Professional Documents
Culture Documents
J. Mark Lawther
Professor and Deputy
and
W. B. Banks
Professor and Head
School of Agricultural and Forest Sciences
lJniversity of Wales
Bangor, Gwynedd LL57 2UW, UK
(Received May 1997)
ABSTRACT
Delignifi cation of wheat straw with aqueous methanol, ethanol, 1-propanol, n-butanol, dioxane, and
acetone in the presence of acid catalyst (0.02 N H,SO,) at low temperature (75C) for 2 h was studied.
The effect of ethanol-water ratios on the yield of dissolved lignin is also reported here. There was no
significant difference in the organosolv lignin yields among the various organic solvents used, which
accounted for 24-28% of the total amount of acidic chlorite lignin present in wheat straw. Increase
of ethanol-water volume ratio from 40160 to 70130 resulted in raising lignin yields from 25 to 31%,
while the reverse yield from 31 to 24% appeared in the increase of volume ratio from 70130 to 90110.
The isolated organosolv lignin fractions contained low amounts of polysaccharide sugars (4.5-5.3%)
and had low average molecular weights (1 190-1650 Da), which corresponded with the ball-milling
lignin, enzyme lignin, and alkali lignin obtained from wheat straw. The predominant components of
the alkali nitrobenzene oxidation products were found to be vanillin and syringaldehyde. The yield of
vanillin was slightly higher than that of syringaldehyde in all the nitrobenzene oxidation products of
the isolated organosolv lignin preparations.
Keywords: Wheat straw, organosolv lignin, phenolic acids and aldehydes, alkaline nitrobenzene ox-
idation, molecular weight, polysaccharides, Fourier transform infrared spectra.
ing process, a combined sulfide-sulfite, a sul- of lignin side chains, while over 60% ferulic
fide-sulfite process with anthraquinone addi- acids are linked by ether bonds at P- and y-
tion, a neutral sodium- or potassium-based sul- positions of lignin side chains. Until recently,
fite process, alkaline sodium sulfite process, relatively little research effort has been devoted
and sulfur-free delignification process-soda to fundamentals of the acidic organosolv straw
pulping, only about 50% of the initial straw is pulping process. The chemistry of this process
recovered as cellulosic pulp. Dissolved hemi- has so far been incompletely characterized, par-
celluloses, lignin, and their degradation prod- ticularly for lignin obtained from a straw
ucts have not generally been used for indus- organosolv pulping process. The objective of
trial applications except for fuel material, after the work presented in this paper was to isolate
concentration of the black liquor. and characterize the dissolved lignin fractions
Organosolv pulping, in general, can be di- in a variety of organic solvents, including
vided into "uncatalyzed," base-catalyzed, and methanol, ethanol, propanol, butanol, dioxane,
acid-catalyzed processes. In the first category, and acetone, in an effort to increase under-
pulping is actually promoted by acetic acid re- standing of the pulping chemistry. Such infor-
leased from wood or straw. The rate of delig- mation should also be valuable in the use of
nification in alkaline systems was found to be the dissolved lignins in various applications.
governed by the hydrolysis of P-ether bonds
in lignin. Under acidic conditions, a-ether MATERIALS AND METHODS
cleavage occurs to a great extent, and the like-
lihood of 6-ether cleavage is greater in a more The ground and dried wheat straw (10 g)
strongly acidic system (Sarkanen and Hoo was defiberized in a laboratory blender with the
1981). Meanwhile, when part of the original following various organic solvent-water
hemicelluloses is hydrolyzed by acid, acces- mixtures (400 ml): (a) ethanol/water, methanol/
sibility of the cell wall is opened up through water, 1-propanollwater, n-butanollwater, diox-
creation of macropores, subsequently resulting anelwater, and acetonelwater (60140, vlv) in
in increase of delignification during the 0.02 N H,SO, at 75C for 2 h, respectively; (b)
organosolv pulping under acidic conditions. ethanollwater (40160, 50150, 60/40, 70130,
The straw lignins are known to be different 80120, and 90110, vlv) in 0.02 N H,SO, at 75C
from those of softwoods or hardwoods. Straw for 2 h, respectively. The residues, after filtra-
lignins are composed of guaiacyl, syringyl, and tion, were then subsequently washed three
p-hydroxyphenyl monomeric units, while wood times with the corresponding organic solvent-
lignins are composed of only guaiacyl units water (60140, v/v) 200 rnl and finally washed
(softwood), guaiacyl and syringyl units (hard- with 300 ml of distilled water. Washed residues
wood), or guaiacyl and p-hydroxyphenyl units were dried in an oven at 50C for 16 h.
