Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sections
Continued
Charts
Figures
Tables
In India, national highways, with a length of close to 67,000 km, constitute a mere 2 per cent of the road network
but carry about 40 per cent of the total road traffic. On the other hand, state roads and major district roads the
secondary system of road, carry another 40 per cent of traffic and account for 18 per cent of road length.
In the decreasing order of the volume of traffic movement, road network in India can be divided in the following
categories:
We have arrived at the figures of laned network based on laning of different types of road network, number of
lanes on each road network, which is normalised to 3.75 m per lane for national highways and state highways.
The laned network, which considers the upgradation in terms of increase in number of lanes in the national
highways, state highways and major district roads further bifurcates the road network.
In 1999, roads accounted for 54 per cent of the total freight traffic, which increased to 62 per cent in 2008.
Comparatively, railways contributed 36 per cent in 1999 to the total freight transport and declined to 29 per cent
in 2008-09.
Road
Rail
54
36 Road
Rail
62
29
Note
For details, kindly refer to CRISIL Researchs report, Domestic Freight Transportation Service
Source: CRISIL Research
60
51
40 49
29 36
20 28 28
18 13
0
1950-51 1960-61 1970-71 1980-81 1990-91 2000-01 2004-05(P)
Source: Working Group Report on Road Transport for the Eleventh Five-Year Plan
Since 1950-51, the passenger traffic for railways has come down from 85 per cent to 13 per cent while passenger
traffic for roads has consistently grown from 30 per cent in 1950 -51 to 87 per cent in 2004-05.
Preference for road transport for freight movement is primarily on account of large capacity expansions carried
out by fleet operators, flexibility and door-to-door movement. In addition, roads act as a primary means for last
mile travel. Further, there are many players in road transport while Indian Railways is the only player in railways.
There has been an upgradation in terms of lanes in national highways, which has gone from being single lane and
double lane to four lanes. Single lane roads have decreased from 35 per cent in 2004-05 to 28 per cent in 2007 -
08. Double lane roads have increased from 56 per cent in 2004-05 to 59 per cent in 2007- 08, while four lane
roads have increased from 9 per cent to 14 per cent in the same period.
Institutional framework
At the Central government level, several line ministries handle transport planning, coordination and policy setting,
with overall coordination by the Planning Commission.
Chart 1: Road sector - Institutional arrangement at the Central and state level
Planning Commission
Planning Commission
(Overall
(Overall policy
policy framework,
framework, overall
overall integration, approval plans)
integration, approval plans)
MORTH MORD
(Release and allocation of funds for development (Release and allocation of funds for development
and maintenance of national highways) and maintenance of rural roads)
Road dept
Road dept
NHAI
NHAI
(NHDP
(NH implementation,
& NHDP operations
implementation, andand
operations Central level
maintenance)
maintenance)
(Planning, policy
(Planning, policy and
and budgeting)
budgeting) Secretary
(Panchayat Ra j)
State PWD
State PWD for roads
for roads
StatePWDs
State PWDs for
for Roads-SH
Roads-NH wing
w ing (Construction
(Construction and
and maintenance of
maintenance of Panchayat Raj engineering dept
(Construction and
(Construction and maintenance
maintenance state
MDRsroads and
and rural
rural roads
roads (For construction and
of SH)
of NH) [for states] ))
some states]
[for some maintenance
of rural roads in some states )
In June 2009, the erstwhile Ministry Of Shipping, Road Transport and Highways (MoSRTH) has been segregated
in to two ministries, Ministry of Road Transport and Highway (MoRTH) and Ministry of Shipping and Ports
(MOSP).
At the Central level, the Planning Commission in consultation with the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways
(MoRTH) and the Ministry of Rural Development (MoRD) prepares the overall policy, programme development
and resource planning. MoRTH's duties relate to the development and maintenance of national highways and
policies on road transport.
At the state level, the overall policy, programme development and resource planning is done by the State planning
cell in consultation with the Central level planning commission and the state ministry of roads.
State Public Works Department (PWDs) and Road development corporations are implementing agencies at the
state level implementing, operating and maintaining the State Highways, Major district roads and rural roads in
few states.
The Ministry of Rural Development (MoRD) is responsible for policy development as well as monitoring and
coordination of rural roads.
Apart from the state PWDs, the Panchayati Raj also implements the construction and maintenance of rural roads.
