You are on page 1of 7

367-373 Women's Issues.

qxd 2/12/09 11:22 PM Page 367

Womens Issues

BACKGROUND
Throughout history, with rare exceptions, earnings for women employed in full-time work
women have been relegated to second-class sta- were $530 in 2002, or 78 percent of the $680
tus, their lives controlled, regulated, and lim- median for their male counterparts (U.S. De-
ited. In the United States, women were denied partment of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics,
the right to vote, attend school, own property, 2003). Also, earnings differed according to race.
keep their wages, or obtain custody of their For instance, the median weekly earnings for
children. Although gains have been realized, white women were $549 compared with $702
largely because of the first and second waves of for white men; $474 for black women compared
the womens movement, much remains to be with $523 for black men, and $396 for Latinas
done. There is a measure of water in the glass, compared with $449 for Latinos (U.S. Depart-
although some might view it as half empty and ment of Labor, Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2003).
others as half full. Documentation of the cur-
Household income varied dramatically by
rent status of women and girls through numer-
type of family. For instance, in 2001 among
ical evidence builds a case for the social work
married heterosexual-couple families only
profession to continue to monitor womens
2 percent had an income below $10,000 com-
issues and progress (or lack thereof ), with a
pared with 17 percent for female-headed house-
special focus on unique populations of women
holds with no spouse present, and 8 percent for
who are disparately affected by discrimination
male-headed households with no spouse pre-
as a result of the intersecting oppressions of
sent (U.S. Census Bureau, 2003).
race or ethnicity, sexual orientation and gender
identity, citizenship status, disability, socioeco- Women are more likely to live in poverty
nomic status, or religious affiliation. The fol- than men. For ages 18 to 64, the poverty rate
lowing statistics indicate the continued dispar- for women was 11.6 percent compared with
ity between men and women: 8.5 percent for men (U.S. Census Bureau, 2003).
The differences in rates are more pronounced
In 2002 there were 144 million females in
for older women. For those 65 years and older,
the United States, 51 percent of the population
(U.S. Census Bureau, 2003). the poverty rate for women was 12.4 percent
compared with 7.0 percent for men. Poverty,
In 2002, 60 percent of women were in the like income, varied by household type. Of fam-
labor force compared with 74 percent of men ilies living in poverty in 2001, 50.9 percent were
(U.S. Census Bureau, 2003). The majority of female-headed households with no spouse
women were in occupations traditionally iden- present, 40.5 percent were married-couple fam-
tified as female. For instance, women held ilies, and 8.5 percent were male-headed house-
79 percent of administrative support positions, holds with no spouse present (U.S. Census
whereas men held 91 percent of the jobs in pre- Bureau, 2003). Poverty also varies by race. In
cision production, craft, and repair occupations 2002, 24.0 percent of African Americans lived
(U.S. Census Bureau, 2003). in poverty compared with 21.8 percent of His-
There continued to be a gender gap in earn- panics, 10.2 percent of Asian Americans, and
ings between men and women. Median weekly 8.0 percent of European Americans.

