Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10
Benchmarking 2013
The Vodacom CEO improvement project was a three weeks joint venture
of Huawei and Vodacom where Huawei improved the network
performance in three weeks. New features were part of the project and it
includes all the 2G and 3G new features that were implemented on this
project.
New Features Benchmarking
Table of Contents
3G FEATURES ................................................................................................................................ 6
1 Control Channel Parallel Interference Cancellation (Phase 2) .................................................. 6
2 CE OVERBOOKING ............................................................................................................... 8
10.1.1 DESCRIPTION...................................................................................................... 23
11.1.1 DESCRIPTION...................................................................................................... 26
12.1.1 DESCRIPTION...................................................................................................... 28
2G FEATURES .............................................................................................................................. 33
14 PDCH Busy Threshold............................................................................................................ 34
14.1.1 DESCRIPTION...................................................................................................... 34
15.1.1 DESCRIPTION...................................................................................................... 39
16.1.1 DESCRIPTION...................................................................................................... 40
3G FEATURES
Following tables illustrates the brief details of New Features trialed in CEO Network
Quality Improvement Project
1.1.1 DESCRIPTION
1.1.2 BENEFIT:
This feature significantly increases the uplink system capacity. When the DPCCH uses
a large proportion of received total wideband power (RTWP) in a cell, this feature
increases system capacity by up to 20%. This gain is possible when, for example, the
uplink throughput is not high but there are a large number of UEs in the cell.
2 CE OVERBOOKING
2.1.1 DESCRIPTION
After Dynamic CE Resource Management is applied, the RNC calculates the credit
resource usage of an admitted HSUPA UE by using the following formula:
Credit resource usage = Max (Credit resources required for ensuring the GBR, Credit
resources required for transmitting one RLC PDU)
RNC performs this calculation to ensure HSUPA user experience. However, Because
the NodeB calculates the actual CE usage based on the UE rate which is lower than
the GBR or the rate at which an RLC PDU is transmitted in most cases due to the high
penetration rate of smart phones with a 2 ms HSUPA transmission time interval (TTI),
2013-9-10 New Features Benchmarking Page 8of 44
New Features Benchmarking
the actual CE usage of the NodeB is lower than the calculated credit resource usage
of the RNC. As a result, the RNC may reject new UE access attempts even if the
actual CE usage of the NodeB is low. This limits the RNC's capability to perform
admission control based on credit resource usage.
To address this issue, Huawei introduces CE Overbooking in which the NodeB
calculates the actual CE usage of admitted UEs, includes the calculated CE usage in a
private information element (IE) in a measurement report, and sends the report to
the RNC every measurement report period. The RNC then directly uses the reported
CE usage as the credit resource usage
2.1.2 BENEFIT
This maximizes the RNC's capability to perform admission control based on credit
resource usage.
When the penetration rate of smart phones with a 2ms HSUPA TTI is high, the
average HSUPA service throughput is low, and this feature provides the following
benefits:
Reduces the credit resource usage of admitted UEs.
Increases the number of admitted UEs and the number of HSUPA UEs with a
2ms TTI.
Increases cell uplink throughput when Uu and Iub resources are sufficient.
CE utilization is stable.
3.1.1 DESCRIPTION
ALGO1 - RNC allocates the smallest available CID for an AAL2 path whose ownership
is local and allocates the biggest available CID for an AAL2 path whose ownership is
peer. This is available since R14 software.
ALGO2 - RNC allocates the available CIDs from 8 to 255 in succession for an AAL2
path whose ownership is local, and then restarts the allocation, starting from 8 again;
and the RNC allocates the available CIDs from 255 to 8 in succession for an AAL2
path whose ownership is peer, and then restarts the allocation, starting from 255
again.
The result is positive. The CID confliction problem disappears after applying ALGO1.
The IUR between MT07 and MT01 was improved very much on Aug-27. The
abnormal CID is caused by IUR inter-failing starting from Aug-28 due to TX.
