Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Materials
csd
Center for Sustainable Development
UTSoA - Seminar in Sustainable Architecture
Cody Fithian
Andrea Sheets
Fig. 01 Survey conducted by National Geographic and international polling firm Globescan to 17,000 consumers on a variety of
issues measuring their eco-friendliness.
1
UTSoA - Seminar in Sustainable Architecture
However all of the programs weigh likely to choose materials with these
the importance of these issues ratings. This is because they want
differently and consequently their efforts to be widely recognized,
establish their own unique checklists. and they automatically trust these
The decision of which matters companies since everyone else
are more important to a specific seems to think they are superior.
label often stems from the desires
of sponsors and investors. If a Four of the largest and most
labeling program receives funding recognized green labeling programs
from another organization, they are:
will unfairly rate that organizations LEED
products as greener than the really Energy Star
are. Green Globe
Green Seal
Corruption in the green labeling
industry makes it difficult to discern Each are administered by different
which are the most credible and organizations, have their own rating
trustworthy programs. Knowing who criteria and focus most heavily on
is behind the labeling is the first step different issues. By looking at all
in uncovering truly green materials. four of these, one can begin to see
overlaps and shortcomings. One
Although there are many green can begin to develop a more holistic
labeling programs in America, there approach to defining a true green
are really only a handful that are material.
well-known. Builders are more
2
Green Building Materials
3
es What LEED delivers What LEED Is What LEED Measures What
How LEED
to get delivers
started How to get started
UTSoA
point scale, and - Seminar
credits are weighted in reflect
LEED points
to Sustainable
aretheir
awarded Architecture
on a environmental
potential 100-point scale, and credits
impacts. are weighted
Additionally, to reflect their potential environmental impacts. Additionally, 10 bonus
10 bonus
creditsissues.
dress regionally specific environmental are available,
A projectfour of satisfy
must which address regionallyand
all prerequisites specific
earn aenvironmental issues. A project must satisfy all prerequisites and earn a minimum number
minimum number
of points to be certified.
Think
box of crackers: LEED provides the of kind
same it likeofthe nutritiondetail
important label about
on a box
the of crackers:
green LEED
aspects of aprovides
buildingthe same kind of important detail about the green aspects of a building that,
that,
mance. taken together, deliver higher performance.
Think of
n a box of crackers: LEED provides it same
the like the nutrition
kind label on
of important a box
detail of crackers:
about the greenLEED provides
aspects the same
of a building kind of important detail about the greenpoints
that, aspects ofas buying
a building that, 50% of your energy
4
Green Building Materials
Energy Star To be rated, you submit data about assembly plants, cement plants,
your building. This information and corn refineries
Definition includes total square footage, Municipal Water Treatment
A government backed number of occupants, number Plants
organization focusing on of computers, location, etc. A
improving energy efficiency computer than takes this data and To determine if a building qualifies to
Administered by the US formulates a figure that would be be Energy Star rated, fifty percent of
Environmental Protection the optimal energy spending. This the gross square footage (excluding
Agency and the US Department is derived from data gathered garages/parking) must belong to one
of Energy by the Department of Energys of the above categories.3
Standards for Energy Star rated Energy Information Administration.
buildings are set by the EPA Then your building is evaluated in Problems with Energy Star
comparison to this data and ranked
Their motto is Energy-efficiency among its peers. The top twenty Although Energy Star takes a strict
comes first. Founded in 1992, five percent in each building type approach to cutting down on energy
Energy Star began as a labeling category receive the Energy Star use therefore reducing greenhouse
program that only rated consumer label. gas emissions and saving money,
products. Products like household it fails to look at materials in depth.
appliances and air conditioning units Currently Energy Star has ratings for They are really only focused on the
with the Energy Star label now save the following building types: way that the end product performs
between twenty and thirty percent of in relation to energy savings.
energy. Bank/financial institutions, Whatever means needed to be
courthouses, hospitals (acute taken to get a product a certain way,
Buildings can receive an Energy care and childrens), hotels and even if extremely harmful to the
Star Label too. To qualify they motels, K-12 schools, medical environment, would be dismissed
must reduce the amount of energy offices, offices, residence by Energy Star. Plus there have
needed to operate and cause less halls/dormitories, retail stores, been reports that the organization
carbon dioxide emissions than other supermarkets, and warehouses sometimes uses loose and outdated
buildings of the same type. (refrigerated and non- standards and lets companies rate
refrigerated) their own products.4
Rating System and Criteria Industrial Facilities: automobile
Fig. 07 Energy Star Logo Fig. 08 Statewide participation rates in the Energy Star program.
