You are on page 1of 9

Journal of Visceral Surgery (2011) 148, 311

REVIEW

Hepatocellular cancer in the non-cirrhotic liver


B. Alkofer a,, V. Lepennec b, L. Chiche a

a
Unit de chirurgie hpato-biliaire et transplantation, service de chirurgie digestive, CHU de
Caen, Cte-de-Nacre, 14000 Caen, France
b
Service de radiologie, CHU de Caen, 14000 Caen, France

KEYWORDS Summary Less than 20% of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) develops in the non-cirrhotic liver
Hepatocellular (NCL). The diagnosis of HCC in NCL is suggested by a large hypervascular tumor in a 6075 year
carcinoma; old patient (usually male), particularly if the alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) level is high. But AFP is
Non-cirrhotic liver; normal more often than not. Surgical resection is the only curative therapy of HCC; resection
Surgical resection; is more commonly feasible in HCC in NCL due to the healthy parenchyma of the underlying
Intrahepatic liver. The prognosis of HCC in NCL is better than that for HCC on cirrhosis with a 5-year survival
recurrence approaching 50%. Prognosis is best in the patient with a small HCC with no vascular invasion or
satellite nodules for whom an R0 resection can be achieved without the need for intra-operative
transfusion. While intra-hepatic recurrence occurs frequently, it should be aggressively sought
and treated; there is a major role for repeat hepatic resection and a lesser role for hepatic
transplantation where results are poorer than those obtained for HCC on cirrhosis.
2011 Published by Elsevier Masson SAS.

Introduction
Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is by far the most common primary tumor of the liver,
and it typically develops in the cirrhotic liver (80% of cases). It is a hepatocellular
tumor, typically hypervascular, and tends to have a long phase of intrahepatic growth;
it has the capacity to invade the hepatic vessels but only rarely exhibits the classical
presentation of tumor rupture. Worldwide, it is the fth most common human malig-
nancy (8th in women) but the third most common cause of mortality (5th in women)
[1,2].
HCC develops in the non-cirrhotic liver in less than 20% of cases. The normal quality
of the non-tumoral liver parenchyma makes this type of HCC a very different entity epi-
demiologically, clinically and in its management and prognosis. It is classically stated that
HCC is rare in the non-cirrhotic liver and it is usually diagnosed at a more advanced stage,
but is also more readily treated by surgery with a better prognosis than HCC on cirrhosis.
The purpose of this review is to dene the characteristics of HCC occurring in non-cirrhotic
healthy liver.

Corresponding author.
E-mail address: barbaraalkofer@yahoo.fr (B. Alkofer).

1878-7886/$ see front matter 2011 Published by Elsevier Masson SAS.


doi:10.1016/j.jviscsurg.2010.12.012
4 B. Alkofer et al.

Epidemiology iron overload, particularly hemochromatosis, is an impor-


tant risk factor, iron being both directly and indirectly
It would be an oversimplication to compare HCC on cir- involved in carcinogenesis [10]. Again, while this data is
rhosis with HCC in the healthy liver because, between clearly established in patients with cirrhosis, it remains
these two extremes, there is a wide range of parenchy- more controversial in HCC on NCL;
mal pathology without cirrhosis including F2 and F3 brosis; neither alcohol nor alcoholism is recognized as an intrinsic
steatosis greater than 30% and steatohepatitis (NASH), and carcinogen.
early-stage hemochromatosis.

