You are on page 1of 7

[Downloadedfreefromhttp://www.ijaweb.orgonFriday,November14,2014,IP:117.201.155.

79]||ClickheretodownloadfreeAndroidapplicationforthisjournal

Review Article

Legal and ethical issues in safe blood transfusion

Address for correspondence: Shivaram Chandrashekar, Ambuja Kantharaj


Dr. Shivaram Chandrashekar, Department of Transfusion Medicine, Manipal Hospital, Bangalore, India
No.802,3rdmain, BEML
5thStage, Rajarajeshwarinagar,
Bangalore - 560 098, ABSTRACT
Karnataka, India.
Email:shivaram@
Legal issues play a vital role in providing a framework for the Indian blood transfusion service(BTS),
manipalhospitals.com
while ethical issues pave the way for quality. Despite licensing of all blood banks, failure to revamp the
Drugs and Cosmetic Act(D and C Act) is impeding quality. Newer techniques like chemiluminescence
or nucleic acid testing(NAT) find no mention in the D and C Act. Specialised products like pooled
platelet concentrates or modified whole blood, therapeutic procedures like erythropheresis, plasma
exchange, stem cell collection and processing technologies like leukoreduction and irradiation are not
a part of the D and C Act. Ahighly fragmented BTS comprising of over2500 blood banks, coupled with
a slow and tedious process of dual licensing(state and centre) is a hindrance to smooth functioning
of blood banks. Small size of blood banks compromises blood safety. New blood banks are opened
in India by hospitals to meet requirements of insurance providers or by medical colleges as this a
Medical Council of India(MCI) requirement. Hospital based blood banks opt for replacement donation
Access this article online as they are barred by law from holding camps. Demand for fresh blood, lack of components, and
Website: www.ijaweb.org lack of guidelines for safe transfusion leads to continued abuse of blood. Differential pricing of blood
components is difficult to explain scientifically or ethically. Accreditation of blood banks along with
DOI: 10.4103/0019-5049.144654
establishment of regional testing centres could pave the way to blood safety. National Aids Control
Quick response code
Organisation(NACO) and National Blood Transfusion Council(NBTC) deserve a more proactive role
in the licensing process. The Food and Drug Administration(FDA) needs to clarify that procedures
or tests meant for enhancement of blood safety are not illegal.

Key words: Blood transfusion services, Drugs and Cosmetic Act(D and C Act), ethical, legal,
National Aids Control Organisation, transfusion

INTRODUCTION and Cosmetics Rules, 1945.[3] With the classification


of blood as a drug, the drugs controller became the
Legal issues play a vital role in shaping the structure regulatory authority. Licensing is only the first step
of blood transfusion services(BTS) in the country towards quality. The Indian BTS is highly fragmented
and ethical issues play a more significant role in with over2500 blood banks and poses unique
determining the quality of transfusion services. Thanks challenges.
to the Supreme Court directive in 1993, making
licensing of blood banks in the country mandatory, ELEMENTS OF BLOOD SAFETY
all blood banks are licensed today. Licensing became
mandatory consequent to the landmark judgement in Safe donor
the petitionCommon Cause vs. Union of India in Safe blood comes from an altruistic voluntary donor
January, 1992.[1] The honourable court also directed that who donates blood without any expectations. Arepeat
the National Blood Transfusion Council(NBTC) along voluntary donor[4] is one who donates blood at least
with State Blood Transfusion Councils(SBTC) be set once a year and is considered safer than occasional
up for monitoring the activity of blood banks in India.[2] voluntary donors, as the blood bank is aware of his
previous test results also. Friends and relatives of
Blood has been treated as a drug under the Drugs patients called replacement donors constitute a
and Cosmetic Act(D and C Act), 1940 and Drugs significant chunk of blood donors in our country but

How to cite this article: Chandrashekar S, Kantharaj A. Legal and ethical issues in safe blood transfusion. Indian J Anaesth 2014;58:558-64.

