Measurement Canada

Volumetric Engineering
Technical Paper 003

Gravimetric Calibration of
Volumetric Standards

Issued: June 2, 1999

Revised Dec 1st, 2009

By: Christian Lachance, P. Eng.

Senior Engineer - Liquid Measurement
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 2 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

Table of Contents
1.0 The Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3

2.0 Mathematical Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3

2.1 General . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
2.2 Water Density . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
2.3 Mass Determination of the Delivered Water . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
2.3.1 Method A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5
2.3.2 Method B . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10
2.3.3 The Use of Apparent Mass . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11

3.0 Gravimetric Calibration Uncertainty Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12

4.0 Uncertainty of the Base Volume Determination . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13

4.1 Volumetric Standard Temperature Uncertainty, u(Tshell) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
4.2 Cubical Coefficient of Expansion Standard Uncertainty, u(") . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
4.3 Water Density u(D(Tw)) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15
4.3.1 Water Temperature Standard Uncertainty, u(Tw) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16
4.4 Mass Determination Standard Uncertainty, u(Mw) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17
4.4.1 Air Density Standard Uncertainty, u(Da ) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
4.4.1.1 Air Temperature Uncertainty, u(Ta) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
4.4.1.2 Relative humidity uncertainty u(RHa) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
4.4.1.3 Atmospheric pressure uncertainty, u(Pa) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
4.4.2 Reference Mass Uncertainty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
4.4.3 Reference Mass Density Uncertainty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
4.4.4 Comparator Uncertainty and Method Repeatability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21
4.4.5 Water Density Uncertainty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 22

5.0 Volumetric Standard Reproducibility . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23

5.1 Leveling Error . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
5.2 Scale Plate Reading Error . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24
5.3 Wetting Variance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24

6.0 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 3 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

1.0 The Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards

Common large volumetric standards are calibrated to deliver a known volume. Gravimetric
calibration of volumetric standards consist of weighing water delivered by the volumetric
standard and then deriving the volume from the mass and density of the water. Since the volume
of the standard is dependent on temperature, the reported value is corrected to a reference
temperature.

2.0 Mathematical Model

2.1 General
Volume is determined from mass and density by the following equation:

M
VT (2.1)
T

where T = temperature
VT = volume @ T
M = absolute mass
DT = density @ T

The volume of the standard is a function of the temperature such that:

VTref VT 1 Tref Tshell (2.2)

where VTref = volume of standard @ Tref

VT = volume of standard @ T
Tref = reference temperature
" = cubical coefficient of expansion of the standard
Tshell = temperature of the standard

Combining (2.1) and (2.2) we obtain:

VTref
Mw

Tw

1 Tref Tshell (2.3)
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 4 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

where Mw = absolute mass of water

Tw = temprature of water

Tw = density of water @ Tw

2.2 Water Density

Water density values are obtained from published formulation by Tanaka 1 where the density is
provided as a function of temperature and isotopic content. The formulation provides the density
values and their uncertainties for Standard Mean Ocean Water (SMOW) at a pressure of 101 325
Pa.

Tw a 2 Tw a
SMOW Tw a5 1 kg m 3
1 2

a 3 Tw a 4
(2.4)

where a1 = -3.983 035

a2 = 301.797
a3 = 522 528.9
a4 = 69.348 81
a5 = 999.974 950
DSMOW(Tw) = Standard Mean Ocean Water density

SMOW is air free water characterized by isotopic content. Most sources of water will have
isotopic content that differ from SMOW. When the highest accuracy is required, the isotopic
abundance of the water source must be determined and the density correction applied.

The expected difference between aerated and air free water density is calculated as per Bignell2
with the following equation:

Daerated = -0.004612 + 0.000106 Tw (2.5)

Where Tw is in degrees C and Daerated is in kg/m3.

Water that has been distilled and not exposed to air is considered air-free water while water that
has been exposed to air will become air saturated. The gravimetric calibration process and
distilled water storage at MC laboratories are such that the water can be assumed to be fully
saturated. The density of the water at Tw is then:
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 5 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

Tw SMOW Tw aerated Tw

Where
)D(Tw) = is the deviation in the actual water density from SMOW with correction for
aeration.

