You are on page 1of 3

Brief Report

Development and Clinical Outcomes of a


Dialectical Behavior Therapy Clinic

Travis Lajoie, M.D.


Joshua Sonkiss, M.D.
Anne Rich, M.D.

Objective: The authors describe the rst 6 months of a dialec-


tical behavior therapy (DBT) clinic operated by trainees in a
general adult psychiatry residency program. The purpose of this
B orderline Personality Disorder (BPD) is a severe and
persistent mental disorder, with a prevalence of ap-
proximately 4% in the community and as high as 20% in
report is to provide a model for the creation and maintenance of clinical psychiatric populations (1). It is a condition char-
a formalized resident DBT clinic.
acterized by emotional dysregulation and behavioral dys-
control, with high rates of self-harm, poor quality of life,
Methods: Residents participated in the DBT clinic, attended a
weekly combined lecture series and consultation group super- and behaviors that interfere with therapy. An estimated
vised by the clinic director, and completed a 20-hour online 69% to 80% of individuals with BPD attempt suicide, and
Continuing Medical Education course in DBT skills training. 10% complete suicide (10). BPD is associated with heavy
utilization of psychiatric services; medical complications;
Results: Eight residents participated in the clinic, each carrying involvement in divorce, libel, and childrearingrelated
one patient with Borderline Personality Disorder. The clinic did lawsuits; violence, and sexual indiscretions (2). The public
not experience any major administrative problems during 6
health costs of this disorder are still unknown, but are
months of operation.
believed to be tremendous (3).
Conclusion: A Resident DBT Clinic was successfully imple- BPD is the only major psychiatric disorder for which
mented as an elective rotation in the adult psychiatry residency psychosocial interventions remain the primary treatment
training program at the University of Utah. (1). Outpatient Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) is one
treatment supported by randomized, controlled studies
Academic Psychiatry 2011; 35:325327 demonstrating superiority over treatment-as-usual for pa-
tients with BPD (4). DBT was evaluated initially in a 1991
randomized trial and follow-up and assessed subsequently
in eight published randomized, controlled trials across ve
separate research centers (4). The evidence from these
studies has consistently demonstrated reductions in sui-
cidal behavior, suicidal ideation, and frequency of inpa-
tient hospitalizations, along with improved treatment re-
tention (4 6).
Despite the proven effectiveness of DBT as a major
approach to the treatment of borderline personality disor-
der, there is lack of standing presence in the treatment of
BPD in most psychiatric training curricula. A literature
Received December 22, 2009; revised April 30, May 26, 2010; accepted review of the PubMed database for resident DBT clinics
May 27, 2010. From the Dept. of Psychiatry, University of Utah School produced two articles, each of which described the dif-
of Medicine, Salt Lake City, UT. Correspondence: Anne Rich, M.D;
Anne.Rich@hsc.utah.edu (e-mail). culty of implementing DBT-based treatment in a training
Copyright 2011 Academic Psychiatry environment and the need for greater exposure to DBT

Academic Psychiatry, 35:5, September-October 2011 http://ap.psychiatryonline.org 325


DIALECTICAL BEHAVIOR THERAPY CLINIC

training during residency to increase the likelihood of its in person for 24 hours after the self-harm behavior oc-
use upon graduation (3, 8). curred. Patients could contact other members of the DBT
In order to improve resident psychotherapy training in team during this time period, as described by Linehan in
DBT, psychiatry residents and clinical faculty at the Uni- her model (6).
versity of Utah developed a DBT clinic that began oper- DBT therapists and skills-group leaders met weekly for
ation in January 2009. The purpose of this report is to consultation group.
describe an innovative model that may be used by other
residency programs for the creation and maintenance of a
Implementation
formalized resident-run DBT clinic that incorporates both
The DBT clinic was integrated into the existing resident
academic and clinical teaching and provides needed clin-
psychotherapy clinic. Participation in the DBT clinic was
ical services to high-risk patients with personality disor-
strictly voluntary for residents. The clinic utilized existing
ders.
administrative infrastructure in the resident psychotherapy
clinic. Because existing facilities and administrative re-
Method
sources were utilized, no additional administrative ex-
penses were incurred. No departmental funding was re-
Design
quested or provided. DBT Clinic patients were required to
The University of Utah Resident DBT Clinic was de-
pay the same nominal fee charged to all resident clinic
signed to adhere as closely as possible to the model de-
patients for each individual therapy session. No additional
scribed in Linehans classic text, Cognitive-Behavior
fee was charged for the weekly skills-group meetings.
Therapy of Borderline Personality Disorder (6). Skills-
Senior residents at the University of Utah are required to
training groups were designed around the four skill mod-
carry a minimum number of psychotherapy patients, and
ules described in Linehans Skills Training Manual for
the proposal was worded such that DBT patients would
Treating Borderline Personality Disorder (7). The follow-
count toward the required total caseload in the resident
ing key principles were incorporated into our clinic:
clinic. Also, the clinic required two residents to lead the
Referrals were initially screened by a clinician trained
DBT skills-group for 75 minutes per week. For skills-
in DBT. Acceptable referrals met criteria for BPD.
group leaders, the proposal stipulated that the skills-group
No medications were prescribed in the clinic, as patients
would count as one patient in their required caseload.
received medications from other providers.
Patients who passed the initial screening were expected
to sign a 6-month treatment contract stipulating required Supervision and Training
attendance at both individual therapy sessions and skills- Residents who participated in the DBT clinic were re-
training sessions every week. sponsible for obtaining 1 hour of one-on-one supervision
Patients agreed that all therapists and skills trainers per month from a faculty member for each patient. Also,
involved in the DBT clinic would be actively involved in they were required to attend a weekly combined lecture
their treatment and would have access to their personal series and consultation group supervised by the clinic di-
health information. rector. Furthermore, DBT clinic participants were ex-
Patients agreed that if they missed more than three pected to purchase and read Linehans Cognitive-Behavior
consecutive therapy and/or skills-training groups, DBT Therapy of Borderline Personality Disorder (6) and Skills
would be terminated for the duration of their 6-month Training Manual for Treating Borderline Personality Dis-
contract, after which they could negotiate a new contract if order (7). All of the original participants in the resident
desired. DBT clinic completed a 20-hour online CME course of-
The DBT contract permitted patients to contact their fered by Behavioral Tech, LLC (9). Residents who at-
individual therapists for telephone consultation and skills- tended the 6-month lecture series, completed the online
coaching during and outside of normal clinic hours, with a CME course, completed 6 months of therapy with a pa-
goal of 24-hour telephone coverage. There was no require- tient, and passed a nal written exam administered by the
ment of 24-hour telephone coverage, which differs from clinic director received a letter of certication as a DBT
the original Linehan model (6). therapist. To evaluate the DBT curriculum, residents took
Patients who engaged in self-harming behavior were not a pre-test before beginning the course and a post-test at the
permitted to contact their individual therapist by phone or completion.