558 Indian Journal of Anaesthesia | Vol. 58 | Issue 5 | Sep-Oct 2014


[Downloadedfreefromhttp://www.ijaweb.orgonFriday,November14,2014,IP:117.201.155.79]||ClickheretodownloadfreeAndroidapplicationforthisjournal

Chandrashekar and Kantharaj: Legal and ethical issues in blood transfusion

are not really safe donors[5] as they are forced by family Role of National Aids Control Organization
or friends to donate blood. Professional/paid donors Many improvements seen in our country over the
may sometimes be passed off as replacement donors last decade and a half has been the result of licensing
too. Some papers have shown that one time voluntary which laid down minimum requirements in terms of
donors are no better than replacement donors[6] space, staff and equipment and also National Aids
Control Organization(NACO) support for blood
Safe blood safety.[17] While the drugs controller is the regulatory
Blood banks have traditionally employed enzyme authority, NACO/NBTC has been the main technical
linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) techniques for body to frame guidelines for the practice of transfusion
donor screening. Tests with greater sensitivity or those medicine. The NBP is an offshoot of the National Aids
which take lesser time duration like chemiluminescence Control Program.[18] NACO together with NBTC has
(CLIA)/enzymelinked fluorescence assay(ELFA) are played a pivotal role in improving blood safety by
increasingly being used by blood banks.[7] Of late, infrastructure development, setting up component
expensive technologies like nucleic acid testing(NAT) separation units, promoting voluntary blood donation,
have added to blood safety.[810] In addition to training staff and has also laid down standards for
transfusion transmitted infections(TTI) testing, red blood banks in India [Figure 2].[19]
cell antibodies screening being adopted by many blood
banks and the newer gel/bead techniques have also Licensing of blood banks by drugs controller
added to blood safety. Blood processing techniques The procedure for licensing of blood banks is written
like leukoreduction,[11] Irradiation[12] and pathogen in the D and C Act 1940 and Drugs and Cosmetics
inactivation[13,14] are expected to play an increasingly Rules, 1945. Basic licensing standards for blood banks
important role in enhancing blood safety in future.[15] have remained unchanged over the past decades.[20]
The D and C act has only seen minor changes such
Safe transfusion as rising the age of donation from 60 to 65years and
While there are some guidelines for safe donor selection recognition of transfusion medicine as a specialty.
and safe blood processing, there are no transfusion Perhaps the only major amendment has been the
triggers or national guidelines for safe transfusion. The guidelines for setting up blood storage centres.
(D and C Act) does not speak about patient informed
consent, patient identification, and administration of Who can operate a blood bank
blood or haemovigilance [Figure 1]. Any individual or institution can apply for opening
of a blood bank. Following an application to the
FRAMEWORK OF INDIAN BLOOD TRANSFUSION drugs controller, a joint inspection is conducted by
SERVICES drug control authorities from state and centre which
make a recommendation to the Central Licensing
National blood policy
Approving Authority(CLAA), which is the ultimate
The National Blood Policy[16](NBP) was published by
authority for grant of license. This drug controller
the Government of India in 2002. The NBP reiterates
inspection is preceded by an inspection by the SBTC,
government commitment to safe blood and blood
the advisory body, which gives its consent to the
components and has well documented strategies, for
drugs controller.
making available adequate resources, technology and
training for improving transfusion services. It also Space requirements
outlines methods for donor motivation and appropriate Minimum standards for space, equipment and staff
clinical use of blood by clinicians. It has also taken have to be met with by all blood banks, and these are
steps for R and D in transfusion medicine. Further, it inspected at the time of grant/renewal of the license. An
is also entrusted with the job of ensuring legislation area of 100 sqm for whole blood and an additional 50
and education to eliminate profiteering in blood banks sqm for blood components and 10 sqm for aphaeresis
is needed for operating a blood bank in India.
Blood Safety
Staff requirements
Safe Donor Safe Blood Safe Transfusion The medical officer may be a person with MD in
Transfusion Medicine or Pathology, Diploma in
Figure 1: Elements of blood safety.
Source: Editor-Dr. Shivaram. Transfusion Medicine for Clinicians, Pathology with 6months experience or MBBS
Prism Publications, 2011 qualified with 1year experience in blood banking.