The ministries allocate and release funds, for the development of roads, to the respective implementing agencies.
(For details of the institutional arrangement, please refer to chart 1 in this chapter.)
Policy framework
Central government policy
Key policy measures for private participation
In order to encourage and facilitate private sector investment and participation in the roads sector, the Central
government has undertaken certain policy measures and provided certain fiscal incentives within the sector:
100 per cent foreign direct equity investment (FDI) will be allowed in road sector projects.
Dispute resolution will be in line with the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996, based on United Nations
Commission on International Trade Law (UNCITRAL) provisions.
Key parameters of New Model Concession agreement (2006) and Bidding process
Concession structure - NHAI projects
New Model Concession Agreement (MCA) for Built Operate and Transfer (BOT) toll-based projects has been
prepared. The MCAs identify risks and specify the terms and conditions for risk sharing between the private
player and the government.
Grant
The maximum grant provided will be 20 per cent of the project cost. In case the grant is inadequate for making a
project commercially viable, an additional grant up to a maximum of 20 per cent of the project cost can be given
for O&M support after the highway has been commissioned.
Concession period
The concession period is generally expected to be 20 years, but may vary depending on the volume of existing and
projected traffic for specific projects.
Construction period
The time required for construction (typically 24-30 months) is included in the concession period. A concessionaire
starts earning revenues from the completion date, and this gives the concessionaire an incentive for early
completion of construction.
Concession fee
The concession fee is fixed on an ascending revenue sharing basis, in line with the cash flow pattern of the project
where debt service obligations entail substantial outflows in the initial years. The MCA provides for concession
fee of Re 1 pa for the first 9 years and 1 per cent of projected revenues from the 10th year onwards. Subsequently,
in each year, it will increase by an additional 1 per cent.
Toll revision
The revision in toll rates was fixed at 40 per cent of change in WPI.
Obligations of NHAI
The obligations of NHAI are as follows: (i) to acquire and hand over possession of at least 80 per cent of the land
required for the project to the concessionaire before financial closure is achieved (ii) obtain all environmental
clearances for the project before financial closure is achieved (iii) NHAI will ensure that no competing road is
constructed where NHDP is being implemented.
Substitution
MCA provides for the concession to be transferred to another company in the event of failure of the
concessionaire to operate the project successfully.
Termination
In the event of termination, the MCA provides for a compulsory buyout by the NHAI
Tolling rates for two laned national highway 60 per cent of toll
rates of 4 laned NH
Tolling of Permanent bridges, If Cost >Rs 0.5 bn then tolled
bypass or tunnel separately
Source: MORTH, CRISIL Research
The most significant change in the new toll policy applicable for future bidding of contracts has been the change
in methodology for revision of toll rates. The toll rate revision has been fixed at 3 per cent plus 40 per cent of
change in WPI.
Other key changes in the new tolling policy include the following:
Removal of ranking and short listing of bidders for future road projects
As per the Delhi High Court judgment, the ranking and short listing of top five to six bidders in the RFQ stage has
been removed for future road projects. Consequently, the cap on bids to be submitted in RFP has also been
removed.
Legal framework
Central level initiatives
Administration of roads is a concurrent subject, with the jurisdiction of the Central government limited to national
highways, and the jurisdiction of the state government limited to state highways, MDRs, village and other roads.
Following are some of the legislations governing the road sector:
Some states like Maharashtra, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, Haryana, Uttar Pradesh, West Bengal, Rajasthan,
Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu have amended the Motor Vehicles Act to provide a legal basis for
involving the private sector in the development of highways on BOT basis.
Ownership
The government usually owns the roads; it also has the right to develop and maintain them. However, in case of
BOT projects, the right to develop, maintain, collection and retention of tolls (known as RoW-Right of Way) is
given to the concessionaire of the project. However, even in such cases the ownership of the roads is not
transferred to the concessionaire. These projects are transferred back to the government at the end of the pre-
determined concession period.
Type of roads
Roads can be classified as per the material used for construction:
Earth roads
Gravel or murum roads
Metalled roads (WBM)
Bituminous roads or black-top surfaces (BT)
Asphalt concrete roads (AC)
Cement concrete roads (CC)
Roads consist of one or more courses of coarse aggregates whose voids are partially filled with finer material,
usually gravel. Earth and gravel roads are of inferior type and are called unmetalled roads. They are suitable for
village roads, which carry light traffic. Gravel used for road surfacing should be well graded and should contain
sufficient amount of fines to give binding property. Metalled roads known as WBM roads are suitable for district
roads
Bituminous concrete is a paving mixture composed of coarse aggregate, fine aggregate and bitumen. Bituminous
materials are well suited for road construction because of their binding or cementing as well as water-proofing
properties.
