Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This report is prepared as a requirement of Business Statistics (BUS 511) course of the MBA
Program. The primary goal of this report is to put into application the different theoretical
1.1 BACKGROUND
Prime Bank Limited operating as a scheduled bank under the banking license issued by
Bangladesh Bank was incorporated on February 12, 1995. The vision of the bank is to be the
best private commercial bank in Bangladesh in terms of efficiency, capital adequacy, asset
quality, sound management and profitability having strong liquidity. Prime Bank Ltd
provides all kinds of commercial corporate and personal banking services covering all
segments of the society. The bank has always been very concerned about providing top
quality customer service, which has now become one of its distinctive competencies. The
management always takes into account the changes taking place in the market and takes a
proactive stance in design and delivery of customer friendly products and products tailored to
their needs and also to match the different segments served by the network- both urban and
rural, which makes it different from other local commercial banks of the country. The bank
has a total of 54 branches all over Bangladesh to provide better services to its customers.
Profit (the net profit) is the key tool, which is used to rate the performance of the banks in the
banking sector. Through out the project profit means the net profit. Prime Bank Ltd holds the
second position in terms of earning of profit; the first position is always retained by Islami
Bank Bangladesh Ltd. The third and the fourth earners of profit are usually Pubali Bank Ltd
and Southeast Bank Ltd. Prime Bank Ltd always tries to maximize its profit as this will
1
enable it to become the best local commercial bank in Bangladesh. For this the bank should
carefully analyze its deposit, loans, export and import to find ways to increase profit.
Profit can be increased through two mechanisms – earning of fee based income (non interest
income) and interest income. Banks encourage export and import to raise their fees income.
Though increased import has a negative implication for the country in terms of negative
balance of payments but for banks it is an attractive source of income, especially fee based
income. Increase in the amount of export and import can significantly increase the amount of
profit. Export and Import have a positive relationship as increase in export leads to an
Deposits lead to creation of interest income. At Prime Bank Ltd, total deposits is being kept
in an account where interest is being generated at the rate of 12%, profit is the difference
between the interest received from prime general account and the cost incurred, which
includes the cost of operations and the cost of deposits (the interest given to customers in lieu
to the amount of deposits being kept). Generally, the amount of deposits received is being
passed on to the borrowers in form of loans from where interest is received. Thus profit is
Profit in the branch is also derived from the spread between the rate paid for deposit of funds
and the rate at which the branch receives from its borrowers. The ability to pool deposits
from many sources that can be lent to many different borrowers creates the flow of funds.
2
1.2 PROBLEM DEFINITION AND STATEMENT
This topic was basically chosen, as it is seen that profitability is slightly on a decreasing trend
in the recent days and the bank need to find ways through which it can increase the profit to
become number one bank operating in the local banking sector in Bangladesh. The study
being undertaken is therefore to investigate whether any relationship exists between deposits,
loans, export and import with the profit earned at Prime Bank Limited. In context to this no
study has been previously being undertaken on this topic. The problem statement therefore is
“Identifying whether deposits, loans, export and import have any influence on the
The study will help researchers to extend their understanding on the significant relationship
deposits, loans, export and import have with the profit. Moreover it will initiate managers and
employees to drive their effort in those directions, which will ultimately increase the profit of
to present and test a model that identifies the impact of different factors on the total
profitability.
to suggest ways the bank and branch management can take to improving the total
profitability by using solutions and parameters derived from empirical and descriptive
statistics.
3
1.5 SCOPE OF THE STUDY
This data collected in this report was limited to the Gulshan branch only and covered a period
of 20 months – December 2005 to July 2007. It will not be possible to provide data before
December 2005 and any development after July 2007 is not being highlighted in this report.