Indian Journal of Anaesthesia | Vol. 58 | Issue 5 | Sep-Oct 2014 559


[Downloadedfreefromhttp://www.ijaweb.orgonFriday,November14,2014,IP:117.201.155.79]||ClickheretodownloadfreeAndroidapplicationforthisjournal

Chandrashekar and Kantharaj: Legal and ethical issues in blood transfusion

Technicians with BSc (MLT) or DMLT and staff nurses Administration is a matter of debate.[21] The drugs
are additional requirements [Table1]. controller is already burdened with so many drugs,
devices and clinical trial licensing that monitoring
PITFALLS IN LICENSING PROCESS 2500+blood banks in the country is a herculean task.
Transfusion medicine is emerging as a superspecialty
Who should regulate today including blood banking, aphaeresis, cell biology,
Whether a blood bank should come under the purview molecular biology and therapeutic procedures. Drugs
of the regulatory authority overseeing Food and Drug controllers being basically pharmacologists have no
training in transfusion medicine but are expected to
Table1 Steps in blood bank licensing process look into quality control(QC) of blood components,
A pplication with fees by individual/institution called the licensee in
form 27C TTI testing, immunohaematology. NACO/NBTC is a
Scrutiny of application by state DC and SBTC technical body well equipped to regulate and monitor
Inspection of blood bank by SBTC and grant of no objection blood banks but plays an advisory role only. Thus,
certificate for grant of license
while the legal aspects pertaining to infrastructure,
Inspection of blood bank premises by joint(centre and state)
inspection team equipments, spacing and staff are monitored by the
Recommendation to CLAA for licensing drugs controller effectively, the medical and quality
Grant of license in form 28C aspects of transfusion medicine are neglected.
S BTCState Blood Transfusion Council; DCDrug Controller;
CLAACentral Licensing Approving Authority Involving carefully chosen experts in transfusion

Figure2: Organogram of Indian Blood Transfusion Service.


Source: Action Plan for Blood safety Manual-NACO/NBTC[16]

560 Indian Journal of Anaesthesia | Vol. 58 | Issue 5 | Sep-Oct 2014


[Downloadedfreefromhttp://www.ijaweb.orgonFriday,November14,2014,IP:117.201.155.79]||ClickheretodownloadfreeAndroidapplicationforthisjournal

Chandrashekar and Kantharaj: Legal and ethical issues in blood transfusion

medicine with the Drug controllers complimenting plateletpheresis, plasmapheresis, leukapheresis


them will make regulation more meaningful. peripheral blood stem cell [PBSC] collection and red
cell exchange. Blood bankers are the most competent
The dual licensing system staff to perform these procedures in conjunction with
The dual licensing system for grant or renewal of the clinicians. Clarity is needed in the D and C Act
the license has made the licensing process very on therapeutic procedures. Surely, use of PBSC for
tedious and slow with no time limits. Like in some traditional applications like leukaemia, lymphomas,
departments, nonadministrative considerations too aplastic anaemia, myelomas, haemoglobinopathies
play an important role in getting a license in some needs no permission. If that were to be the case then
places. The excessive regulations(License Raj) related appendicectomy, hysterectomy, cataract surgery
to system and minimum requirements for blood banks would also need licensing. Accreditation, a peer
should be removed and updated more rationally; review process could be an effective alternative
delays in updating the D and C Act or in setting up wherever licensing is deficient but national guidelines
a mechanism to audit the blood banks is impeding are available.
blood safety considerations in India.
PROBLEMS FACED BY THE INDIAN BLOOD
The Drugs and Cosmetic Act TRANSFUSION SERVICE
This needs urgent revision due to advances in
transfusion science. Clarity on what blood banks can Fragmented blood transfusion service
or cannot do is essential. For instance, leukoreduced Blood banks are opened in India for various reasons.
and irradiated blood components, without which Some hospitals open blood banks as they are denied
many cancer patients and thalassaemic children would permission to open storage centres. Only Regional
not be alive, find no place in the D and C Act. The act Blood Transfusion centre(RBTC) are permitted to open
does not specify whether a separate license is needed storage centres and very few blood banks are RBTCs.
for leukoreduction and irradiation. However, there Some hospitals open blood banks because insurance
are national standards for QC of leukoreduction and providers allow them to charge higher for their services
irradiation laid down by NACO. One suggestion by with a blood bank. Medical colleges open blood banks
authors, pending revamping of the D and C Act, is to to meet Medical Council of India requirement.[26] The
clarify by way of a circular that any additional procedure government opens blood banks in various districts due
done to improve blood safetylike leukoreduction, to pressure from elected representatives. When blood
irradiation or NAT testing requires no licensing. banks are opened, not because there is a real need and
when there are not enough competent people to run
Apheresis licensing them, or enough workload to sustain the operations,
Blood banks are required to seek special permission then quality is compromised. More blood storage
showing equipment, space and staff available centres and not more blood banks is the solution.
for Apheresis. The D and C Act mentions only
plateletpheresis, plasmapheresis and leukapheresis Size of blood banks and screening methodologies
on donors whereas it is the products, that is, single Studies[27] have shown that compared with medium
donor(apheresis) platelets(SDP), plasma and and large labs, small labs have higher rates of false
leukocytes(granulocytes/mononuclear cells) that negativity for human immunodeficiency virus and
need licensing and not procedures. Many other hepatitis B surface antigen. Blood banks with small
specialised products like modified whole blood(whole workloads(5-10 donors/day) compromise safety by
blood minus platelets or cryoprecipitate) must also be using rapid tests, which are associated with a delay
included. While it is legal to give six random donor of over1week in antibody detection.[28] QC measures
platelets one after the other, the same cannot be pooled to guarantee safety in TTI testing like Levy Jennings
in a closed system, filtered and given together as pooled chart for ELISA, is almost nonexistent, except in few
platelet concentrate. Pooled platelet concentrates[2225] blood banks.
are used in Europe as an effective substitute to the
more expensive SDP. Absence of standards for safe transfusion
National Aids Control Organisation/NBTC standards
Therapeutic procedures address only safe donor and safe blood issues and
Today many blood bankers are competent enough do not cover safe transfusion, the third element of
to do specialized procedures like therapeutic blood safety. Transfusion triggers are at best limited
Indian Journal of Anaesthesia | Vol. 58 | Issue 5 | Sep-Oct 2014 561
[Downloadedfreefromhttp://www.ijaweb.orgonFriday,November14,2014,IP:117.201.155.79]||ClickheretodownloadfreeAndroidapplicationforthisjournal

