Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Scope of Presentation
Covers over 90% of the UofA research that we are
involved in
Sequence of coverage:
Heavy steel buildings performance in earthquakes
Reinforced concrete member performance in
earthquakes (yes we have joined the dark side)
Heavy steel buildings performance in severe fires
Cold formed light gauge steel building research
New product or member development
Page 1 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 2 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Apparatus
Connecting
Beam
buckling
Bolted replaceable short
link specimen pairs A-Frame
Page 3 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Experimentation
Cyclic plastic shear
strain Hardness
Yield links via shear Capture bare steel
buckling surface hardness data
Prescribed levels: Before, during & after
testing
3, 5, 7, 10 & 15 %
Constant & variable Strain ageing
amplitudes
Accelerated/artificial
Test; strain age; re-
Relate hardness &
test
plastic strain
Page 4 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
EQ
Page 5 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Experimental Results
Page 6 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Conclusion
RBAL maintains stiffness and strength over a
large amount of cycles
RBAL performance highly dependent on the
hardness of the capping plates.
Bis-Alloy 400 - stable hysteresis (desirable).
Mild steel - gradually increase hysteresis (undesirable)
Further Research
Full scale testing of the EBF and concrete couple shear
walls with RBAL
Finite element analysis to understand local stress on RBAL
during sliding
Optimisation of the RBAL design
SRP Mtg 10th June 2016
Introduction
Page 7 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Importance
The use of the proposed new type bolted replaceable active links
for EBFs would:
Modelling work
FE model of a single storey of a realistic structure, with detailed
modelling of the active link region
Detailed 3D bolt modelling and tightening
An interaction behaviour was defined for all interacting surfaces
A bilinear steel material was modelled with a combined hardening
Cyclic enforced displacements were applied according to AISC
Loading protocol 2010
Page 8 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Experimental work
Two tests of a single storey full-scale EBF structure were carried
out one monotonically loaded while the second one was
subjected to cyclic loading (AISC 2010)
Technical report writing is underway along with the appropriate
analyses
Results
The proposed replaceable active
link has rotation capacity of up to
gp = 0.134 rad
The proposed bolted design
procedure is satisfactory in
suppressing inelastic demand in
all components except the active
linkAn interaction behaviour was
defined for all interacting
surfaces
The bolt tension forces do not
increase which means bolt failure
will not occur during an
earthquake excitation
There is no sliding on the bolted
surfaces of the model, meaning
the no-slip condition is met
Page 9 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Results
Stable hysteretic behaviour
The objective of suppressing the
inelastic demand away from the
active link was achieved
No bolt slippage occurred
The bolts were reused (is this
important?)
FORCE [KN] VS AXIAL STRAINS OF THE BOTTOM RIGHT FLANGE OF FORCE [KN] VS ROTATION [rad]
ACTIVE LINK [m/mm]
500
500
400
400
300
300
Force in the actuator [kN]
100 100
0 0
-10000 -5000 0 5000 10000 15000 -0.040 -0.030 -0.020 -0.010 0.000 0.010 0.020 0.030 0.040 0.050 0.060 0.070
-100 -100
-200 -200
-300 -300
-400 -400
-500
Axial strains of the bottom right flange of the active link -500
Future directions
The two tests were carried out for proving the concept of the
proposed new type bolted replaceable active link
More tests could be carried out in order to enhance the
behaviour of the EBF
An experimental testing of the influence of strain ageing on
the response to a second round of plastic deformation could
also be undertaken.
Page 10 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 11 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Numerical
Modelling
More than 60 different
sections analysed in a
parametric study
Exact same trends as
experimental
i.e. can extrapolate findings
to all sections available
Page 12 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Stiffener Spacing
Equation
Axes are the aspect ratios (X
axis assumes squared
relationship)
Alpha = s/d1; Beta = d1/tw
Dots are experimental
results
Grey line is theoretical
formula
Bottom line is the AISC line
Top line is expansion of
provisions experiments to
the right -> conservative
New Equation
If you use a stocky section
your permitted stiffener
spacing is much higher
For typical lengths Im
guessing the new equation will
just say not to use any
stiffeners
45in. [1.1m] longest link
tested without stiffeners: so
say you have a 310UC137
your spacing is up to 1.2m
from the equation, limited to
1.1m from experimental data.