Frequency Natural history and tumor characteristics

The incidence of HCC in non-cirrhotic liver (NCL) is esti- The natural history of HCC on NCL is poorly understood,
mated at about 1520% of all HCC [13]. If we restrict the particularly the tumor doubling time. Some cases of mis-
entity to HCC in perfectly healthy livers, the percentage diagnosis have resulted in prolonged observation of these
is closer to 1012% [13]. In the most recent French pop- tumors; this and the discovery of asymptomatic tumors at
ulation survey [3], 15% of a cohort of 1007 patients with advanced stages also suggest that the doubling time is quite
HCC had no underlying cirrhosis. These tumors are more long, with tumors evolving over several years.
likely to be amenable to surgical excision leading to an over-
representation of HCC on NCL in surgical series reaching Clinical presentations
almost 25% [4]. Recognizing that the estimated incidence
of new cases of HCC worldwide is 600,000 cases per year, There are several distinct clinical presentations [35]:
the classic form: the patient typically presents with symp-
we can extrapolate an incidence of 90,000 to 120,000 new
cases of HCC on NCL per year [1]. toms of pain associated with a large tumor (average of
810 cm), often necrotic, and unifocal (in more than 50%
of cases). The AFP is elevated in only 40% of these cases
Age and sex ratio (Fig. 1A, B);
tumor rupture with hemorrhage: these tumors are usu-
Epidemiological studies show that men are affected by HCC ally large and hypervascular, and sometimes present with
two to four times more frequently than women, but this portal vein thrombosis: hemoperitoneum is a rare but
distribution mirrors the incidence of cirrhosis [3,4]. Male classical presentation, occurring in about 5% of cases
predominance is less marked for HCC on NCL (75% men for (which is more common than in HCC on cirrhosis) (Fig. 2);
HCC on NCL versus 85% for HCC on cirrhosis); more strikingly, the massive late-stage form: this is often the initial
the sex ratio is equal in patients younger than 50 years [4,5]. presentation in young subjects: there is major tumoral
The average age of onset in published series is lower for invasion within the liver with concurrent nodal, pul-
HCC on NCL (60 years) than for HCC on cirrhosis. This is due monary, or osseous metastases. This clinical presentation
to a subset of HCC on NCL that arises in the second and occurs frequently in HCC on NCL related to neonatal
third decades [5]. It is within this age group that we see the hepatitis B infection, especially among young Africans
unusual entity of brolamellar HCC (mean age of 27 years) (Fig. 3);
[6]. the asymptomatic form: this is diagnosed with increasing
frequency. HCC is either discovered incidentally by imag-
ing studies (the tumor often, but not always, being small)
Risk factors or because of abnormal laboratory ndingsliver function
tests, or paraneoplastic syndromes such as polycythemia.
Certain toxic risk factors, while classical, are rarely seen
in practice: aatoxin B, androgens, vinyl chloride. . .. Other Typical histology and unusual variants
risk factors mirror risk factors for cirrhosis:
hepatitis B and C: we know that the integration of frag- The histological features of the tumor are similar to HCC on
ments of viral DNA into the genome of hepatocytes has an cirrhosis. Stages of differentiation vary from well- to poorly-
intrinsic carcinogenic role. Thus, the presence of anti-HBs differentiated, there may be satellite nodules, the tumor
antibodies, even in the absence of viral DNA, is a risk fac- may or may not have penetrated its capsule, Vascular inva-
tor for development of HCC [3]. However, the presence of sion may include tumor embolization or budding into the
anti-HCV antibodies does not seem to be a risk factor in portal or hepatic veins.
the absence of cirrhosis; Three special variants, while rare, must be recognized
obesity and diabetes, which are oftentimes associated because they may pose diagnostic problems:
with nonalcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH), seem to be degeneration of an adenoma: malignant transformation
related to the development of HCC [7,8]. While these fac- of a hepatic adenoma is rare (less than 8%) and seems
tors are clearly associated with an increased incidence of to be related to a mutation of beta-catenin [11]. In the
HCC in cirrhosis, their risk in the non-cirrhotic liver is more subset of HCC on NCL, this entity represents only a tiny
controversial. At any rate, the metabolic syndrome proportion, given the low incidence of adenoma;
is increasingly recognized as a hepatic carcinogenic fac- brolamellar HCC: this form has a unique histology with a
tor. In the series published by the French Association of brous component that can be misleading. This explains
Surgery (AFC), the metabolic syndrome was present in some diagnostic confusion with focal nodular hyperplasia,
29% of cases of HCC on NCL [4]. In addition, disorders of especially since it also tends to occur in young patients
glucose metabolism are probably implicated in carcino- with a slight female predominance and with a normal AFP.
genesis, as suggested by the high prevalence of HCC in The overall prognosis of brolamellar HCC is somewhat
glycogen storage diseases [9]; better despite frequent recurrence; this justies post-
Hepatocellular cancer in the non-cirrhotic liver 5