367
367-373 Women's Issues.qxd 2/12/09 11:22 PM Page 368

Women are still not represented in govern- nonfatal violent victimizations committed by
ment in proportion to their representation in intimate partners, 85 percent of the incidents
the population. As noted, women are 51 per- were committed against women (Rennison,
cent of the population, but make up only 14.3 2003). In 2000, 1,247 women were killed by an
percent of the presidents cabinet, 14 percent of intimate partner in the United States. Between
the U.S. Senate, 13.6 percent of the U.S. House 1992 and 2000, on average for each year, 131,950
of Representatives, 22 percent of the U.S. females were the victims of completed rapes,
Supreme Court, 20.6 percent of federal judges, 98,970 females were the victims of attempted
16.0 percent of state governors, 20.8 percent of rapes, and 135,550 females were the victims of
state senators, 23.0 percent of state representa- completed and attempted sexual assault (Ren-
tives, 9.0 percent of state judges, and 20.8 per- nison, 2002). Female victims accounted for
cent of big-city mayors (GenderGap, 2004). 94 percent of all completed rapes, 91 percent of
attempted rapes, and 89 percent of all com-
The status of women in the area of educa- pleted and attempted sexual assaults.
tional attainment shows substantial progress
over the years. In 1978, for the first time, more Women face unique health risks, and
women were enrolled in undergraduate edu- womens health issues have received increased
cation in both two- and four-year degree-grant- attention in the past decades. Heart disease
ing institutions than men. That trend continues kills more women than men each year, al-
today with womens undergraduate enroll- though on average women develop the disease
ment increasing at a faster pace than mens 10 years later than men (Society for Womens
(National Center for Education Statistics, 2004). Health Research [SWHR], 2004). Women are
Since 1976, female enrollment in graduate pro- two to three times more likely than men to suf-
grams has increased by 73 percent, while male fer from depression. Female smokers are more
enrollment has increased by only 9 percent. likely to develop lung cancer than male smok-
High school completion rates for men and ers, at the same level of exposure (SWHR). In
women over age 24 were both 84 percent; men fact, lung cancer kills more women than breast
were more likely to have a bachelors degree or cancer. Women are two times more likely than
more and women were more likely than men men to contract a sexually transmitted disease,
to have some college or have completed an and 10 times more likely to contract HIV dur-
associates degree (U.S. Census Bureau, 2003). ing unprotected sex with an infected partner
(SWHR). Women are 18 percent of the cumula-
Although more low-income single parents tive AIDS cases in the United States with the
are working after the institution of welfare most common exposure due to heterosexual
reform, more than three-fourths of those sex, followed by injection drug use (Centers for
workers are concentrated in typically low-wage Disease Control and Prevention [CDC], Divi-
occupations (Institute for Womens Policy sion of HIV/AIDS Prevention, 2003). An esti-
Research [IWPR], 2003b). Low-income single- mated 14 percent of the population was with-
mother families experienced a decrease in their out health insurance in 2000, which included
incomes following welfare reform (from $664 to more than 18 million girls and women (U.S.
$647 per month) and a decrease in participation Census Bureau, 2001).
in Temporary Assistance for Needy Families
(TANF) (from 27.8 percent to 14.6 percent). As a Almost half (49 percent) of all pregnancies
among U.S. women are unintended, and almost
result, these families slid deeper into poverty.
half of these end in abortion (Alan Guttmacher
Violence against women remains a continu- Institute, 2002). In 2000, 1.31 million abortions
ing problem that affects all women, regardless took place, with the rate of abortions slowly
of race, sexual identity, socioeconomic status, or decreasing each year since a record high in
any other identifying characteristic. One study 1980. At the state and federal levels there are
found that almost 3 percent of college women concerted efforts to regulate and restrict legal
experienced a completed or attempted rape abortion, including no federal funding of abor-
(Fisher, Cullen, & Turner, 2000). Of the 691,710 tion unless the mothers life is in danger; the

368 SOCIAL WORK SPEAKS


367-373 Women's Issues.qxd 2/12/09 11:22 PM Page 369

reinstatement of the global gag rule, which U.S. women, especially our clients and others
bans federal aid to family planning clinics at great risk.
overseas that counsel on or provide abortions; The social work professions continued lead-
expanding definitions of children and people ership in the struggle for womens increased
that include fetal life; and numerous state reg- opportunities is essential. Although social work
ulations such as mandated waiting periods, is often mischaracterized as a female-domi-
restriction of minors access, and restriction of nated profession, the profession is more ap-
the inclusion of abortion and family planning propriately described as a female majority,
coverage in insurance plans (IWPR, 2003a). male-dominated profession (McPhail, 2004).
Many women consider the right to control Although the majority of both social workers
their bodies as fundamental to their rights as and social work clients are female, the under-
free citizens in a democratic nation. The issue lying structures and functions of the profession
is also about health and safety, as risks to are often based on male models and theories.
women are significantly reduced when abor- Therefore, achieving gender equity is para-
tion remains legal and accessible (IWPR, mount for both the profession and the clients
2003a). This highlights the necessity to view served. The social work profession commits
womens rights as human rights (Jansen, 2000). itself to social justice and ending the oppres-
sion of all people (NASW, 2000). This statement
of belief exemplifies the perspective of womens
ISSUE STATEMENT rights as human rights (Jansen, 2000). In addi-
tion, the National Association of Social Work-
Women make up a majority of the U.S. pop-
ers Code of Ethics incorporates an antidiscrimi-
ulation and clients that social workers serve.
nation clause, which includes the category of
Attention to womens issues is essential because
sex (NASW, 2000). Also, the Code states, So-
of the disadvantages and discrimination women
cial workers should act to expand choice and
continue to face in many aspects of their lives.
opportunity for all people, with special regard
Women perform the majority of the worlds
for vulnerable, disadvantaged, oppressed, and
work but control a disproportionately small exploited people and groups (NASW, 2000,
share of its resources. Although women in the 6.04b). In the history of our nation, women as a
more prosperous Western nations often fare group are characterized by those adjectives,
better in life circumstances than women in essentially second-class citizens in a country
many of the less wealthy nations of the world, that holds out the promise of equality and jus-
economic, political, social, and cultural forces tice. Part of operationalizing this mandate is
in most societies operate to the disadvantage continuing to monitor and document the sta-
of women and girls. These disadvantages affect tus of women while seeking to make and influ-
education; health care, including reproductive ence policy and practices that improve the
and mental health; crime, especially as victims status of women and girls in this society.
of violence; employment; and social welfare, Because different groups of women experi-
especially income maintenance programs. These ence their gender differently and often in inter-
disadvantages affect the well-being of women action with other oppressions, termed intersec-
and their families at all stages of the life cycle, tionality (Collins, 2000), special attention must
from girlhood through old age. be devoted to women of color, lesbians, women
The social work profession has a long-stand- with disabilities, older women, immigrant
ing commitment to the elimination of all forms women, and poor women.
of discrimination against women. Many efforts Although women are gaining parity with
have been made to address the disadvantages men in selected areas, often achieving liberal
and discrimination women face. However, feminist goals, the goal of changing structures
continuing efforts to develop social work prac- and institutions to make them more equitable
tices, policies, and services that better meet the for both women and men, rather than merely
needs of women are essential for enhancing having women join fundamentally flawed
the health, development, and well-being of all institutions in equal numbers as men, has not

