Professional Documents
Culture Documents
REFERENCES
Linked references are available on JSTOR for this article:
http://www.jstor.org/stable/3510218?seq=1&cid=pdf-reference#references_tab_contents
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/
info/about/policies/terms.jsp
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content
in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship.
For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Religious Research Association, Inc. and Springer are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to
Review of Religious Research.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 142.58.129.109 on Wed, 30 Dec 2015 17:04:50 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RESEARCH AND COMMENTARY 287
ments on an earlier version of this paper. However, sion and the negative reactions was not explicitly
the author alone is responsiblefor any inadequacies. sought. Therefore,the subjectsmay have had sufficient
1. This name was not used by any studentbut has timefortheirbeliefsto grow strong.
been adopted by the author for convenience in this
report. The firststudent chosen and interviewedhad 3. Some subjects also reported improved relation-
made me aware of the existence of Crusade House ships with parents following conversion.
when he visited my officeduring proselytizingactivi-
ties. Interviewswere then conductedwith seven addi- Glock, Charles and Rodney Stark
tional residentswho were available when I visited the 1965 Religion and Society in Tension. Chicago, Ill.:
House for this research purpose, these ending with Rand McNally.
the close of the Fall term. The single individualwho Gordon, Albert
refusedto be interviewedwas a residentwhose sched- 1967 The Nature of Conversion. Boston, Mass.:
Beacon.
ule did not allow time to complete the interviewon
the day he was present. The Crusade staff member Lofland,John
was chosen to maximize informationabout the House 1966 Doomsday Cult. Englewood Cliffs,N.J.: Pren-
and to provide variation in the length of time since tice-Hall.
the beginningof the conversionexperience. Seggar,Johnand Phillip Kunz
2. Two subjects who were asked about the reac- 1972 "Conversion: evaluation of a step-likeprocess
tions of friendsto their conversionmentionednegative for problem-solving."Review of Religious Re-
reactions.However, the elapsed time between conver- search 13 (Spring, 1972): 178-184.
RuthA. Wallace
GeorgeWashington
University
Abstract
This articlearguesthatDurkheim'semphasison civil religion,especiallyon an inter-
nationallevel,and his emphasison the importanceof the public schools in the imple-
mentationof civil religionare importantthemesin Durkheim'swork whichhave not
been givenadequate due. Some largelyneglectedDurkheimiansourceson thesethemes
are presentedand discussed.
Althoughhe never used the term "civil citationin 1973 and Bellah's citationin his
religion,"Durkheim'swritingsreveal that he introduction in 1973 (p. 229, fn. 111) are
saw patriotismas the civilreligionof modern the only references to it whichI have found
society. The purposesof this paper are to in my research on Durkheim's work on
indicatehis emphasison thecivilreligioncon- education. As one of the last five or six
cept and to reveal some little-knownwritings pieces of writingpublishedbeforehis death,
of Durkheimwhich provide importantevi- I thinkit deservesto be resurrected; and it
dence concerninghis espousal of the civil is crucialto thepresentdiscussion.
religion. Durkheim'sbelief in national solidarity
through secular education comes through
loud and clear in "The School of Tomorrow"
DURKHEIM AND CIVIL RELIGION whenhe says(1919:188):
This content downloaded from 142.58.129.109 on Wed, 30 Dec 2015 17:04:50 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
288 REVIEW OF RELIGIOUS RESEARCH
in this result, since its pupils representthe ma-
We can, therefore,
the issue of nationalismversusinternational-
jorityof theschoolpopulation.
withperfectcertainty concludethat it has per- ism,Durkheimplaces a priority on thelatter;
formedits taskwell. and he insiststhat nationalismshould be a
It is no wonder,then,thatBellah (1973b: stepping-stone to internationalism.