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
In recent years banks have become increasingly aware of the need to measure the
most economies. Recent research, as surveyed by Levine (1996), has shown that the
efficacy of financial intermediation can also affect economic growth. Crucially, banks
take deposits from savers but paying them interest. They pass it to the borrowers,
receiving interest on loans. The ability to pool deposits from many different sources that
can be lent to many different borrowers creates the flow of funds inherent in the banking
sector. The spread between these two returns mirrors the bank interest margins. This
suggests that bank’s interest spread can be interpreted as an indicator of the efficiency of
the banking system. This is basically due to efficient utilization of bank’s deposits and
loans. According to Levine, profit is a function of the bank’s interest margin and
efficiency of the employees. Profit is the dependent variable. Bank’s interest margin and
efficiency of the employees are the independent variables, which are positively related to
According to Karim (2000), export is creation of wealth in any country which depends on the
expansion of production and increasing participation in international trade and import is the
flow of goods and services purchased by economic agents located in one country from
economic events of another country. Karim further mentioned that though increased imports
4
have negative implications for the country in terms of negative balance of payments but for
banks, it is an attractive source of income. Banks are the main driving forces which can
initiate in increasing the import and export, though the emphasis should more be on export
than on import. He undertook a study on how export and import affect profitability of the
bank. Export and import helps in reducing the burden of interest that has to be given to the
depositors for keeping their money in the bank and in increasing the amount of profit through
Sayeed (2001) in his study mentioned that profit is a function of corporate image, customers’
satisfaction and quality of the products. He, in his study found that, there exists a positive
relationship between profit (dependent variable) and customer satisfaction, quality of the
PBL (2007): Deposits are the principal input for a bank, upon which it develops its capacity
of business expansion through the mechanism of money creation. Thereby, banks come up
with persuasive deposit schemes to attract a portion of public income in form of savings
The major depositors of Prime Bank Ltd constitute of high cost depositors (deposit schemes)
and less of no cost (current account) and low cost deposits (general saving account. The
5
Non-resident Taka Account Non-resident Investors Taka Account
House Building Deposit Scheme Prime Millionaire Scheme
Customers mainly prefer FDR, Contributory Saving Scheme and Lakhopati Saving Schemes
Loans are the principal product of a bank through which it not only maximizes its
shareholders profit but also helps to boost up the economy of the country by channeling them
to the investment gateway. In granting loans the bank basically looks at the borrower’s
integrity, honesty and intention to pay the borrowed money, borrower’s ability of doing
business, financial strength of the borrower and general business conditions. The loans
Prime Bank Ltd also caters to the trade finance market. Manufacturing activity in Bangladesh
is relatively subdued, but there are certain industries such as textiles, where the country has a
exporters for example) and it is this customer segment that the bank mainly caters to. The
bank is involved at all stages of the export cycle: it gives pre-shipment finance and post-
shipment facilities In addition, the bank also undertakes some amount of project financing for
its clients’ plant and machinery or modernization requirements. In case of export the facilities
provided are:
Purchase of Bills
6
The import facilities provided are:
between the dependent and the independent variables. Theories are basically guidelines used
for the purpose of formulating the theoretical/conceptual model. The objective in multiple
regression is to analyze the relationship between a single dependent (criterion) variable with
Basically four independent variables are taken and shown as the function of the dependent
variable. The four independent variables are deposits, loans, export and import and profit is
the dependent variable. These four independent variables are taken into account as there are
considered to the important elements which affects profitability. The model is give below.
7
RESEARCH DESIGN
Is there any significant relationship between deposits and profit in context of Prime
Bank Ltd.?
Is there any significant relationship between loans and profit in context of Prime Bank
Ltd.?
Is there any significant relationship between export and profit in context of Prime
Bank Ltd?
Is there any significant relationship between import and profit in context of Prime
Bank Ltd?
