Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Operation
L Lu1, R J Holmes2, J R Manuel3, A Edenton4, M Adam4, R Smyth4 and S Hapugoda5
et al, 1976; Shimomura et al, 1976). The conditions the burden Unlike sinter, which is always produced on site, lump ore often
material is subjected to, such as temperature, gas composition has a higher tumble index, which is needed to resist mechanical
and compressive load, vary widely both vertically and radially. degradation during transportation. The resistance of lump ore to
Different quality requirements therefore need to be imposed on mechanical degradation is believed to be mainly influenced by
the burden material, such as lump ore, in different zones of the the mineralogy and texture of the ore involved. After measuring
furnace. Table 1 summarises the key reactions occurring in the the toughness of three lump ores using a combination of macro-
lumpy and cohesive zones of the furnace and the corresponding and microfracture tests, Dukino et al (1995) concluded that
operational requirements for these two zones, which largely tough lump ores with strong grain boundaries are resistant to
determine the quality requirements for the burden material. degradation, and therefore generate a low proportion of fines.
Below the cohesive zone, the lump ore loses its identity due to Two mechanisms may be responsible for the mechanical
the softening and melting process resulting from heating and degradation of individual lump particles in the blast furnace, ie
reduction, and therefore will not have significant impact on the impact and abrasion. If an individual lump particle is incapable
processes occurring in the zones below the cohesive zone, of accommodating the energy due to impact during charging as
although the gangue minerals from the lump ore will partition to well as the abrasion between particles and between the particles
the slag phase and are expected to change the slag chemistry and the furnace wall, this individual particle is likely to break
slightly. down to generate fines. These fines fill the voids in the packed
First of all, lump ore needs to be strong enough to resist any burden material and reduce the permeability in the furnace shaft.
significant size degradation during the charging operation. Then,
the resistance to decrepitation and disintegration due to release of Decrepitation index (DI)
combined moisture (LOI), thermal shock and reduction in the
upper part of the lumpy zone, and the reducibility of lump ore in As the cold burden lands on the top of the hot burden in the
the lower part of the lumpy zone become important furnace and descends, it is subject to thermal shock, which may
characteristics for stable blast furnace operation. Finally, in the also cause breakdown of the lump particles. To assess this
cohesive zone of the furnace the softening and melting character- behaviour of lump ore, the ISO decrepitation index (DI) is usually
istics of lump ore become important. measured in accordance with ISO 8371. The decrepitation index
quantifies the resistance of lump ore to thermal degradation.
PHYSICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF LUMP ORE The presence of hydrated and carbonate minerals as well as
combined moisture are closely linked to the decrepitation of lump
Standard physical characteristics ore (Tenuta de Azevedo and Cardoso, 1983; Da Silva and Muniz,
2008). It is therefore not surprising that thermally processed ores,
such as fired sinter and pellets, do not decrepitate. Previous
Tumble and abrasion indices (TI and AI) experience has also suggested that ore texture has an important
Ore degradation in transit can significantly reduce the amount of impact on the degree of decrepitation. As shown in Figure 2,
lump ore available for charging into the blast furnace and can porous ore does not decrepitate as much as dense ore even though
have an adverse impact on blast furnace operation if degradation it has a higher LOI content. A high decrepitation index results in
occurs during the charging operation. To assess the resistance to more iron loss through dust generation and has a negative impact
degradation of lump ore during charging, handling and on blast furnace permeability.
transportation, the tumble (TI) and abrasion (AI) indices are
often determined in accordance with ISO 3271. While both Low temperature reduction disintegration index
indices are measured in the tumble test, usually only the tumble (RDI)
index is reported in the literature. Basically the tumble index
demonstrates the resistance of lump ore to mechanical As the burden material descends further in the furnace shaft,
degradation, while the abrasion index gives an indication of the reduction of haematite (Fe2O3) to magnetite (Fe3O4) commences
degree of fines generation. with the increase in temperature and decrease in oxygen
TABLE 1
Key reactions, operational and quality requirements of the blast furnace lumpy and cohesive zones.
A B
FIG 3 - Reflected optical micrographs showing mineralogical characteristics of two different lump samples (-2 +1 mm fraction of crushed
lump samples): (A) sample A and (B) sample B; H haematite, M martite, G goethite, HY hydrohaematite, S shale, Q quartz.