WOMENS ISSUES 369


367-373 Women's Issues.qxd 2/12/09 11:22 PM Page 370

been realized (Saulnier, 1996). Although women ing work-related social insurance programs to
have gained some measure of equity in the pub- all workers (including unwaged caregivers),
lic spheres, the private spheres remain largely universal preschool for all three- and four-year-
unchanged. Therefore, social work needs to olds, subsidized child care, child allowances,
continue to monitor, assess, and advocate for free health care coverage to all children and
womens issues in policy and practice. their primary caregivers, and including unpaid
caregiving labor into the calculations of the
nations gross domestic product (Crittenden,
POLICY STATEMENT 2001).
NASW recognizes the wide range of issues
that affect women and is committed to advanc-
ing policies and practices to improve the status PUBLIC ASSISTANCE
and well-being of all women. Although every PROGRAMS
issue is a womans issue, only a select num-
NASW supports the following:
ber of policies and practices are highlighted in
this document. More important than a focus on comprehensive funding of TANF that would
specific issues, it is vital for social workers to address structural causes of poverty as well as
develop a critical consciousness about gender provide temporary assistance, which would
(Brown, 2004) or use a feminist policy analysis include creating stable jobs with living wages,
(McPhail, 2003) that enables the ramifications with special attention to the inner cities; allow-
of gender to be made visible in every issue, in ing education (including college) and training
every policy and every practice, at all three as alternatives to work requirements; subsi-
levelsmicro, meso, and macro. dized child care and health insurance coverage
while on TANF and continuing after leaving
the program; transportation assistance; and
EMPLOYMENT addressing the multiple problems that often
NASW supports the following: affect women and their children who receive
assistance, such as mental and physical health
legislative and administrative strategies issues, learning disabilities, domestic violence,
that address pay equity and comparable worth and drug and alcohol abuse (Anderson, Halter,
initiatives for increasing womens wages in & Gryzlak, 2004; Taylor & Barush, 2004)
both the public and private sectors, including
addressing the pay inequities within the pro- programs for the enforcement, collection,
fession of social work (Koeske & Krowinski, and distribution of child support
2004) initiatives for social security and Medicare
breaking the glass ceiling, the Lucite reform to provide increased retirement secu-
ceiling for women of color, and the maternal rity for women who are disproportionately
wall that affects mothers in the paid labor poor as they age
force, while addressing the glass escalator viewing housing as a womens issue and
phenomenon for men in social work (Williams, increasing funding to programs that provide
1995) affordable housing.
ending sexual harassment and occupational
segregation, which clusters women in low-
paying, pink-collar occupations Education
NASW supports the following:
initiatives that conceptualize caring as work,
to value it socially, legally, and economically, adequate and equitable funding for non-
which might include reducing the paid work sexist public education for all students, includ-
week, creating more part-time jobs with bene- ing vocational education, special education,
fits, equalizing social security for spouses, offer- and higher education for all women