Hypotheses 1:
Profit is positively related to deposits, if deposits (x1) increase, profit (y) will increase and
Hypotheses 2:
Profit is positively related to loans, if loans (x2) increase, profit (y) will increase and vice
Hypotheses 3:
Profit is positively related to export, if export (x3) increases, profit (y) will increase and vice
Hypotheses 4:
8
Profit is positively related to import, if import (x4) increases, profit (y) will increase and vice
DATA COLLECTION
Majority of the data was collected from secondary sources, from the internal database of the
branch, especially from the statements, which are being sent to the Financial Administration
Department (FAD) of the bank and Bangladesh Bank (BB) at the end of every month.
Moreover, primary data in form of face-to-face interviews with people working related to the
relevant departments was used to gather information regarding the independent and the
dependent variables. All the variables - independent and dependent are quantitative variables
Time series data (data collected at several successive periods of time) is used in this study, a
period of 20 months is taken from December 2005 to July 2007, and the sample size is
therefore 20. Moreover the amount of deposits, loans, export and import are expressed in
million Tk. Internet was also used to gather information to enhance data collection, especially
DATA ANALYSIS
To effectively analyze the independent variables and the dependent variable, both descriptive
and empirical statistics were used; the multiple regression model, relationship analysis and
test of hypotheses helped in determining the relationship and extent of relationship between
the dependent and the independent variables. For this research MS-Excel was used as the
9
TIME FRAME AND COST
The total time that will be taken to completer the study was 6 weeks and cost incurred was
around TK 2000 to finance transportation cost, purchase of secondary research materials, fees
Regression method provides a mean of objectively assessing the degree and character of the
relationship between dependent and independent variables. Multiple regression model uses
several independent variables to predict the dependent variable. The least square method is
used
є = error term that accounts for variability in y which cannot be explained by the relationship
One of the assumption of the regression model is that the mean or expected value E(Є) = 0
Hence
10
In light of our study
Table 1: Data Set Representing the Relationship between Dependent and Independent
Variables.
11
Dec-06 323.00 24,244.00 12,323.00 5,600.00 4,329.00
Jan-07 425.00 26,673.00 20,232.00 7,623.00 6,230.00
Feb-07 195.00 24,835.00 21,236.00 4,532.00 3,217.00
Mar-07 230.00 28,324.00 15,000.00 6,235.00 4,217.00
Apr-07 392.00 32,222.00 18,323.00 9,323.00 5,239.00
May-07 439.00 36,623.00 29,174.00 6,893.00 4,490.00
Jun-07 422.00 32,323.00 25,000.00 7,123.00 3,217.00
Jul-07 311.00 34,323.00 15,032.00 6,896.00 3,112.00
$7,579.00 $596,585.00 $509,313.00 $129,135.00 $110,560.00
The above table represents the data set used in this study, y is the dependent variable and x0,
x2, x3, x4 are the independent variables, y = profit, x1 = deposits, x2 = loans, x3 = export and x4 =
import. All the above data are quantitative and in million taka.
Descriptive statistics uses tabular, graphical and numerical methods to analysis the set of
data. This tool is basically used to provide summaries of the information in the data set. The
table below highlights the important information about the dependent and independent
variables.
12
Y X1 X2 X3 X4
Mean 378.95 29,829.25 25,465.65 6,456.75 5528
Standard Error 39.996347 882.5698 2,207.94496 810.5488 402.61839
Median 380.5 30,106.00 2,5000.00 6,894.5 5,268.00
Mode - - 18,323 - 3,217
Standard Deviation 178.8691 3,946.972 9,874.23003 3,624.884 1,800.5642
Sample Variance 31,994.155 1,55,78,589 9,75,00,418.8 1,31,39,786 32,42,031.4
Kurtosis -0.0969759 -1.15794 0.90020075 0.571779 -1.29308
Skewness 0.5767167 -0.07911 1.06178516 0.559949 0.2380053
Range 642 12,719 37,000 14,087 5,578
Minimum 120 23,904 12,323 1,234 3,112
Maximum 762 36,623 49,323 15,321 8,690
Sum 7,579 5,96,585 50,9313 1,29,135 1,10,560
Count 20 20 20 20 20
Table 2 provides information about the mean, median, standard deviation, mode, range, etc of
Mean is the measure of central location for the data set. From the above table it can be
seen that the mean of the profit is Tk. 378.95 million, deposits is Tk 29,829.25 million,
loans is Tk 25,465.65 million, export is Tk. 6,456.75 million and Import is TK 5,528
million.