Figure 1. Typical presentation of hepatocellular carcinoma in healthy liver: intra-operative view prior to hepatectomy. The arrows point
to the primary tumor and a satellite nodule (A); specimen from a left lobectomy extended to include a portion of segment IVthe tumor
deforms the contours of the left lobe (B).

operative surveillance and an aggressive re-intervention For all HCC on NCL, the primary objective is an oncologi-
policy [12,13]; cally complete surgical resection with minimal hemorrhage.
the cystic form of HCC: Here again the diagnosis can be
difcult. This rare presentation includes cases of tumor
necrosis with liquefaction leading to degenerative cysts,
Diagnosis
but there is also a truly cystic form HCC, which can be very
In most cases, diagnosis is straightforward. CT with con-
misleading for both imaging and histological diagnosis [14]
trast injection shows a large heterogeneous tumor with
(Fig. 4).
necrotic and hemorrhagic components, hypervascular in the
arterial phase (Fig. 5), and with no evidence of underlying
liver disease (Fig. 6). Fibrolamellar HCC has a characteristic
appearance; it is usually located on the left, and often has
Management
a central brous component and calcications.
Management is based on these currently accepted princi- Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) provides additional
pals: information: T1 images show an isointense lesion with a
surgical excision is the only curative treatment; hypointense capsule, while T2 images show an isointense
prognostic factors, as described in the literature, are lesion with a slightly hyperintense capsule. After injection of
tumor size and vascular invasion, the ability to achieve R0 gadolinium in the arterial phase, the lesion becomes hyper-
resection, and intraoperative blood transfusion (Table 1) intense; in the portal phase, the lesion is isointense relative
[1519]; to adjacent parenchyma, and, in the late phase, it becomes
recurrences must be aggressively treated because they hypointense. A well-delineated capsule during the portal
are sometimes amenable to a second curative resection, phase supports the diagnosis of HCC (Fig. 7).
which may result in prolonged survival.

Figure 3. CT image of a massive HCC on NCL in the portal phase.


Figure 2. View of a ruptured HCC on healthy liver: clotted blood There are numerous bilobar hypodense nodules and a thrombus in
adjacent to the capsular rupture. the right portal vein (*).
6 B. Alkofer et al.

Figure 4. Cystic form of HCC: CT with IV contrast injection during the arterial phase: there is a frankly hypodense lesion which occupies
the entire right liver and part of segment IV; it contains loculations with contrast uptake (A); macroscopic view of the lesion in the same
patient: the lesion appears hemorrhagic and necrotic and several loculations are visible (B).

For any hypervascular tumor, HCC is statistically the diseased, much more extensive resections are feasible; the
likely diagnosis. An increase in AFP is then sufcient to con- rate of resectability is therefore higher. The positive point
rm the diagnosis. If the AFP is not elevated, a biopsy may be is that the liver is healthy or minimally diseased which
necessary (biopsy was performed in 50% of cases in the AFC allows extensive resections and hence a fairly high rate of
series). Subclinical cirrhosis should be ruled out; depend- resectability. On the negative side, these tumors are often
ing on the context, this sometimes requires biopsy of the very large at presentation and are situated in close proximity
uninvolved liver. to vascular structures.
In some cases the diagnosis is more difcult: this is espe- This emphasizes the need for an accurate assessment:
cially true for smaller tumors discovered incidentally or of the tumor characteristics including its vascular rela-
having less characteristic imaging morphology; here the dif- tionships (the intersection of the hepatic veins with
ferential diagnosis includes multiple entities: focal nodular the vena cava), evidence of satellite nodules, the pres-
hyperplasia, adenoma, endocrine metastases, and others. ence of tumor thrombus in a portal vein branch (vein
Circumstances vary but a biopsy is most often required for enlargement with an arterial signal on Doppler scan and
diagnosis. contrast enhancement during the arterial phase of the CT
scan);
of the quality of the underlying liver parenchyma
Evaluation of resectability with estimation of the volume of residual liver
after resectionthis determination is usually quite
The assessment of resectability differs from HCC on cirrho- simple;
sis. Since the liver parenchyma is healthy or only minimally

Table 1 prognostic factors for hepatocellular cancer in non-cirrhotic liver.


