Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Brand Positioning
May 26, 2017
jankelley 1
Agenda
1. Welcome and introductions
2. Why are we here today?
3. Current situation key findings
4. Competitive positioning
5. Brand positioning exercise
jankelley 2
Jan Kelley Team
jankelley 3
Why are we here today?
jankelley 4
Gate Threes customer value proposition for external customers is not well defined or
supported internally, limiting the ability to position its core value against competitors in
the market.
1. Gate Three construction management software is the only software solution created by
construction experts to meet the needs of todays construction projects.
2. Developed to serve internal EllisDon projects:
Supports some of Canadas largest construction projects
Reflects EllisDon systems and processes
Internally focused development and support along with limited external customer feedback
have a significant impact on the user experience
3. Competitor applications, while potentially lacking construction expertise, have strong user
experience and support.
4. EllisDon is Gate Threes only customer, essentially.
Development and support skews to EllisDon needs, which limits focus of insight and resources
dedicated to external customer needs.
jankelley 5
Business is Personal
jankelley 6
Google/Motista Research: www.thinkwithgoogle.com/articles/promotion-emotion-b2b.html
Providing business value to customers isnt enough.
jankelley 7
Brand Development Process
jankelley 8
Our Challenge Deliverables
Develop a clear, relevant and 1. Understanding customer needs, competitive positioning and
differentiated value proposition current barriers
for ideal customers of the Gate 2. Gate Three positioning statement and messaging map
Three solution to:
Enable sales growth
Guide product
development and support
jankelley 9
Our Approach Discovery
Audit material in market
Competitive positioning
Stakeholder interviews
# Internal
Scott Chatterson - EllisDon Project Manager
Andrew Anderson - EllisDon Project Manager
Mark Wiseman - EllisDon Project Manager
Paula Dobrowolska - EllisDon Customer Experience Manager - PS
Pegah Moghani - EllisDon Project Manager - PS
Lisa Brown - EllisDon Costing Manager
# Customers
Corey Stearne - Cooper Construction Limited Project Manager
Murray Chidley - Chimo Construction Limited Controller
Themis Tzovolos - Steelcore Construction Ltd. President
jankelley 10
Current Situation Key Findings
jankelley 11
1. Gate Three customers outside EllisDon are likely mid-sized
companies with different needs and processes.
jankelley 12
2. Gate Threes software and service experience to address needs of small to
mid-size enterprises (SMEs), which may be inclined to trial Gate Three based
on lower price of entry.
Larger organizations already recognize
the SaaS as a cost of doing business and
are prepared to pay for applications
with proven performance and time in
market.
Software and service requirements of Procore was three times the cost and in US dollars and they didnt
SMEs include integration, they were going to charge us another $8,000 USD.
Cost considerations (subscription
and time/labour to manage) From an overall cost of operation, whether something is $20,000
End-to-end management (26 USD/year if it creates the efficiencies, I can bank that into what we do.
modules)
Intuitive experience Its (Procore) a little on the pricy side, but were finding there is a lot
Accessibility (web) of development and Open API features that work for our organization.
Support
Onboarding
Self-customization
Integration with complementary
software jankelley 13
3. Alignment with EllisDon brand is positive with some skepticism about data
sharing.
jankelley 14
4. External sales success means moving beyond where Gate Three is today
created for and serving, almost solely, EllisDon internal customers and projects
jankelley 15
5. Support is top notch; however, clear expectations re: time to implement and
maintain Gate Three are critical to long-term adoption and customer
retention.
Customer Support and background Remo had Paula lead the demonstration who had a great
of Professional Services was knowledge of construction so as we were asking questions, she
referenced as extremely positive
understood the terminology and what we wanted to see. Procore
Depending on experience and salesperson didnt have any knowledge so when we wanted to see
background, some users were
initially shocked by the amount of
some of the nuts and bolts, he couldnt answer any of those things.
setup and training time required (1-
3 months)
End result (ease of documentation, I really liked the fact that Gate Three would have a dedicated
searchability, time saving, etc.) Raquel on our team for assistance, but where we felt the not so
makes it worth it strong points were price and the mobile apps.
jankelley 16
6. The software is not intuitive and is seen as inefficient, contributing to a
weak user experience.