Median reflects similar scenario as the mean. In terms all the variables there is not much
differences between the mean and median of the dependent and independent variables,
Mode also a measure of central location is defined as the value of a variable that occurs
most frequently. In this case for loans (x2) and import (x4), the mode is Tk 18,232 million
and Tk 3,217 million which means these two values have occurred more than once in
Variance is the measure of variability based on the square deviations of the data values
about the mean and standard deviation is also a measure of variability which is computed
by taking the positive square root of the variance. From the above data it can be seen that
13
there is high variability in the data set for all the variables especially in case of loans (x2)
Range also measure variability is the difference between the largest value and the smallest
value for each variables in the data. An interesting finding is that in this case the range for
loans(x2) and export(x3) is the highest at Tk 37,000 million and Tk 14,087 million
respectively.
comprehend the relationship each independent variable has with the dependent variable.
Below four scattergrams are given which depict the relationship deposits, loans, export and
800.00
700.00
Profit (in million Tk.)
600.00
500.00
400.00
300.00
200.00
100.00
0.00
0.00 6,000.00 12,000.00 18,000.00 24,000.00 30,000.00 36,000.00 42,000.00
Deposits (in million Tk. )
800.00
Figure 2: Partitioned Scatter Diagram of Profit and Deposits
700.00
Profit (in million Tk.)
600.00
500.00
400.00
300.00
200.00
100.00
0.00
- 8,000.00 16,000.00 24,000.00 32,000.00 40,000.00 48,000.00 56,000.00
14
Figure 3: Partitioned Scatter Diagram of Profits and Loans
800.00
700.00
Profit (in million Tk.)
600.00
500.00
400.00
300.00
200.00
100.00
0.00
0.00 2,500.00 5,000.00 7,500.00 10,000.00 12,500.00 15,000.00 17,500.00
15
800.00
700.00
500.00
400.00
300.00
200.00
100.00
0.00
0.00 1,500.00 3,000.00 4,500.00 6,000.00 7,500.00 9,000.00 10,500.00
From the above scatter diagrams, it can be depicted that as maximum of the data values falls
in (I) and (III) quadrants, there exists a positive linear association between each of the
independent variables – deposits, loans, export and import with the dependent variable –
increase/decrease in the same direction. An interesting finding is that in case of export and
profit, almost all the data are in the (I) and (III) quadrants, therefore it can be said almost a
perfect positive linear association exists between profit and export. In all the above diagrams,
the horizontal line represents the mean of profit (dependent variable). The vertical line
values, the correlation coefficient and test of hypotheses along with the level of significance
to summarize data.
16
Table 3: Output Summary for the Regression Equation.
REGRE SSION ANALYSIS
Multiple R 0.975898947
R Square 0.952378754
Adjusted R Square 0.939679756
Standard E rror 43.93057327
Observations 20
ANOVA
df SS MS F Significance F
Regression 4 578940.521 144735.1302 74.99636517 9.86919E-10
Residual 15 28948.42902 1929.895268
Total 19 607888.95
Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P-value Lower 95% Upper 95% Lower 95.0%Upper 95.0%
Intercept- Profit (y) -163.329326 101.9354019 -1.60228265 0.129938078 -380.5996257 53.94097374 -380.5996257 53.94097374
Deposits (x1) 0.005036769 0.002132978 2.361378325 0.021976506 -0.003346181 0.013419719 -0.003346181 0.013419719
Loans (x2) 0.003960151 0.001829186 2.164980071 0.046922093 6.13312E-05 0.007858971 6.13312E-05 0.007858971
Export (x3) 0.029156619 0.004629279 6.298306264 1.42799E -05 0.019289538 0.039023701 0.019289538 0.039023701
Import (x4) 0.018620019 0.00895503 2.079280449 0.055161024 -0.000467188 0.037707225 -0.000467188 0.037707225
The value of y intercept, b0 = -163.33, which means that if there are no deposits, loans, export
and import, there would be a loss of 163.33 million taka and which is highly possible. Firstly,
these variables are the core determinants which significantly affect the profit. Secondly, even
if no income is generated from these areas, the banks still have to pay the cost of operations
which includes salaries of employees, utilities etc. and the bear the cost of deposits (interest).
