Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. Dickens presents his stingy critique of the obsession with wealth and
status, by showing that material wealth does not confer happiness
In each case, Dickens contrasts societal perceptions with what he feels are
more important values.
1.
Magwitch identifies Pips material possessions watch, which are markers
of his status as a gentleman which society would identify as well. Dickens
neatly undercuts this with the depiction of Pips revulsion towards
Magwitch. Outwardly he is a gentleman but his character has lost its
original compassion for the poor convict.
2.
Dickens is also an advocate for honest work, be it manual or not. He
presents the corrupting effects of idleness.
The link between status and avoidance of manual labour has perpetuated
throughout affecting working class woman, for e.g, Mrs Joe is deeply
resentful of Joes status and financial inability to hire a servant. Her apron
symbolises the domestic duties she has to perform.
3.
Metaphor of varnished wood in chapter 22 makes clear that what matters
is the quality of the person underneath, if what is underneath is flawed,
then fancy clothes and manners highlight the flaws, if what is underneath
is true and good, then fancy clothes and manners highlight the good. The
surface finish cannot mask what a person really is.
As pip becomes wealthier he buries the traits that made Magwitch want to
make him a gentleman in the first place
Conclusion:
Wealthy people like Miss Havisham and Drummle are not necessarily
happy and are not better human beings.
Wealth is only of lasting benefit when it is used for others (Pip purchasing
a partnership for Herbert, Joe paying off Pips debt)
Herbert and Joe stand as models for true gentlemanliness in the novel.