2.3 Mass Determination of the Delivered Water

Mass can be determined by the single substitution method using an electronic single pan balance.
Two methods will be presented. Both methods require a container which can be the volumetric
standard or a separate container into which the water is delivered.

2.3.1 Method A

Method A is a general purpose method where the weight of the water is obtained by subtracting
the empty container weight from the weight of the filled container.

This method is a 4 step process:

1. Weighing of the empty container, record:

IE

2. Weighing of reference weights close in value to that of empty

container, record:

IRE
MRE
DR
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 6 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

3. Weighing of container and water, record:

Da
IF
D(Tw)

4. Weighing of reference weights close in value to that of container and the water, record:

IRF
MRF
DR

Where

Mw = absolute mass of water delivered or contained

ME = absolute mass of container empty

MF = absolute mass of container filled

MRE = absolute mass of reference weight for empty container

MRF = absolute mass of reference weight for filled container

D(Tw) = density of water @ Tw

DR = density of reference weights

Da = density of air during weighing

Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 7 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

IE = scale indication of empty container

IRE = scale indication of reference weights for container

IF = scale indication of a filled container

IRF = scale indication of reference weight for filled container

Ww = weight of water

WF = weight of filled container

WE = weight of empty container

The mass of water can then be calculated from the recorded data.

The weight of an object is related to its mass by

W gM 1 a (2.7)
x

where
W = weight of object
g = acceleration due to gravity
M = absolute mass of object
Da = density of air surrounding object
Dx = density of object

let

Kx 1 a (2.8)
x

For an electronic single pan balance the indication, I, is proportional to the weight applied, such
that:

I=$MK (2.9)
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 8 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

where $ is a calibration factor which includes g.

For the weighing method presented we have for the weighing of the empty container:

I E I E M E KE (2.10)

I RE I RE M RE K RE (2.11)

The ideal balance will have a value of $ that is constant for all weighings. In practice, however,
a number of factors will cause this parameter to vary. Of concern are the effects of the balance
repeatability, non- linearity, stability and off-center loading. These effects and their contribution
to the weighing uncertainty can be mitigated by proper weighing method. Other factors such as
ambient temperature, loading method and magnetism may be significant in certain applications
or with certain equipment. These should be investigated to ensure that they are accounted for in
the determination of the uncertainty if required.

In order to account for the effects of linearity, eccentricity and stability in the estimate of the
uncertainty, the difference between the sensitivity coefficients of the artefact and the subsequent
reference mass weighing for the empty container is written as:

I I E
RE E
(2.12)

Combining (2.10), (2.11) and (2.12) we obtain:

I E M RE K RE
M E KE (2.13)
I RE M RE K RE E

Since the )$ terms is a small value and MREKRE is close in value to IRE, (2.13) can be
approximated by:

I E M RE K RE
M E KE
I RE 1 E
(2.14)

the same is true for MF, where:

Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 9 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

I F M RF K RF
M F KF (2.15)
I RF (1 F )

The weight of the water delivered is obtained by:

Ww WF WE (2.16)

Combining (2.7) , (2.8) and (2.16) we obtain:

M w Kw M F K F M E K E (2.17)

Combining (2.17), (2.14) & (2.15) we obtain:

I F M RF K RF I M K (2.18)
M W KW E RE RE
I RF (1 F ) I RE (1 E )

If reference weights of the same density are used for the filled substitution and the empty
subsitution, then:

KRF KRE KR (2.19)

By combining (2.18) and (2.19), we obtain:

(2.20)
K I F M RF I E M RE
MW R
KW I RF (1 F ) I RE (1 E )

The mass of the water is obtained by assuming a value of 0 for the )$ terms.
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 10 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

2.3.2 Method B

Method B tares the weight of the empty container thus only requiring one substitution weighing.
It can be used when the substitution weight can be weighed with the empty container.

This method is a 3 step process:

1. Weigh the empty container, record Ie ( please note that this step is last when the standard test
measure is used as the container).

