Professional Documents
Culture Documents
295
Hiew et al.
unaffected by GBS. It is the most common and We defined hyponatraemia as serum sodium
important electrolyte disorder encountered in crit- levels 133 mmol/l occurring at any time during
ical care units (7). Admission serum sodium levels the first 3 weeks of inpatient stay. Patient demo-
have been found useful together with plasma glu- graphics, total duration of inpatient stay, inten-
cose and white cell count, in predicting inpatient sive care admission and length of stay in
mortality as well as mortality in community pop- intensive care, Medical Research Council (MRC)
ulations with chronic conditions (8), while several sum score at admission and discharge, were
more recent studies have since highlighted the ascertained. In addition, use of diuretics, concur-
independent value of hyponatraemia in predicting rent malignancy, preceding diarrhoea, cranial
mortality in various patient populations. In GBS, nerve and autonomic involvement, sepsis, use of
hyponatraemia has been associated with disease intravenous immunoglobulin (IVIg) pre-dating
severity and death in few studies with indepen- hyponatraemia, presence of antiganglioside anti-
dent associations being mostly unconfirmed, par- bodies and summated compound muscle action
ticularly regarding muscle strength outcomes. potential were also determined.
There are otherwise, to our knowledge, currently Statistical analyses were performed using SPSS
no recent data on frequency and correlates of 22.0 software (SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA).
hyponatraemia in patients with GBS from Eur- Fisher exact tests were used for comparison of
ope or North America. proportions. Spearmans rank correlation with
The objectives of our study was first to retro- 2-tailed analysis was used to search for associa-
spectively determine the incidence and determi- tions. We, in addition, performed, as appropriate,
nants of hyponatraemia in GBS and secondly multivariate logistic regression analyses to deter-
ascertain the relationship with severity of muscle mine the eventual independent determinants of
weakness at hospital discharge, in our tertiary hyponatraemia as well as of the primary outcome
UK. Neuromuscular centre over a 5-year period. of our study, predefined for the purposes of this
Other relevant intercorrelations were performed. retrospective analysis, as the MRC sum score at
We also aimed to conduct a systematic review of discharge, in our cohort. P values <0.05 were
the literature regarding the frequency and signifi- considered as significant.
cance of hyponatraemia in GBS. Findings were We also performed a systematic literature review
then analysed in the context of recent literature on hyponatraemia in GBS, as per the standard
on hyponatraemia in other conditions. guidelines for systematic literature reviews outlined
in the PRISMA statement (3). We conducted a
Medline search of all original articles published
Materials and methods
between 1966 and February 2015 with the search
We retrospectively reviewed our institutional data- MeSH terms GuillainBarre syndrome, acute
base of patients admitted with a diagnosis of GBS inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropa-
between 2007 and 2012 (University Hospitals of thy, acute motor axonal neuropathy, acute
Birmingham, UK). The diagnosis was made in motor and sensory axonal neuropathy, acute
each case in accordance with established clinical motor conduction block neuropathy, AIDP,
criteria (5). Patients with Miller Fisher syndrome AMAN, AMSAN, AMCBN, hyponatraemia,
(MFS), or incomplete MFS, as well as with natraemia, sodium, syndrome of inappropriate
acute-onset chronic inflammatory demyelinating ADH secretion and SIADH. For meaningful
polyneuropathy (CIDP), were excluded. MFS or analysis of frequency and associations, we included
incomplete MFS was defined as the full or incom- only articles describing series of at least 20
plete triad of ataxia, ophthalmoplegia and areflex- patients.
ia, without associated limb weakness (9). Acute-
onset CIDP was defined by a characteristic clinical
Results
picture of GBS with subsequent progression
beyond 9 weeks and/or with more than 3 episodes We included 48 consecutive patients (32 males, 16
of deterioration (5, 10). This work, which was part females) with a clinical diagnosis of GBS admit-
of a larger retrospective analysis of clinical, biolog- ted during the study period of 20072012. Mean
ical and electrophysiological features of GBS at age was of 55.7 years (SD: 16.05). Mean length
our institution, was a registered and approved ret- of inpatient stay was 40.4 days (range 4217).
rospective Clinical Audit by our relevant institu- Concurrent malignancy was present in 5/48
tional board (CAD-05169-13, University Hospitals (10.4%) patients, 5/48 (10.4%) were diabetic, and
of Birmingham). Ethics committee approval was 15/48 (31.25%) were hypertensive. Nine patients
not required. (18.75%) required mechanical ventilation.