(compression wood). Moreover, straw and After organosolv removal with a rotary vac-
grass cell walls are typified by the presence of uum evaporator at 40C, the lignin in solution
hydroxycinnamic acids, linked to poly- from the black liquor was precipitated by ad-
saccharides and/or lignins. Ferulic acid is dition of 20% HCl to pH 1.5-1.8 and then
known to be esterified with hemicelluloses and filtered. The lignin was washed, air dried, and
etherified with lignin, whereas p-coumaric acid further dried in an oven at 40C for 12 h. The
is known to be extensively esterified with lig- methods for chemical analysis and physico-
nin. Our previous studies showed that wheat chemical characterization of the isolated lignin
straw ball-milled lignin is composed mainly of fractions have been described in previous pa-
P-0-4 ether bonds. The less common 5-5', P-5, pers (Lawther et al. 1995, 1996; Sun et al.
and p-p carbon-carbon linkages are also pres- 1995, 1996). All nitrobenzene oxidation re-
ent. It was found that about 77% of p-coumaric sults represent the mean of at least triplicate
acids are linked by ester bonds at the y-position runs and each oxidation mixture was chro-
58 WOOD AND FIBER SCIENCE, JANUARY 1998, V. 30(1)
TABLE1. Yield (% acidic chlorite wheat straw lignin) o f drogen ion concentration (Lora and Aziz
organosolv lignin in various extraction conditions.
1985). Treatment temperature is an important
Ethanol-water in parameter affecting lignin separation. With the
0.02 N H,S04 at
Organic solvents-water 75C for 2 h at use of 50% vlv aqueous butanol solution and
(60.40. vlv) in 0.02 N HISO, Yield different volume Yield
at 75C for 2 h (%) ratios (%I 0.3% HC1 catalyst at 115"C, lignin separated
from rice straw was nearly 50%, whereas at
170C it was more than 90% (Selvam et al.
1983). However, with the increase in temper-
ature there was an undesirable cellulose deg-
radation. At 170C, cellulose loss was ob-
served to be nearly 9% from rice straw (Sel-
vam et al. 1983). A comparatively low tem-
matographed twice. Other experiments were perature process at 75C chosen in this study
performed in duplicate. The standard errors or was more advantageous in reducing cellulose
deviations were always observed to be lower degradation and formation of lignin resin con-
than 5% except for the variations among trip- densation products, which was confirmed by
licate nitrobenzene oxidation (8-16%). the glucose content (0.749%) in the isolated
organosolv lignin fractions.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Solvent systems often play dominant roles
in the rate of delignification. It was found that
Lignin yield triethyleneglycol-water and dimethylsulfoxide
Lignin yield was calculated by comparing (Orth and Orth 1977) are more effective in
the amount of lignin precipitated with 20% HC1 delignification than the ethanol-water system.
at pH 1.5-1.8 from the black liquor after re- However, the high boiling point of thriethy-
moval of organic solvents with the total amount leneglycol (190C) makes its recovery diffi-
of acidic chlorite lignin present in the wheat cult, and dimethylsulfoxide has been shown to
straw (about 14.1% by weight). Table 1 pre- react with lignin (Sarkanen 1980; Sarkanen
sents yields of organosolv lignins extracted and Hoo 1981). Aqueous solutions of volatile
with different organosolv or ethanol-water in solvents such as acetone and alcohol are easily
various volume ratios. Apparently, using vola- recovered by simple flash evaporation and
tile organic solvents instead or inorganic chem- condensation of the vapors formed for recycle
icals resulted in slow delignification at low use. As shown in Table 1, ethanol, 1-propanol,
temperature. This result was in good agreement and acetone appeared to be more effective sol-
with the study of Vhzquez-Torres et al. (1992). vents for delignification at low temperature
The authors mentioned that when organosolvs than methanol, n-butanol, and dioxane. The
were used in the systems instead of alkaline maximum delignification was obtained by use
solutions, lower yields of lignin were obtained. of ethanol as a solvent mixed with water at
In our previous studies (Lawther et al. 1996), 60140, vlv in 0.02 N H,SO, at 75C for 2 h.
