You are on page 1of 36

4/10/2017

PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur


FORGING / TEMPA

Forging

• Forging is manufacturing process


where metal is pressed, pounded or
squeezed under great pressure into high
strength parts known as forgings.

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

1
4/10/2017

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Advantages of Forging

 The forgings are consistent in shape and do not have


any voids, porosity, inclusions, or defects.

 This is especially helpful in later finishing and coating


operations as surface preparation is minimized.

 Parts that are produced by this method have high


strength to weight ratio and therefore used in the
design of the aircraft frames.

 It offers low cost for moderate to long runs.

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

2
4/10/2017

Outline
1 Metallurgical Basics

2 Forging Operation

3 Machinery

4 Design

5 Application

6 Die Forming Forces

7 Economics

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur 5

Forgeable materials I
All metals and metal alloys, with very few exceptions, are suitable for forging

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

3
4/10/2017

Forgeable materials II

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Grain Structure

• Parts have good strength


• High toughness
• Forgings require additional heat treating

Fig : A part made by three different procedures, showing grain flow (a) casting (b) machining (c) forging

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

4
4/10/2017

Grain-flow I
In an optimal forming process, this grain-flow is retained and runs parallel to
the surface of the component.

Optimal grain-flow increases the dynamic strength of the component

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Grain-flow II
Grain-flow breaking out of the side would result in an
undesirable stress-raising notch effect.

The gear profile is milled in the two collars. In the area of the teeth, the grain-flow
is perpendicular to the direction of the load

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

5
4/10/2017

Outline
1 Metallurgical Basics

2 Forging Operation

3 Machinery

4 Design

5 Application

6 Die Forming Forces

7 Economics

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur 11

Forging Processes
Five main methods are
used in forging:
- Drop-forging
- Upsetting
- Extrusion
- Open-die forging
- Ring rolling
Drop-forging Upsetting

Extrusion Open-die forging Ring rolling

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

6
4/10/2017

Special forging processes

These special processes


are largely used for the
mass production of
families of similarly
shaped parts

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Roll Forging

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

7
4/10/2017

Processes prior to forging I

Sawing offers the Cold shearing has the Hot shearing is


advantage of the advantages of low independent of material
greatest precision and material wastage and hardness and is well suited
the largest cross- short cycle times. The for integration into high
sections, but has disadvantage is that the speed automated forging
higher material cross-sectional area is lines
wastage, longer cycle limited (to max.
times and higher 150mm)
costs.

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Processes prior to forging II

Inductive heating equipment

Inductive heating of cut-off blanks to a forging


temperature of approx. 1,250 oC

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

8
4/10/2017

Process stages in manufacture

Production stages of a drop-forged


crankshaft form left to right:
 Steel blank
 Pre-formed blank
 Rough-forged part
 Finish-forged part
 Forging and trimmed
 flash
 Crankshaft

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Process steps after forging

Flash and piercing-slugs


are removed by trimming
and hole-piercing.

Post-forging processes
save material and
processing costs, reduce
the dimensional variation
and make possible
undercuts

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

9
4/10/2017

Tooling for forging

Open-die forging
Various forms of saddle Drop-forging: typical types of die

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Toolroom: manufacture of dies and other tooling

The form of a die is produced either by spark-erosion or by high-speed milling. The


surface of the form is treated is various ways to improve its life (e.g. by grinding,
polishing, nitriding and/or hard-chrome plating ).

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

10
4/10/2017

Outline
1 Metallurgical Basics

2 Forging Operation

3 Machinery

4 Design

5 Application

6 Die Forming Forces

7 Economics

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur 21

Forging machinery I
Three main types Of machine are used for Forging: energy-dependant ;
press-force-dependant ; machine-stroke- dependant

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

11
4/10/2017

Forging machinery II

The machine types are shown depicting the limiting conditions at the end of the
working stroke.