370 SOCIAL WORK SPEAKS


367-373 Women's Issues.qxd 2/12/09 11:22 PM Page 371

curricula that include womens issues, his- vices; education and screening for a variety of
tory, and experiences, including social work sexually transmitted diseases, including HIV,
education, especially theories developed by with special attention to groups of women at
and about women such as the relational-cul- increased risk, such as African American women
tural theory or the tend-and-befriend model
gender-sensitive and culturally competent
of stress response (Jordan & Hartling, 2002;
Taylor et al., 2000) substance abuse programs that provide child
care and other child services along with inte-
vigorous enforcement of Title IX and other grated substance abuse and mental health ser-
civil rights laws, including affirmative action vices for dually diagnosed women (DiNitto &
initiatives that address sexual discrimination Crisp, 2002).
in education.
participation in both prevention and inter-
vention efforts that address all forms of vio-
Health and Mental Health lence against women across the life span, in-
NASW supports the following: cluding adequate health and mental health
services, crime victim assistance, and other
initiatives to reduce teenage pregnancy, as social services while educating all social work-
it has been demonstrated that, intended or ers about violence, including screening for past
unintended, adolescent motherhood truncates and current violence in all psychosocial assess-
the educational, vocational, and economic lives ments (Danis & Lockhart, 2004)
of young women
efforts to seek out, study, develop, and dis-
adequate funding and increased research seminate theories of psychosocial development
on health and mental health services and issues and models of services delivery in the social
that address the special needs of women, in- work curriculum that recognize, and do not
cluding adolescent women, poor women, women pathologize, the unique developmental pat-
of color, lesbians, older women, and women terns of women, recognizing the diversity of
with disabilities womens experiences, situations, cultural and
access to adequate health and mental health ethnic identifications, and sexual orientation
services regardless of financial status, race and and gender identities, including critiques of
ethnicity, age, or employment status, which the gender bias in the Diagnostic and Statistical
would require universal health care coverage, Manual of Mental Disorders (Caplan, 1995).
although incremental expansions of coverage
for low-income women and their children are a
first step Global Womens Issues
developing practices and programs that NASW supports the following:
empower women and girls, enabling them to ratification by the United States of the Con-
resist gender stereotypes; become resilient to vention to Eliminate All Forms of Discrimina-
shame; critique sexist and misogynist media tion against Women (CEAFDW)
representations of females; develop positive
self-esteem and body image; confront internal international programs that address womens
and external sexism, racism, and homophobia; rights as human rights, including having
and challenge sexual double standards, so girls women in each country involved in defining
and women might develop the power and their needs, identifying their oppressions, and
sense of entitlement that fuels self-advocacy developing programs that meet their needs
reproductive freedom and safe access to the increased attention by social work educa-
full range of reproductive health services for tion to problems facing women internationally,
all women, including access to abortion; over- often due to the effects of globalization and col-
the-counter emergency contraception; compre- onization, as well as traditional patriarchal
hensive sexual education; family planning ser- structures.