310UC137 up to 1.1m -> no
stiffeners
200UC60 up to 800mm ->
no stiffeners
Beta = d1/tw this is already
available in steel tables
Beta of 25 is marginal, 21.3
and lower is very high
performance (exponential
relationship)
Page 13 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Other Experiments
Web Doubler Plates
Secondary Element
Demands
Contact Stiffeners
T-EBF concept
Gusset Plates
Page 14 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Motivation and
Objective
2
1. Research Motivation:
1. Conventional ductile structures under severe earthquakes rely on:
1. Inelasticity of the lateral resisting systems.
2. Yielding of selected members to dissipate energy.
2. Structural damage with residual deformation may require
expensive structural repair or demolition.
2. Research Objective:
A novel rocking system utilising a centralised rocking mechanism and
energy dissipation devices is developed to keep the system elastic
during earthquakes and self-centre
the structure after earthquakes.
Vbase
Double Acting
Ring Springs Systems
3
Type I Type II
Experimental testing: Completed Experimental testing: Completed
Page 15 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Test Results
4
Double Acting Ring Springs
Type I Type II
Displacement (mm)
Displacement (mm)
Time (s) Time (s)
Loading Protocol
Loading Protocol
BOT, COMP.
Force (kN) BOT, COMP. Force (kN)
Summary
5
1. The experimental results showed good agreement with the
numerical analysis of the double acting ring springs systems.
Their hysteresis curves are stable, consistent and repeatable.
2. The system self-centring:
1. Type I: Relying on the dynamic force and gravity loading.
2. Type II: Actively self-centring.
3. The final testing phase, bottom storey sub-assemblages
testing, will commence in late June 2016. This testing is to
observe the rocking behaviour and the joints behaviour during
rocking.
Page 16 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 17 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Findings
Further established
findings and ongoing research
Establishing the optimum surface
preparation/roughness level for the AFC plies
sliding surfaces using an AFC test rig on the
MTS machine designed in 2015 (27 tests).
Experimentally investigating the following AFC
configurations:
A shim-less AFC
AFC with TiN coated shims
AFC with abrasion resistant cleat and shims
Developing the analytical SHJAFC elastic bolt
model.
Developing the FEM of the AFC using the
ABAQUS software to redesign the SHJAFC old
test rig to test SHJAFC with customized BeSs,
three rows of bolts, and SFC configuration.
The AFC component tests on the MTS machine
to establish the optimum level of installed bolt
tension and the benefit of customized BeSs.
Developing the design procedure for the use of
BeSs in the friction sliders.
Developing analytical models for the SHJAFC
to optimize the joints design and behaviour
e.g. the optimum beam-column gap.
SRP Mtg 10th June 2016
Page 18 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 19 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 20 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 21 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Research topic
PhD project
By
Behnam Zaboli
Motivation:
Frame action imposes severe demand on gusset plate and
framing components
Inadequacy of existing design equations in predicting the
gusset plate failure loads, and need for a reliable design
approach
Objectives:
Investigate the influence of the flexible gusset to
beam/column connections on the frame actions interaction
with the in-plane actions from the brace
Research further the design procedure that use in NZ which is
based on fundamental principles of resisting a 2.5%
restraining force
Revise the current design equations and effective length
factors for gusset plates
SRP Mtg 10th June 2016
Page 22 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Current research
Current research
Page 23 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Current research
Method
Page 24 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Future directions
Page 25 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 26 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
14 RC beam tests
Holes in cover concrete allow displacement gauges to
be attached directly to longitudinal rebar
Dynamic vs. static loading rates and how this affects strain
distribution in plastic hinge
Page 27 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 28 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Objectives
1. To analyse the behaviour of continuous CFST column with
different types of concrete infill; plain, fibre and reinforcing bar.