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Hammers for drop forging I


1. Power unit
2. Ram
3. Upper die
4. Lower die
5. Anvil block
6. Vibration
damper
elements

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

12
4/10/2017

Hammers for drop forging II

1. Drive
2. Ram
3. Upper die
4. Hammer frame
5. Lower die
6. Lower ram
The counterblow hammer is 7. Hydraulic ram
driven pneumatically – ideal
for large pieceweights clutch

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Presses for drop forging I

1. Frame
2. Punch slide
3. Punch guide
4. Screw spindle
5. Spindle nut
6. Clutch
7. Flywheel bearings
8. Spindle brake
Hydraulic
equipment
The screw press is suitable
for long runs and can be
9. Ejector
automated 10. Pneumatic
counterweight

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

13
4/10/2017

Presses for drop forging II

1. Hydraulic
cylinder
2. Ram
3. Table
4. Machine frame
5. Electric motors
6. Walking beam
automation
The hydraulic press offers a
constant maximum press 7. Forming station
force over the whole stroke
8. Material feed

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Presses for drop forging III

The eccentric press is machine


stroke dependant and readily
automated at high rates of
production (strokes per minute)
1. Frame 6. Counterweight
2. Ram 7. Ram adjustment
3. Connecting rod 8. Reduction gearbox
4. Ram guide 9. Double-helical gearing
5. Clutch and brake system 10. Upper and lower ejector
TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI
PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

14
4/10/2017

Automation of important forging equipment

1. Feed gripper
2. Transport
grippers
3. Lower die
4. Tongs arms
5. Tongs slide
6. System drive
unit
7. Transverse
slide
8. Press framer
Tongs arm system

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Automated production line

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

15
4/10/2017

Outline
1 Metallurgical Basics

2 Forging Operation

3 Machinery

4 Design

5 Application

6 Die Forming Forces

7 Economics

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur 31

General rules of closed-die design


• The die set should be designed for smooth metal flow – symmetry dies
(spherical or blocklike) are the easier than thin and long section.
• Shape changes in section are to be avoided.
• Dies should be designed for the minimum flash to do the job.
• Generous fillet dimensions should be allowed, therefore, forging dies must
be tapered or drafted to facilitate removal of the finished piece.
• Draft allowance is approximately 3-5o outside and 7-10o inside.
• Dies with inclined angles should have counterlock to prevent the dies from
sliding apart from each other due to side thrust.

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

16
4/10/2017

Parting Line

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Minimum Corner and Fillet Radii

Height, h 24 32 48 64 80 96 130 160 194


Rounded end
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 10 12
radius, r1
Inside fillet radius,
1.2 1.6 2 2.4 2.8 3.3 4 4.5 5
r2
Outside fillet radius,
0.8 1.2 1.6 2 2.4 2.8 3.3 3.6 4
r3
Corner radius, r4 3 4 5 6 7 7 8 8 10

In mm

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

17
4/10/2017

Die failures

• Different parts of dies are liable to permanent deformation and wear resulting from
mechanical and thermal fatigue.
• Important factors: shape of the forging, die materials, how the workpiece is heated,
coating of die surface, the operating temperature (should not exceed the annealing
temperature).

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Die materials I
Required properties
• Thermal shock resistance Die materials: alloyed steels (with
• Thermal fatigue resistance Cr, Mo, W, V), tool steels, cast steels
• High temperature strength or cast iron. (Heat treatments such
• High wear resistance are nitriding or chromium plating
• Hgh toughness and ductility are required to improve die life)
• High hardenability
• High dimensional stability during hardening
• High machinability
Note:
1) Carbon steels with 0.7-0.85% C are appropriate for small tools and flat
impressions.
2) Medium-alloyed tool steels for hammer dies.
3) Highly alloyed steels for high temperature resistant dies used in presses and
horizontal forging machines.
TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI
PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

18
4/10/2017

Die materials II
Die life can be increased by
1) Improving die materials such as using composite die or
2) Using surface coating or self-lubricating coatings

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Outline
1 Metallurgical Basics

2 Forging Operation

3 Machinery

4 Design

5 Application

6 Die Forming Forces

7 Economics

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur 38

19
4/10/2017

Machining of forged parts


High-speed steel (HSS), tungsten carbide (TC) and ceramics are all used to
make cutting tools

Recommended cutting speeds for the machining of forgings


TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI
PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Diversity of forms in automotive manufacturing


In car manufacture special properties are required, which can be achieved using hot-,
warm- and cold-forging or a combination of several manufacturing steps.