Chandrashekar and Kantharaj: Legal and ethical issues in blood transfusion

to individual institutions. Further, there are no audits Informed consent for transfusion
by a competent technical body to ensure compliance This requirement again is an offshoot of a legal
with standards. directive by the National Consumer Redressal Forum.
In the case of M. Chinnaiyan vs Sri Gokulam Hospital
Curbs on conducting blood donation camps and Anr, which declared consent of the patient is
Only licensed RBTCs, government blood banks, Indian required for transfusion of blood. Surgery carries
Red Cross Society or licensed blood bank run by risks, but blood transfusion carries additional risks.[31]
voluntary or charitable organisations are permitted to
hold blood donation camps as per the D and C Act.[29] Informed consent must be a written document
Withholding permission for camps affect many good explaining the risks, benefits and alternatives to
blood banks and could be a factor impeding voluntary transfusion[32,33] taken after a dialogue between the
blood donation. This law needs a relook, if we want to treating physician and the transfusion recipient. For
achieve 100% voluntary blood donation. minors and unconscious patients the next of kin should
sign an informed consent. Authors also feel that it is
Failure to incorporate new technologies and employ safer to have a neutral witness in the case of highrisk
centralised testing transfusions, like autoimmune haemolytic anaemia.
Newer testing technologies like NAT/CLIA/ELFA do
not find any mention in the D and C Act, and some Positive patient identification
regulatory authorities are also ignorant about these new A documented method/protocol for positive(correct)
techniques. While closing down small blood banks in a patient identification is essential. Absence of this may
fragmented BTS is easier said than done, centralization lead to wrong transfusions and may be construed as
of TTI testing is not difficult to achieve by legislation. negligence on the part of the doctors. Use of wrist bands is
WHO also recommends centralized/regionalised testing oneway of achieving this. Clerical errors account for the
as one of the policies to be adopted to improve blood majority of preventable adverse transfusion reactions.[34]
safety.[30] Centralised testing centres for ELISA/NAT
Monitoring transfusion
manned by experts in transfusion medicine, coupled
Transfusion should be prescribed and administered
with an effective courier system may be set up as a first
under medical direction. National(NACO) guidelines
step towards consolidation of the Indian BTS. recommend continuous supervision during transfusion.
Over reliance on testing technologies
Most international guidelines[35] recommend monitoring
TTI testing alone cannot guarantee safe blood. The
the vital signs before the start of transfusion(time 0),
world has moved on from testing technologies to 15min after transfusion, completion of transfusion
processing technologies but processing technologies and 1h posttransfusion for delayed reactions.
find no mention in the Dand C Act. While NACO/ Atransfusion card developed on the lines of the drug
NBTC laid down guidelines for leukoreduction and card to document patient demographic data and vital
irradiation as early as in 2007, there is ignorance signs along with details of the unit administered will
regarding this among many blood bankers and drug help in correct and complete documentation.
inspectors alike.
Failure to amalgamate good manufacturing practices
Deficiencies in documentation and monitoring of with good clinical practices
bedside transfusions The clinical establishment(registration and regulation
Blood request form act 2010) if implemented will go a long way in
As per the D and C Act the blood and/or its components blending of good manufacturing practices with good
shall be distributed on the prescription of a Registered clinical practices guidelines and can bring blood
Medical Practitioner. However, owing to practical bankers closer to clinicians and help in delivery of
difficulties, this rule is seldom followed. The D and safer transfusion practices. This is, unfortunately,
C Act must be revamped to replace manual signatures implemented to a small extent in some states only.
with electronic signatures of doctors.
CHANGING FACE OF TRANSFUSION MEDICINE IN
Indication for transfusion INDIA
This is another D and C Act requirement which
is seldom followed, possibly because there are no Thankfully things are changing in India.
standard guidelines. Nongovernmental organisations can be credited for