A key selling point and feature
construction workers seek in
their software is efficiency;
however, navigating Gate Three If you input something incorrectly the error says you have an incorrect field but you
often confuses users dont know which one it is. Need something that is a little more clear that ties into
Multi-step processes and long the way it looks and makes something easier to use.
click journeys to get to specific
locations within the software Gate Three is a closed loop, if you want to find an RFI in a folder, you have to go back
creates frustration into the RFI for that job and drill down into the trail and find it. It seemed a bit more
If a software is not intuitive, it cumbersome.
wont be efficient for the worker,
thereby forcing users to seek I would say the day-to-day tasks probably take 30 minutes more to complete in Gate
better solutions elsewhere Three than they would in our old system.
Users who are less
technologically savvy or who
have not had to work with
technology frequently as part of
their jobs need software to be
easy to use and intuitive, with
easy access to job files and
flexible folder structures
jankelley 17
7. Gate Three hasnt been around long enough to be a truly polished piece of
software.
Major competitors have been in
business significantly longer than
Gate Three and those looking for
software are more comfortable The other thing was some parts of Gate Three didnt seem to be quite there. It
with products that have been out seemed like it needed another couple of years of development to be on a
in the market and have time to comparable level.
work through the kinks
Users are more wary of A decision maker had experience with (CMIC), so there was that and Gate Three
connecting with a company who being a brand new product, even though it grew out of Edge Builder, its a new
doesnt have a proven track product.
record in the software industry
We can combat this with strong
messaging around clients who are
currently using the software
jankelley 18
Competitive Positioning
jankelley 19
Company Positioning Marketing Activities Software Integration
Website N/A
Gate Three Better Decisions. Faster.
Media Relations
SEM Trade Shows Sage 300 CRE
A mobile and collaborative all-in-one Social Media Conferences Quickbooks
Procore
platform built to streamline Website Webinars Dexter + Chaney Spectrum
15 yrs
construction project management. Media Relations eBooks
Road Shows Procore TV
SEM Blog Proprietary
CMiC
Construction software. Evolved. Social Media Trade Shows
43 yrs
Website Conferences
SEM Buildertrend.tv Sage 300 CRE ProEst
Social Media Webinar Quickbooks Cadsoft
Builder Trend The #1 Software for home builders & Website Blog Xero Cubit
11 yrs remodelers ChiefArchitect Stack
SilverStone Group Active Takeoff
Wepay SoftPlan
Viewpoint is built on a foundation of SEM eBooks Proprietary
ViewPoint Rock Solid Collaboration. Social Media Newsletter
27 yrs Offering Smoother, Easier & More Website Trade Shows
Profitable Results Webinars Conferences
SEM Webinars Exchange data with systems for ECM, cost,
Integrated Estimating, Project
Aconex Social Media Videos scheduling, ERP, and more.
Management, and Job Costing for Small
17 yrs Website eBooks
to Medium-Sized Construction
Media Relations Brochures
Companies
Blog Reports
jankelley 20
Gate Threes capabilities are on par with its competitors, but the user
experience on the website might detract people from discovering and
understanding its capabilities.
Those who have used Gate Three Website visitors miss key company/tool features and PODs due to lengthy
agree that the software demonstrates sentences and heavy language
capabilities equal to or better than Bullet points, images, icons, etc. are all potential replacements for long, hard-
the competitive software they have to-understand content
used (ViewPoint, EdgeBuilder, etc.);
Capabilities should be up front and concise
however, the messaging on Gate
Threes website is difficult to get
through.
jankelley 21
Most leading software options are focusing on their accessibility and
collaboration within their value propositions.
jankelley 22
Positioning
Price
User Experience
jankelley 23
SWOT Analysis
STRENGTHS WEAKNESSES
EllisDon is a well-known, credible company within the construction Software is not intuitive
industry No offline version available
Built by construction workers, for construction workers Outdated look and feel (although this is currently being updated)
Web-based Wait time for custom reports
Mobile app (Daily Site Report) Long training period
Excellent searchability Long setup period
Everyone in a work flow can benefit from using the software Lack of presence in social and digital space
Bundles (Procurement, Foundation, etc.) allow companies to choose
which features make the most sense for them and just pay for those
Once trained, the software is easy to use and effective
OPPORTUNITIES THREATS
The industry is moving away from traditional paper-to-pen Over 200 construction management software options
The construction industrys tech landscape is constantly evolving and Competitors are increasingly using paid support
growing New technologies that could replace some, or all, of what Gate Three
Demand for construction management software is high does
People who have grown up with technology are joining the workforce
and are/will be decision makers and managers
Shift towards integrated project delivery
Leverage credibility of EllisDon
Leverage fact that the software was built by those who needed the
software themselves jankelley 24
Positioning Gate Three to External Customers
jankelley 25
1 2
Establish and Continue to evolve
articulate Gate Three with
Gate Threes external customer
current value to needs in mind
customers
jankelley 26
1
Establish and
articulate
Gate Threes
current value to
customers
jankelley 27
Understanding the customer mindset
jankelley 28
Customer Needs
Grow Business Manage Risk Drive Efficiency/Effectiveness Manage Cost/ Profitability Improve Data Mgmt / Analysis
How can I differentiate my
Did I double check the numbers? Project controls Budget Hub
business?