In Prime Bank Ltd, also for Gulshan Branch, there is mostly high cost deposits i.e. high
The value of b1= 0.0050, that is dy/dx1 >0, where dy =per unit change of y and dx1=per unit
change in x1 which means that if the amount of deposits increase by 100 million taka, profit
17
The value of b2= 0.0040, that is dy/dx2 >0, where dy =per unit change of y and dx2=per unit
change in x2 which means that if loans increase by 100 million taka, profit will increase by
The value of b3= 0.0292, that is dy/x3 >0, where dy =per unit change of y and dx3=per unit
change in x3 which means that if export increases by 100 million taka, profit will increase by
The value of b3= 0.0186, that is dy/dx4 >0, where dy =per unit change of y and dx4=per unit
change in x4 which means that if import increases by 100 million taka, profit will increase by
Coefficient of Determination:
equation. It can be interpreted as the proportion of variability in the dependent variable y that
is explained by the estimated regression equation. From table 3, the unadjusted coefficient of
means that the variation in deposits, loans, export and import explains 95.23% of the
two variables. Values of correlation coefficient are always between -1 and +1. A value of +1
indicates that the two variables are perfectly related in a positive linear sense, a value of -1
indicates that the two variables are perfectly related in a negative linear sense. Values of
correlation coefficient close to zero indicate that two variables are not linearly related.
18
Sample Correlation Coefficient is
= ± √r2
If any two independent variables depict correlation greater than 0.90, it creates the problem of
For the above table, it can be seen that none of the two independent variables depict
multicollinearity between the independent variables and thus the independent variables are
not highly correlated with each other. The maximum correlation is between loans and import
and between deposits and export at 0.76 and 0.72 respectively, which being less than 0.90. It
can be seen that a somewhat high correlation exists between Import and Loans. In Prime
Bank Ltd, in case of import, a loan account is created to make payment to the exporter which
leads to an increase in loans and later on it is adjusted when the customer pays for it from his
own source. Export is related to deposits because after undertaking an export, proceeds are
received against the export and which is usually kept in the account maintained in the bank
19
by the client and also a portion of the proceeds received are build up by the bank. These lead
Setting up and testing hypotheses is an essential part of statistical inference. For testing of
hypotheses two point are noted, the sign of relationship and the level of significance. For test
of hypotheses, the t-test has been used. According to the rule if the absolute tcalculated value is
greater than the ttable value, then the variables are said to be significant at α level.
The ttable value is tα , df (degree of freedom = n-k-1, n= sample size, k= number of parameters
At 99% confidence level, where α = 1-0.99 = 0.01, ttable value at t.01, 15=2.602, tcalculated values
for some of the variables are not greater than t table value, hence at this confidence level some
of the independent variables are not statistically significant with the dependent variable.
At 95% confidence level, where α = 1-0.95 = 0.05, ttable value at t.05, 15=1.753. As all the
tcalculated values are greater than ttable value, hence at this confidence level all the independent
20
Loans (x2), tcalculated value = 2.16 > t.05, 15=1.75
It can also be seen from table 3, that the signs of the coefficient of the variables – deposits,
Therefore, it can be concluded that, at 95% confidence level all the independent variables are
statistically significant with the dependent variables as tcalculated value is greater than ttable value.