4.1.1 DESCRIPTION
The hybrid automatic repeat request (HARQ) entity for High Speed Uplink Packet
Access (HSUPA) is located on the NodeB side and used to receive MAC-e protocol
data units (PDUs). When a cell cannot correctly receive MAC-e PDUs from a UE, the
HARQ entity requires the UE to retransmit MAC-e PDUs. The average number of
retransmissions on the NodeB side needs to converge to a target number of
retransmissions on the RNC side. This target number on the RNC side is dynamically
adjusted by the feature HSUPA Adaptive Retransmission.
With the HSUPA adaptive retransmission feature, a small target number of
retransmission is used under normal circumstances. When the uplink load or the UE
transmit power is limited, one UE is selected to use a large target number of
retransmissions during each period. Without this feature, a small target number of
retransmission is always used. For details about the HSUPA adaptive retransmission
feature, see HSUPA Feature Parameter Description.
In versions earlier than RAN14.0, the small target number of retransmissions is
specified by the EdchTargetLittleRetransNum parameter and cannot be adaptively
adjusted. When the uplink load is limited, a small target number of retransmissions
will require a high signal-to-interference ratio (SIR) on the Dedicated Physical Control
Channel (DPCCH), and the DPCCH must have a higher power. This leads to decreased
available power on the Enhanced Dedicated Channel (E-DCH) and Enhanced
Dedicated Physical Data Channel (E-DPDCH), a lower UE throughput, and a lower cell
throughput. To address these problems, RAN14.0 introduced the feature Adaptive
Adjustment of HSUPA Small Target Retransmissions. This feature supports an
alternative small target number of retransmissions for each typical type of service.
The actual small target number of retransmissions can dynamically shift between the
original fixed number and the alternative number based on the cell uplink load and
UE rates, which are configured by the EdchTargetLittleRetransNum and
EdchAltTarLittleRetransNum parameters, respectively. This improves the system
capacity when the uplink load is limited.
Figure 5- shows the relationship between the features HSUPA Adaptive
Retransmission and Adaptive Adjustment of HSUPA Small Target Retransmissions.
With the HSUPA Adaptive Retransmission feature, only one UE is selected to use the
large target number of retransmissions during each period. With the Adaptive
Adjustment of HSUPA Small Target Retransmissions feature, when the uplink load is
limited, multiple UEs are selected for adjustment to the small target number of
retransmissions. This further improves the cell throughput.
4.1.2 BENEFIT
This feature improves the uplink performance. It is recommended that this feature
be enabled if the uplink load of the cell is restricted and there are a large number of
HSUPA UEs using a 10 ms TTI. If some UEs in the cell are engaged in continuous
uploading, this feature improves the uplink throughput by 10% to 15%. If all services
in the cell are burst services, this feature lowers the RTWP by around 0.5 dB.
RTWP on 31st August is lower than 24th August, but traffic is also decreased.
Besides, RTWP of RO15 was on a good level, hardly to get improvement.
5.1.1 DESCRIPTION
5.1.2 BENEFIT
RTWP can be improved and also uplink capacity and HSUPA throughput.
6.1.1 DESCRIPTION
Generally, a small target block error rate (BLER) is configured for an R99 channel. For
example, the typical target BLER for PS services over R99 channels is 1%. A small
target BLER raises data transmission rates and reduces the retransmission ratio but
requires high transmit power.
When the system load is heavy, a small target BLER restricts the number of UEs that
the system can serve. This compromises the uplink capacity of the system. To solve
this problem, raise the target BLER for each UE so that the transmit power of each
UE can be reduced and more UEs can be admitted. This approach sacrifices a little
throughput for a reduced load on each link and thereby increases the overall
capacity of the system.
The load-based uplink target BLER configuration function dynamically configures the
target BLER for each R99 link based on the system load. That is, a small target BLER is
configured for each link when the system load is light, and a large target BLER is
configured for each link when the system load is heavy.