2. Weigh the filled container, record: IF , Da.

3. Weigh the empty container and reference weight close in value to the water delivered, record:
IRF , MR , DR.

Because reference weights are added directly to the tare, the filled container indication less the
tare indication will be proportional to the reference weights such that:

I RF I E I RF I E M R KR (2.21)

and

(2.22)
I F I E I F I E M W KW

In order to account for the effects of linearity, eccentricity and stability in the estimate of the
uncertainty, let:

I RF IE I F I E (2.23)

combining (2.21), (2.22) and (2.23) and since the )$ term is a very small value and MRKR is
close in value to ( IRF - IE), we obtain the following:

(I F I E ) KR
MW (2.24)
( I RF I E ) KW 1 R
M

The mass of the water is obtained by assuming a value of 0 for the )$ term.

Since the weighing is done at filled load, the error introduced by the scale linearity, stability
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 11 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

and eccentricity MR/(1-)$) can be approximated with MF/(1-)$F). This is convenient if the
estimate of )$F is available while )$ is not.

2.3.3 The Use of Apparent Mass

Apparent mass is related to absolute mass by the following:

a
M apparent 1 M 1 a (2.25)
apparent

Where: M = absolute mass

Mapparnt = apparent mass
Dapparnt = apparent density
Da = density of air
D = density of mass

The apparent mass of an object is thus a function of air density. The difference in the value of
the apparent mass due to a difference in air density can be obtained by:

M apparent M apparent 1 1
M (2.26)
a a apparent

The difference of the apparent mass value, or resulting error, due to differing air density in
calibration and in use is:

1 1
Error
air _ during _ cal ai _ during _ use
apparent
(2.27)

This error is small in relation to the uncertainty of the mass. For example for a situation where
the apparent density is 8000 kg/m3 but the actual mass density is 8600 kg/m3 and where the
difference between the air density during the calibration of the mass and it use differs by 0.1
kg/m3 the error will be less than 1 ppm. Therefore the following approximation can be made:
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 12 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

use use
M 1
M apparent , cal 1 (2.28)
apparrent

Where Mapparnt, Dcal = apparent mass determined in calibration air density.

3.0 Gravimetric Calibration Uncertainty Overview

Gravimetric calibration gives rise to uncertainty due to two key factors: base volume
determination and the volumetric standard reproducibility.

The mathematical model for the base volume determination is provided by equation (2.3), it
covers the following influence factors:

1) uncertainty in the mass determination;

2) uncertainty in the water density determination;
3) uncertainty of the cubical coefficient of expansion; and
4) uncertainty of the temperature of the volumetric standard.

The uncertainty of the base volume determination is obtained by root sum square of the influence
factors such that:

determination u Tshell u u ( W ) u MW
2 2 2 2 2
u Volume (3.1)

The amount of volume delivered by a volumetric standard can be expected to vary, this
reproducibility characteristic is due to:

1) leveling of the standard (u leveling);

2) reading of the standard (u reading); and
3) wetting and drip variances.

The uncertainty due to the reproducibility of the standard will be the combined effect of the
above. Since these effects are independent they can be combined by a root sum square:

2
ureproducibility u 2 leveling u 2 reading u 2 wetting (3.2)
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 13 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

The combined standard uncertainty is the reproducibility of the standard combined with the
uncertainty of the base volume determination. These can be combined by root sum square as per
the following equation:

uVTref 2 u 2 Tshell u 2 u 2 ( W ) u 2 MW
(3.3)
u 2 leveling u 2 reading u 2 wetting

4.0 Uncertainty of the Base Volume Determination

The mathematical model for the base volume determination was given in (2.3). Although Tw and
Tshell are assumed to be the same value, we can also assume the error of the two values to be
independent since the error of Tshell is mostly due to the measurement process while the error of
Tw is mostly due to the thermometer reading uncertainty. We will thus consider all influence
factors independent. The combined standard uncertainty can then be calculated by the
following:
fVTref 2
2

u i
n
uc 2 (VTref )
i 1 i (4.1)

where:
uc = combined standard uncertainty
xi = influence quantities
u(xi) = standard uncertainties attributed to the influence quantities

The following table lists the influence quantities, their sensitivity coefficients and the square of
the uncertainty contribution of the influence factor. The uncertainty terms have been
approximated, where appropriate.
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 14 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