296
Hyponatraemia in GBS
r = 0.336;
P = 0.026
point during the first 3 weeks of inpatient stay
in 18/48 (37.5%) patients. In 10 cases, this was
mild (130133 mmol/l), and in 8, moderate/sev-
ere (<130 mmol/l). In 10/18 patients (55.5%),
hyponatraemia occurred after IVIg therapy.
r = 0.493; P = 0.001
Main findings of correlation analyses and logistic
Lowest FVC
regression are summarized in Tables 1 and 2.
NS
Significant correlations were ascertained between
hyponatraemia with age >50 years (Spearmans
rho: 0.363; P = 0.011), concurrent malignancy
(Spearmans rho: 0.299; P = 0.039), diuretic use
NS
score at discharge (MRCSSD) (Spearmans rho:
r=
0.336; P = 0.026). No correlations were found
between hyponatraemia and bulbar weakness,
0.32; P = 0.034
ophthalmoplegia, autonomic dysfunction, pres-
Summated CMAP
ence of antiganglioside antibodies or mechanical
ventilation. There was no significant correlation
with MRC sum score on admission (MRCSSA)
NS
(Spearmans rho: 0.19; P = 0.217). Significance
r=
was not reached for a correlation with facial
weakness (P = 0.072) or summated CMAP
P < 0.001
r = 0.628;
(P = 0.113). Logistic regression showed that only
NS
concurrent malignancy (P < 0.001) and diuretic
use (P < 0.001) independently predicted hypona-
traemia. Excluding diuretic use from the analy-
sis, we found that age >50 years and malignancy r = 0.294; P = 0.042
Preceding diarrhoea
r = 0.488;
at discharge
297
Hiew et al.
Table 2 Logistic Regression analysis results of the independent associations of Hyponatraemia and MRC Sum Score at Discharge in 48 patients with GuillainBarre
syndrome from Birmingham, UK, admitted between 2007 and 2012
(Spearmans rho: 0.346; P = 0.016), but not with There has been to date a single prospective
age >50 years. Significance was approached for study of presence of hyponatraemia in GBS (3).
correlations with MRCSSA (P = 0.061) and bul- This study from Kerala, India, evaluated 50
bar weakness (P = 0.065). patients with GBS and found that using a cut-off
We retrieved from our systematic literature of <135 mmol/l, 24 (48%) had SIADH. However,
review, a total of 4 articles which had descrip- only 18/50 (36%) had moderate or severe
tions of incidence and correlates of hypona- hyponatraemia (<130 mmol/l). The authors used
traemia in 20 patients with GBS (3, 6, 9, 10). chi-square and Students t-tests for statistical
The reviewed articles are summarized in Table 3. analysis. Admission and discharge MRC sum
All four studies analysed frequency of hypona- score were significantly poorer in hyponatraemic
traemia in GBS. Three of those also evaluated subjects who had bulbar weakness and needed
the correlates of hyponatraemia. mechanical ventilation significantly more fre-
An initial descriptive study of management and quently. Subjects with SIADH had longer stays
outcome of 79 UK patients with GBS found in hospital and were deemed to need plasma
25.3% had hyponatraemia (11). Somewhat exchange more frequently. Age >50 years,
against the hypothesis of implication of mechani- mechanical ventilation, bulbar weakness, but also
cal ventilation, this series had an unusually high hyponatraemia, were said to be significantly asso-
rate of respiratory involvement, of 73.4%. ciated with mortality. Again, timing of death was
The first large retrospective analysis dedicated not specified. The Fisher exact test result compar-
to the study of hyponatraemia in GBS, which ing mortality in the SIADH vs the non-SIADH
included in a total cohort of 84 subjects, patients group, calculated from data provided in the
with MFS, was that from Christchurch, New paper, gave a P value 0.045. Independent associa-
Zealand (6). This study described hyponatraemia tions of any of these factors with muscle strength
<133 mmol/l in 26/84 patients (31%). Hypona- at discharge or with mortality were not available.