Steel and aluminium Engine parts are mostly Gear-box parts made of
chassis made of steel -
components for car hot-forged steel hot-forged and cold-sized
manufacture

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

20
4/10/2017

Diversity of forms in automotive manufacturing

Forged components are ideal


for handling the extreme
mechanical and dynamic loading
on heavy construction machinery.
• Blade hinge
• Cylinder eye
• Scarifier tooth
• Drive sprocket
• Track guide
• Track idlers
• Track links

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Use in aircraft manufacture


Alongside their use in jet
engines, forged
components are also
used in highly-loaded
areas such as wings,
rudders, control surfaces
and landing gear

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

21
4/10/2017

Outline
1 Metallurgical Basics

2 Forging Operation

3 Machinery

4 Design

5 Application

6 Die Forming Forces

7 Economics

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur 43

Analysis of Open-Die Forging


Upsetting or upset forging, reduces the height of the work and increases its diameter

Under these ideal conditions, the true strain experienced by the work during the process,
h0
  ln
h
ho = starting height of the work, mm; and
h = the height at some intermediate point in the process, mm.
hf = true strain reaches its maximum value
TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI
PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

22
4/10/2017

Estimates of force to perform upsetting

F = Yf ·A

Where F = force, N
A = cross-sectional area of the part,mm2
Yf = flow stress, MPa

The strain-hardening exponent n = 0, and flow stress Yf equals


the metal’s yield strength Y

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

An actual upsetting operation

F = Kf ·Yf ·A

Where F = force, N
A = cross-sectional area of the part,mm2
Yf = flow stress, MPa
Kf = the forging shape factor

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

23
4/10/2017

The forging shape factor

0.4    D
K f  1
h

where μ = coefficient of friction


D = workpart diameter or other dimension representing contact
length with die surface, mm
h = workpart height, mm

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Example :

A cylindrical workpiece is subjected to a cold upset


forging operation. The starting piece is 75 mm in height
and 50 mm in diameter. It is reduced in the operation to
a height of 36 mm. The work material has a flow curve
defined by K = 350 MPa and n = 0.17. Assume a
coefficient of friction of 0.1. Determine the force as the
process begins, at intermediate heights of 62 mm, 49
mm, and at the final height of 36 mm.

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

24
4/10/2017

Solution:
Workpiece volume V = 75π ·(502/4) = 147,262 mm3

At the moment contact is made by the upper die, h = 75 mm


and the force F = 0

At the start of yielding, his slightly less than 75 mm

assume that strain = 0.002

the flow stress is,


0.17
Y f  K n  3500.002  121.7 MPa

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

The diameter is still approximately D = 50 mm

area A = π(502/4) = 1963.5 mm2

For these conditions, the adjustment factor Kf is

0.4  (0.1)  50


K f  1  1.027
75

The forging force

F = Kf ·Yf ·A

F  1.027  121.7   1963.5  245.41 N


TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI
PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

25
4/10/2017

75
At h = 62 mm,   ln  ln1.21  0.1904
62
Yf  350  0.1904   264 MPa
17

Assuming constant volume, and neglecting barreling,

A  147.262 / 62  2357.2 mm 2
4  2375.2 
D  55 mm

0.4  0.1  55
K f  1  1.035
62
F  1.035  264  2375.2  649.303 N
Similarly, at h = 49 mm, F = 955.642 N; and at h = 36 mm,
F = 1467.422 N.
TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI
PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

The load stroke curve was developed from the values in this
example

Upsetting force as a function of height h and height reduction (ho - h).


This plot is sometimes called the load stroke curve.
TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI
PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

26
4/10/2017

HW

Sebuah batang dikenakan proses forging upset


menggunakan open die. Do = 50 mm dan ho = 40 mm.
Ketebalan akhir = 20 mm. Koefisien friksi pada permukaan
die = 0,2. Material benda kerja mempunyai nilai flow curve
sebesar K = 600 MPa dan n = 0.12 .
1. Carilah gaya yang diperlukan untuk operasi:
a. Saat yield point dicapai (strain = 0.002)
b. h = 30 mm
c. h = 20 mm.
2. Bangunlah sebuah diagram yang menggambarkan
hubungan gaya operasi dengan ketebalan material yang
terbentuk menggunakan ms excel.

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Outline
1 Metallurgical Basics

2 Forging Operation

3 Machinery

4 Design

5 Application

6 Die Forming Forces

7 Economics

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur 54

27
4/10/2017

Economics

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Tool design and profitability

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

28
4/10/2017

Material Losses in Forging (1)

Shear loss : The blank required for forging a component is cut from
billets or long bars. Shear loss is generally taken as 5
percent of net weight.

Tonghold loss : Drop forging operations are performed by holding the


stock at one end with the help of tongs.

Tonghold loss = Area of X-section of bar × Length of tonghold

Scale loss : As the forging process is performed at very high


temperature, the Oxygen from air forms iron oxide by
reacting with hot surface. Scale loss is taken as 6 percent of
net weight.
TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI
PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Material Losses in Forging (1)

Flash loss : Flash is generally taken as 20 mm wide and 3 mm thick.