Experimental test
Table 1: Experiment test data
e fc Load Load Failure
Column ColumnSize fy FRR
S/N Distance B.C (MPa) (kN) Level Mode
Number (mm) (MPa) (Mins)
(mm)
1 P-1 200 x 200 x 6 0 Fixed-Fixed 86.9 450 1378 0.37 37 b
2 P-2 200 x 200 x 6 0 Fixed-Pinned 81.33 450 1378 0.37 26 b
3 P-3 200 x 200 x 6 25 Fixed-Pinned 89.55 350 1068 0.42 48 b
4 P-4 200 x 200 x 6 50 Fixed-Pinned 78.8 350 872 0.42 26 c
5 P-5 220 x 220 x 6 0 Fixed-Fixed 84.4 310 1415 0.37 38 a
6 P-7 220 x 220 x 6 25 Fixed-Pinned 76.8 310 1127 0.37 80 c
Page 29 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 30 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 31 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Results
SPM results compared with VULCAN simulation
Six slab panels with various slab continuities
were investigated
Aspect Ratio effects were investigated 9m x
9m, 9m x 12m, 9m x 6m
Results
SPM required deflection Vs Vulcan deflections
Slab Panel under fire limit load
9m x 6m
9m
12m
Page 32 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Future Directions
Strength and stiffness requirements for
supporting edge beams (refining current
recommendations_
Page 33 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Introduction
Introduction
Page 34 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Simplified Methods
Membrane enhancements
L
C C nL
S S
T2 T2
T2 T2
T1
Page 35 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Failure Mechanism
Isolated slab panel
Page 36 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Collapse Mechanisms
Collapse Mechanisms
Page 37 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Collapse Mechanisms
Mechanism 1
Collapse Mechanisms
Mechanism 2
Page 38 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Collapse Mechanisms
Edge slab panel
Mechanism 3
Collapse Mechanisms
Corner slab panel
Mechanism 4 - Development
Fire in whole compartment
Page 39 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Collapse Mechanisms
Corner slab panel
Mechanism 4
Collapse Mechanisms
Corner slab panel
Mechanism 4
Page 40 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Conclusions
Edge & Corner slab panel
Mechanism 3
Mechanism 4
Recommendations
Edge & Corner slab panel
Page 41 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 42 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 43 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
by Dr Antony Gillies
Lakehead University, Canada
(Visiting Professor - University of Sheffield and
University of Auckland, 2015-16)
Page 44 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 45 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 46 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 47 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Importance
Combination of thin gauge steel members and large
loading makes storage racking susceptible to collapse
under strong ground motion.
Results to date
Lighter baseplates (S8) have the ability to dissipate much
more energy through uplift cycles than heavy baseplates
(HD).
Page 48 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Future directions
Full-scale static pushover and
snapback testing (June, 2016)
Page 49 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Importance
Combination of thin gauge steel members and large
loading makes storage racking susceptible to collapse
under strong ground motion.
Results to date
Lighter baseplates (S8) have the ability to dissipate much
more energy through uplift (by steel yielding) cycles than
heavy baseplates (HD).
Page 50 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Results to date
15
Influenceofloadingvelocity 15
Influenceoflateralload
10 10
0 0
0 5 10 15 20 5 0 5 10 15 20 25
Displacement(mm) Displacement(mm)
5 5
10 10
15 15
35
30
Number of bolts
Friction force (kN)
25
20
15
10
5
0
1 2 3
Bolt Bolts Bolts
Number of bolts
Page 51 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Future directions
Full-scale static pushover and
snapback testing (June, 2016)
Page 52 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 53 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Future Study
Components Tests
Howick has recently developed new channel section and HRC for
industrial building construction such as warehouses. There are range
of tests need to be conducted to measure the capacity of every
components.
Truss Tests
The truss system is the major part of this research. It is crucial to
test the channel section and the HRC within a system i.e. truss
assembly to determine the ultimate limit state and serviceability of
the Howick truss system.
Full-scale Tests
A truss portal framing system will be designed based on the
collected experimental data. It is proposed to have two bays (three
portal frames) where they are connected through purlins, girts and
fly bracing in out-of-plane direction. This is to experimentally
determine the performance of the complete portal framing system.
