Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Reasoned Document and preparation of Draft of SCADA specification after incorporating the comments/suggestion received
from SCADA Vendors. M/s Synergy Systems & Solutions, Faridabad, M/s ASHIDA, M/S ITI & ABB, Bangalore offered comments
on the draft SCADA specification displayed on RDSO web site.
5.3.3 RTU shall support Separate transducers The RTUs can The energy
Maximum Demand for V, I, PF perform a transducers having
(Apparent power) measurement should calculation on real- window period of
calculation based be avoided for MD time values and 15 minutes shall
on 5 to 60 calculation. Energy send it to control be used. Energy
minutes window meters can be used center on real time meter on HV side
periods based on instead which can give basis. The historical provided at TSS
inputs received very accurate MD storage and can be used for
from reading. Also, we calculations on MD value by
energy/power believe that HT-side historical values are interfacing with
transducers. The metering should be part of SCADA RTU through
value of MD shall considered for MD software functions. RS485.
be reported to calculation as that Hence, if these Methodology of
RCC after each would match better calculations are time
window period. with EB meter. required (based on synchronization
Current location of the MFMs capability between EB meter
CT/PT inputs for MD to send these and TSS meter
calculation has always values on MODBUS) shall be explored
been a contention they may be and implemented
when comparing with included in SCADA by SCADA vendor
EB readings. Also, if section. for matching the
possible, so method of MD. Location of
ensuring time CT/PT may not be
synchronization same for EB and
between EB meter and TSS meters.
TSS meter should be
ensured?
5.3.5 RTU firmware Since IEC101 protocol File formats may File formats
shall be capable of over serial links will be be submitted. Not document shall be
being reconfigured used, remote interoperability. submitted along
(under password configuration of RTUs with design/
control) locally will have to be carried drawings of SCADA
from the out through SCADA to RDSO for
laptop/portable using file transfer approval.
programming function. And since
device and from each vendor will have
the Central Master their own format,
Station by using interoperability
RTU Maintenance between SCADA and
Software. SCADA RTU of different
tenderer vendors will be
shall furnish difficult.
authentic copies of
RTU firmware in
CD/DVD to the
purchaser.
5.3.6 The RTU shall This will also be a Vendor-specific
have self- vendor-specific implementation of
monitoring/diagno implementation of diagnostic
stic for fault diagnostic functions, functions shall be
conditions. This as there is no the part of design
shall provide standard procedure drawings
various details defined in IEC101. submitted for
such as status of approval.
ROM, data bus, The following
RAM check, incorporated-
battery low, SCADA vendor
defective cards shall submit the
etc. The RTU details of specific
should generally diagnostic function
support the test to RDSO at the
procedures as per time of design
standard protocol document and
IEC 60870-5-101. drawing approval.
5.3.8 RTU At least 32 bit a. Purpose of RJ45 We recommend RJ-45 meant for
ARCHITECTURE- processor should be ports: Refer clause RDSO to implement Ethernet
TECHNICAL specified. Otherwise 5.3.8, two RJ45 IEC 60870-5-104 connectivity. The
DETAILS low quality products ports are indicated and 61850 based same is not
Processor: As can easily qualify. for CPU card. Refer relays and modify required as the
approved in chapter-4, where the specification protocol shall be
design. Non- Non-Volatile Memory: RS232 port is accordingly. as per IEC-60870-
Volatile Memory: 512 MB indicated for 5-101. However
512 MB It should It should be changed communication one number of RJ-
be changed to to 128MB and battery purpose. Clarity 45 port
128MB and backed RAM for shall be brought for incorporated as
battery backed events shall be the purpose of two suggested by M/s
RAM for events separately specified. RJ45 ports in CPU ITI.
shall be separately card. Also the Memory size as
specified. +/- 1ppm accuracy indication of per M/s ITI should
protocol IEC-60870- be 16 MB. The
Optical isolation 5-104 in the clause memory size may
should be specified for 5.3.8 is missing with be decided by the
comm. ports. Surge respect to RJ45 SCADA vendor as
Clock: +/- 3ppm protection level 3 port. Even if the per their design
accuracy compliance should be RJ45 port is for requirement and
specified future use, the should submit the
Communication same shall be details in BOM at
Ports: IEC 61850 protocol for indicated as one the time of design
. relay integration over RJ45 port along with drawing approval.
Ethernet should also an external Ethernet
be specified as Power Hub at RTU.
Sector throughout b. Memory: Refer
India has already clause 5.3.8. The
moved to this protocol RAM (128MB) and
for communication Flash (512MB) sizes
with protection relays. indicated for CPU is
very high and also
overkill. The same
may be limited to
16 MB or less for
CPU card, which will
provide sufficient
memory for SCADA
RTU applications.
Anti-chatter : Brief explanation to
algorithm be included
DO Card: DO Card: Not acceptable
General: On It should emphasize
receipt of that this function be
command from implemented using
master station hardware interlocking
using the select in DO module.
check before- Software
execute operate implementation should
(SCBO) sequence; not be allowed.
the appropriate
control output
shall be operated
for a preset time
period which shall
be adjustable.
AI Card: Please clarify that card Incorporated. AI
type is AC AI Card to card can be used
be used for sensing PT for sensing PT and
inputs. the same
incorporated as
AI card to be
used for PT/CT
inputs.
5.5.3 (i) Voltage (Each Accuracy of primary Not accepted
phase to neutral parameters, i.e., V, I
and should be 0.2%,
phase to phase) = derived instantaneous
0.5% parameters
(ii) Current (each (Active/Reactive
phase) = 0.5% Power etc.), 0.25%,
(iii) Active Power, and accumulated
Reactive power, energy values 0.8%
Apparent Power = Auxiliary power can
0.5% / 1% also be of voltage
(iv) Import & level compatible with
Export Energy the output of Power
(active/reactive) = Supply installed in the
1% / 2% RTU, e.g., 24VDC.
(v) Power Factor
(measuring range)
=
0.5 lag to 0.5 lead
(vi) Auxiliary
Power supply =
110 V DC