6.1.2 BENEFIT
When the total uplink load and actual uplink service load in a cell are restricted,
increasing the target BLER lowers the uplink load in the cell and raises the uplink
throughput of the cell.
Emulation results show that the uplink load decreases by at most about 15% when
there are 30 online R99 UEs and the target BLER is adjusted.
RTWP was improved on 30th and 31st August, but from 1st Sept, traffic increased,
cant benchmark.
Besides, RTWP of RO14 was on a good level, hardly to get improvement.
7.1.1 DESCRIPTION
With the traffic growth, FACH is showing more congestion, When UE is on PCH state
and CS is triggered, normally, UE will perform P2F then F2D, there is high risk of
setup failure due to FACH congestion.
With this feature enabled, when CS is triggered while UE is on PCH, UE will perform
P2D instead of P2F->F2D to avoid setup failure due to FACH congestion or complex
signaling procedure.
7.1.2 BENEFIT
8.1.1 Description:
This feature can balance the consumption of currently available code resources and
power resources, to avoid code or power unilaterally congestion in order to improve
resource utilization, enhance cell capacity.
SET MACHSPARA: LOCELL=0, RSCALLOCM=POWERCODE_BAL;
8.1.2 Benefit:
Relative to the code priority, the power code balance can enhance the cell downlink
load, while reducing the resource utilization of code.
9.1.1 Description
The CQI measures the channel conditions of a UE and is reported from the UE to the
NodeB. With this feature, the NodeB determines an appropriate TBS based on the
reported CQI, system resources, and the TFRC policy. If the reported CQI and related
conditions remain the same, the NodeB does not change the TBS because it does not
consider the ever-changing radio environments.
The constant changes in radio environments, caused by multipath effects and UE
mobility, lead to fluctuating channel quality. Under these circumstances, choosing a
TBS based on the reported CQI makes it difficult to always achieve the optimum
2013-9-10 New Features Benchmarking Page 22of 44
New Features Benchmarking
downlink throughput. With the feature CQI adjustment based on dynamic BLER
target, the NodeB monitors the channel quality fluctuations for HSDPA users in a cell
in real time and dynamically selects a proper BLER target based on the monitoring
result. The NodeB then uses the BLER target to adjust the CQI reported by the UE.
The BLER described in this section refers to the SBLER at the MAC-(e)hs layer and
reflects the average block error rate at the MAC layer. Accordingly, the BLER target
described in this section refers to the SBLER target at the MAC-(e)hs layer.
CQI Adjustment Process
CQI adjustment based on dynamic BLER target is performed in each TTI. The
following describes the adjustment process:
1. Based on the CQI reported by the UE, the NodeB checks the actual radio
environment, which is affected by multipath effects and UE mobility.
2. Based on the actual radio environment and channel quality of the UE, the NodeB
obtains an optimum BLER target, which helps to achieve the highest possible
throughput for the UE.
3. Based on the ACK, NACK, or DTX indication from the UE in the current TTI and on
the optimum BLER target, the NodeB calculates the CQI offset, which can be a
positive or negative number. The NodeB then uses the CQI offset to adjust the CQI.
4. Based on the adjusted CQI, the NodeB selects an appropriate TBS by using the
TFRC algorithm.
9.1.2 Benefit:
Based on the adjusted CQI, the NodeB determines an appropriate TBS to achieve
higher downlink throughput for HSDPA users and higher cell throughput.
10.1.1 DESCRIPTION
A channel quality indicator (CQI) reported by an HSDPA UE reflects the radio quality
at the current location of the UE. Based on the CQI, the NodeB selects an
appropriate data block size and modulation scheme to ensure data transmission
performance. Due to fluctuations in the radio environment, the UE needs to report
CQIs promptly.