treatment of wheat straw with 0.5 N NaOH at Table 1 also shows that the yield of delig-
75C for 2 h released 52% lignin, which was nification increased from 24.8% to 31.2% as
about twice higher than those obtained from the ethanol concentration was increased from
organosolv systems. No significant difference 40% to 70%. After that, the yield decreased to
in lignin yields was observed among the vari- 24.1% with the raise of ethanol concentration
ous organic solvents used. to 90%. This trend has been reported previ-
The main variables that affect the extent of ously for organosolv pulping at high temper-
delignification and of cellulose degradation of ature from wood samples (Paszner and Cho
organosolv pulps are: extraction temperature; 1989; Goyal et al. 1992). Although anhydrous
extraction time; solvent composition and hy- alcohols were found to be more selective de-
Sun et a1.-ORGANOSOLV LIGNINS FROM WHEAT STRAW 59
TABLE2. UV absorption parameters of wheat straw or- lignin, and the second one at 3 16-3 18 nm cor-
ganosolv lignin fractions extracted with dtfferent organo-
responding to conjugated phenolic groups in
solv-water systems (60/40, v/v) in 0.02 N H z S 0 4 at 75C
for 2 h: wavelength (A, nm) and absorbance coeficient ferulic and p-coumaric acids (Scalbert et al.
(A, L. O.l/g cm) at the absorption maxima. 1986). The absorption coefficient of organo-
solv lignin fractions obtained by ethanol-water
Organosolv-water XI AI hz A2
and n-butanol-water (60140, vlv) in 0.02 N
Methanol-water 274, 1.3 318, 1.2 H,SO, at 75C for 2 h is higher than other
Ethanol-water 274, 1.5 316, 1.3
1-Propanol-water 274, 1.4 318, 1.2
lignin fractions. This is probably due to lower
n-Butanol-water 274, 1.5 318, 1.3 non-lignin content such as polysaccharides,
Dioxane-water 274, 1.4 318, 1.2 protein, and ash in ethanol-water and n-buta-
Acetone-water 274, 1.3 318, 1.2 nol-water extracted lignin fractions.
Content of polysaccharides
lignifying agents than their aqueous counter- As compared with milled-straw lignin and
parts at high temperature, Paszner and Cho enzyme lignin (Scalbert et al. 1986; Scalbert
(1989) indicated that the alcohols had higher and Monties 1986), it is observed that organo-
pulping efficiencies such as better fiber sepa- solv lignins have low polysaccharide content
ration in the presence of water. They also men- (4.5-5.3%, Table 3), suggesting that the bonds
tioned that the rate of delignification and de- anchoring lignin to hemicelluloses in wheat
gree of delignification were controlled by the straw are readily hydrolyzed under acidic con-
hydrolysis of the lignin macrogel and conden- ditions. This is in accordance with the hypoth-
sation of the solvolysis products, respectively.esis that these bonds consist of ether linkages
Evidently, lignin condensation is considerably between the polysaccharide and the a-carbon
retarded at alcohol concentrations greater than atoms of lignin sidechains (McDonough
50%, resulting in a higher rate of delignifica- 1993), and it is interpreted in terms of a struc-
tion, but discouraging hemicellulose dissolu- ture with polysaccharide-ester-ferulic acid-
tion. Goyal et al. (1992) stated that delignifi-ether-lignin bridges (Scalbert et al. 1986),
cation increased with decreasing ethanol con- since such ether bonds are known to be readily
centration over the range studied (50-70% by hydrolyzed during the acidic organosolv pro-
volume). Optimum selectivity in terms of de- cess. Meanwhile, it was found that these ether
lignification and pulp viscosity was obtained bonds were more readily hydrolyzed than the
at 60% ethanol concentration. P-0-4 bonds (Sarkanen 1980). Release of lig-
nin in the organosolv process, therefore, prob-
UV spectra ably results from the hydrolysis of a-aryl ether
The UV absorption spectra (Table 2) show bonds and lignin-hemicellulose bonds. Rela-
two maxima, the first one at 274 nrn originat- tively high content of uronic acids in isolated
ing from nonconjugated phenolic groups in organosolv lignin fractions indicated the ap-
TABLE3. Content (9%dry weight of organosolv lignin) of polysaccharide sugars and uronic acids in organosolv lignin
fractions isolated with different organosolv-water systems (60/40, v/v) in 0.02 N H 2 S 0 4 at 75C for 2 h.
