Professional Documents
Culture Documents
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Department of Business Administration, East West University Plot A/2, Jahurul Islam City, Aftabnagar, Dhaka
1212, Bangladesh
Abstract
In a developing country like Bangladesh, the growth of leasing industry signals a remarkable change in the source
of industrial and agricultural financing. As opposite to the traditional source of funds obtained from commercial
banks and stock markets, many large scale businesses have become more dependent on leasing companies to obtain
the required financing to continue business smoothly. Thus, the leasing business in Bangladesh has become more
and more popular day by day. The journey of leasing business has started in Bangladesh in the early 80s. After
commencement the leasing corporations play a vital role in the economic development of the country. Therefore an
attempt has been made through this study to explore the leasing industry in Bangladesh, by analyzing the financial
performance of selected leasing companies based on growth percentage and ratio analyses of some company specific
variables. Also the paper tried to shed light on the determinants of net profitability of the selected leasing
companies through regression analysis and thus tried to focus on the future prospects of leasing industry in
Bangladesh.
Introduction
Leasing in its simplest form is a means of with weak creditors rights and collateral laws
delivering finance, with leasing broadly defined as and registries, for instance, in countries where
a contract between two parties where one party secured lenders do not have priority in the case of
(the less or) provides an asset for usage to another default.
party (the lessee) for a specified period of time, in
return for specified payments. Leasing, in effect, With both leasing and bank financing involving
separates the legal ownership of an asset from the credit decisions and financial risks, the key
economic use of that asset. Leasing is a medium- differences are that two additional factors apply
term financial instrument for the procurement of to leasing companies: First, they have knowledge
machinery, equipment, vehicles, and/or of the asset (and often the industry), and hence
properties. Leasing provides financing of assets- are lending to some degree on an asset basis. This
equipment, vehicles-rather than direct capital. is different from collateral-based lending,
Leasing is based on the proposition that profits however, in that they are lending based on the
are earned through the use of assets, rather than ability of the asset to contribute to cash flow
from their ownership. It focuses on the lessees (either to the lessee or in case of forced
ability to generate cash flow from business sale/liquidation). Banks and other lenders tend to
operations to service the lease payment, rather look at the balance sheet value of collateral. The
than on the balance sheet or past credit history. second is that leasing companies are more sales
This is why leasing is particularly advantageous and service oriented-they are using their
for new, small and medium-size businesses that specialized knowledge to bridge the gap between
do not have a lengthy credit history or a suppliers and purchasers, and the specialized
significant asset base for collateral. Furthermore, knowledge of leasing companies may also give
the lack of a collateral requirement with leasing them an advantage in disposing of the
offers an important advantage in countries with repossessed leased assets. Suppliers are generally
weak business environments, particularly those not specialists in finance or credit decisions, while
Growth (%) - 0 0 0 0
4 United Leasing Company Ltd.(ULCL) 5 5 6 10 13
Growth (%) - 0 20 66 30
5 Peoples Leasing & Financial Services Ltd. (PLFSL) - 1 1 1 1
Growth (%) - 100 0 0 0
6 First Lease International Ltd. (FLIL) 2 2 2 2 2
Growth (%) - 0 0 0 0
7 Premier Leasing International Ltd.(PLIL) 1 1 1 2 3
Growth (%) - 0 0 100 50
Source: Annual Reports of Leasing companies of Bangladesh (2007-2011)
growth has been observed for branch expansion in
Table 1 shows the growth of branches. The growth 2007 which was reduced to 20% in the year 2010.
of branches was the highest in 2008 for PLFSL IDLC has the highest number of branches of 15 in
and in 2010 for PLIL, which was 100% in both the 2011. ULCL and PLIL did not increase their
year for both the companies. On the other hand, number of branches during 2007 and 2008, where
the growth of branches of BLIL, ILFSL, and FLIL in subsequent years they have opened up
were stagnate during 2007 to 2011. For IDLC 33% branches slowly.
Table 2 shows the growth of employees. IDLCs in 2009 which was almost 91%. It has been also
manpower strength was highest in 2011, which observed that BLIL, ILFSL, ULCL, PLFSL, PLIL
were 559. On the other hand, the highest growth faced declining growth rate in manpower strength
rate in manpower strength was observed by FLIL during the year 2008 and 2009.
Table 3 shows the growth of deposits. During amount of deposit was highest for IDLC, which
2007 to 2011 every year the deposit of IDLC, was BDT 17639 million in the year 2011, whereas
ULCL, PLFSL, FLIL and PLIL has been the highest growth in deposit was observed for
increased from the previous year. The total FLIL in the year 2011 which was 130.67%.