5
UTSoA - Seminar in Sustainable Architecture
6
Green Building Materials
Green Seal Green Seal Environmental materials that are claimed to be the
Standards greenest are missing at least one of
Definition Construction Materials, these attributes. Here are just a few
a non-profit, third party certifier Equipment and Systems of such cases:
and standards development Facility Operations, Maintenance
party and Services Bamboo
the largest U.S.-based Hospitality, Lodging and Food
ecolabelling organization Service Usually used as flooring, this is
the U.S. member of GEN (Global Home Products and Services the material that all architects
Ecolabelling Network), which Office Products and seem to turn to for a quick addition
consists of 26 of the worlds Communications of sustainability to their designs.
leading ecolabelling programs Personal Care and Consumer However, bamboo is not always the
develops standards from green Packaged Goods greenest choice. Although it is a
cleaning products to lodging rapidly renewable product, the forest
Conditionally Green Materials that it comes from is sometimes not.
Green Seal uses life cycle In order to ensure this materials
assessment, evaluating products green credibility, it needs to come
The majority of available green
from raw materials extraction to from a FSC source.7
products have one or more
manufacturing and use to disposal or of the following health and/or
recycling. If a product meets Green In general, a better and greener
environmental attributes:
Seal standards, it will be awarded flooring material would be rammed
Promote good indoor air quality
the Green Seal. This organization earth. It is just as strong and durable
(typically through reduced
works with the marketplace in an as concrete and its source can be
emissions of VOCs)
effort to create a more sustainable at the immediate site. It has ninety
Durable and require little
world.6 percent less embodied energy than
maintenance
Incorporate recycled content concrete also.8
(post-consumer and/or post-
industrial) Insulated Concrete Forms (ICF)
Have been recycled from
existing or demolished buildings These are stackable blocks of
Are made using renewable expandable polystyrene which
resources are filled with concrete and re-bar
Have low embodied energy as needed. They are strong and
extremely well insulated cutting
Do not contain
down on energy costs greatly.
Chlorofluorocarbons,
They also get rid of the necessary
Hydrochloroflurocarbons or other
wood formwork traditionally used in
ozone depleting substances
poured concrete forms. However,
Obtained from local resources
the polystyrene is a fossil fuel based
and manufacturers
product and could contain VOCs.
For wood or bio-based products,
These are extremely harmful to a
Fig. 11 Green Seal Logo. they employ sustainable
persons health. There is an ICF
harvesting practices
made from recycled wood chips
Recyclable
called Durisol, and this would be
Biodegradable
the best choice for an ICF wall.9
However not many, maybe even
none at all, carry all of these
characteristics. Even some
7
UTSoA - Seminar in Sustainable Architecture
The name says it all. Low VOC These are wall panels comprised
is better for the environment and of rigid foam insulation sandwiched
everyones health. However this between two pieces of oriented
label is misleading. In order to be strand board. They can have
considered Low VOC, the paint insulative values up to R-60. This
must contain less than 250 grams high value saves energy and
per liter of the compound. However money. However, they are usually
many companies count the grams not made of green materials. Some
per liter before the pigment is added, companies are now using bio-based
which has a large amount of VOC in materials, but others still used
it as well. So these really arent what expanded polystyrene, which as
they claim to be. The best option for in ICF can contain VOCs and be a
paint is a Zero VOC paint.10 health and environmental hazard.12
Fig. 12 Insulated Concrete Forms. Fig. 13 Recycled Denim Insulation. Fig. 14 Structurally Insulated Panels.
8
Green Building Materials
9
UTSoA - Seminar in Sustainable Architecture
Glossary of Green Terms and harvesting as well as certain naturally produce and no more. This
social and economic criteria for provides future generations with the
When reading about green materials, workers. assurance of these resources.
certain terms appear quite frequently.