1er author (references) Number of Dates of Overall 5 Year Factors of poor prognosis
patients study survival (%)
Bege et al. [15] 116 19872005 40.0 R1 resection
Vascular involvement
HBV infection
Dupont-Bierre et al. [16] 84 19982003 44.4 Multiple tumors
Gross vascular involvement
Lang et al. [17] 83 19982005 30.0 UICC stage
Vascular involvement
Tumor grade
Laurent et al. [18] 108 19872005 29.0 Blood transfusion
Absence of capsule
Satellite nodules
Resection margin < 1cm
Capussotti et al. [19] 47 19852002 30.9 Size > 10 cm
Satellite nodules
HBV: hepatitis B virus; UICC: Union Internationale Contre le Cancer
Hepatocellular cancer in the non-cirrhotic liver 7

Figure 5. CT of HCC on NCL: images without IV contrast shows an isodense lesion deforming the contours of the left liver (A); in the
arterial phase, the lesion takes up contrast but has a hypodense center. There is a subcapsular satellite nodule in segment IV (B); in the
portal phase, there is washout of the lesion (C).

of any evidence of extra hepatic extension; Operative management


metastasis to lymph nodes, lung, or bone is not
uncommon. The incision must be large and tailored to the tumoral loca-
tion and to patient morphology; a right subcostal incision
A good quality spiral CT of the chest and abdomen is may be adequate for a centrally contained tumor or for a
essential, possibly supplemented by MRI with vascular recon- superior location (segment VIII) or a left lobe tumor. It is
struction. This assessment is essential to the planning of the important to be able to enlarge this incision (bi-subcostal
operative procedure; vascular problems must be anticipated with or without a xiphoid extension, or a J-shaped incision).
in order to obtain an R0 resection. This is the basis for all At times, a thoraco-abdominal incision with division of the
problematic decisions regarding surgical resection of large diaphragm may be necessary for large tumors near the junc-
malignant liver tumors. There is usually adequate hepatic tion of the hepatic veins and vena cava; this permits safe
reserve in the non-cirrhotic residual liver, making the need supradiaphragmatic control of the vena cava.
for portal vein embolization rare; but this procedure should Inow and outow cross clamping should be carefully
be performed without hesitation to obtain liver hypertro- considered, prepared for, and used whenever there is need,
phy if the percentage of remaining liver is estimated at since morbidity and mortality and even long-term survival
less than 25%. When the size of the residual liver is the are related to intraoperative blood loss. While selective
limiting factor, it is essential to have biopsy evidence of clamping of the hemi-liver to be resected is usually suf-
normal liver parenchyma since, in case of steatosis, early cient, one must still be prepared to resort to total vascular
brosis or other parenchyma abnormality, it is reasonable exclusion of the liver.
to require at least a 3035% volume of residual liver, and The anterior approach now seems the technique of choice
therefore to resort to pre-operative portal vein emboliza- for large tumors, especially since long-term prognosis is
tion. improved by use of this technique [20].
It is also unusual to have to resort to preoperative
chemotherapy-embolization, since its use in neoadjuvant The type of resection
therapy has not been conrmed. It may nevertheless be
a useful technique to decrease tumor mass in exceptional The predilection of this lesion for endo-portal spread is an
cases. argument in favor of anatomical resections. Whereas, in the
8 B. Alkofer et al.

Figure 6. CT of HCC on NCL with necrotic and hemorrhagic alterations: before contrast injection, the lesion in the right liver has a
hypodense center corresponding to the central necrosis (A); in the arterial phase, the hypodense center persists without contrast uptake
(necrosis). There is a satellite nodule in segment IV (B); in the portal phase, there is persistent central hypodensity (C).