Non-standard physical characteristics (softening Figure 5 shows the softening and melting curves measured for
and melting characteristics) an Australian lump iron ore sample under typical SAM testing
conditions by CSIRO. The softening, melting and dripping
The softening and melting (SAM) test is aimed at simulating the temperatures, as well as the cohesive zone temperature range, are
physical and chemical changes occurring in a small volume of defined below and illustrated in Figure 5:
sample as it descends in a blast furnace, particularly in the
cohesive zone. During the test, the sample is sandwiched Softening temperature (C), TS the sample temperature at
between two layers of graphite or coke particles and subjected to 50 per cent bed compaction. Above this temperature, the
a programmed time-dependent variation of temperature, gas pressure drop across the bed starts to increase rapidly. This
composition and loading conditions. The physical and chemical temperature usually coincides with the temperature at which
changes occurring in the sample during the test are monitored direct reduction starts and is defined here as the start of the
continuously by measuring and recording the changes in bed cohesive zone.
height, pressure drop across the sample bed and sample and melt Melting temperature ( C), Tm the temperature at which the
collector temperatures. As different blast furnaces operate under pressure drop across the sample bed returns to that at TS or
distinct working conditions, and given the complexity of this test, 1550C, whichever is lower. This indicates the end of
there is no standard procedure for the softening and melting test. meltdown and compaction of the bed.
A fully computerised testing facility has been developed at Cohesive zone temperature range (C), T the temperature
CSIRO to characterise the softening and melting characteristics interval between the softening and melting temperatures. It is
of ferrous burden material under realistic conditions similar to important to ensure the temperature difference between
those encountered in the blast furnace. Figure 4 presents a softening and melting of the burden is not too great. A thick
schematic diagram of the CSIRO softening and melting test cohesive zone will result in poor permeability in the furnace
facility. It consists of an induction furnace, a gas distribution burden.
system, a loading system and a data acquisition system. The
induction furnace is capable of heating the test sample at Dripping temperature (C), Td the temperature at which the
required heating rates up to the temperature of 1550C. The gas first drop of molten material is recorded. This is detected by
distribution system enables simulation of the compositions of a thermocouple positioned in the melt collector.
gaseous mixtures of N2, CO, CO2 and H2 that are typically found S value (kPa C), the area under the pressure drop curve,
in blast furnaces. The loading system applies a fixed or variable above the pressure drop at TS and bordered by the softening
load to the surface of the sample bed via an air cylinder and and melting temperatures. This is often referred to as the S
monitors the compaction of the sample bed. The data acquisition value in Japan. The S value indicates the pressure accumulated
system is used to preset the initial values and ramping rates of in the cohesive zone. As shown in the insert in Figure 5, the S
the sample load and gas flow rates, and records the changes in value is calculated using the following equation:
bed height and pressure drop across the sample bed, as well as
Tm
sample and melt collector temperatures for analysis. Table 2
summarises the typical testing conditions used in the CSIRO S = (P P )dT
Ts
SAM test. Ts
FIG 4 - Schematic diagram of the softening and melting testing facility at CSIRO.
where:
P and PT s are the pressure drops across the sample bed at any
instantaneous temperature and at TS, respectively
While many factors, such as composition, pore structure and
mineralogy, can affect the softening and melting characteristics
of the burden material, it is thought that the reducibility of the
material determines the amount of FeO in the sample during high
temperature reduction and therefore the softening characteristics FIG 6 - Phase stability fields of iron and various iron oxides, blast
of the material. On the other hand, the liquidus temperature and furnace working conditions and the conditions of different standard
the amount of slag formed from the burden material determine ISO physical tests: (1) ISO 4696-2, (2) ISO 7215, (3) ISO 4695,
the dripping temperature of the material (Lu et al, 2009). and (4) ISO 7992 (Ricketts, 2000).
400 10
10
Pr essure Dr op , kpa
S Value
9
350 8
Pressure drop
6 8
300
Bed compaction (x10,%) and
4
Dripping Temp ( C)
TS Tm 7
o
2
Pressure Drop (kPa)
250 0 6
1050 1100 1150 1200 1250 1300 1350
o
Sample Temp, C
200 5
4
150
Bed compaction 3
TS
100
2
Dripping Temp
50
1
Td Tm
0 0
400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400
o
Sample Temp, C
FIG 5 - Softening and melting curves measured for an Australian lump iron ore under typical CSIRO softening and
melting testing conditions. T = Tm Ts .
FIG 7 - Effect of burden tumble index and reduction disintegration index on blast furnace permeability (V/P) (Ranade, 2000).
reducibility as well as the softening and melting properties of ISO 7992, 2007. Iron ores for blast furnace feedstocks Determination of
lump ore, the physical characteristics play an important role to reduction under load (ISO: Geneva).
stable blast furnace operation. ISO 8371, 2007. Iron ores for blast furnace feedstocks Determination of
the decrepitation index (ISO: Geneva).