Asphalt and cement are two binding agents. Hot-mix asphalt is mostly used for surfacing roads. Constructing
roads by this method involves applying a layer of the mixture on the foundation or the existing road surface and
compacting it to form a compact and tough surface. The black colour of asphalt lends its colour to the road
surface. A high proportion of the long-haul roads and most inter-city and urban roads are constructed using this
method.
The use of cement as a binder is also a popular method of road pavement, where the aggregate is bound together
using Portland cement, by preparing a water-based mixture and allowing it to set on the road surface. Concrete
pavements are costly in comparison to asphalt pavements, but last longer and have low maintenance requirements.
Most expressways are constructed using the cement concrete mix.
Bituminous roads and concrete roads are preferable for state and national highways, which carry heavy and fast
traffic. They are also known as modern, superior or high cost roads
Since the last few years, fly ash is also being used for road construction and embankment work. The erstwhile
Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MoRTH) had directed all its agencies to use fly ash up to a specified
quantity for all road and embankment construction work within a radius of 100 km (earlier the limit was 50 km)
from the thermal plant.
Plastic roads mainly use plastic carry bags, disposable cups and PET bottles that are collected from garbage
dumps as an important ingredient of the construction material. When mixed with hot bitumen, plastics melt to
form an oily coat over the aggregate and the mixture is laid on the road surface like a normal tar road. The use of
plastic in roads is just a recent phenomenon, which seems to have huge potential in the sector.
Most of the roads awarded by NHAI under NHDP comprise bitumen roads. The cost of construction of a
particular stretch would depend upon the terrain, topography, nature of the soil, structures like flyover, bridges,
bypasses, culverts involved in the project. However, on an average for a 4 lane road project, the cost of
construction per km has reduced from Rs 100 million - Rs 120 million in 2008 to Rs 750 million- Rs 800 million,
on account of decline in bitumen and steel prices coupled with restructuring of NHDP road projects.
Subgrade
Once the above activities are completed, the native soil, known as the subgrade, is compacted. Weak soils may be
stabilised with additives such as portland cement and quicklime, or dug out and replaced with imported soils.
Base course
Then a base course consisting of gravel or crushed stone (aggregates) is usually placed on the subgrade and
compacted.
Surface course
After constructing the granular sub-base, a surface course, consisting of asphalt concrete or portland cement
concrete, is placed on top of the base course. This surface course strengthens the pavement structure by spreading
out the vehicle loads applied to the subgrade.
Today, a contractor has the option of meeting his equipment requirements either by buying the equipments from
the equipment manufacturers or hiring the equipments on a lease or rental basis. The strong and continuous
growth in roads sector has allowed most of the bigger players to own substantial portion of their equipment
requirements. On the other hand, the smaller players, on account of lack of funds, often have to meet their
requirements by either buying second hand equipments from bigger players or by hiring the equipments on a
rental basis from equipment banks like Quipo, etc.
In this section, we have put together various types of road equipments, along with their main functions that are
currently being used in roads construction in India.
Loaders
Loaders are used mainly for trenching, ditch cleaning, uploading materials into trucks, clearing rubble, and
Tippers/Dumpers
These are new generation trucks that carry materials, sand, aggregates, etc. and dump at the desired place.
Tippers and dumpers perform the same functions. Usually dumpers have a larger carrying capacity (35 50
tonnes) than tippers that carry weights between 5 to 10 tonnes. Major road construction equipment player in
this segment is Bharat Earth Mover Ltd.
Pavers
A paver is an engineering vehicle used to lay asphalt on roadways. A roller is then used to press the hot
asphalt mix, resulting in a smooth, even surface.
Road roller
These equipments are used to compact dirt, gravel, concrete, and asphalt in construction for roads and
foundations. Road rollers are also used in landfill compaction. There are two types of rollers static rollers and
tandem roller. Major road construction equipment player in this segment is L&T Case Equipment Ltd.
Motor Graders
Graders are commonly used in road construction to prepare the base course to create a wide flat surface for
the asphalt to be placed on.