setting of cirrhosis, the surgeon may be limited by the imper- vant therapy, and the need for a long-term surveillance
ative to preserve parenchyma, this is less often the case for protocol with appropriate treatment of recurrences.
HCC on NCL. In the AFC series, 59% of HCC on NCL required
a major hepatectomy and 84%, an anatomical hepatectomy Adjuvant treatment
[4].
Tumor extension or budding into the portal veins must There is no generally recommended adjuvant therapy
be identied because, even though such vascular invasion after resection because none has been proven effective,
is undoubtedly a factor of poor prognosis, many authors especially in this rare setting of HCC on NCL. Only the post-
have nonetheless shown a benet from surgical resection operative intra-arterial infusion of lipiocis seems to have
despite this [21]: what is most important is to achieve an R0 demonstrated benet in the experience of the team of
resection with an optimal margin of at least 1 cm [18]. Rennes (France) [16].
Similarly, it is critical to search for lymph node involve-
ment, which is more common than in HCC on cirrhosis.
Management of recurrence
Lymph node dissection in association with hepatectomy in
a young patient is justied, especially in the brolamellar These patients must be monitored regularly over the long
form of HCC [6]. term. The tendency to recurrence has been known for
years [20]. Intrahepatic recurrences can be amenable to
Postoperative management re-resection while extrahepatic recurrences (lung, adrenal)
may also be surgically treatable. These recurrences may
Long-term survival after surgical resection for HCC on NCL be delayed: while they are more frequent in the rst two
is about 50% at 5 years; this is signicantly better than that years, they may occur as late as 4 or 5 years after surgery.
observed for HCC with cirrhosis [4,1519,22]. Surveillance must therefore continue beyond 5 years.
However: An aggressive response to recurrence should always be
the survival falls off at 10 years. Ten-year survival was considered: the primary goal, as always, should be surgi-
only 20% in the series of the AFC [4]; cal removal, as long as an R0 resection can be achieved. In
disease-free survival was lower (about 30%) [4,1519,22]. the case of unresectable intrahepatic recurrence, treatment
This means that recurrences are common and may be long options including the possibility of liver transplantation
delayed [22]. This nding has led to consideration of adju- (LT) with curative intent [23], or chemoembolization as
Hepatocellular cancer in the non-cirrhotic liver 9

Figure 7. Magnetic resonance image of an HCC on NCL (the same patient as in Fig. 6): the T1 sequence shows a heterogeneous lesion
with hypointensity of the capsule (A); T2 sequence (B); T2 sequence with gadolinium injection (C); late phase the capsule is visible with
a hyperintense signal (D).

a palliative procedure, should be discussed. In the case 32.5% and 26%, respectively. Prognostic factors were nodal
of unresectable extrahepatic recurrence, chemotherapy status, bilobar disease, and TNM stage [23,24]. Unlike these
or systemic treatment with Sorafenib can be considered two studies, the team at Paul Brousse Hospital reported
(though it has not been validated for this indication). Pro- their experience with 34 transplants for HCC on normal liver
longed survival is possible, even in case of recurrence [5]. excluding HCC and brolamellar HCC on NCL. Eight of these
patients had had a previous resection. Overall survival was
respectively 85%, 60% and 41% at 3, 5 and 10 years. Favorable
What treatment for unresectable HCC on NCL? prognostic factors were surgical resection for recurrence
and a > 2 year interval between the rst resection and HT
Hepatic transplantation (HT) has a place in the treatment of [25].
HCC on NCL, although it is less well-dened than for HCC on The major axes of decision-making regarding HT include:
cirrhosis. In many cases, HCC on NCL develops and remains Patients with indications for HT for HCC on NCL are those
purely intra-hepatic for a long time, but recurrence after with unresectable tumor at the outset or unresectable
resection is common. In some cases, HCC on NCL presents intrahepatic recurrence without evidence of associated
in an unresectable multinodular form. HT is then a logical extrahepatic disease. For cases of recurrent HCC, the
consideration. indication of HT should principally reect the initial histo-
HT is not indicated for resectable HCC on NCL at present; prognostic characteristics as well as those present at the
the results for HT are worse than those for resection. time of recurrence (histological differentiation, vascular
However, the condition of the non-tumoral liver must be invasion, or lymph node spread) and the natural history of
carefully weighed in this equation: in effect, if there is the disease after resection.
underlying liver disease (hemochromatosis, severe F3 bro-
sis), resection becomes more risky and TH should be included
in the discussion, in light of patient age and tumor charac- Role of systemic therapy
teristics.
There is little published data on HT for HCC on NCL, and HCC is relatively insensitive to chemotherapy. However,
the published series combine both HCC on NCL and bro- chemotherapy is sometimes the only therapeutic option
lamellar HCC. for advanced stages of disease. Chemotherapy based on
Indeed, two earlier series (1991 and 1995) analyzing their 5-uorouracil, epirubicin or adriamycin plus platinum,
results of HT for HCC on healthy liver, combined HCC and using protocols similar to those used for hepatoblas-
brolamellar HCC on NCL. In both studies, the median over- toma, has been shown to provide objective responses
all survival was 26%, with survival at 1, 3 and 5 years of 70%, in 20 to 30% of cases [26]. The therapeutic role
10 B. Alkofer et al.

of Sorafenib is worthy of evaluation for this indica- Conict of interest statement


tion.
The authors have no conict of interests.

