Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Author(s): S. G. Williams
Source: Plant Physiology, Vol. 45, No. 4 (Apr., 1970), pp. 376-381
Published by: American Society of Plant Biologists
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/4261994
Accessed: 04/08/2010 21:43
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless
you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you
may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use.
Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at
http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=aspb.
Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed
page of such transmission.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
American Society of Plant Biologists is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to
Plant Physiology.
http://www.jstor.org
Plant Physiol. (1970) 45, 376-381
S. G. WILLIAMS2
Department of Agricultural Biochemistry, Waite Agricultural Research Institute, University of Adelaide,
Adelaide, South Australia
60
._
c40
E
0
Days Days
FIG. 1. Fresh weight (a), dry weight (a), and moisturecontent (A) of the whole grain (WG) from the normal (a) and water-stressed(b)
plants plotted againstthe time after anthesis.The period ("a" to "b") duringwhich water was withheldfrom the lattergroup of plants is indi-
cated in Figure lb.
FIG. 2. Fresh weights of the fractionstesta (T), embryo plus scutellum(E + S), aleurone (A), and endosperm(En) for the normal (a) and
stressed(b) grainare plottedagainsttime after anthesis.That portionof the freshweightequivalentto the dry weight is representedby the cross-
hatchedareas. The remaindercorrespondsto the moisturecontent. Data for the whole grain (WG) taken both before and after dissectionwas
possibleare also presented.
FIG. 3. Total phosphorus(PT) content of the fractionsT, (E + S), A, and En for the normal (a) and stressed (b) grain plotted againsttime
after anthesis.That portion of PT which was phytic acid phosphorusis representedby the cross-hatchedareas.Data for WG taken both before
and afterdissectionwas possibleare also presented.
378 WILLIAMS Plant Physiol. Vol. 45, 1970
were adjusted to 4 ml with water. Then 6 ml of isobutanol and phytate solution buffered to pH 5.5 with acetic acid this enzyme
1 ml of acid molybdate reagent were added(24), and the method preparation liberated 3.8 ,moles of inorganic phosphate per hr
of Jennings and Morton was followed (11). per mg of protein at 20 C. The exchange of 32p inorganic phos-
Phytic Acid Phosphorus. Portions (0.20 ml) of the centrifuged phate (32Pi) with phytic acid was examined under these condi-
extracts were applied in a narrow transverse band 4.0 cm long tions.
across a Whatman 3MM chromatography paper which had been A solution (pH 5.5) containing 1% sodium phytate (w/v),
previously washed first in 0.1 M oxalic acid and then with dilute phytase (1.2 mg/ml), and 2.2 ,c of 32Pi per ml was incubated at
ammonia solution. Two such bands together with phytic acid 20 C. Samples were removed at intervals, and the reaction was
standards were spaced across a 15-cm strip of paper which was stopped by adding perchloric acid (0.05 ml of 70% [w/v] HC104
subjected to electrophoresis at 2 kv for 45 min in the apparatus per ml). The precipitated protein was removed by centrifuging,
described by Tate (23). When dry the electrophoretograms were and the phytic acid in aliquots (0.05 ml) of the supernatant was
passed through the 95% acetone dip reagent of Harrap (8) and
heated at 65 C for 15 min before irradiating with an ultraviolet
lamp. The blue spots which indicated phytic acid were cut from Table I. Effect of Dissection on Various Parameters of Wheat Grain
the paper (areas less than 10 cm2) and digested with 10 ml of In each case values for the four dissected fractions were summed
70% (w/v) perchloric acid in Kjeldahl flasks fitted with cold and expressed as a percentage of the value of the parameter ob-
fingers, and the phosphorus was determined as described (3). tained from a similar sample of whole grain. This figure indicates
The recovery of standard phytic acid solutions in these procedures the change in a given parameter brought about by dissection.
was at least 90%.
Luciferin-LuciferaseAssay for ATP. To 0.1 ml of each of the In-
Total Phytate
centrifuged extracts was added 0.9 ml of water, and 0.1-ml Parameter FreshDry organic
Weiht Phos- Phos- ATPo Phos-
Weight Weight
weight
aliquots of this solution were analyzed for ATP by the method phorus phorus phorus
of Strehler and Totter (22) as modified by Stanley and Williams
(21). Internal standards were incorporated in all assays which Numbers of dissections 17 17 15 11 17 17
were performed within a few hours of the extraction. Range of recovery (%) 83-108 89-110 87-112 60-12946-98 80-128
Exchange of Inorganic Phosphate with Phytic Acid. Phytase was Mean recovery (%) 90 96 100 92 73 109
prepared by ammonium sulphate precipitation of a wheat bran Standard deviation of ±9 ±5 ±9 ±20 =-16 =14
extract according to the method of Nagai (14). The dialyzed solu- mean recoveries (%)
tion contained 12.5 mg of protein per ml. In 1% (w/v) sodium
I-
!<
o
-i
DaysDays
FIG.4. ATP content of the fractionsT, (E + S), A, and En for the normal (a) and stressed (b) grain is plotted againsttime after anthesis.