This is a greatly summarized list of Greenwashing: The practice of Volatile Organic Compound: V.O.C.
some of those terms.13 companies disingenuously spinning An organic chemical compounds that
their products and policies as have high enough vapor pressures to
Carbon Footprint: A measure environmentally friendly. vaporize and enter the atmosphere.
of an individuals impact on the They can come from methane,
environment in terms of the amounts Greenway: Undeveloped linear formaldehyde, office equipment
of greenhouse gases produced, open space usually set in cities, set
measured in units of carbon dioxide. aside and used for recreation or
conservation. Greenways can be Recyclable vs Green vs
Carbon Sink: A natural or man- used to created connected networks Sustainable Materials
made reservoir that accumulates of open space that include traditional
and stores some carbon-containing parks and natural areas. Recyclable: A material that can be
chemical compound for an indefinite used again.
period. Major examples are oceans, Half-life: The time required for a
forests and landfills. pollutant to lose half of its effect on Green: A material that has at
the environment. least one positive environmental
Chlorofluorocarbon: CFC; an organic characteristic.
compound that contains carbon, Post-Consumer Recycled Material:
chlorine and fluorine. Most widely reclaimed waste product that has Sustainable: A material that meets
found in refrigerants and aerosols, already served a purpose to a the needs of the present without
when released into the air these consumer, and has been diverted or compromising those of future
compounds lead to ozone depletion. separated from waste management generations.
collection systems for recycling.
Embodied Energy: The available Example: used newspaper that
energy that was used in the work is made into cellulose building
of making a product. This is an insulation.
accounting methodology which aims
to find the sum total of the energy Pre-Consumer Recycled Material:
necessary for an entire life cycle A material that is removed from
process. production processes (including
scrap, breakage, or by-products)
Forest Stewardship Council: FSC; and reused in an alternative process
A non-profit organization which before consumer distribution.
promotes responsible management Example: mineral (slag) wool, a
of the worlds forests. It sets by-product of the steel blast furnace
standards and independently process, used for mineral fiber
certifies and labels forest products acoustical ceiling panels.
10
Green Building Materials
7.-12. Discovery Communications, Green Figure 13: Instructables, Make, How To, Reference 10 Big Room, Inc. Whos Deciding
Materials Guide, Planet Green, http://www. and DIY, www.instructables.com, accessed Whats Green? Ecolabelling.org. www.
planetgreen.discovery.com, accessed October October 2009. ecolabelling.org. Accessed October 2009.
2009.
Figure 14: Sustainable Design Update Blog, Reference 11 Green Globe International,
13. Richard E. Saunier and Richard A. Me- 10 Tips for Building a Sustainable Home, Inc. Green Globe. www.greenglobe.org.
ganck, Dictionary and Introduction to Global www.sustainabledesignupdate.com, accessed Accessed October 2009.
Environmental Governance (London: TJ October 2009.
International Ltd., 2009).
References
Figures
Reference 01 U.S. Environmental Protection
Figure 01: National Geographic and Glob- Agency and Green Power Partnership.
eScan, Greendex: Survey of Sustainable Glossary. U.S. Environmental Protection
Consumption, National Geographic, http:// Ageny. http://www.epa.gov/greenpower/pubs/
www.nationalgeographic.com/greendex/#, ac- glossary.htm. Accessed October 2009.
cessed October 2009.
Reference 02 Saunier, Richard E., and
Figure 02: Big Room, Inc., Whos Deciding Richard A. Meganck. 2009. Dictionary
Whats Green?, Ecolabelling.org, www.ecola- and Introduction to Global Environmental
belling.org, accessed October 2009. Governance. London: TJ International Ltd.
Figure 03: U.S. Green Building Council, Reference 03 Hands-on-Guide and Building
LEED, www.usgbc.org/LEED, accessed Intelligence Group. Green Building Dictionary.
October 2009. Hands-on-Guide. http://www.green-building-
dictionary.com. Accessed October 2009.
Figure 04: U.S. Green Building Council,
LEED, www.usgbc.org/LEED, accessed Reference 04 U.S. Environmental Protection
October 2009. Agency and U.S. Department of Energy.
Energy Star. U.S. Environmental Protection
Figure 05: U.S. Green Building Council, Agency. http://www.energystar.gov. Accessed
11