CQIs are periodically reported over the HS-DPCCH. If a short CQI feedback period is
used, CQIs are frequently reported. Consequently, the scheduling module promptly
learns about the radio quality and performs data scheduling accordingly. This way,
data blocks are more likely to be correctly transmitted on the downlink. However,
frequent CQI feedback imposes a heavy load on the uplink and requires UEs to use
high transmit power. As a result, call drop rates may increase at cell edges. This
feature supports three functions for dynamically adjusting the CQI feedback period:
2013-9-10 New Features Benchmarking Page 23of 44
New Features Benchmarking
state transiting from the E-DCH to the DCH (E2D transition) due to limited coverage
When a service carried over HSUPA needs to fall back to the DCH channel due to
limited coverage. A long CQI feedback period needs to be used to ensure coverage.
These three functions can work side by side.
10.1.2 BENEFIT
When a large number of HSDPA UEs are online, CQIs sent over HS-DPCCHs
contribute to a large proportion of the uplink load and reduce uplink capacity. In this
case, if the total uplink load and actual uplink service load are both restricted, the
RNC configures the long CQI feedback period (which can improve capacity) for UEs to
reduce power occupied by control channels and increase power available on traffic
channels. This raises the uplink throughput.
Emulation tests were performed based on small-packet transmission. The test
results are as follows: If the CQI feedback period is adjusted from 2 ms to 8 ms and
there are 40 online HSDPA UEs, the uplink actual load decreases by a maximum of 20%
during busy hours. If the CQI feedback period is adjusted from 4 ms to 8 ms, the
uplink actual load decreases by a maximum of 10% during busy hours.
11.1.1 DESCRIPTION
Before Dynamic Target RoT Adjustment is introduced, the target uplink load level is
specified by MaxTargetUlLoadFactor. However, a fixed MaxTargetUlLoadFactor
value cannot account for varied scenarios. That is because a small value is required
to ensure the cell coverage in scenarios with poor coverage and a large value is
required to ensure high cell capacity in scenarios with good coverage. To consistently
achieve an optimum maximum uplink load level, there is a need to introduce
Dynamic Target RoT Adjustment.
The target RoT is obtained by subtracting the noise floor from the RTWP and is used
for NodeB fast scheduling. A large target RoT leads to a heavy cell load and
consequently a high cell throughput. However, UMTS is a system that produces
interference within itself. As a result, a heavy cell load leads to increased
interference and decreased cell coverage. Dynamic Target RoT Adjustment allows
the target RoT to be adjusted to increase the cell throughput without affecting key
performance indicators (KPIs) related to the call drop rate.
The relationship between the RoT and uplink load is as follows:
RoT = -10 x log10(1 Uplink load factor)
DynTgtRoTCtrlSwitch controls whether Dynamic Target RoT Adjustment is enabled.
MaxTargetUlLoadFactor specifies the initial target RoT.
Adjusting the target RoT for a cell depends on the RNC's decision on whether the
power of an R99 UE is insufficient and on the IE UL Timeslot ISCP. This IE is contained
in the COMMON MEASUREMENT REPORT message sent from the NodeB to the RNC.
Based on the transmit power of HSUPA UEs in the cell, cell throughput, and actual
RoT, the IE UL Timeslot ISCP can be set to one of the following values:
0: indicates that the NodeB requests the RNC to reduce the target RoT. This IE is
set to 0 when at least one HSUPA UE in the cell meets the following two
conditions:
The UE's transmit power approaches the maximum.
The UE throughput is low.
1: indicates that the NodeB requests the RNC to increase the target RoT. This IE is
set to 1 when no HSUPA UE in the cell meets the preceding two conditions and the
actual RoT is close to the target RoT.
2: indicates that the NodeB requests the RNC to keep the target RoT unchanged.
This IE is set to 2 when no HSUPA UE in the cell meets the preceding two
conditions and the actual RoT is not close to the target RoT.