Values for WG taken both before and after dissectionwas possibleare also presented.
FIG.5. Inorganicphosphoruscontent (Pi) of the fractionsis plotted in the same manner.
Plant Physiol. Vol. 45, 1970 PHYTIC ACID IN WHEAT GRAIN 379
separatedby the method describedfor determiningphytic acid. Variationin FreshWeightandDry Weight.Figure2 showsthat
The area of the paper containingphytic acid was cut from the the effect of the waterstressis to inducea low fresh weightand
chromatogramand counted in a Beckman low 3II gas flow moisturecontentbetweendays 14 and 31 and also to depressthe
proportionalcounter,and then the phosphoruswas determined rate of accumulationof dry matter during this period. These
as before. effects are most pronouncedin the endospermand testa which
A similarexperimentwas performedexceptthat the incubation appearto bufferthe aleuroneand embryofromthis changein the
mixture contained 20 mg/ml of wheat bran which had been environment.
homogenizedin liquid nitrogenin place of the sodium phytate Distributionof Phytic Acid Phosphorus (P4) and Total Phos-
and purifiedphytaseenzyme. phorus(PT). The rate of accumulationof phytic acid in the
aleuronelayeris maximalat day 23 in the stressedgrain and at
RESULTS day 28 in the normalgrain(Fig. 6, a and b) althoughboth grains
finallydehydrateat approximately the sametime (Fig. 2). Similar
effectsare noted in the embryoplus scutellumfractionalthough
Accuracyof the Data. The changes in fresh weight and dry
weightduringgraindevelopmentare shownin Figurela. Similar they are not so marked(Figs. 3 and 6).
resultsfor the whole grainfraction(WG) were obtainedon two It would appearfrom Figure 3 that the endospermcontains
otheroccasionsfromwheatgrownunderfieldconditions,and the significantquantitiesof phytic acid, but at severalstages during
same patternis observedwhen wheat is grown under optimum developmentboth beforeand after day 30 no trace of this com-
conditionsin the phytotron(P. E. Stanley,personalcommunica- pound was found in endospermwhich had been carefullydis-
sected from the cheeks of the grain so that contaminationwith
tion). All are very similarboth quantitativelyand qualitatively the aleuronelayerwas avoided.This resultis in accordwith the
to the resultsrecordedby Jenningsand Morton (10). Although
our data were obtainedfrom samplesof only 10 grains from a work of Rijven (17). It is concluded,therefore,that significant
amountsof phytic acid do not occurin the endospermand that
single head, it appears,therefore,that for componentsof the the levelsrecordedin Figure3 merelyrepresentcontaminationof
grain which exhibit little variationfrom day to day this small the endospermfractionby the aleuronelayer.
samplesize introducesa negligiblesamplingerror.The differences Distributionof ATP and InorganicPhosphorus.Figure4 shows
between the normal growth pattern (Fig. la) and the one for
the amounts of ATP found in the fractions.The water stress
grain grown with an interruptedwater supply (Fig. lb) are
thereforereal differences. produceda markeddecreasein the total ATP levelwhichreached
Before the 7th day after anthesisthe grain was too small to
dissect,and afterthe 35th day it is too dehydrated.Examination
of the individualmorphologicalfractionswas thereforerestricted
to the centralperiodof the grain'sdevelopment.
For eachvariablewhichwas recordedfor the dissectedfractions
the same one was recordedfor a similarsample of whole grain
taken from the same head. The sum of the values for the testa
fraction (T), the embryo and scutellumfraction (E + S), the
aleurone fraction (A), and the endospermfraction (En) was
expressedas a percentageof the value for WG. Percentagere-
coveriesfor each component,after each dissection,were deter-
minedin thisway,anda summaryof theresultsis givenin TableI.
Recoveryof dry materialand total phosphoruswas about 100%.
However,therewas a small loss of freshweightprobablycaused
by evaporationof waterduringdissection.Small changesin the
inorganic and phytic acid phosphorusare consistent with the
action of phosphatases.The recoveryof ATP is definitelylow,
however, and must reflect the high level of ATPase in these
tissues.A loss of between12 and 33% of the ATP presentin the
intact wheat grain was reported by Jenner (9) although his
dissectionprocedurewas simplerand more rapid than the one
describedhere.