Then, the middle frame will be tested.
PhD project by
Amir Mohammad Yousefi
Supervising by
James Lim and Charles Clifton
Page 54 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Research Underway:
Investigate web crippling behaviour of cold-formed steel with
web opening using numerical techniques.
Propose design recommendation.
Proposing new strength reduction factor equations
Future Research
Plain and Lipped channel sections
One and two flange loadings
Both flanges fastened and unfastened to the bearing plates
Two types of web openings
Examine effects of web openings on web crippling strength
Proposing new web crippling strength equations
Page 55 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Research Objective
1. To fully understand the behaviour of steel weatherboards and interlocking panels under rain and wind load.
2. To determine the effect of condensation on the inside face of the steel weatherboard and how to eliminate
undesirable effects of this.
5. To Perform Lab Testing for large-scale water leakage at steady pressure and fluctuating air pressures.
6 To Perform Lab Testing for small-scale water leakage at steady pressure and fluctuating air pressures.
7. To develop an advanced CFD (Computational fluid dynamics) model that will be validated against the
experimental tests and can be used to predict the behaviour of different weatherboard profiles under wind and
rain.
8. To develop an insulated steel weatherboard comprising steel with bonded PIR or PUR.
Page 56 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
2. Steel weatherboard cladding and interlocking panel system can be used in buildings designed for weather
tightness in accordance with New Zealands building control system.
3. From this research we can get an optimised steel weatherboard profile, which will give maximum weather
resistance even at severe weather condition.
2. Results will have application for pacific countries (New Zealand) using steel weatherboard and interlocking
panels, because of the generic nature of the results obtained and the capability of the CFD model.
4. This will increase the confidence to use steel weatherboard and interlocking panels in buildings. It is ideal,
attractive (Can give classic finish) and low-maintenance alternative to timber weatherboards.
5. The industry will benefit from the results of this project as there will be less need to conduct full scale weather
tests on different steel weatherboard and interlocking panels systems, as a CFD model will be developed to
validate the tests results which will minimize the projects cost.
Future Studies
Experimental Tests:
Test Rig-(2.4*3.6m)
1. Preconditioning-
Apply a preconditioning loading to the external face of the test sample for a period of 1
minute of positive pressure, followed by a period of 1 minute of negative pressure(suction).
The loading shall be 1515 Pa.
Numerical Modelling:
An advanced CFD model will be developed to predict the behaviour of steel weatherboards and
interlocking panels under rain and wind load.
CFD model will be used for parametric studies. SRP Mtg 10th June 2016
Page 57 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
-LGSF Connections
(Stud to Bottom Track)
-Multi-Story Cold Formed Building
Students: Chia Mohammadjani (PhD) Sidhant Kumar (ME)
Supervisors: Professor Charles Clifton and Dr James Lim
The University of Auckland
Project Scope
The limiting strength of the bottom storey connection is the attachment of the wall base to the concrete in tension. This is
potentially a good mode of failure as, provided the wall doesnt start to slide due to vertical uplift, the rocking mode of
behaviour will absorb energy and allow a structural ductility factor greater than 1.25 to be used. It could be used in the
following way:
For attachments to the seismic bracing panels.
These are designed to rock, with uplift on the tension side. So the hold down system comprises HD bolts with springs between
the plate washer and the head of the HD bolt. That fastener (or pairs of fasteners) would be near the edge column of the
bracing panel (BP) so that, under seismic induced tension, controlled uplifting of the column can occur through elastic
squashing of the spring. On further thought, maybe the fastener on one side is as per the tested detail ie without the spring
and it is intended to be firmly connected to the concrete under the seismic design tension action on the stud associated with
say = 2 and Sp = 0.7. When uplift occurs, this one starts to pull out and the fastener on the other side can uplift on the
spring providing increasing resistance to further uplift
On the compression side the bearing forces go straight into the concrete slab; there is no gap between the end of the stud and
the web of the bottom plate.