traemia was present prior to any therapeutic The largest study to date is the latest published,
intervention in 7/26 (26.9%, 12.5% of total from northern China. This was a retrospective anal-
cohort) and was considered by the author to be, ysis published in Chinese (12). The authors studied
in these patients, purely GBS related. However, 455 patients (283 males, 172 females) seen between
12/26 (46.1%) had experienced hyponatraemia 2003 and 2012, mean age 44.5 years, amongst
after treatment with IVIg, suggesting pseudohy- whom 61 (13.4%) had been mechanically ventilated,
ponatraemia as a frequent contributing factor. In and 322 (70.7%) treated with IVIg. A total of 98
8 of those 12 patients, there was a well-docu- patients (21.5%) had hyponatraemia <135 mmol/l.
mented progressive decrease in serum sodium Exclusion criteria described were varied and in some
matching the IVIg infusion. In 7, the cause was cases insufficiently detailed including other neuro-
potentially multiple and complex with hypona- logical illness, poor oral intake, use of diuretics,
traemia occurring in contexts of positive pressure thyroid, adrenal, liver or kidney impairment,
ventilation and/or plasmapheresis, multiple drug paraneoplastic syndrome, past illness resulting in
therapy, jejunostomy, parenteral nutrition. Using weakness, difficult to differentiate from GBS, and
Fisher exact tests, the author described a signifi- incomplete data or absence of tested sodium levels.
cantly greater number of deaths in hyponatraemic Number of exclusions for the latter reason was not
patients (P = 0.001), although mortality was also specified. Chi-square and logistic regression meth-
associated with age >50 years (P = 0.007) and ods were used. Correlates of hyponatraemia were
mechanical ventilation (P = 0.002). Timing of age (P < 0.001), MRC sum score on admission
death was not specified. The conclusion of this (P < 0.001), MRC sum score at nadir (P < 0.001),
study described strong inter-relationships between facial weakness (P < 0.001), respiratory muscle
these 3 factors, but independent effects were not weakness (P < 0.001), bulbar weakness (P < 0.001)
evaluated. and pneumonia (P < 0.001). Only age (P = 0.014),
298
Hyponatraemia in GBS
Not ascertained
Not applicable
mechanical ventilation (P = 0.992). Hyponatraemia
(1) Age >50
(3) Hyponatraemia
(3) Hyponatraemia
Death
Discussion
Correlations
Not studied
Table 3 Previous studies of hyponatraemia in GuillainBarre syndrome from systematic review of the literature 1966-February 2015
4 (5.1)
4 (8)
6 (7)
25.3
48
31
14.47
33
455
50
84
79
(Retrospective)
(Prospective)
Ng et al. (11)
299
Hiew et al.
GBS. Iatrogenic causes are common as demon- There was no correlation of mortality with
strated by the independent link with diuretic use hyponatraemia in our series. The reasons for this
in our series. The post-IVIg pseudohypona- may be multiple and, besides sample size, could
traemias are related to a dilutional and usually also include selection bias, and the study period
asymptomatic phenomenon (15). Excluding these, which was limited to inpatient stay within our
our study and that of Colls (6), both demon- institution. Interestingly, one recent study of
strated a similar frequency of hyponatraemia patients with heart failure showed in a cohort of,
about 1 in 6. We found that hyponatraemia was similarly of older subjects with more comorbidities,
more common in older patients, in keeping with that hyponatraemia did not predict mortality as to
data from all 3 other studies. We, like Colls (6), opposed to in other patient groups (18), suggesting
but unlike Saifudheen et al. (3) and Wang and these factors may influence the role of hypona-
Liu (12), failed to demonstrate an association of traemia on outcome, at least in the short term.
hyponatraemia with mechanical ventilation. We, Global results from all studies performed to date
on the other hand, not unexpectedly, found con- in GBS, however, favour an association of hypona-
current malignancy and diuretic use as indepen- traemia with mortality, with an independent associ-
dent predictors of hyponatraemia. As regards ation demonstrated by Wang and Liu (12).