WOMENS ISSUES 371


367-373 Women's Issues.qxd 2/12/09 11:22 PM Page 372

REFERENCES Declaration from the UN sponsored Human


Rights Conference in Vienna, 1993.)
Alan Guttmacher Institute. (2002). Induced abor-
Jordan, J. V., & Hartling, L. M. (2002). New
tion: Facts in brief. New York: Author.
developments in relational-cultural theory.
Anderson, S. G., Halter, A. P., & Gryzlak, B. M.
In M. Ballou & L. S. Brown (Eds.), Rethink-
(2004). Difficulties after leaving TANF: Inner-
ing mental health & disorder: Feminist per-
city women talk about reasons for returning
spectives (pp. 4870). New York: Guilford
to welfare. Social Work, 49, 185194. Press.
Brown, B. (2004). Women & shame: Reaching out, Koeske, G. F., & Krowinski, W. J. (2004). Gen-
speaking truths, & building connection. Austin, der-based salary inequity in social work.
TX: 3C Press. Social Work, 49, 309317.
Caplan, P. J. (1995). They say youre crazy: How the McPhail, B. A. (2003). Feminist policy analysis
worlds most powerful psychiatrists decide whos framework: Through a gendered lens.
normal. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley. Social Policy Journal, 2(2/3), 3961.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, McPhail, B. A. (2004). Setting the record straight:
Division of HIV/AIDS Prevention. (2003). Social work is not a female-dominated pro-
HIV/AIDS Surveillance report. Atlanta: Author. fession [Commentary]. Social Work, 49, 323
Collins, P. H. (2000). Black feminist thought (2nd 326.
ed.). New York: Routledge. National Association of Social Workers. (2000).
Crittenden, A. (2001). The price of motherhood. Code of ethics of the National Association of
New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston. Social Workers. Washington, DC: Author.
Danis, F. S., & Lockhart, L. L. (Eds.). (2004). National Center for Education Statistics. (2004).
Breaking the silence in social work education: The condition of education 2003 (NCES 2003-
Domestic violence modules for foundation 067). Washington, DC: U.S. Department of
courses. Alexandria, VA: Council on Social Education, Institute of Education Sciences.
Work Education. National Council for Research on Women.
DiNitto, D. M., & Crisp, C. (2002). Addictions (2004). Missing: Information about womens
and women with major psychiatric dis- lives. Washington, DC: Author.
orders. In S.L.A. Straussner & S. Brown National Womens Law Center. (2004). Slip slid-
(Eds.), The handbook of addiction treatment for ing away: The erosion of hard-won gains for
women (pp. 423450). San Francisco: Jossey- women under the Bush administration and an
Bass. agenda for moving forward. Washington, DC:
Fisher, B. S., Cullen, F. T., & Turner, M. G. Author.
(2000). Sexual victimization of college women Rennison, C. M. (2002). Rape and sexual assault
(NCJ 182369). Washington, DC: U.S. Depart- [Crime Data Brief] (Publication No. NCJ
ment of Justice, National Criminal Justice 194530). Washington, DC: U.S. Department
Reference Service. of Justice, Office of Justice Programs.
GenderGap. (2004). Gender gap in government. Rennison, C. M. (2003). Intimate partner violence,
Retrieved May 13, 2004, from http://gen- 19932001 [Crime Data Brief.] (Publication
dergap.com/goverme.htm No. NCJ 197838). Washington, DC: U.S.
Institute for Womens Policy Research. (2003a). Department of Justice, Office of Justice Pro-
Policy update on safe and legal abortion 30 years grams, Bureau of Justice Statistics.
after Roe v. Wade (No. B241). Washington, Saulnier, C. F. (1996). Feminist theories and social
DC: Author. work. New York: Haworth Press.
Institute for Womens Policy Research. (2003b). Society for Womens Health Research. (2004).
Before and after welfare reform. Washington, Women and men: 10 differences that make a dif-
DC: Author. ference. Retrieved from http://www.wom-
Jansen, G. G. (2000, Feb.). Womens rights are ens-health.org/sbb/10diff.htm
human rights: Violence against women rede- Taylor, M. J., & Barusch, A. S. (2004). Personal,
fined. Paper presented at CSWE 46th APM, family, and multiple barriers of long-term
New York. (The phrase is part of the Vienna welfare recipients. Social Work, 49, 175183.

372 SOCIAL WORK SPEAKS


367-373 Women's Issues.qxd 2/12/09 11:22 PM Page 373

Taylor, S. E., Klein, L. C., Lewis, B. P., Grue- U.S. Census Bureau. (2003). Women and men in
newald, T. L., Gurung, R.A.R., & Upde- the United States: March 2002. Washington,
graff, J. A. (2000). Biobehavorial responses DC: U.S. Department of Commerce, Eco-
to stress in females: Tend-and-befriend, not nomics and Statistics Administration.
fight-or-flight. Psychological Review, 107, U.S. Department of Labor, Bureau of Labor Sta-
411429. tistics. (2003). Highlights of womens earnings
U.S. Census Bureau. (2001). Health insurance in 2002. Washington, DC: Author.
coverage: 2000. Washington, DC: U.S. De- Williams, C. L. (1995). Still a mans world: Men
partment of Commerce, Economics and who do womens work. Berkeley: University
Statistics Administration. of California Press.

Policy statement approved by the NASW Delegate Assembly, August 2005. This policy supersedes the policy statement on Womens
Issues approved by the Delegate Assembly in 1996, in 1987, in 1977, and referred by the 2002 Delegate Assembly to the 2005 Del-
egate Assembly for revision. For further information, contact the National Association of Social Workers, 750 First Street, NE, Suite
700, Washington, DC 20002-4241. Telephone: 202-408-8600 or 800-638-8799; e-mail: press@naswdc.org

WOMENS ISSUES 373

You might also like