Conclusion
References
HCC on NCL is a relatively rare condition for which surgery
plays the preponderant role. Indeed, only complete resec- [1] Sherman M. Hepatocellular carcinoma: epidemiology, risk fac-
tion offers hope of a cure. After R0 resection, nearly one tors and screening. Semin Liver Dis 2005;25:14354.
out of two patients is alive at 5 years. However, recur- [2] Altekruse SF, McGlynn KA, Reichman ME. Hepatocellular carci-
rences are common, probably related not only to tumor noma incidence, mortality, and survival trends in the United
States from 1975 to 2005. J Clin Oncol 2009;27:148591.
characteristics at the time of initial discovery but also to
[3] Borie F, Bouvier AM, Herrero A, et al. Treatment and progno-
the condition of the underlying non-tumoral parenchyma,
sis of hepatocellular carcinoma: a population based study in
which may have subclinical liver disease. Routine long-term France. J Surg Oncol 2008;98:5059.
surveillance is necessary to detect and treat recurrences, [4] Boudjema K, Cherqui D. Le carcinome hpatocellulaire. Mono-
thereby improving survival. The role of neoadjuvant and graphie de lAssociation Franc aise de Chirurgie. Arnette, 2006.
adjuvant treatments is uncertain but should continue to be [5] Xu L, Huang L, Li BK, Zhang YQ, Li JQ, Yuan YF. Clinicopatho-
evaluated, as data are too limited at this time to judge its logic features and long- term outcomes of Chinese patients
efcacy. with hepatocellular carcinoma in non-cirrhotic liver. Dig Surg
2008;25:37682.
[6] El-Gazzaz G, Wong W, El-Hadary MK, et al. Outcome of liver
resection and transplantation for brolamellar hepatocellular
KEY POINTS carcinoma. Transpl Int 2000;13(Suppl. 1):S4069.
[7] Caldwell SH, Crespo DM, Kang HS, Al-Osaimi AM. Obesity and
Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) develops in the
hepatocellular carcinoma. Gastroenterology 2004;127(5 Suppl.
non-cirrhotic liver (NCL) in only 20% of cases. The 1):S97103.
host liver parenchyma may be perfectly healthy or [8] El-Serag HB, Tran T, Everhart JE. Diabetes increases the risk of
may exhibit various degrees of brosis, steatosis or chonic liver disease and hepatocellular carcinoma. Gastroen-
other abnormalities such as hemochromatosis. terology 2004;126:4608.
The diagnosis of HCC in the non-cirrhotic liver is [9] Davis MK, Weinstein DA. Liver transplantation in children
suggested by a large hypervascular tumor in a 60- with glycogen storage disease: controversies and evalua-
75 year old patient (usually male), particularly if tion of the risk/benet of this procedure. Pediatr Transplant
2008;12:13745.
the alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) level is high. But the
[10] Kowdley KV. Iron, hemochromatosis and hepatocellular carci-
frequent absence of AFP elevation and the large
noma. Gastroenterology 2004;127:S7986.
number of entities in the differential diagnosis [11] Zucman-Rossi J, Jeannot E, Nhieu JT, et al. Genotype-
often mandate protected biopsy to conrm the phenotype correlation in hepatocellular adenoma: new classi-
diagnosis. cation and relationship with HCC. Hepatology 2006;43:51524.
Fibrolamellar carcinoma is a variant form of HCC, [12] El-Serag HB, Davila JA. Is brolamellar carcinoma different
which characteristically arises, in young patients from hepatocellular carcinoma? A US population-based study.
(M:F ratio close to 1), with a normal AFP; despite Hepatology 2004;39:798803.
a high frequency of nodal spread, the prognosis is [13] Stipa F, Yoon SS, Liau KH, et al. Outcome of patients with bro-
generally favorable. lamellar hepatocellular carcinoma. Cancer 2006;106:13318.
The only curative treatment for HCC is surgical [14] Heywood G, Van Buren SF, Smyrk T, Nagorney DM. Mul-
tilocular cystic hepatocellular carcinoma (CHCC) mimick-
excision. The absence of cirrhosis makes resection
ing mucinous cystadenocarcinoma. Hepatogastroenterology
feasible more often. When the tumor is 2003;50:36870.
unresectable, liver transplantation should be [15] Bge T, Le Treut YP, Hardwigsen J, et al. Prognostic factors after
considered if the clinical context is favorable, resection for hepatocellular carcinoma in nonbrotic or moder-
as long as there is no vascular invasion or ately brotic liver. A 116-case European series. J Gastrointest
extrahepatic metastasis. Chemotherapy based on Surg 2007;11:61925.
adriamycin and platinum salts, or antiangiogenic [16] Dupont-Bierre E, Compagnon P, Raoul JL, Fayet G, de
agents results in response rates of 2040%. Lajarte-Thirouard AS, Boudjema K. Resection of hepatocellu-
The prognosis for 5-year survival after tumor lar carcinoma in noncirrhotic liver: analysis of risk factors for
survival. J Am Coll Surg 2005;201:66370.
resection is 50%a much better prognosis than
[17] Lang H, Sotiropoulos GC, Brokalaki EI, et al. Survival and recur-
for HCC on cirrhosis. However, recurrence after
rence rates after resection for hepatocellular carcinoma in
surgery is common and may occur late. Such noncirrhotic livers. J Am Coll Surg 2007;205:2736.
recurrences may still be amenable to curative [18] Laurent C, Blanc JF, Nobili S, et al. Prognostic factors and
resection, which justies ongoing surveillance longterm survival after hepatic resection for hepatocellular
after resection. carcinoma originating from noncirrhotic liver. J Am Coll Surg
The prognostic factors for HCC in the non-cirrhotic 2005;201:65662.
liver are: R0 resection, those same histological [19] Capussotti L, Muratore A, Amisano M, Massucco P, Polastri R,
factors that have been observed in HCC on Bouzari H. Liver resection for large-size hepatocellular carcino-
cirrhosis (tumor size, satellite nodules, vascular mas in 47 non-cirrhotic patients no mortality and long-term
survival. Hepatogastroenterology 2006;53:76872.
invasion), and intraoperative transfusion.
[20] Liu CL, Fan ST, Cheung ST, Lo CM, Ng IO, Wong J. Anterior
approach versus conventional approach right hepatic resection
for large hepatocellular carcinoma: a prospective randomized
controlled study. Ann Surg 2008;247:3901.
Hepatocellular cancer in the non-cirrhotic liver 11