occurrence in context of known malignancy, our Recent literature in relation to hyponatraemia
patients importantly had typical GBS of demyeli- in other disorders is extensive. The largest retro-
nating or axonal subtypes, without associated spective study of >151,000 intensive care patients
common antineuronal antibodies to indicate, con- showed a similar prevalence of hyponatraemia of
firming a paraneoplastic phenomenon. Interest- 17.7% to that of most of the GBS studies and
ingly, we only found age to be an independent demonstrated that it represented an independent
predictor of hyponatraemia when we excluded predictor of hospital mortality (19). A large
use of diuretics from the analysis, similar to prospective point prevalence study of >13,000
Wang and Liu (12). In a cohort with many exclu- participants also showed a comparable rate of
sions, including lack of adequate records, these hyponatraemia in intensive care patients (12.9%),
authors described, besides age, facial weakness confirming it as an independent predictor of mor-
and mechanical ventilation as independently asso- tality (20). Hyponatraemia has also been recently
ciated with hyponatraemia (12). Although the been found to be present in 16% of a large
relationship with age and positive pressure venti- cohort of >3000 patients with ischaemic stroke,
lation may have a pathophysiological basis, the as well as represent a predictor of acute mortality
independent link with facial weakness is more dif- (21). Similarly, a large inpatient study of >50,000
ficult to comprehend. Facial weakness is patients has shown very frequent relative hypona-
described more commonly in post-CMV GBS traemia <138 mmol/l in admitted patients reach-
(16), although we are not aware of a link with ing 38.2%, with again independent association
hyponatraemia in these cases. with mortality for community hyponatraemia and
We found, as in 2 of the other studies (3, 12), hospital-acquired hyponatraemia (22). Likewise,
a correlation of hyponatraemia with MRC score. in a population-based cross-sectional U.S. study
Timing of the MRC score, however, differed in of >14,000 subjects, hyponatraemia prevalence
between studies. Interestingly, both of these was of 1.72% but it represented a predictor of
other two studies found that hyponatraemia cor- death independent of age, gender and comorbid
related both with MRC sum score on admission conditions (23).
and at discharge or nadir. The former correla- These data demonstrate that hyponatraemia
tion would importantly suggest greater disease occurs at fairly similar frequencies in different
severity in hyponatraemic patients at onset, hospitalized patients and is an independent pre-
rather than hyponatraemia itself altering the dictor of death in all, including probably, asymp-
neurological disease course and ultimately result- tomatic individuals. The limited data on GBS,
ing in poorer functional outcome. We were our- mainly due to its low incidence, are confirmatory
selves unable to find a correlation with of comparable rates, between 16% and 25%,
MRCSSA but found one with MRCSSD. As excluding the non-IVIg induced, outlying higher
also previously described by others, (17), we rate of 48% found in the Indian study. Hypona-
ascertained an independent association between traemia similarly appears a mortality predictor in
MRCSSD and MRCSSA but not with hypona- GBS as shown in other disorders, in three of four
traemia. Independent associations of strength studies performed to date. The mechanisms impli-
and hyponatraemia were not confirmed by Wang cated in the higher mortality risk remain
and Liu either (12). unknown, and hyponatraemia may be a surrogate
300
Hyponatraemia in GBS
marker for other unknown risk factors (24). controlled treatment trials in patients with neurological
There is importantly no evidence of independent diseases. Muscle Nerve 1997;20:11027.
5. LENHARD T, GRIMM C, RINGLEB PA. Renal salt wasting
implication of hyponatraemia on strength and as part of dysautonomia in Guillain-Barre syndrome. J
functional prognosis in GBS from studies per- Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry 2011;82:10513.
formed so far and the findings of the above-men- 6. COLLS BM. Guillain-Barre syndrome and hyponatraemia.
tioned studies in other disorders also plead Intern Med J 2003;33:59.
against this. 7. PATEL GP, BAULK RA. Recognition and treatment of
hyponatremia in acutely ill hospitalized patients. Clin
In conclusion, although well described in recent Ther 2007;29:21129.
years and often in practice specially monitored in 8. ASSADOLAHI K, HASTINGS IM, BEECHING NJ, GILL GV.
patients with GBS, hyponatraemia appears a non- Laboratory risk factors for hospital mortality in acutely
specific, possible surrogate marker of underlying admitted patients. QJM 2007;100:5017.
disease severity (19), unrelated to GBS directly. 9. WAKERLEY BR, UNCINI A, YUKI N, GBS Classification
Group, GBS Classification Group. Guillain-Barre and
Discounting pseudohyponatraemia caused by Miller Fisher syndromesnew diagnostic classification.