In orderto compensatefor this loss of ATP the valuesfor the
fractionsT, (E + S), A, and En obtainedafter each dissection
werecorrectedaccordingto the percentagerecoveryof ATP noted
for that dissection.Valuesof the othercomponentswerecorrected
in a similarmanner.
The variationin the data shown in Table I is small relativeto
the changes most of the variablesexhibit during development
(Figs. 1-5). Errorsof this size do not, therefore,obscureany 10
over-alltrendor markedchangeswhich occur. Days
Presentationof the Data. The changesin the testa, embryoplus FIG. 6. a: Values for the molar concentrationof ATP (0), in the
scutellum,aleurone,and endospermof fresh weight,dry weight, aleuronefraction(A) andthe embryoplusscutellum fraction(E + S)
totalphosphorus(PT), phytatephosphorus(P<), ATP, and inor- fromthe normalgrainwerecalculatedby dividingthe ATPcontent
ganic phosphorusare shown in Figures2 to 5. For the dissected of thesefractions(Fig.4) by the respective
moisturecontent(Fig.2a)
fractionsthe values obtainedfor T werefirstplottedand a curve andareplottedagainsttimeafteranthesis.Therelativerateof change
in the phyticacidphosphorus (Ps)withtime (dP,/dt)for thesefrac-
drawnthroughthese points. The resultsfor (E + S), A, and En tionsis similarlyplotted(I). Thisfunctionwasdetermined
were superimposedsimilarly.Whenthe grainwas eithertoo small graphically
froma plotof Ps againsttimeforthesetissues(Fig.3a).b: Dataforthe
or too maturefor dissectionthe datafor the whole grainfraction stressedgainanalogousto thosepresentedin parta for normalgrain
has been plotted. aredisplayed.
380 WILLIAMS Plant Physiol. Vol. 45, 1970
ADP ATP
Time Phytic Acid Phosphorus Net Radioactivity
per 0.05 ml in Phytic Acid
inositol pentaphosphate < , , > inositol tetraphosphate
hr Pug cpm ADP ATP
0 240 0
2 112 0 then it might be expected that inorganic phosphate would ex-
4 20 0 change with the phytic acid via exchange reactions with the ATP.
6 12 0 No such evidence for the postulated phosphotransferase proper-
ties of phytase was observed with either the purified enzyme or
the crude bran homogenate.
Table III. Exchange of 32P with EndogenousPhytic Acid There is, therefore, no substantiated evidence to support the
Exchange of 32Pi(2.2 ,c/ml) with the endogenous phytic acid in hypothesis that the phytin in seeds supplies energy for the proc-
homogenized wheat bran (20 mg/ml) suspended in sodium acetate esses of germination. On the contrary, recent work has shown
buffer (0.1 M), pH 5.5, at 20 C. At the times indicated the mixture that respiration in wheat grain begins very early during germina-
was analyzed as described in the legend of Table II. tion and certainly before substantial amounts of phytic acid have
been hydrolyzed (15). It is unlikely, therefore, that stored energy
Time Phytic Acid Phosphorus Net'Radioactivity
in Phytic Acid
is required during this period.
per 0.05 ml
If Sobolev's postulate (c) is true, then the level of ATP should
hr Ag cpm fall substantially with the rise in phytic acid. In fact, the results
0 18.0 3 presented in Figure 6 show that this is not so since the concen-
0.33 14.0 2 tration of ATP does not fall to low levels until approximately
0.67 12.5 3 7 days after the maximum rate of phytic acid formation (Fig. 6).
1.00 13.0 4 Nevertheless, in rice grain (1) and in the potato tuber (18) a
1.50 8.0 6 sharp rise in phytic acid occurs shortly before maturity, which
2.00 4.0 6 suggests that the synthesis of phytic acid is associated with the
onset of dormancy.
Plant Physiol.Vol. 45, 1970 PHYTIC ACID IN WHEAT GRAIN 381
Comparisonof Figure6a with 6b showsthat maximumrate of 8. HARRAP, F. E. G. 1960. The detection of phosphate esters on paper chromato-
accumulationof phytic acid in the aleuronelayer of the normal grams. Analyst 85: 452.
9. JENNER, C. F. 1968. The composition of soluble nucleotides in the developing
grainoccurredlater (day 28) than in the stressedgrain (day 23). wheat grain. Plant Physiol. 43: 41-49.
This suggeststhat a prematuresynthesisof phytinis part of the 10. JENNINGS,A. C. AND R. K. MORTON. 1963. Changes in carbohydrates, protein
reaction to the environmentalstress and may reflect a general and non-protein nitrogenous compounds of developing wheat grain. Aust. J.
mechanismby which the synthesisof phytin plays a part in the Biol. Sci. 16: 318-331.