Along the length of the bottom plate bracing unit into the concrete slab are one or preferably two other HD bolts without
springs. These are away from the tension columns (say midway between studs) so that they wont be pulled out of the concrete
and are designed to transfer the earthquake induced base shears into the walls and thus prevent base sliding.
For the attachments to the non seismic bracing unit walls.
These are the standard HD detail placed as specified in the NASH book or probably better placed midway between studs so
they are not subject to strong uplifting tension.
Page 58 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 59 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Experimental Results
Tension test was conducted on a concrete slab and once
tension force was applied there was a pull out of anchor bolt
at about 20kN. Further tension tests are now being carried
out in the lab on a steel beam to find the connection
capacity.
Compression test carried out on a 1.15mm
thickness Cee section with and without end bearing 8.00E+01
Graph of Loading vs
showed the following results. The local buckling 6.00E+01
Dispalcement
failure was observed and the complete failure of 4.00E+01
Loadings (kN)
specimen is around 55kN. Axial shortening has
2.00E+01
been noticed. It follows that bearing type without W
0.00E+00
any gap is a superior choice for cold form steel stud
0.2028642
1.4912546
2.5460248
4.2726222
4.4200332
4.5501346
4.5965238
4.6635358
4.7648524
4.4337964
4.7034416
3.887477
4.507272
Displacement (mm)
in medium rise buildings in terms of axial -2.00E+01
shortening performance
Page 60 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
General Concepts
The aim of the HERA project is to built a multi-story
apartment purely made of light-gage steel elements. Therefore,
the vertical studs, horizontal stubs, joists and even the cold-
formed trusses will make a unique structural system consisting
of only thin walled members. These structural members had
to be integrated to make the specific cold formed walls. The
walls are responsible to withstand both against the vertical
gravity loads and against the lateral load shocks made by
earthquake and wind loads.
Shear Walls
The shear walls had to be designed to take the gravity loads
and the lateral loads
After placing the first story walls, the second story walls will sit
on them so that the bottom section of upper studs will
coincide with the top section of below studs of the below
wall.
After that the wall was affected by the lateral load, one edge
will be under compression while the other one will act under
tension. For the tension side, the pull out strength of the
connections should be checked under different earthquake
loadings. Shear Walls sitting on top of each other
Page 61 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Objective:
Develop ULW concrete ( < 300 kg/m3 ) for
structural applications.
Aggregate is PLA from wood waste
No toxic gasses in fire
Use with thin steel sheet
High sustainability rating
SRP Mtg 10th June 2016
Page 62 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Page 63 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Results to date
21 beams in total, each batch group containing fibre dosage
rates of 20kg/m^3 and 25kg/m^3:
Group 1: 6 beams with unaltered paperclips as fibres
Group 2: 6 beams with Dramix 3D steel fibres
Group 3: 6 beams with paperclips cut in half as fibres
Group 4: 3 beams with standard reinforcement
Concrete mix design (without any fibre/standard
reinforcement) trails (specified 36MPa at 28 days)
Cylinders (200x100)
7 days: 29MPa
28 days: 38Mpa
Paperclips within the concrete matrix are in good condition;
they have not reacted to the alkaline of the cement
Have not encountered major clumping/tangling of paperclips
in mix
Individual paperclip strength under tensile loading ~758MPa
Page 64 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Photos of trials
Page 65 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Push-off Tests
Push-off testing will be
undertaken to
determine shear
connector behaviour
when attached to a
thin flange
Shear connector
ductility (and any
flange bending
contribution to this
ductility) will be
established th
SRP Mtg 10 June 2016
Page 66 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Shear
Load connector
Steel decking
Page 67 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
Disadvantages
1- 15% heavier
2- More End-plate
connection is needed for Fabricated three-plate I-Shaped Cold-formed Nested Channels
long spans
Software Creation
Creating a Software to minimize :
1- Material Weight
2-Waste
3-Erection cost
4- Design time
Page 68 of 21
2016 Steel Research Panel University of Auckland Presentation 10 June 2016
To investigate
The Validity of the design procedure for the members and connections
Page 69 of 21