562 Indian Journal of Anaesthesia | Vol. 58 | Issue 5 | Sep-Oct 2014


[Downloadedfreefromhttp://www.ijaweb.orgonFriday,November14,2014,IP:117.201.155.79]||ClickheretodownloadfreeAndroidapplicationforthisjournal

Chandrashekar and Kantharaj: Legal and ethical issues in blood transfusion

improving voluntary blood donation with support banks need to be avoided to ensure ethical practices
from NACO. Private hospitals are trying to improve especially with reference to manufacturers/suppliers
the quality by focusing on emerging technologies. of kits and reagents. Hierarchy of reporting should
The industry must be credited for pushing improved be clearly delineated with checks and balances to
testing in the form of NAT, antibody screening, avoid bias and ensure that science and ethics play a
antigen typing, better blood bags, leukoreduction and more important part than commerce in the practice of
bacterial detection systems. The transfusion medicine transfusion medicine.
associations like Indian Society of Transfusion
Medicine and Asian association of Transfusion Absence of transfusion triggers poses an ethical
Medicine also deserve credit for the reforms that we challenge to blood bankers, as the treating physician
see with respect to blood usage. Whole blood is a who goes by his instinct is always right. The
thing of the past and now in many good institutions community perceives blood bankers as businessman
technologies like leukoreduction, irradiation is a selling blood to earn a livelihood. In reality blood,
routine practice. We have a National Accreditation bankers are one of the poorly paid professionals
Board for Hospitals and Healthcare Providers(NABH) compared to other clinical specialties. If blood bankers
accreditation programme exclusively for blood banks, need minimum qualification to run a blood bank, so do
run by Quality Council of India(QCI). We also have drug inspectors. Drug inspectors must be trained for at
a National Haemovigilance Program of India[36] to least a year in the basics of blood banking, apheresis
monitor recipient adverse transfusion reactions, and molecular biology before inspecting blood banks.
but these being voluntary programs, participation is Inspection team should be drawn from a list of experts
limited. with blood banking experience lead by a technical
expert and should include the drugs controller.
ETHICAL ISSUES IN SAFE BLOOD TRANSFUSION
SUMMARY
Hospital based blood banks are compelled to practice
replacement donations as they are denied permission The D and C Act needs to be reviewed every 2years, to
to hold camps. Scientifically, directed donations are to keep in tune with the changing times and needs to be
be discouraged, but practically they are sought after by modified to state that in the event of any component or
recipients and physicians, posing an ethical challenge procedure not included in the D and C Act, the same
to blood bankers. All blood bankers would like to may be performed by the blood bank as per standards
use blood judiciously as blood components, however laid down by NACO/NABH. NBTC should engage in
demand for whole blood leads to the contrary. The the licensing process more actively. Dual licensing
transfusion trigger for red cells was set at 10g/dl at system by state and centre should be abolished, and the
the turn of the 20thcentury as it left little room for licensing procedure simplified to grant/renew licenses
anaesthetic errors.[37] This has changed considerably within a maximum of 3months. SBTCs must run one
over the years. However, some anaesthetists refuse large stateoftheart blood bank in every state to get an
to administer anaesthesia unless the haemoglobin idea of the costing of blood, which can be employed to
is up to their expectation leading to unnecessary fix processing fees for other blood banks. Accredited
transfusions. Ablood bank doing lifesaving regional testing centres by private players or through
procedures like erythropheresis, plasma exchange, publicprivate partnership should be encouraged to
not mentioned in the D and C Act is scientifically ensure quality in testing and bring down cost. Suitable
and ethically correct, but may be legally incorrect. amendments to the act are necessary to facilitate this.
NBTC prescribes differential rates for different blood Emphasis of inspection, audits should be to enhance
components, based on economic considerations, the quality by adherence to standards and protocols
rather than ethical considerations. If the money is for and must facilitate smooth functioning of blood banks.
processing only, then all components should be priced Licensing should not become a hindrance to the
uniformly. Blood bankers are expected by community adoption of safe transfusion practices.
to provide the highest quality blood, free or at a low
price, which maybe ethically right but economically REFERENCES
unviable. Ethical practices need to be implemented
1. DhotPS. Amendments to Indian drugs and cosmetics act and
by management and staff of blood banks. Conflict rules pertaining to blood banks in armed forces. Med J Armed
of interest involving management and staff of blood Forces India 2005;61:26466