The RNC decides whether to reduce or increase the target RoT every period specified
by TgtRoTAdjPeriod as follows:
If the transmit power of an R99 UE in the cell is insufficient or the value of the IE UL
Timeslot ISCP is 0, the RNC reduces the target RoT by one step, whose size is
2013-9-10 New Features Benchmarking Page 26of 44
New Features Benchmarking
11.1.2 BENEFIT
In scenarios where the cell coverage is not limited, this feature raises the target RoT
to increase the maximum uplink load for HSUPA UEs, increasing the uplink cell
throughput. When the uplink traffic is heavy, the uplink capacity can be increased by
up to 20%.
Cell coverage has an inverse relationship with cell capacity. In a cell where there are
no UEs with limited transmit power, this feature increases the target RoT for the cell
and cell coverage shrinks with the increase of uplink cell throughput. As a result, the
RRC connection success rate decreases. In a cell where there are UEs with limited
transmit power, this feature increases cell coverage by reducing the target RoT at a
step (MaxTargetUlLoadFactor specifies the lower limit). Before the target RoT is
adjusted to a proper value, call drops, handover failures, and throughput decrease
may occur on the UEs with limited transmit power.
12.1.1 DESCRIPTION
UEs that do not send SCRI messages because there is no PS data to be transmitted
Pre fast dormancy UEs. This type of UE does not read the T323 information element
(IE) carried in the system information block type 1 (SIB1) message. After PS data
transmission is complete, this type of UE sends an SCRI message to the RNC, but the
SCRI message does not carry the IE Signaling Connection Release Indication Cause.
Both T323 and Signaling Connection Release Indication Cause are introduced in 3GPP
Release 8.
R8 fast dormancy UEs. This type of UE reads the T323 IE carried in the SIB1 message
and sends an SCRI message to the RNC after PS data transmission is complete. The
SCRI message carries the IE Signaling Connection Release Indication Cause that is set
to "UE Requested PS Data session end."
The T323 IE carried in the SIB1 message controls the frequency at which the R8 fast
dormancy UEs send SCRI messages with the IE Signaling Connection Release
Indication Cause set to "UE Requested PS Data session end". The T323 timer starts
after an SCRI message is sent by the R8 fast dormancy UEs, and the second SCRI
message with the IE Signaling Connection Release Indication Cause set to "UE
Requested PS Data session end" can be sent only after the T323 timer expires.
The EFD feature applies only to the pre fast dormancy UEs and R8 fast dormancy UEs.
Users can configure EFD to be enabled for only the pre fast dormancy UEs or R8 fast
dormancy UEs.
When this feature is disabled, the RNC releases the signaling connection and puts
the UE into idle mode after receiving the SCRI message regardless the UE types.
When this feature is enabled, the RNC performs different processing based on the
UE type:
For the pre fast dormancy UEs, the RNC checks for compatibility issues after
receiving an SCRI message. If there are no compatibility issues, the RNC puts the UE
into the CELL_FACH or PCH state. If there is a compatibility issue, the RNC puts the
UE into idle mode.
For the R8 fast dormancy UEs, the RNC puts the UE into the CELL_FACH or PCH
state after receiving an SCRI message.
When there is no PS data to be transmitted, the intelligent UE sends the RNC an SCRI
message to request the UTRAN to release the signaling connection. This procedure
saves power. In addition, the UE periodically sends heartbeat messages to the core
network, for example, to check for new mails on the mail server. If the EFD feature is
disabled, the RNC releases the signaling connection and puts the UE into the idle
state. In this case, sending heartbeat messages leads to the procedures for RRC
connection setups, authentication, encryption, and RAB setups. These procedures
increase the RNC signaling processing load.
EFD addresses this problem. With EFD, the RNC transits a UE to the CELL_FACH or
PCH state instead of idle mode upon receiving an SCRI message from the UE. In this
case, when the UE periodically sends heartbeat messages, the signaling procedure
between the UE and RNC is simplified because the RRC connection is maintained. As
the number of signaling exchange messages decreases, significant CPU resources can
2013-9-10 New Features Benchmarking Page 29of 44
New Features Benchmarking
be saved for the RNC, and the UE consumes about the same low amount of battery
power as a UE in idle mode.