11. JENNINGS,A. C. AND R. K. MORTON. 1963. Changes in nucleic acids and other
slowingof metabolismprior to dormancy.The resultsdescribed phosphorus-containing compounds of developing wheat grain. Aust. J. Biol.
hereindicatethat removalof the ATP pool is not the mechanism Sci. 16: 332-341.
for such a reaction.An alternativemechanismmay be that syn- 12. MIHAILOVIC, M. L., M. ANTIC,ANDD. HADZIJEV.1965. Chemical investigation
of wheat. VIII. Dynamics of various forms of phosphorus in wheat during its
thesis of the stronglychelatingphytic acid (16) exerts an effect
oogenesis. The extent and mechanism of phytic acid decomposition in germinat-
on the cellularmetabolismby combiningwith multivalentcations ing wheat grain. Plant Soil 23: 117-128.
(19) which are known to play a significantpart in the control of 13. MORTON, R. K. ANDJ. K. RAISON. 1963. A complete intracellular unit for in-
many cellular processes,particularlythose involving phospho- corporation of amino acid into storage protein utilizing adenosine triphosphate
transferaseson which energymetabolismdepends(5). generatedfrom phytate. Nature 200: 429-433.
14. NAGAI, Y. AND S. FUNAHASHI. 1963. Phytase from wheat bran. Agr. Biol. Chem.
Acknowledgments-The author would like to thank Professor D. J. D. Nicholas for 27: 619-624.
his continuous encouragement throughout this work and the Australian Common- 15. NEGVOGOROVA, L. A. ANDN. M. BORIsOVA.1967. Trigger mechanism of ger-
wealth Wheat Industry Research Council, who gave generous financial assistance. minating seeds. Soviet Plant Physiol. 14: 65-71.
Thanks are also due to Miss P. Lim of this departmentfor a gift of purifiedwheat bran 16. POSTERNAK, T. 1965. The Cyclitols. Holden-Day Inc., San Francisco. p. 223.
phytase and to Mr. Geoffrey Clarke for skillful technical assistance. 17. RIJVEN, A. 1964. Distribution of phosphorus during wheat grain development.
Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 17: 572-574.
LITERATURE CITED 18. SAMOTUS, B. ANDS. SCHWIMMER. 1962. Phytic acid as a phosphorus reservoirin
the developing potato tuber. Nature 194: 578-579.
1. ASADA,K. AND Z. KASAI. 1962. Formation of myo-inositol and phytin in 19. SEN,T. L. N. ANDA. M. ALTSCHUL.1967. Isolation of globoids from cotton-
ripening rice grains. Plant Cell Physiol. 3: 397-406. seeds aleurone grain. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 121: 678-684.
2. ATKINSON, M. R. AND R. K. MORTON. 1959. In: M. Florkin and H. S. Mason,
20. SOBOLEV, A. M. ANDM. A. RODIONOVA.1966. Phytin synthesis by aleurone
eds., ComparativeBiochemistry, Vol. 2, Part 1. Academic Press, New York.
3. BARTLETT, G. R. 1959. Phosphorus assay in column chromatography. J. Biol. grain in ripening sunflower seeds. Soviet Plant Physiol. (Eng. Transln.) 13:
958-961.
Chem. 234: 466-468.
4. BISWAS,S. AND B. B. BISWAS. 1965. Enzymatic synthesis of guanosine tri- 21. STANLEY,P. E. AND S. G. WILLIAMS. 1968. Use of the liquid scintillation spec-
trometerfor determiningadenosine triphosphateby the luciferaseenzyme. Anal.
phosphate. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 108: 710-713.
5. BYGRAVE, F. L. 1967. The ionic environment and metabolic control. Nature Biochem. 29: 381-392.
214: 667-671. 22. STREHLER,B. L. AND J. R. TOTTER. 1952. Firefly luminescence in the study of
6. GALANOS,D. S. AND V. M. KAPOULAS. 1966. A rapid method for the determina- energy transfermechanisms. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 40: 28.
tion of organic nitrogen and phosphorus based on a single perchloric acid deter- 23. TATE,M. E. 1968. Separation of myo-inositol pentaphosphates by moving
mination. Anal. Chim. Acta 34: 360-366. paper electrophoresis. Anal. Biochem. 23: 141-149.
7. HALL, J. R. AND T. K. HODGES. 1966. Phosphorus metabolism of germinating 24. WEIL-MALHERBE,
H. AND R. H. GREEN. 1951. The catalytic effect of molybdate
oat seeds. Plant. Physiol. 41: 1459-1464. on the hydrolysis of organic phosphorus bonds. Biochem. J. 49: 286-292.