How do I allocate resources to set back and Am I working from the correct
Getting the next job Safety Blitz Estimates
track? version?
Projects more complex/harder to
Complaints Double entry Profit Overwhelmed by data
manage
More risk on general contractors Manpower costs vs. manpower
Workflows Spread data
plates receivable
Someone leaves, all knowledge goes with How much money am I leaving
Do I know what I do not know? Spreadsheets
them on the table?
How can I do this faster? Close out hold back (where is it) Is the information accurate?
Losing info/data (i.e. pay
I dont have time (process, training, teaching) Am I losing money?
dispute)
Keeping track of change orders
I cant grow if we dont standardize process Data in one place
($$$)
Lack of transferring (i.e.
Is there a better way to run my business? Predictability (i.e. forecast)
drawings)
Do I know how much of the Consolidate info to different
Out of control
budget has been spent? stakeholders
I want data to make better
Supervisors (field) Managing people & money
decisions
Ensuring all invoices are
Do not know what is outstanding (to do) Live project view
entered
Who is looking at what when? Paying everyone
On schedule substantial completion
Efficiency = more projects = more revenue
jankelley 29
Identifying Points of Difference
What are the tangible (rational) points of difference for us?
What are the intangible (emotional) points of difference for us?
These are the unique benefits of the brand that must be consistently
delivered
Where do we perform better and best in the market today?
Where do we need to be best?
jankelley 30
Tangible/Rational Benefits -- As Good As Better Best
Points of
Keep all design docs in one place AI Access -
Workflow
User-experience
Intangible/Emotional Benefits
jankelley 32
Developing the Brand Position
jankelley 33
What is brand positioning?
And why do you need it?
Every organization needs a clear and common understanding of what it is they
offer to customers, why its different or better than alternatives and the
reasons why customers should believe those claims.
jankelley 34
Brand Positioning Exercise
Target audience: the attitudinal description of the core group of people to
whom you want to appeal
Brand promise: the compelling benefit that sets you apart from your
competition
Frame of reference: the segment or category in which your company
competes
Reason to believe: evidence to prove the brand will deliver on its promise
jankelley 35
Brand Positioning Exercise
jankelley 36
Brand Positioning Exercise
Example:
For world wide web users who enjoy books, Amazon.com is a retail book
seller that provides instant access to over 1.1 million books. Unlike other
book retailers, Amazon.com provides a combination of extraordinary
convenience, low prices and comprehensive selection.
jankelley 37
Brand Positioning
jankelley 38
1
Establish and
articulate
Gate Threes
current value to
customers
jankelley 39
Messaging Context Our Approach Benefit
Point What the customer/audience How and why we can support this claim What value it provides to the
High-level thinks or believes customer
themes
meaningful to
customers
Im in construction, not
Gate Three is the construction management software built and supported by one of the worlds leading Knowing that Gate Three is used
computers, so I just want a
Expertise construction companies, EllisDon. Taking on some of the most complex global projects in the last 65 years, and trusted by leaders in my
software that is going to do the
Gate Three has EllisDons pure construction management expertise for projects large and small comes through in Gate industry is important to me. When I
job and do it right. With so much
unmatched Three, the software built by construction experts for construction companies. can count on support for my
on my plate, I worry that Ill have
experience and management software where and
to spend too much time learning
expertise in the EllisDon has delivered thousands of projects across four continents, receiving recognition as one of ENR's when I need it, it allows me to focus
the ins and outs of a new
construction top 100 global General Contractors and Deloittes Best Managed Companies. Gate Three itself manages on the many other needs of my
software, with unanswered
industry. over $4 billion in projects annually and was named on CIOs 25 Construction Applications Transforming business and contributes to my
questions, and wont end up
Business 2016 list and on CIOs 25 Most Promising Project Management Solution Providers 2016 list. overall operational success.
getting the ROI I need.