[21] Pawlik TM, Poon RT, Abdalla EK, et al. Hepatectomy for hepato- [25] Scatton O, Adam R, Plasse M, et al. Liver transplantation for
cellular carcinoma with major portal or hepatic vein invasion: hepatocellular carcinoma in patients without cirrhosis: is it
results of a multicenter study. Surgery 2005;137:40310. worthwhile? Communication la 12e runion de lEuropean
[22] Bismuth H, Chiche L, Castaing D. Surgical treatment of hep- Society for Organ Transplantation (ESOT), Genve, 1619 Octo-
atocellular carcinoma in non cirrhotic liver. World J Surg bre 2005.
1995;19:3541. [26] Edeline J, Raoul JL, Vauleon E, Guillygomach A,
[23] Pilchmayr R, Weimann A, Oldhafer KJ, et al. Role of liver trans- Boudjema K, Boucher E. Systemic chemotherapy for
plantation in the treatment of unresectable liver cancer. World hepatocellular carcinoma in non-cirrhotic liver: a
J Surg 1995;19:80713. retrospective study. World J Gastroenterol 2009;15:
[24] Iwatsuki S, Starzl TE, Sheahan DG, et al. Hepatic resection 7136.
versus transplantation for hepatocellular carcinoma. Ann Surg
1991;214:2218.

You might also like