Indian Journal of Anaesthesia | Vol. 58 | Issue 5 | Sep-Oct 2014 563


[Downloadedfreefromhttp://www.ijaweb.orgonFriday,November14,2014,IP:117.201.155.79]||ClickheretodownloadfreeAndroidapplicationforthisjournal

Chandrashekar and Kantharaj: Legal and ethical issues in blood transfusion

2. AgrawalSC, PattanaikGB. Court of India Common 22. PlazaEM, LozanoML, GuiuIS, EgeaJM, VicenteV, De TernLC,
Cause vs Union of India and Others on 4January, 1996; etal. Evaluation of platelet function during extended storage
Bench. Available from http://www.indiankanoon.org/ in additive solution, prepared in a new container that allows
doc/1449517/?type=print/.[Last accessed on 2014Aug08]. manual buffycoat platelet pooling and leucoreduction in the
3. Drugs and Cosmetic Act. Available from http://www.cdsco.nic. same system. Blood Transfus 2012;10:4809.
in/writereaddata/Drugs and CosmeticAct.pdf.[Last accessed 23. SchifferCA, AndersonKC, BennettCL, BernsteinS, EltingLS,
on 2014Aug08]. GoldsmithM, etal. Platelet transfusion for patients with
4. Voluntary Blood Donation ProgrammeAn Operational cancer: Clinical practice guidelines of the American Society of
Guideline, National AIDS Control Organization Ministry Clinical Oncology. JClin Oncol 2001;19:151938.
of Health and Family Welfare, Government of India, 2007. 24. LozanoML, RiveraJ, VicenteV. Platelet concentrates from
Available from http://naco.gov.in/upload/Policies%20 and %20 wholeblood donations(buffycoat) or apheresis: Which one to
Guidelines/29,%20voluntary%20blood%20donation.pdf[Last use?. Med Clin(Barc) 2012;138:52833.
accessed on 2014Aug08]. 25. BurchM, SchneiderR, BarakatA, AbushahinL, CaoY,
5. JainR, GuptaG. Family/friend donors are not true voluntary EwingJ, etal. Results of an educational program to promote
donors. Asian J Transfus Sci 2012;6:2931. the use of pooled instead of singledonor platelet transfusions.
6. AllainJP. Moving on from voluntary nonremunerated donors: Proc(Bayl Univ Med Cent) 2013;26:35.
Who is the best blood donor? Br J Haematol 2011;154:7639. 26. Minimum Standard Requirements for the Medical College
7. AlvarezM, ChuecaN, GuillotV, Bernal MdelC, Garca F. for 50 Admissions Annually Regulations, 1999,(amended
Improving clinical laboratory efficiency: Introduction of up to November 2010). NewDelhi: Medical Council of
Systems for the Diagnosis and Monitoring of HIV Infection. India. Available from http://www.mciindia.org/forcolleges/
Open Virol J 2012;6:13543. Minimum%20Standard%20Requirements%20for%2050%20
8. ChandrashekarS. Half a decade of minipool nucleic acid Admissions.pdf[Last accessed on 2014Aug08].
testing: Costeffective way for improving blood safety in India. 27. GrijalvaMJ, ChiribogaRF, VanhasselH, ArcosTeranL.
Asian J Transfus Sci 2014;8:358. Improving the safety of the blood supply in Ecuador through
9. ChatterjeeK, CoshicP, BorgohainM, Premchand, ThapliyalRM, external performance evaluation of serological screening of
ChakrobortyS, etal. Individual donor nucleic acid testing for blood donors. JClin Virol 2005;34Suppl2:S4752.
blood safety against HIV1 and hepatitis B and C viruses in a 28. NarayanS. Microbes and blood transfusion. Indian J Med
tertiary care hospital. Natl Med J India 2012;25:2079. Microbiol 2001;19:11926.