Influence quantity Sensitivity coefficient Square of the uncertainty

contribution of the
influence factor (the
sensitivity coefficient has
been replaced by an
equivalent approximation
where appropriate)
Pi VTref VTref 2
2

u
2
u i
i i
xi

Tshell
Mw
(V " u(Tshell) )2
(Tw)
" Tref Tshell
V T
2
Mw
( Tw)

ref Tshell u( )

SMOW Tw 1 T T
shell Mw
2

u SMOW (Tw )
Mw
ref

(Tw )
2
2
(Tw)

MW
1 Tref Tshell u M w
2

(Tw )

(Tw)

)D(Tw)
1 T T
shell Mw
2
M w
u (Tw )
ref

(Tw )
2 2
(Tw)

4.1 Volumetric Standard Temperature Uncertainty, u(Tshell)

The volumetric standard temperature, Tshell, is assumed to be the same as that of the water Tw.
The uncertainty of this value is influenced by the thermometer calibration uncertainty,
thermometer drift and, for the most part, the uncertainty due to the temperature measurement
method. The latter is a function of the following factors:
- the assumption that the shell temperature is the same as that of the water, this is influenced
by the temperature difference between ambient and the water;
- possible temperature non-uniformity in the standard.
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 15 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

The volumetric standard temperature uncertainty is:

u 2 (Tshell ) u 2 calibration u 2 drift u 2 method (4.2)

Where:
u calibration can be obtained from calibration certificate;
u drift can be obtained from manufacturer specifications, based on calibration history or based
on ice point verification tolerance;
u method is estimated based on expected ambient conditions and water temperature differential.

4.2 Cubical Coefficient of Expansion Standard Uncertainty, u(")

The uncertainty of the assumed cubical coefficient of expansion is estimated at +/- 10 %:

.
01
u (4.3)
3

4.3 Water Density u(D(Tw))

The uncertainty of the water density determination is a function of the water temperature
measurement uncertainty, the density model uncertainty and the level of purity of the water
sample.

The uncertainty of the water density due to the measured temperature is obtained as follows:

SMOW ( w )
u SMOW ( w ) uTw (4.4)
T w

The uncertainty of the SMOW density formulation is reported at 0.9 ppm. However, certain
isotopic ratio must be measured to obtain this level of uncertainty. Where the isotopic ratios
have not been measured a value of 20 ppm is suggested4 as appropriate.

The correction for aerated water density is approximately 2 to 3 ppm at room temperature. Since
the correction is small relative to the 20 ppm uncertainty of air free water mentioned above, the
uncertainty of this correction can be neglected.
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 16 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

In some instance, where large volumetric measure are calibrated and where the facilities do not
provide a large supply of purified water such as the Measurement Canada gravimetric calibration
laboratory, purified water can be re-circulated and re-used. In order to assess the quality level of
the purified water used for gravimetric calibrations, the water density can be monitored by
comparing the density of representative samples to that of ultrapure water such as that produced
at the NRC facility. Comparisons should be conducted using a high precision densitometer. For
very high accuracy applications the results can be used to estimate a correction for the water
density when the reference water sample is traceable.

Unless a density correction is used, the uncertainty due to deviations from SMOW ,with
correction for aeration, is assumed to be +/- 20 ppm so that:

0.020 kg / m 3
u Tw
(4.5)
3

If a correction is used, the uncertainty of the correction must be estimated from the reference
sample stated uncertainty and the densitometer measurement repeatability.

4.3.1 Water Temperature Standard Uncertainty, u(Tw)

The uncertainty of this value results from the thermometer calibration uncertainty and the
uncertainty due to the temperature measurement method. The latter is a function of the
following factors:
- water temperature uniformity in the standard;
- self-heating effect of the probe in static water.

The volumetric standard temperature and water uncertainty is obtained by the root sum square of
the above mentioned factors:

u 2 (TW ) u 2 calibration u 2 drift u 2 method (4.6)

Where:
Ucalibration can be obtained from the thermometer calibration certificate;
Udrift can be obtained from thermometer manufacturer specifications, calibration history or it
can be estimated from ice point check tolerance;
Umethod can be estimated from temperature gradients in the standard and self heating
characteristics of the thermometer.
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 17 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

4.4 Mass Determination Standard Uncertainty, u(Mw)

The uncertainty of the mass determination is again determined as per equation (2.20) and (2.24)
for methods A and B respectively.