x) labels Durkheimas a "highpriestand the- Earlierin his careerDurkheimhad stressed
ologianof the civil religionof the ThirdRe- the importanceof secondarygroupsfor the
public" because Durkheim'snationalismwas integration of the individualinto the larger
more than evident in his writings,in his society. I would suggest that Durkheim's
teaching,and in his own patrioticactivities emphasison patriotism was akin to a stress
duringWorld War I. What Bellah adds to on anotherformof intermediate group.What
Durkheim's title is extremelyinteresting,Durkheimwas proposingwas that the na-
though it may seem inconsistentwith the tion as intermediate group should integrate
wordsjust quoted fromDurkheim.He says its membersinto the larger societyof the
that Durkheim is also a "prophetcalling universeand thatnationalinterests could not
not onlymodernFrance but modernWestern be self-serving. My contentionis that Durk-
societygenerallyto mendits way in the face heim became all the more convincedof the
of a greatsocial and moralcrisis."How Durk- need to reconcile national patriotismwith
heim can maintainthe titles of priest for world patriotismas he witnessedthe conse-
France and prophetfor Westernsocietyis quences of Germany'snationalism. I can
one of themainconcernsof thispaper. findproof of this in anotherexcerptfrom
GermanyAbove All which was written,as
Durkheimexplains,on the veryday the news
NATIONAL CIVIL RELIGION: of the Lusitania outragewas received. He
A STEPPING-STONE says (1915a:45):
As we have seen, Durkheimwas a strong ern There is no State so powerfulthat it can gov-
eternallyagainst the will of its subjects and
supporterof French nationalism. On the force them, by purely external coercion, to sub-
mit to its will. There is no State so great that it
otherhand, Germany'sbrand of nationalism is not mergedin the vaster systemformedby the
repelledhim; this is not surprising, for it is agglomerationof other states, that does not, in
other words, formpart of the great human com-
a counterpartof his own endorsementof munity,and owe respectto this. There is a univer-
conscience and a universalopinion, and it is
Frenchnationalism.In a pamphlethe wrote sal no more possible to escape the empire of these
duringWorldWar I, entitledGermanyAbove than to escape the empire of physical laws; for
they are forces which react against those who
All, Durkheim not only criticizedGermany's transgressthem; a state cannot subsist when all
behaviorduringthewar buthe also expressed humanityis arrayed against it.
his horrorat the Germancontemptof inter-
national law. He clearly labels Germany's INTERNATIONAL CIVIL RELIGION:
nationalismas immoralpreciselybecause he A MAJOR EMPHASIS
saw it as a returnto a sortof tribalor pagan
moralitywhich assumed that (1915a:3, 23- As earlyas 1898,in an articleentitled"In-
24) "humanitywas confinedto the tribe." dividualismand the Intellectuals"(Bellah,
Here Durkheimarguesthat civilizednations 1973:43-57), Durkheimstatedhis preference
must go beyondthe tribalor nationallevel; for a universalcivil religion.He called it a
and theymusthave as a "primaryobjectthe "cult of man" or the "religionof humanity,"
realizationof humanity" whichplaces human and he saw it replacingotherreligions.He
interestsovernationalinterests. picturedthis cult as addressingitself"to the
To be consistentwith his own patriotic human person (la personnehumaine) wher-
efforts,DurkheimmustrejectGermany'sna- ever it is to be found,and in whateverform
tionalism;but what is of interesthere is the it is embodied."This he sees as an extended
reason Durkheim gives for his rejection. form of individualism,springingnot from
What he arguesis not thatall nationalismis egoism,but from"sympathyfor all that is
immoralbut thatthe typeof nationalismhe human."
sees in Germany's National Socialism is Durkheim'sanxietyabout the consequen-
regressive, chieflybecause it closes the door ces of excessiveegoismhad been articulated
to internationalism. Ratherthanside-stepping in Suicide. In his search for a remedy for the
This content downloaded from 142.58.129.109 on Wed, 30 Dec 2015 17:04:50 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
RESEARCH AND COMMENTARY 289
This content downloaded from 142.58.129.109 on Wed, 30 Dec 2015 17:04:50 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
290 REVIEW OF RELIGIOUS RESEARCH
curred so soon afterthe end of a war in could have expectedDurkheimto have elab-
which he himselfhad been so deeply in- oratedon what he saw as the ultimategoal,
volved. Had he lived well beyond 1918, we an international
civilreligion.
Paul R. Voss
Department of RuralSociology
of Wisconsin
University at Madison
This content downloaded from 142.58.129.109 on Wed, 30 Dec 2015 17:04:50 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions