Professional Documents
Culture Documents
S
ince the Asian financial crisis in 1997, the the countrys own currency to affect its demand and
world has seen foreign currency reserves hold- supply; thus, helping maintain a stable value in the
ings in Asian countries skyrocket. China and international markets.
India rank as second and fifth in foreign currency This argument is valid mostly for emerging
reserve holdings in the world, respectively. Together, economies, whose debt is mostly denominated in for-
the Asian emerging countries comprise approximate- eign currencies and would be greatly affect by deval-
ly 40% of all world foreign currency holdings uation. Devaluation would also affect the cost of
(Aizenman, 2003). The amount of reserves being inflated goods and raise inflation. This was the
held is one of the highest in history. Because of this, counter argument of the Indian Central Bank to the
it is interesting to examine the factors that are driving plan to use foreign exchange reserves domestically.
this increase in reserves. They argue that doing so
It is important to would fuel inflationary
examine why countries China and India hold approxi- pressures in the economy
would hold large amounts of and lead to instability
reserves. To that extent, mately 40% of the world for- (www.indiadaily.com).
there is an ongoing debate eign currency holdings. This argument describes the
on whether having large precautionary theory for
holding of international reserves, that is, to hold
reserves is beneficial or not. The critics main argu- reserves as a means of self-insurance in case of a
ment is that those resources could and should be used financial crisis.
in a more productive manner to develop the economy, Clearly, there are pros and cons to holding
such as investing in building roads, bridges and large amounts of foreign reserves. However, regard-
schools (Aizenman, 2003). In particular, the Indian less of whether reserves are being held as self insur-
Planning Commission Chairman announced on ance or as ways to manage the exchange rate system,
October 12th, 2004 the viability of using foreign there have to be variables that help determine the
reserves to finance local infrastructure projects. In optimum level. What this paper seeks to examine is
his opinion, since the reserves are enough to finance the effect that different exchange rate regimes have
17 months of imports (www.indiadaily.com), excess on reserve holdings. As I mentioned before, central
reserves should be used to finance projects that would banks are generally thought to hold stocks of foreign
help India eradicate poverty. reserves so their economies can avoid incurring the
On the other hand, those who support large cost of adjusting to every international imbalance that
holdings of reserves argue that the opportunity cost of would be transmitted to the domestic economy
holding the foreign reserves is small compared to the through changes in exchange rates (Batten, 1982).
economic consequences of sharp devaluation of the Under a fixed exchange rate system, reserve
currency (Aizenman, 2003). Reserves are held to holdings are expected to be larger, since they are nec-
influence the exchange rate of a currency and prevent essary to maintain the exchange rate stable. The rea-
GRAPH 1
Reserve Holdings in China and India 1980 -2003
4.50E+02
4.00E+02
3.50E+02
Billions of Dollars
3.00E+02
2.50E+02
china
india
2.00E+02
1.50E+02
1.00E+02
5.00E+01
0.00E+00
1980 1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003
Year
Aizenmann, J. and Marion, N. The High Demand Higgins, M. and Klitgaard, T. Reserve
for International Reserves in the Far Accumulation: Implications for
East: Whats Going On? Working Global Capital Flows and Financial
Paper, UC Santa Cruz and the NBER; Markets Current Issues in Economics
Dartmouth College, 2002 and Finance , 10, 2004
Batten, D. Central Banks Demand for Foreign India can use foreign reserves to fund projects
Reserves Under Fixed and Floating official. India Daily. October 14,
Exchange Rates, Federal Reserve 2004 <http://www.indiadaily.com/
Bank of St. Louis, 1982 breaking_news/10755.asp>
Disyatat, P. Currency Crisis and Foreign Reserves: Kapur, D. and Patel, U. Large Foreign Currency
A Simple Model Working Paper, Reserves: Insurance for Domestic
International Monetary Fund, 2001 Weaknesses and External
Uncertainties? Economic and
Fischer, Stanley. Opening Remarks for IMF/World Political Weekly, March 15, 2003;
Bank International Reserves: Policy 1047-1053
Issues Forum. Washington, DC, 2001
Kenen, P. and Yudin, E. "The Demand for
Flood, R. and Marion, N. Holding International International Reserves" The Review
Reserves in an Era of High Capital of Economics and Statistics, 47, 1965:
242-250