Gate Three is set up with standard best practices for managing risk throughout the entire lifecycle of a
construction project. Gate Three tracks and saves every action and communication between the project
Risk team, subcontractors, consultants and owners in a single place, through workflow, document logs and
Construction projects are
Management historical information, reducing inefficiencies and inaccuracies along the way.
increasingly complex, dynamic I have peace of mind knowing that
Formal
and fraught with uncertainty. Im Gate Three keeps everything
documentation Using Gate Three ensures the right processes are in place at the start of a project and followed by all users
constantly trying to keep all the documented throughout the entire
throughout a from start to finish. Gate Three offers a full and accurate view of the project in real time, while also tracking
moving parts of a project in check project. People can trust me and my
project limits what future costs are committed versus actual costs. No step can be skipped. No change deleted.
in order to protect the business work knowing that everyone on my
risks associated Gate Three manages risk through:
and my reputation. team is being held accountable.
with managing Pre-defined checklist for financial management and project workflows so nothing can be skipped,
large projects. overlooked or ignored
Payment Schedule management
Change Orders that automatically update a projects budget, costing and billing jankelley 40
Messaging Context Our Approach Benefit
Point What the customer/audience How and why we can support this claim What value it provides to the
High-level thinks or believes customer
themes
meaningful to
customers
Customization
Gate Threes
Weve developed our own way The foundations Gate Three had
processes,
of doing things in the office and in place allowed me to adjust a
workflows and
on the job site so a cookie- few of our norms and actually
reports are Gate Three offers the best of both worlds when it comes to standard offering and customization. The
cutter product just wont work increase our productivity and
standardized software is built from four generations of construction management experience and best practices
for my team and project efficiencies, while still having the
but can be and configured to your needs because, after all, every business has its differences.
partners. If we have to change ability to customize the software
configured
how we do things, will to get exactly what I want and
around your
productivity go down? need for my business.
needs.
jankelley 41
2
Continue to evolve
Gate Three with
external customer
needs in mind
jankelley 42
jankelley 43
1. Confirm short- and
long-term customer
segments
2 2. Primary customer
Continue to evolve research
- Quantitative survey
Gate Three with - Qualitative
external customer interviews
needs in mind 3. Develop user personas
4. Benchmark Gate Three
against leading
competitors
jankelley 44
Appendix: Market Segment Info
jankelley 45
Most (79%) construction organizations make less than $50
million per year, with almost half (44%) earning between $5
million and $50 million.
jankelley 46
Source: www.capterra.com/construction-management-software/user-research
The most common type of buyers are small to midsize general contracting
firms.
Prospective Buyer Size by Number of Users Prospective Buyer Size by Number of Segment
jankelley 47
Source: www.softwareadvice.com/resources/construction-buyer-report-2015/
US new construction starts in 2016 to grow 6% to $712 billion for
housing, commercial and institutional building sectors
jankelley 48
Source: www.capterra.com/construction-management-software/user-research
52% of prospective buyers use pen and paper to conduct
estimating, takeoff, big management and other processes.
jankelley 49
Source: www.softwareadvice.com/resources/construction-buyer-report-2015/
Unsurprisingly, the biggest reason respondents switched from
their previous construction management method was because it
was too hard to use.
jankelley 50
Source: www.capterra.com/construction-management-software/user-research
One-third of prospective buyers say that improving the accuracy
of estimates is their top reason for seeking new construction
software.
jankelley 51
Source: www.softwareadvice.com/resources/construction-buyer-report-2015/
Nearly 50% of construction firms seek extensive materials-list
functionality, followed by job costing and takeoff.
jankelley 52
Source: www.softwareadvice.com/resources/construction-buyer-report-2015/
When choosing a software, support, company reputation, and implementation training were
hardly a factor when compared to the software's functionality and ease of use. The emphasis on
robust, easy to use software is a reflection of the construction industry's culture of self-reliance
and desire to get the best product.
jankelley 53
Source: www.capterra.com/construction-management-software/user-research
Prospective buyers dedicate anywhere from 0.01 to 0.64 percent
of their annual revenue to the deployment of new construction
software.
jankelley 54
Source: www.softwareadvice.com/resources/construction-buyer-report-2015/