Sugars or uronlc acids Methanol-water Ethanol-water I-Propanol-water n-Butanol-water Dioxane-water Acetone-water
TABLE 4. Content (% lignin sample, w/w) of phenolic monomers obtained by nitrobenzene oxidation of organosolv
lignin fractions extracted with different organosolv-water systems (60/40, v/v) in 0.02 N H2SO4 at 75OC for 2 h from
wheat straw.
Organosolv-water systems
Phenoltc monomers Methanol-water Ethanol-water I-Prooanol-water n-Butanol-water D~oxane-water Acetone-water
Gallic acid
Protocatechuic acid
p-Hydroxybenzoic acid
p-Hydroxybenzaldehyde
Vanillic acid
Syringic acid
Vanillin
Syringaldehyde
p-Coumaric acid
Ferulic acid
Total
pearance of ester bonds between glucuronic degradation of guaiacyl and syringyl noncon-
acid or 4-0-methylglucuronic acid and lignin densed units, respectively. Occurrence of a
units, which was confirmed by I3C-NMR spec- low amount of p-hydroxybenzaldehyde was
trum (Sun et al. 1996). due to the noncondensed p-hydroxyphenyl
unit, indicating incorporation of p-hydroxy-
Composition of phenolic acids and aldehydes cinnamoyl alcohol in wheat straw lignin. the
In an effort to gain insight into the organo- yield of vanillin was slightly higher than that
solv lignins and for comparison purposes, iso- of syringaldehyde from the nitrobenzene oxi-
lated lignins in each of the fractions were also dation products in all the isolated organosolv
investigated by nitrobenzene oxidation. The lignin fractions. These results agreed with
results are summarized in Tables 4 and 5. As those from the study of milled-wheat straw
can be observed, the phenolic compositions of lignin LM and enzyme lignin LE (Scalbert et
each lignin fraction were not significantly dif- al. 1986) as well as our previous study on
ferent. The predominant degradation products, wheat straw alkali-soluble lignin preparation
vanillin and syringaldehyde, resulted from the LA (Sun et al. 1996). The authors mentioned
TABLE5. Content (% lignin sample, w/w) of phenolic monomers obtained by nitrobenzene oxidation of organosolv
lignin fractions extracted with ethanol-water at deferent volume ratios in 0.02 N H2S04 at 75C for 2 h from wheat
straw.
Ethanol-water volume ratlos (vlv)
Phenoltc monomer5 40160 50150 60140 70130 80120 90110
TABLE6. Molecular weight of organosolv lignin fractions extracted with different orgnnosolv-water (60/40, v/v)
systems in 0.02 N H2SO4 at 7jCfor 2 h from wheat straw.
Organosolv-water systems
that the wheat straw lignin preparations LM, ferences in molecular weight were observed
LE, and LA contained roughly equal amounts using various organosolvs at low temperature
of noncondensed guaiacyl and syringyl units (Table 6). Increases in ethanol concentration
with relatively fewer p-hydroxyphenyl units. over 60% (vlv), in general, resulted in increas-
When compared with the corresponding es of molecular weight (Table 7). The results
yield of hardwood or softwood, the lower obtained here agreed with those of Sarkanen
yield of nitrobenzene oxidation products (1980) using wood samples. According to hy-
found in the case of all the organosolv lignin drolyzable linkages in lignins from softwood
fractions indicated that a higher condensation or hardwood samples, Sarkanen (1980) esti-
degree was observed in wheat straw organo- mated that organosolv lignins should have an
solv lignins, and they appeared to be more average DPn of approximately 14, which cor-
condensed than the ball-milled straw lignin responds to a molecular weight range 2500-
LM, enzyme lignin LE and alkali lignin LA 2800. After precipitation and isolation, the sol-
from wheat straw. id organosolv lignins exhibited a relatively
low molecular weight (Mw = 1700-2000),
Molecular weight distribution slightly lower than predicted values. On the
The isolated organosolv lignins were sub- other hand, with the study of organosolv de-
jected to careful determinations of weight- and lignification of black cottonwood in aqueous
number-average molecular weights. The re- methanol at 150-170C using 0.02-0.10 N
sults are given in Tables 6 and 7. The data in H2S04 as catalyst, Tirtowidjojo et al. (1988)
Tables 6 and 7 showed that the organosolv lig- showed that the recovered lignin had consid-
nin fractions isolated from wheat straw under erably higher molecular-average weight (M,)
various conditions appeared to have low ranging from 3300 to 50200. These different
weight average molecular weight ranging be- molecular weights of organosolv lignins were
tween 1190 and 1650. These results agreed probably due to the nature of the sample and
with those of our previous study on ball- the various organosolv pulping conditions
milled wheat straw lignin LM, enzyme lignin used such as the reaction system, reaction tem-
LE, and alkali lignin LA isolated by two steps perature, and time.
