan. How big is opposition to women in combat units among Marines? This
www.washingtonpost.com/news/checkpoint/wp/2016/03/10/survey-detail
s-depth-of-opposition-in-marine-corps-to-allowing-women-in-combat-jobs/?
Lauretta, Ashley. Does your Period Really effect your Performance? Womens Running,
womensrunning.competitor.com/2015/04/health-wellness/does-your-perio
d-really-affect-your-performance_37543#x6GS960dGMoLP4v9.97. Accessed
1 Dec. 2016.
"Putting Women in Combat Is an Even Worse Idea Than Youd Think." National
Parker, Kathleen. Women in Combat will Put Men at Greater Risk. The Washington
Post,
www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/women-in-combat-put-men-at-risk/201
5/12/11/f0e00768-a04b-11e5-bce4-708fe33e3288_story.html?utm_term=.b
Ledger-Enguier,
www.ledger-enquirer.com/news/local/article29456032.html. Accessed 1
Dec. 2016.
2016.
Page 17
www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/3
Women, Trauma, and PTSD. Washington, DC, 13 Aug. 2015. U.S. Department of
Veterans Affairs,
www.ptsd.va.gov/public/PTSD-overview/women/women-trauma-and-ptsd.a