The conditions used for standard physical tests are compared
with the working conditions of typical modern blast furnaces. Kanbara, K, Hagiwara, T, Shigemi, A, Kondo, S-I, Kanayama, Y,
Wakabayashi, K-I and Hiramoto, N, 1976. Dissection of blast
This is important when interpreting the data from standard furnaces and their inside state 1, report on the dissection of blast
physical tests. furnaces, Tetsu-To-Hagane/Journal of the Iron and Steel Institute of
Japan, 62:535-546.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Kojima, K, Nisi, T, Yamaguchi, T, Nakama, H and Ida, S, 1976. Change
of coke properties in the blast furnace 4, report on the dissection of
The authors would like to thank CSIRO for its financial support blast furnaces, Tetsu-To-Hagane/Journal of the Iron and Steel
and permission to publish this work. Institute of Japan, 62:570-579.
Loo, C E and Bristow, N J, 1998a. Properties of iron bearing materials
under simulated blast furnace indirect reduction conditions, I, review
REFERENCES and experimental procedure, Ironmaking and Steelmaking,
Chaigneau, R, Bakker, T, Steeghs, A and Bergstrand, R, 2001. Quality 25:222-232.
assessment of ferrous burdens: utopian dream, in Proceedings 60th Loo, C E and Bristow, N J, 1998b. Properties of iron bearing materials
Ironmaking Conference, pp 689-703 (Association for Iron and Steel under simulated blast furnace indirect reduction conditions, II
Technology: Warrendale). Reduction degradation, Ironmaking and Steelmaking, 25:287-295.
Da Silva, E M and Muniz, G L F, 2008. Pre drying of Rio Tinto Lu, L, Holmes, R J and Manuel, J R, 2007. Effects of alumina on
Corumbas lump iron ore for direct reduction, in Proceedings Third sintering performance of hematite iron ores, Transactions of the Iron
International Meeting on Ironmaking and Second International and Steel Institute of Japan (ISIJ) International, 47:349-358.
Symposium on Iron Ore, Sao Luis, pp 416-427 (ABM Brazil). Lu, L, Holmes, R J, Manuel, J R, Edenton, A, Hapugoda, S, Adam, M
Dawson, P R, 1987. Determination of the high temperature properties of and Smyth, R, 2009. CSIRO softening and melting facility and high
blast furnace burden materials, SEAISI Quarterly, pp 23-42. temperature characteristics of blast furnace ferrous burdens, in
Dawson, P R, 1993. Recent developments in iron ore sintering, Proceedings Asia Steel 2009, Busan, South Korea.
Ironmaking and Steelmaking, 20:135-159. Ranade, M G, 2000. Iron-bearing Burden Materials, Blast Furnace
Dukino, R D, Swain, M V, Loo, C E, Bristow, N and England, B M, Ironmaking (McMaster University: Ontario).
1995. Fracture behaviour of three Australian iron ores, Transactions Ricketts, J A, 2000. Historical development and principles of the iron
of the Institutions of Mining and Metallurgy, Mineral Processing and blast furnace, Blast Furnace Ironmaking (McMaster University:
Extractive Metallurgy, 104:C11-C19. Ontario).
Higuchi, K, Naito, M, Nakano, M and Takamoto, Y, 2004. Optimization Sasaki, M, Ono, K, Suzuki, A, Okuno, Y, Yoshizawa, K-I and Nakamura,
of chemical composition and microstructure of iron ore sinter for T, 1976. Formation and melt-down of softening-melting zone in blast
low temperature drip of molten iron with high permeability, furnace furnaces 3, report on the dissection of blast furnaces,
Transactions of the Iron and Steel Institute of Japan (ISIJ) Tetsu-To-Hagane/Journal of the Iron and Steel Institute of Japan,
International, 44:2057-2066. 62:559-569.
ISO 3271, 2007. Iron ores for blast furnace and direct reduction Shimomura, Y, Nishikawa, K, Arino, S, Katayama, T, Hida, Y and
feedstocks Determination of the tumble and abrasion indices (ISO: Isoyama, T, 1976. Inside state of the reducing zone of a blast furnace
Geneva). 2, report on the dissection of blast furnaces, Tetsu-To-
ISO 4695, 2007.Iron ores for blast furnace feedstocks Determination of Hagane/Journal of the Iron and Steel Institute of Japan, 62:547-558.
the reducibility by the rate of reduction index (ISO: Geneva). Tenuta de Azevedo, A L and Cardoso, M B, 1983. Decrepitation of iron
ISO 4696-2, 2007. Iron ores for blast furnace feedstocks Determination ores: A fracture-mechanics approach, Ironmaking and Steelmaking,
of low-temperature reduction-disintegration indices by static method, 10:49-53.
Part 2: Reduction with CO and N2 (ISO: Geneva). Wu, S L, Xu, H F and Tian, Y Q, 2009. Evaluation of lump ores for use in
ISO 7215, 2007. Iron ores for blast furnace feedstocks Determination of modern blast furnaces as part of mixed burden practice, Ironmaking
the reducibility by the final degree of reduction index (ISO: Geneva). and Steelmaking, 36:19-23.