10. ShyamalaV. Factors in enhancing blood safety by nucleic 29. The Gazette of India: Extraordinary, Ministry of Health
acid technology testing for human immunodeficiency virus, and Family Welfare, Notification GSR 218(e). 28Mar, 2001.
hepatitis C virus and hepatitis B virus. Asian J Transfus Sci Available from: http://www.cdsco.nic.in/writereaddata/
2014;8:138. GSR_218(E).pdf [Last accessed on 2014Aug08].
11. SniecinskiI, ODonnellMR, NowickiB, HillLR. Prevention of 30. Screening donated blood for transfusionWHO
refractoriness and HLAalloimmunization using filtered blood recommendations. Available from http://www.who.int/
products. Blood 1988;71:14027. bloodsafety/Screening DonatedBloodforTransfusion.pdf
12. PrzepiorkaD, LeParcGF, StovallMA, WerchJ, LichtigerB. Use [Last accessed on 2014Aug08].
of irradiated blood components: Practice parameter. Am J Clin 31. Chinnaiyan M Vs Sri Gokulam Hospital and Anr. On
Pathol 1996;106:611. 25September, 2006. Available from http://www.indiankanoon.
13. SchmidtM, GeilenkeuserWJ, SireisW, SeifriedE, HourfarK. org/doc/1919829/[Last accessed on 2014Aug08].
Emerging PathogensHow Safe is Blood? Transfus Med 32. GoodnoughLT, ShuckJM. Risks, options, and informed
Hemother 2014;41:107. consent for blood transfusion in elective surgery. Am J Surg
14. LozanoM, CidJ. Pathogen inactivation: Coming of age. Curr 1990;159:6029.
Opin Hematol 2013;20:5405. 33. KolinsJ, KolinsMD. Informed consent, risk, and blood
15. SandlerSG. Emerging technologies in transfusion medicine. transfusion. JThorac Cardiovasc Surg 1990;100:8891.
NEngl J Med 2004;351:5134. 34. de VriesRR, FaberJC, StrengersPF, Board of the International
16. Action Plan for Blood Safety. Available from http://www.hsph. Haemovigilance Network. Haemovigilance: An effective tool
harvard.edu/population/aids/india.aids. 07.pdf[Last accessed for improving transfusion practice. Vox Sang 2011;100:607.
on 2014Aug08] 35. HarrisAM, AtterburyCLJ, ChaffeB, ElliottC, HawkinsT,
17. RamaniKV, MavalankarDV, GovilD. Study of bloodtransfusion HennemSJ, etal. Guideline on the Administration of Blood
services in Maharashtra and Gujarat States, India. JHealth Components. British Committee for Standards in Hematology;
Popul Nutr 2009;27:25970. 2009. Available from http://www.bcshguidelines.com/
18. MarwahaN. Whole blood and component use in resource poor documents/Admin_blood_components_bcsh_05012010.pdf.
settings. Biologicals 2010;38:6871. [Last accessed on 2014Aug08].
19. Standards for Blood Banks NACO/NBTC. Available from 36. BishtA, SinghS, MarwahaN. Hemovigilance programIndia.
http://www.naco.gov.in/upload/final%20publications/ Asian J Transfus Sci 2013;7:734.
blood%20safety/standards%20for%20blood%20banks%20 37. MyhreBA. Clinical commentary: The transfusion triggerThe
and%20blood%20transfusion%20services.pdf[Last accessed search for a quantitative holy grail. Ann Clin Lab Sci
on 2014Aug08]. 2001;31:35964.
20. NanuA. Blood transfusion services: Organization is integral to
safety. Natl Med J India 2001;14:23740.
21. ChoudhuryN. Need to change present regulatory framework Source of Support: Nil, Conflict of Interest: None declared
for blood banks in India. Asian J Transfus Sci 2011;5:12.

564 Indian Journal of Anaesthesia | Vol. 58 | Issue 5 | Sep-Oct 2014

You might also like