Scrapers
The scraper pulls up roadway, crushes it and loads it into a heavy truck. Any other thing left behind by the
scraper is then taken away by means of front loader.
There has been considerable growth in the national highway (NH) network since independence. Major growth in
NH has taken place from 1992-2007. Almost 33,000 km of national highways have been added to the NH network
during the same period.
66590 66754
60000
40000 33689
28977
23769
21440
20000
0
1947 1962 1977 1992 2007 2008
NHAI manages the project under the aegis of Ministry of Road Transport and Highways. In next 5 years, close to
54 per cent of the total investment on national highways will be incurred on NHDP. Despite rising budgetary
deficits, and a change of government at the Centre, the NHDP has been accorded top priority and its scope has
been significantly expanded beyond the original scope of Golden Quadrilateral and North-South and East-West
corridors.
VI Expressways - NHAI
VII Ring roads - NHAI
Source: CRISIL Research
Note: For the purpose of our analysis, we have considered entire length of NSEW Corridor in Phase II and entire
others National Highways (NH) in Phase I.
As can been seen from the table above, 33 per cent of the total road length under NHDP has achieved completion
(as on March 31, 2009). The focus of implementation has shifted to the Phase II (NSEW Corridor) and Phase III.
Golden Quadrilateral (GQ) connecting four major metropolitan cities viz. Delhi-Mumbai- Chennai-Kolkata,
with a total length of 5,846 km
North South & East West (NSEW) Corridors connecting Srinagar to Kanyakumari and Silachar to Probandar.
(981 km of this Corridor was included in Phase I.), with a spur from Salem to Cochin
380 km of Port Connectivity, this connects major ports (Haldia, Paradeep, Vishakhapatnam, Chennai &
Ennore, Tutrocorin, Kochi, New Mangalore, Marmugoa, Jawarharlal Nehru Port Trust and Kandla) from east
to west coast and to GQ
Other National Highway (NH) stretches of 962 km.
As on March 31, 2009, around 93 per cent of Phase I was complete and cost incurred has been Rs 320 billion.
As on March 31, 2009 around 46.7 per cent of NSEW Corridor was complete and further 41.7 per cent is under
implementation. Nearly 12 per cent of NSEW has not yet been awarded .The total cost incurred has been Rs 288
billion.
In 2009, six projects worth Rs 74 billion have been awarded out of the total 48 projects to be awarded in Phase III
in 2008. As on March 31, 2009 around 6.5 per cent was complete and 15.5 per cent under implementation and
total cost incurred has been Rs 84 billion. Close to 78 per cent of the phase is yet to be awarded.
The government aims to implement all projects from Phase III to Phase VII on BOT-Toll basis.
Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana (PMGSY), a sub programme under Bharat Nirman, has been launched for
providing all-weather access to unconnected habitations. PMGSY estimates that 66,802 habitations would be
provided new connectivity with a road length of 146,185 km. It is also proposed to upgrade 194,132 km of
existing routes for ensuring full farm-to-market connectivity.
PMGSY is a 100 per cent centrally sponsored scheme, wherein the existing sources of funding are budgetary
sources, Central Road Fund (CRF) on High Speed Diesel (HSD), market committee fees, loan assistance from
NABARD, World Bank and Asian Development Bank. It is implemented through cash contracts only.
Around Rs 40 billion have been allocated for rural roads in the Interim Budget 2009-10 and would be routed
through a separate window created under the Rural Infrastructure Development Fund (RIDF). This will provide
necessary funds for the upgradation and development of rural roads planned under Bharat Nirman. The corpus of
RIDF was increased from Rs.5.5 billion in 2003-04 to Rs.140 billion for the year 2008-09 ensuring greater
availability of funds for its activities.
As on April 2009, around 52.6 per cent of the road works planned was completed. The target for 2008-09 was
39,887 km but only 343 km of roads have been completed. The slow rate of implementation has been further
marred on account of scattered road patches, tiny ticket sizes, low capacities of contractors. Value of proposals
cleared by the government is Rs 901 billion; however, only Rs 413 billion has been released till date. Expenditure
incurred in this programme until date is Rs 441 billion, which exceeds the amount released from the government.
The cost per kilometre is Rs 2.3 million and on an average, the ticket size of a project would vary from Rs 10 to
30 million arriving at 5 km to 10 km of typical size of contract.