REVIEW COMMENTS ON:-

DOCUMENT TITLE: FUEL GAS AND INSTRUMENT GAS SYSTEM CALCULATION REPORT

DOCUMENT NO:

S PAG IMPaC Comment

. E FRAZIMEX
REFER FRAZIMEX
N NU ZEL COMMENTS ZEL COMMENTS RESPONSE
ENCE RESPONSE
O MB
. ER

1- In 2nd line of 1. Implemented see 1- OK CLOSED 1. Noted.

point 3, values of page 16 of document !!!!
pressure and number NTCOB3-
temperature are LOTA-X-EC-012 (A
mentioned as 75- 03)
Clause
80 barg and
6.0:
50oC. Kindly 2. Noted.
Design
update these 2- OK CLOSED
basis
values as per 2. Implemented see !!!!
16 of and
1. latest revision of page 16 of document
25 Assump
lot A P&IDs. number NTCOB3- 3. Implemented
tion for
2- Remove the LOTA-X-EC-012 (A
fuel gas
sentence and 03) 3- First line states
require
water bath that the Fuel gas
ment
heaters 3. Implemented see will be taken
distribution page 16 of document from the gas
header from the number NTCOB3- supply line 24
last line of point LOTA-X-EC-012 (A GP-1001-6113.
3. 03) Kindly change
3- Kindly update this from the
 the first line of updated P&IDs
point 4 as per (NTC-OB3-
latest revision of LOTA-X-DW-
lot A P&IDs. 004 sht#1/26 rev:
A12).

1- Number of Level 4. Implemented see 1- OK CLOSED !!! 1 Noted 3

control valves page 17 of document
should be 15 number
instead of 13, NTC-OB3-LOTA-X-
because 2 no. of EC-012 (A 03) 5. 2- OK CLOSED !!! 2 Noted
level control Implemented see page
17 & valves are also in 18 of document
Table of
2. 18 of fuel and number
valves
25 instrument gas NTC-OB3-LOTA-
system. X-EC-012 (A 03)
2- Total number of
valves should be
110 (35+75)
instead of 100.
Kindly correct it.
Clause Implemented see page OK CLOSED !!!!
6.3: 19 of document
1- Replace
Instrum number NTCOB3-
Instrument gas
ent gas LOTA-X-EC-012 (A
19 of scrubber with
3. receiver 03)
25 Instrument gas
VF-
receiver in the
1030
1st line.
sizing
basis
Clause 1- Review and 1. Please Sir that is the Please see the comment Mark up comments Some comments base on
20 of 6.3.1: correct the formula we know for on the attached PDF Implemented. See doc. consultant response were
4.
25 Calculat formula of sizing Doc. calculation report No. NTC-OB3-LOTA- not closed out. Please
ion receiver volume Air/Gas Receiver (NTC-OB3-LOTA-X- X-EC-012 Fuel Gas And give us the basis of
 (V) because flow volume. Otherwise EC-012, A03) Instrument Gas System the Purge gas flow
rate (Q) will not give us another Calculation Report Rev. calculation.
be divided by 2. better formula with A 04 AS per P&ID (NTC-
2- Total instrument reference 2. The sizing OB3-LOTA-X-DW-004
gas flow rate of the Gas sht#26/26 rev. A12),
should be receiver vessel is never the Vent dia is 906
considered for sized for the total mm with 0.5 Mach#.
sizing of instrument gas Consider using
instrument gas requirement but rather formula below
receiver instead as a buffer volume that
of ESD gas flow will last for
rate because in 15 minutes to allow for
case of operators intervention
emergency, to prevent
instrument gas plant sudden Please refer to page 134-
flow rate cannot shutdown. 135 of API 521-6th ed.
be restricted to
ESD valve only.
1- H= 8 barg is the Above 8barg is control Please see the comment Mark up comments
operating/regulat valve failure, see page on the attached PDF Implemented. See doc.
ed pressure of 21 of Doc. calculation report No. NTC-OB3-LOTA-
Clause:
instrument air document number (NTC-OB3-LOTA-X- X-EC-012 Fuel Gas And
21 of Instrum
5. receiver instead NTC-OB3-LOTA-X- EC-012, A03) Instrument Gas System
25 ent air
of High pressure EC-012 (A 03) Calculation Report Rev.
receiver
alarm. Kindly A 04
review and
correct.