of precipitation from wheat straw (Lawther et The molecular weight distribution of orga-
al. 1996; Sun et al. 1996). No significant dif- nosolv lignin extracted with ethanol-water (601
TABLE 7. Molecular weight of organosolv lignin fractions extracted with ethanol-water at different volume ratios in
0.02 N H 2 S 0 4 at 75'C for 2 h ,from wheat straw.
Ethanol-water volume ratios ("1")
40160 50150 60140 70130 80120 YO110
62 WOOD AND FIBER SCIENCE, JANUARY 1998, V. 30(1)
Microns
,2.; 2.: 3.; 3.: 4.; 4.; 5.; 6.: 7.; 8, 1: 1: 2:
,
FT-IR spectra h showed relatively similar FT-IR spectra as
The FT-IR spectra of organosolv lignin frac-
tions are shown in Figs. 2 and 3, and are very ,2,: 2.; 3,; 3.: 4.;
Microns
4,: 5.; 6.: 7.: 8, 1: 17 2;
similar, confirming that the "core" of lignin
structure does not change dramatically during
the various organosolv treatments. An absorp-
tion band at 1722 cm-I confirms the presence
of nonconjugated C=O groups in isolated lig-
nins, while conjugated C=O groups with the
aromatic ring in lignin fractions are assigned at
1650 c m ' . Aromatic skeleton vibrations in lig-
nin are assigned at 1418, 1502, and 1610 cm-'
(Buta et al. 1989). Absorbances for these bands
had similar intensities for the different lignin
fractions, indicating the same aromaticity. The 1000 3500
I ~ ' ' ' I ' ' ' ~ I ' ~ ' ' I ' 1 ' ~ 1
3000 2530 2000 1500 1000 500
4 c J ' I ~
1325, 1260, and 1200 cm-I bands have been Wavenumber (cm-')
assigned to ring breathing with C - 0 stretch.
F I G . 3. FT-IR spectra of organosolv lignin fractions
The 1325 cm-I band has been associated with extracted with ethanol-water at volume ratios of 40160
sinapyl units, and 1260 and 1220 cm-' bands (v/v) (a), 70130 (vlv) (b), and 90110 (vlv) (c) in 0.02 N
with coniferyl units (Ahmad and Khan 1988). H2SO4 at 75OC for 2 h.
Sun et a[.-ORGANOSOLV LIGNINS FROM WHEAT STRAW 63
lignin fractions shown in Fig. 2, obtained by by white rot fungus Stropharia rugosoannulara with
methanol-water, ethanol-water, and dioxane- different oxygen concentrations. J. Agric. Food Chem.
37:1382-1384.
water (60140, vlv) treatments. The very weak GOYAL,G. C., J. H. LORA,AND E. K. PYE. 1992. Auto-
absorbances at 1040 and 890 cm-I indicated catalyzed organosolv pulping of hardwoods: Effect of
the associated polysaccharides, which corre- pulping conditions on pulp properties and characteris-
sponded with the chemical analyses. tics of soluble and residual lignin. Tappi 75:110-116.