The flash loss in weight is then calculated by multiplying the
volume of flash by density of the material.

Sprue loss : When the component is forged by holding the stock with
tongs, the tonghold and metal in the die are connected by a
portion of metal called the sprue or runner. This is cut off
when product is completed. Sprue loss is taken as 7
percent of net weight.

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

29
4/10/2017

Estimation of Cost of Forgings

The cost of a forged component consists of following


elements :
o Cost of direct materials.
o Cost of direct labour.
o Direct expenses such as cost of dies and cost of
press.
o Overheads.

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

1. Cost of Direct Material


Cost of direct material used in the manufacture of a forged component
is calculated as follows :

Calculate the net weight of forging :


Net weight of the forged component is calculated from the drawings by first
calculating the volume and then multiplying it by the density of
material used.

Net weight = Volume of forging × Density of material

Calculate the gross weight :


Gross weight is the weight of forging stock required to make the forged
component.

Gross weight = Net weight + Material loss in the process

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

30
4/10/2017

Diameter and length of stock : The greatest section of forging gives the
diameter of stock to be used,

Gross weight
Length of stock 
X - sectional area of stock  Density of material

The cost of direct material is calculated by multiplying the gross weight by


price of the raw material

Direct material cost = Gross weight × Price per kg

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

2. Cost of Direct Labour

Direct labour cost is estimated as follows :

Direct labour cost = t × l

t = time for forging per piece (in hours)

l = labour rate per hour.

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

31
4/10/2017

3. Direct Expenses
Direct expenses include the expenditure incurred on dies and other equipment,
cost of using machines and any other item, which can be directly identified with
a particular product.

Apportioning of Die Cost


cost of Die = Rp. X

No. of components that can be produced using this die (i.e., die life) = Y components

Cost of die/component = Rp. X/Y

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Apportioning of Machine (Press) Cost

Let cost of press = Rp. A


Life of press = n years

= n × 12 × 4 × 5 × 8 = 1920n hours

A
Hourly cost of press 
1920  n

No. of components produced per hour = N

A
Cost of using press per component 
1920  n  N
This excludes cost of power consumed and cost of consumables

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

32
4/10/2017

4. Overheads

The overheads include supervisory charges, depreciation of plant and


machinery, consumables, power and lighting charges, office expenses
etc. The overheads are generally expressed as percentage of direct
labour cost.

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

The total cost of forging is calculated by


adding the direct material cost, direct labour
cost, direct expenses and overheads.

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

33
4/10/2017

Example
Calculate the net weight and gross weight for the component shown in below.
Density of material used is 7.86 gm/cc. Also calculate :

Length of 14 mm dia bar required to forge one component.

Cost of forging/piece if :
Material cost = Rp. 16000 per kg
Labour cost = Rp. 1000 per piece
Overheads = 150 percent of labour cost.

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Solution :
Net volume of forged component=

Net weight = 56.76 × 7.86 = 446 g

Losses :
Shear loss = 5 percent of net weight

Scale loss = 6 percent of net weight

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

34
4/10/2017

Taking flash width = 20 mm


Flash thickness = 3 mm

Flash loss = (periphery of parting line) × 2 × 0.3 × 7.86


= [2 (2 + 2.5 + 2 + 5) + 1.4 + (2 – 1.4) + (3 – 2) + (4 – 3) + 4] × 2 × 0.3 × 7.86
= 31.0 × 2 × 0.3 × 7.86 = 146 g

Tonghold loss = 2 × Area of cross-section of bar × 7.86


= 2 × π/4(1.4)2 × 7.86 = 24.22 g

Sprue loss = 7 percent of net weight


=7/100 × 446 g

= 31.22 g

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

Total material loss = 22.3 + 26.8 + 146 + 24.22 + 31.22


= 250 gms

Gross weight = Net weight + Losses

= 446 + 250 = 696 g

New length of 14 mm f bar required per piece


Volume of forging

Area of X – Section of bar

56.76
  36.86 cm
  1.42
4

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

35
4/10/2017

Direct material cost = 696/1,000 × 16000

= Rp. 11136

Direct labour cost = Rp. 1000 per piece

Overheads = 150 percent f labour cost

= 1.5 × 1000 = Rp. 1500

Cost per piece = 11136 + 1000 + 1500

= Rp. 13636

TEKNIK DAN SISTEM PRODUKSI


PE4652 – Teknologi Manufaktur

36

You might also like