12.1.2 BENEFIT
Will revert back, PS CSSR degradation under investigation, and need to trail again
when solution provided
13 MULTIRAB OPTIMIZATION
13.1.1 Background
13.1.2 Recommendation
13.1.3 Results
2G FEATURES
14.1.1 DESCRIPTION
14.1.2 BENEFIT
14.1.3 Conclusion:
DR12 Trail: Changed the PS Busy threshold to 20 & reduced the No. of PDCHs
by 25%
It saved the PS channel resource by 25%. PS EDGE single TS throughput was
improved about 10%. It improved PDCH bearing efficiency as well.
15.1.1 DESCRIPTION
The number of TBFs multiplexed on a PDCH cannot reflect the actual PDCH
usage. For low throughput services, data transmission time is a small part of a
TBF life cycle. This leads to a PDCH usage.
The BSC implements the Active TBF Allocation feature as follows:
Monitors the downlink data transmission on each PDCH in real time and
periodically measures the downlink load of each PDCH.
Preferentially allocates PDCHs with lighter loads to MSs based on the latest
load information of PDCHs. This balances the loads between PDCHs and
improves the downlink user rate.
15.1.2 BENEFIT
15.1.3 Conclusion:
After enabling this feature in PW12, the EDGE Downlink throughput per User was
improved, and all other CS/PS KPIs are keep stable.
16.1.1 DESCRIPTION
The voice quality index (VQI) feature provides a direct method of measuring
the voice quality of the radio network. By measuring the uplink VQI and
downlink VQI, the voice quality of the network is quantified, which provides a
reference for future network optimization.
Obtaining the VQI Information
In each call, when the parameter RPTVOICE is enabled, the BTS receives the
customized extended measurement reports every five measurement report
periods (within 2.4 seconds). The uplink measurement reports contain the
short-time VQI information.
Classification of VQI Scores
The MOS analysis method is applied in VQI to measure the voice quality. MOS
is used to assess the quality of the middle-rate and low-rate voice codecs.
The MOS score ranges from 1 to 5.
5: Excellent
4: Good
3: Fair
2: Poor
1: Unsatisfactory
Measurement of Voice Quality
To avoid floating-point calculation when the VQI performance is measured,
the VQI score is multiplied by 50 and then the result is converted into an
integer. The integer is sent to the BSC. After receiving the VQI score integer,
the BSC forwards the score to the M2000 for processing. The M2000 divides
the value by 50 and then obtains the average short-time VQI score. The
methods of measuring VQI voice quality are as follows:
Voice quality levels
Based on the score range of the MOS analysis method, the voice quality is
further classified into 11 levels for measuring performance, as listed in Table
below.
Table Voice quality levels
Level Description
16.1.2 BENEFIT
The VQI establishes the mapping between the radio network performance and voice
quality. The VQI value, which helps learn the voice quality, is calculated based on the
parameters related to the radio quality of the uplink/downlink speech signals. The
MOS analysis method is applied in VQI to measure the voice quality. The MOS is used
to assess the quality of the middle-rate and low-rate voice coding. The MOS value
ranges from 1 to 5.
Based on the MOS analysis method, Huawei further divides the voice quality into 11
levels. In this manner, the voice quality is quantified to facilitate the identification of
the voice problem and network optimization.
According to actual wireless environment signal quality, BSS adjusts coding rate
dynamically to improve the voice quality.
We trailed to reduce the AMR UL/DL coding rate adjust threshold to increase the
high codec proportion to improve the VQI.
2013-9-10 New Features Benchmarking Page 42of 44
New Features Benchmarking
16.1.3 Conclusion:
No visible gain seen from RS13 trail, and also there were lots of operation on this
BSC, so it is recommended to trial in another BSC.