IVIg, it appears no more frequent in GBS than in Nat Rev Neurol 2014;10:53744.
hospitalized patients with other acute or critical ill- 10. RUTS L, DRENTHEN J, JACOBS BC, VAN DOORN PA, Dutch
nesses. There is accumulating evidence that GBS Study Group. Distinguishing acute-onset CIDP
hyponatraemia is a predictor of mortality in all from fluctuating Guillain-Barre syndrome: a prospective
study. Neurology 2010;74:16806.
inpatients, including those with GBS. Whether this 11. NG KK, HOWARD RS, FISH DR et al. Management and
is specific to certain GBS patient groups is outcome of severe Guillain-Barre syndrome. QJM
unknown and requires further study. The mecha- 1995;88:24350.
nisms implicated are uncertain, but there may be 12. WANG Y, LIU J. The relationship between hyponatraemia
additive effects contributing to death. In GBS, and the prognosis of Guillain-Barre syndrome. Chin J
Neurol 2013;9:597600.
these may be in addition to underlying autonomic 13. SAKR Y, ROTHER S, FERREIRA AM et al. Fluctuations in
dysfunction. There is, however, currently no evi- serum sodium level are associated with an increased risk
dence for hyponatraemia as independent predictor of death in surgical ICU patients. Crit Care Med
of neuromuscular prognosis in GBS as assessed by 2013;41:13342.
motor strength. 14. TZOULIS P, EVANS R, FALINSKA A et al. Multicentre study
of investigation and management of inpatient hypona-
traemia in the UK. Postgrad Med J 2014;90:6948.
Acknowledgements 15. STIEHM ER. Adverse effects of human immunoglobulin
therapy. Transfus Med Rev 2013;27:1718.
We thank the Clinical Audit Office and Informatics at the 16. ORLIKOWSKI D, PORCHER R, SIVADON-TARDY V et al.
Queen Elizabeth Hospital, Birmingham, UK, for their help Guillain-Barre syndrome following primary cytomegalo-
with this work. virus infection: a prospective cohort study. Clin Infect
Dis 2011;52:83744.
17. WALGAARD C, LINGSMA HF, RUTS L, VAN DOORN PA,
Conict of interests STEYERBERG EW, JACOBS BC. Early recognition of poor
prognosis in Guillain-Barre syndrome. Neurology
None Declared in relation to this work. 2011;76:96875.
18.
LORIDO JC, GOMEZ JC, FORMIGA F et al. Hyponatremia
as predictor of worse outcome in real world patients
Funding admitted with acute heart failure. Cardiol J 2013;20:506
None. 12.
19. FUNK GC, LINDNER G, DRUML W et al. Incidence and
prognosis of dysnatremias present on ICU admission. In-
References tensive Care Med 2010;36:30411.
20. VANDERGHEYNST F, SAKR Y, FELLEITER P et al. Incidence
1. COOPER WC, GREEN IJ, WANG SP. Polyradiculopathy and prognosis of dysnatraemia in critically ill patients:
(Guillain-Barre syndrome) with immunologic features analysis of a large prevalence study. Eur J Clin Invest
suggestive of neural hypersensitivity and with hypona- 2013;43:93348.
tremia: report of a case. Rep U S Nav Med Res Lab 21. RODRIGUES B, STAFF I, FORTUNATO G, MCCULLOUGH LD.
1963;15:17. Hyponatremia in the prognosis of acute ischemic stroke.
2. POYART C, POCIDALO JJ. Hyponatremia with natriuresis J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis 2014;5:8504.
conserved due to disorder of elimination of free water in 22. WALD R, JABER BL, PRICE LL, UPADHYAY A, MADIAS
the course of Guillain-Barre syndrome. Rev Fr Etud Clin NE. Impact of hospital-associated hyponatremia on
Biol 1964;9:106871. selected outcomes. Arch Intern Med 2010;170:294302.
3. SAIFUDHEEN K, JOSE J, ABDUL GAFOOR V, MUSTHAFA M. 23. MOHAN S, GU S, PARIKH A, RADHAKRISHNAN J. Preva-
Guillain-Barre syndrome and SIADH. Neurology lence of hyponatremia and association with mortality:
2011;76:7014. results from NHANES. Am J Med 2013;126:112737.
4. KOFFMAN BM, DALAKAS MC. Effect of high-dose intra- 24. HOORN EJ, ZIETSE R. Hyponatremia and mortality: mov-
venous immunoglobulin on serum chemistry, hematology ing beyond associations. Am J Kidney Dis 2013;62:139
and lymphocyte subpopulations: assessments based on 49.
301