LAWTHER, J. M., R:C. SUN,AND W. B. BANKS.1995. EX-
traction, fractionation, and characterization of structural
CONCLUSIONS
polysaccharides from wheat straw. J. Agric. Food
1. Aqueous methanol, ethanol, 1-propanol, Chem. 43(3):667-675.
n-butanol, dioxane, and acetone in a rela- -- , AND - . 1996. Extraction and com-
parative characterization of ball-milled lignin LM, en-
tively high concentration (60140, vlv) and zyme lignin LE, and alkali lignin LA from wheat straw.
low temperature (75C) for 2 h produced Cellulose Chem. Technol. 30:395-410.
low yields of organosolv lignins (24-28%) LORA,J. H., AND S. AZIZ. 1995. Organosolv pulping: A
as compared with alkali lignin extracted versatile approach to wood refining. Tappi 68:94-97.
with 0.5 N NaOH at 75C for 2 h (51.8%). MCDONOUGH, T. J. 1993. The chemistry of organosolv de-
lignification. Tappi 76: 186-193.
It is possible to increase the rate of delig- ORTH,G. O., JR., AND R. D. ORTH.1977. US. Patent 4,
nification by prior dissolution of hemicel- 017, 642 pp.
luloses from wheat straw in two steps. PASZNER, L., AND H. J. CHO. 1989. Organosolv pulping:
2. After distilling off the organosolv from the Acidic catalysis options and their effect on fiber quality
black liquor, the major fraction of the sol- and delignification. Tappi 72: 135-142.
SARKANEN, K. V. 1980. Acid-catalyzed delignification of
ubilized lignins can be obtained as a dry
lignocellulosics in organic solvents. Prog. Biomass
powder and is relatively similar in physical Conv. 2: 127-145.
properties to milled lignin LM, enzyme lig- , AND L. H. HOO. 1981. Kinetics of hydrolysis of
nin LE, and alkali lignin LA. erythro-guaiacylglycerol P-(2-methoxyphenyl) ether
3. Organosolv lignins can be used for funda- and its veratryl analogue using HCl and aluminum chlo-
ride as catalysts. J. Wood Chem. Technol. 1:ll-27.
mental studies which focus on the charac-
SCALBERT, A,, AND B. MONTIES.1986. Composition of
terization of the chemical structure of lig- wheat straw lignin preparations. Holzforschung 40:249-
nins, or as potential chemical feedstocks, 254.
particularly as phenol formaldehyde resin -- , E. GUITTET,AND J. Y. LALLEMAND. 1986.
extenders or the synthesis of polymers, Comparison of wheat straw lignin preparations I. Chem-
such as polyarnides. ical and spectroscopic characterizations. Holzforschung
40~119-129.
SELVAM, I? V. P., T. K. GHOSE,AND F? GHOSH.1983. Cat-
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS alytic solvent delignification of agricultural residues: In-
The authors thank Dr. James Bolton, Direc- organic catalysts. Proc. Biochem. 13:13-15.
SUN,R.-C., J. M. LAWTHER, AND W. B. BANKS. 1995. In-
tor of the BioComposites Centre, for the award
fluence of alkaline pre-treatments on the cell wall com-
of a senior research fellowship to R.-C. Sun, ponents of wheat straw. Indust. Crops Prod. 4:127-145.
and the financial support for the research from --, AND -. 1996. Effects of pre-treat-
LINK Collaborative Programme in Crops for ment time and different alkalis on the composition of
Industrial Use under Agreement CSA 2054. alkali-soluble wheat straw lignin. J. Agric. Food Chem.
44:3965-3970.
TIRTOW~DJOJO, S., K. V. SARKANEN, E PLA,AND J. L. Mc-
REFERENCES
CARTHY. 1988. Kinetics of organosolv delignification in
AHMAD, M., AND L. KHAN.1988. Spectroscopic studies of batch- and flow-through reaction. Holzforschung 42:
lignins from wheat straw and kai grass. J. Chem. Soc. 177-183.
Pak. 10:299-302. VAZQUEZ-TORRES, H., G., CANCHG-ESCAMILLA. AND C. A.
BUTA,J. G., E ZADRAZIL, AND G. C. GALLETTI. 1989. FT- CRUZ-Was. 1992. Coconut husk lignin. 1. Extraction
IR determination of lignin degradation in wheat straw and characterization. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 45:633-644.