Moreover as the slope coefficients are all positive, there exists a statistically significant
relationship between the dependent and the independent variables, especially between profit
and export. Hence it can be concluded that if deposits, loans, export and import increases
3.0 RECOMMENDATIONS
Based on the findings and analysis, several strategic recommendations have been devised that
Reducing High Cost Deposits: In Prime Bank Ltd, high cost deposits are more than 65
percent of the total deposits. As high cost deposits carry higher rate of interest, this puts
pressure on the total income earned by increasing the cost of deposits and ultimately the cost
of funds. The bank should try to have a deposit portfolio which has more of no cost low cost
deposits and less of high cost deposits. For this the marketing department of the bank has to
tighten their belts. The bank may also look for cheaper sources of funds that are held by
various government agencies. Thus even if less income is generated the bank will not it have
to take funds from other sources to finance for the depositors interest.
21
Increasing Loans: According to Bangladesh Bank, a bank will be able to use 89% of its
deposits to finance loans to customers, in this case it is only 85%, and hence the bank has
the capacity to increase loans by 4%, which will lead to increase in profit through increase
in interest income.
Increasing Investments: The bank should increase its investments in sectors like
automobiles, real state, health care etc. in order to make adjustment in its credit portfolio.
Because the present portfolio is somewhat off-balance due to heavy exposure in garments
sector. Though it may have negative impact on its profitability, the bank will find it in
Increasing Fee Based Income: It is been seen that to maintain excellent clientele
relationship, especially in case export and import, the bank waives some portion of the
commission and other changes to some of its clients. .Instead if charges Tk. 0.90% on
every Tk.1 amount of import, the bank for some of its clients charges only TK 0.25% and
sometimes even TK 0.1%. Also in case of export instead of charging 0.20% on the amount
of export, the bank charges a flat rate of Tk.2000 or Tk. 3000 irrespective of the amount of
export. These all greatly reduce the amount of income generated from export and import.
Thus the bank should try to reduce doing this otherwise profit will not increase and might
even fall.
Increasing Export: From the analysis it has been seen that export is highly related to
profit. If export increases profit will increase more than increase in other independent
variables. Prime Bank Ltd should try to increase the volume and amount of export by
Arranging for More Workshops and Seminars: The bank should arrange for more
workshops so that the employees and management are equipped and well informed about
22
the ways they can develop a quality portfolio of assets and liabilities, which will increase
profitability.
Prime Bank Ltd maintains strict confidentiality about providing their information
especially in case of quantitative data; therefore it was quite difficult to obtain all the
necessary data that was required to extensively complete the report and to make the report
more analytical.
Some part of the report is based on the face-to-face interviews, which consists of view
and opinions of those people. As the employees of the bank interviewed were very busy it
was difficult to get time from them to get sufficient information. Moreover some of them
were not able to or were reluctant to provide concrete facts and figures.
The sample size taken was small, only monthly data of 20 months and that only of the
Gulshan Branch were taken. It was not possible to get data of the previous years as the
bank did not keep any previous records. So the necessary analysis had to be made based
The nature of information was somewhat confidential and critical to analyze. It was quite
difficult to have the sufficient knowledge and understanding in that particular field, in a
period of 3 months.
23
CONCLUSION
Through descriptive and empirical analysis, I have failed to reject the hypotheses and in a
nutshell, it can be said that deposits, loans, export and import have an influence on the
profitability of the bank. These are the core determinants of profit especially export and
should be further studied and scrutinized by the management and respective departments
to see how and the extent to which they affect profit. Other factors which affect
profitability of a bank are government and Bangladesh Bank’s policies and rules..
Various recommendations have been suggested which can be used to increase the amount of
profit such as reducing dependency on high cost deposits, making the maximum use of
increasing fees based income and arranging for more workshops and seminars.
possible for Prime Bank Limited to be one of the best local commercial bank in Bangladesh
in terms of efficiency, capital adequacy, asset quality, sound management and profitability
having strong liquidity and to become the number one bank in future..
24