The following table lists the influence quantities and their associated sensitivity coefficients for
method A:
Influence quantity Sensitivity coefficient Square of the uncertainty
contribution of the
influence factor (the
sensitivity coefficient has
been replaced by an
equivalent approximation
where appropriate)
Pi Mw
M w
2

u 2 i
ci

i
i

IF M RF K R
u2 I F
I RF Kw

u 2 I RF
IRF 2
K 1
M RF I F R
KW I RF

)$F
I F M RF K R 1

M F2 u 2 F

I RF K w 1 F
2

u2 I E
IE M RE K R

I RE Kw

u 2 I RE
IRE 2
KR 1
M RE I E
K w I RE

)$E
I E M RE K R M E2 u 2 E
1

I RE K w 1 F
2
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 18 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

Da IE w r w 2
IF
M RF 1 1 2
u a
M RE
r w a 2
I RE I RF
M W 2

w R

Dr
a
2
IE

I
M RE F M RF 2 a u R M W 2
2

I RE I RF R KW R

Dw
IE IF R a a
2

I RE
M RE
I RF
M RF
W a 2 M W 2 u 2 w
w

MRF I F KR u 2 M RF

I RF K w

MRE u 2 M RE
I E KR

I RE Kw
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 19 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

The following table lists the influence quantities and their associated sensitivity coefficients for
method B:
Influence quantity Sensitivity coefficient Square of the uncertainty
contribution of the
influence factor
Pi Mw M w
2

u 2 i
i i

IF
u2 I F
MR KR
( I RF I E ) KW

u 2 I RF
IRF
M R ( I F I E ) KR

( I RF I E ) 2 Kw

)$F see text section 2.3.2 2

I RF u 2 F

IE
M R ( I RF I F ) KR ( I RF I F ) 2 2
u I E
M 2 RF
( I RF I E ) 2 Kw

Da IF IE w r w 2
MRkR 1 1 2
u a

I RF I E r w a 2 M R
2

w R

Dr F E M R a a
2

2 u R M RF 2
2

RF E K w R R

Dw
I I a a
2

M R KR F E M R 2 u 2 W
I RF I E W a W
2
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 20 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

MR I F I E KR
u2 M R
I RF I E Kw

4.4.1 Air Density Standard Uncertainty, u(Da )

Air density is calculated using the equation provided by Davis3. The uncertainty of the air
density is a function of air temperature, humidity and barometric pressure.
The uncertainty of the air density can be estimated by the following equation:

u 2 ( a ) (0.00415) 2 u 2 (Ta ) (118

. 10 5 ) 2 u 2 ( Pa ) (122
. 10 4 ) 2 u 2 ( RHa ) (4.7)

The above influence factors are addressed individually below.

4.4.1.1 Air Temperature Uncertainty, u(Ta)

The uncertainty of the air temperature is a function of the following factors:

- u thermometer calibration is obtained form calibration certificate;
- u thermometer drift can be obtained from thermometer manufacturer specifications,
calibration history or it can be estimated from ice point check tolerance;
- u temperature measurement method is estimated from the expected temperature fluctuation
during the calibration.

u 2 (Ta ) u 2 calibration u 2 drift u 2 method (4.8)

4.4.1.2 Relative humidity uncertainty u(RHa)

The magnitude of relative humidity uncertainty can be large without significantly affecting
results. It can be estimated from manufacturers specifications as a type B and or from calibration
process limits.

(4.9)
Tolerance
u RHa
3
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 21 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

4.4.1.3 Atmospheric pressure uncertainty, u(Pa)

The uncertainty of the air pressure is a function of the following factors:

- u calibration;
- u drift can be obtained from manufacturer specifications or calibration history;
- u pressure measurement method is estimated from the expected barometric pressure
fluctuation during the calibration.