326 http://ap.psychiatryonline.org Academic Psychiatry, 35:5, September-October 2011


LAJOIE ET AL.

Results in an adult psychiatry residency program. All eight psy-


chiatric trainees completed the 6-month lecture series and
Eight residents participated as individual therapists online skills-training through Behavioral Tech, LLC, and
and/or skills-group leaders during the rst 6 months of the all passed the post-seminar evaluation. The combined av-
clinic. Each individual therapist was assigned one DBT erage post-test scores were signicantly higher than the
patient. Residents post-test scores signicantly improved combined averaged pre-test scores, suggesting that both
from pre-test scores. The average score on the pre-test was the lecture series and online training were effective edu-
3/20, or 15% correct, whereas, on the post-test, the scores cational tools in improving resident knowledge in DBT. A
had improved to 19/20, or 95%. letter of certication in DBT was also granted to each
The clinic did not experience any major administrative psychiatric trainee who participated in this elective rota-
problems during the rst 6 months of operation. Some tion.
staff members initially expressed concerns about the po- In conclusion, a resident DBT clinic has been success-
tential for undue burden on administrative staff, but these fully developed and implemented as an elective rotation in
burdens never materialized. Obtaining ongoing funding the adult psychiatry residency training program at the Uni-
for online DBT skills-training and certication, however, versity of Utah. Further sources of potential funding are
remains a challenge. being explored to replace the Medical Scholars grant that
covered the costs of the online skills-training. Clinical
Discussion outcome data are also being collected to analyze psychi-
atric trainees efcacy in treating individuals with BPD
This Brief Report was designed to outline the creation
with manualized DBT.
and implementation of a resident DBT clinic within an
existing residency curriculum to improve the educational References
quality and application of DBT among psychiatric train-
ees. Psychiatric trainees completed pre-tests and post-tests 1. Kernberg OF, Michels R: Borderline personality disorder.
to evaluate the DBT curriculum. The resident DBT clinic Am J Psychiatry 2009; 166:505508
was also established to provide an innovative model for 2. Gunderson JG: Borderline personality disorder: ontogeny of
a diagnosis. Am J Psychiatry 2009; 166:530 539
improving and implementing DBT training in other psy- 3. Sharma B, Dunlop BW, Ninan PT, et al: Use of dialectical
chiatric residency programs. behavior therapy in borderline personality disorder: a view
The resident DBT clinic at the University of Utah was from residency. Acad Psychiatry 2007; 31:218 224
successfully implemented into an existing residency train- 4. Linehan MM, Comtosis KA, Murray AM, et al: Two-year,
ing curriculum by: 1) utilizing the physical space and randomized, controlled trial and follow-up of dialectical be-
havioral therapy vs. therapy by experts for suicidal behaviors
administrative staff of a designated resident psychotherapy
and borderline personality disorder. Arch Gen Psychiatry
clinic to minimize additional costs; 2) taking advantage of 2006; 63:757766
a Medical Scholars grant to afford the fees associated 5. Linehan MM, Armstrong HE, Saurez A, et al: Cognitive-
with the online skills training through Behavioral Tech, behavioral treatment of chronically parasuicidal borderline
LLC; 3) offering the seminar during non-didactic and pre- patients. Arch Gen Psychiatry 1991; 48:1060 1064
clinic hours, to minimize interference with required clin- 6. Linehan MM: Cognitive-Behavioral Treatment of Borderline
Personality Disorder. New York, Guilford, 1993
ical duties; and 4) limiting this psychotherapy elective to 7. Linehan MM: Skills Training Manual for Treating Borderline
postgraduate Year 3 and 4 psychiatry trainees, who were Personality Disorder. New York. Guilford, 1993
familiar with the standard operations of the resident psy- 8. Fredrick JT, Comtois AC: Practice of dialectical behavioral
chotherapy clinic. These steps enabled a time-intensive therapy after psychiatry residency. Acad Psychiatry 2006;
and manualized therapy such as DBT to be incorporated 30:63 68
9. http://behavioraltech.org/ol/details.cfm
with minimal disruption into a standing psychiatric cur-
10. McMain SF, Links PS, Gnam WH, et al: A randomized trial
riculum. of dialectical behavior therapy versus general psychiatric
The resident DBT clinic appeared to be successful in management for borderline personality disorder. Am J Psy-
improving the educational quality and application of DBT chiatry 2009; 166:13651374

Academic Psychiatry, 35:5, September-October 2011 http://ap.psychiatryonline.org 327

You might also like