Combining the above by root sum square we obtain:

u 2 ( Pa ) u 2 calibration u 2 drift u 2 method (4.10)

4.4.2 Reference Mass Uncertainty

Reference mass uncertainty can be obtained from the calibration certificate. Otherwise, the
grading of the reference mass can be used to estimate the uncertainty.

Most often the gravimetric calibration will be performed with class F1 weights which have a
tolerance of +/- 0.0005 %. Assuming a square distribution this can be converted to uncertainty
by:

Tolerance
u M R
(4.11)
3

4.4.3 Reference Mass Density Uncertainty

The reference mass density uncertainty component may be included in the uncertainty statement
of the reference mass. In this case, this uncertainty term need not be calculated. When stainless
steel reference mass is used, a tolerance of +/-200 kg/m3 can be used as the density uncertainty.

4.4.4 Comparator Uncertainty and Method Repeatability

When an electronic balance is used as a comparator, the uncertainty of the balance indication is
due to its repeatability, eccentricity, stability and linearity which are dependent on the weighing
method. Linearity errors can usually be reduced to a negligible amount by using reference
weights which are close in value to the object weighed otherwise it must be accounted for.
Stability errors are usually reduced by the appropriate use of a substitution weighing method.

The uncertainty due to the scale eccentricity, stability and linearity must be evaluated in
conjunction with the weighing method.
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 22 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

The uncertainty due to the repeatability of the scale can be established as a type A uncertainty
after an analysis of the scale characteristics and the repeatability conditions under which it will
be used. This will provide the value of u(I). This should be used when a limited number of
calibration runs is carried out.

Alternatively, if many calibrations runs are carried out then it is possible to lump all repeatability
components under one factor which is estimated as a type A uncertainty from the standard
deviation of the calibration runs. Since the average of the determinations is reported then the
contribution of the repeatability is calculated as per:

urepeatability = Standard deviation of volume determination/ sqrt(n)

Where n = number of runs

This last approach will account for the scale repeatability error and therefore u(I) factors are not
counted.

4.4.5 Water Density Uncertainty

The density of the water during the weighing is very well known. As a result the uncertainty of
the mass determination due to the water density uncertainty is very small in relation to the
overall mass uncertainty. It can be neglected.
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 23 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

5.0 Volumetric Standard Reproducibility

5.1 Leveling Error

When open neck volumetric measures are used, it is necessary to obtain a reading of the water
delivered in the measure. Two principal factors affect the accuracy of the reading, the operators
ability to read the scale and the proper leveling of the measure.

Improperly leveling of the volumetric measure will result in a reading error. This error is
dependent on the distance between the center of the measure to the sight tube and is dependent
on the neck diameter of the measure.

The following equations apply:

y tan( ) (5.1)

2
d (5.2)
V y
2
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 24 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

Where:
2 = leveling angle error
x = distance between center of neck and scale plate
)V = volume error
d = internal neck diameter of the volumetric standard

as a result the leveling uncertainty is:

tan( )
2
d
u(leveling ) (5.3)
3 2

5.2 Scale Plate Reading Error

When an open neck volumetric measure is used by filling to the nominal mark, the reading
accuracy is assumed to be +/- 0.5 mm of scale such that:

2
d 0.05cm
u(reading ) (5.4)
2 3

5.3 Wetting Variance

Volumetric standards that are calibrated to deliver a known volume will be subject to variances
in the amount of liquid volume which is delivered. This will be influenced by the liquid
properties, construction of the standard, drip time and method. Wetting variance is estimated
based on the standards calibration history or know characteristics for typical standard design and
construction.
Measurement Canada, Volumetric Engineering Page 25 of 25
Technical Paper 003
Gravimetric Calibration of Volumetric Standards Dec 1st, 2009

6.0 References

1.M. Tanaka, G. Girard, R.Davis, A. Peuto and N. Bignell, Recommended table for the density of
water between 0C and 40 C based on recent experimental reports, Metrologia, 2001,38,301-
309

2.N. Bignell, Metrologia 19, 1983, 57

3. R.S. Davis, Equation for the Determination of the Density of Moist Air, Metrologia, 29, 1992,
67-70

4. Elsa Batista, Richard Paton, The Selection of Water Property Formulae for Volume and Flow
Calibration, Metrologia 44, 2007, 453-463