Table 4: Total Lease, Loan and Advances of Selected Leasing Companies of Bangladesh (Million BDT)
Table 4 shows the growth of lease, loan and the previous year in IDLC, BLIL, ULCL, PLFSL
advances by leasing companies of Bangladesh. It FLIL and PLIL. However, the growth rate pattern
has been observed from the table that in most of is not steady. It shows a fluctuating trend for the
the years during 2007 to 2011, disbursement of lease, lean and advances of the selected leasing
lease, loan and advances has been increased from companies in Bangladesh.
Table 5 shows growth of loan to deposit ratio of FLIL and PLIL have disbursed loan more than
leasing companies of Bangladesh. It has been two times of their deposit base. The highest loan
observed from the table that IDLC, BLIL, ULCL to deposit ratio was observed for FLIL in the year
has disbursed more than one and a half times 2007 which was more than four times.
loans compared to their deposits, whereas PLFSL,
Table 8: Total operating expenditure of selected leasing companies of Bangladesh (In Million BDT)
SN Name of Company Year
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
1 Industrial Development Leasing Company of Bangladesh 272 353 489 966 913
Ltd.(IDLC)
Growth (%) - 29.78 38.53 97.54 5.48
2 Bay Leasing & Investment Ltd.(BLIL) 12 14 32 44 56
Growth (%) - 16.67 128.57 37.5 27.27
3 International Leasing & Financial Services Ltd.(ILFSL) 920 1083 1365 1436 1933
Growth (%) - 17.72 26.03 5.20 34.61
4 United Leasing Company Ltd.(ULCL) 729 116 145 174 229
Growth (%) - (84.09) 25.00 20 31.61
5 Peoples Leasing & Financial Services Ltd.(PLFSL) 49 62 81 133 142
Growth (%) - 26.53 30.65 64.19 6.76
6 First Lease International Ltd.(FLIL) 109 145.5 145.2 141 249
Growth (%) - 33.49 (0.21) (2.89) 76.59
7 Premier Leasing International Ltd.(PLIL) 67 61 63 142 94
Growth (%) - (8.96) 3.28 125.39 (33.80)
Source: Annual Reports of Leasing Companies of Bangladesh (2007-2011)
was less than BDT 100 million whereas the
Table 8 shows total operating expenditure of amount exceeded more than BDT 100 million for
leasing company of Bangladesh. It has been other firms. The highest amount of operating
observed that the amount of total operating expenditure was incurred by ILFSL in the year
expenditure incurred by the leasing firms was 2011, which was BDT 1933 million.
significantly different. The amount of total
operating expenditure for BLIL, PLFSL and PLIL
Table 9: Total Operating Expenditure/Total Operating Income Ratio of Leasing Companies of Bangladesh
SN Name of Company Year
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
1 Industrial Development Leasing Company of Bangladesh
Ltd.(IDLC) 30.80 29.94 25.56 31.70 42.27
2 Bay Leasing & Investment Ltd.(BLIL) 9.76 25.00 16.49 3.29 7.19
3 International Leasing & Financial Services Ltd.(ILFSL) 88.89 85.68 81.64 63.18 92.79
4 United Leasing Company Ltd.(ULCL) 78.30 27.68 32.44 29.49 36.17
5 Peoples Leasing & Financial Services Ltd.(PLFSL) 17.95 15.05 13.55 9.59 13.84
6 First Lease International Ltd.(FLIL) 58.92 88.18 85.92 44.90 66
7 Premier Leasing International Ltd.(PLIL) 44.97 37.65 31.82 50.64 33.35
Table 10: Net Income of Leasing Companies of Bangladesh (In Million BDT)
SN Name of Company Year
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
1 Industrial Development Leasing Company of Bangladesh Ltd.(IDLC) 303 406 822 1327 500
Growth (%) 0 33.99 102.46 61.44 (62.32)
Table 10 shows the amount of net income earned their operation in the year 2011. However, the
by the leasing companies and their growth rate. It growth rate of the net income shows a fluctuating
has been observed that during 2007 to 2011, all trend for all the leasing companies. The highest
the leasing firms have experienced net profit from amount of net profit was earned by IDLC in the
their operation except ILFSL. ILFSL have year 2010 which was BDT 1327 million.
experienced a net loss of BDT 56.58 million from
Table 11: Earnings Per Share of Leasing Companies of Bangladesh (In BDT)
SN Name of Company Year
2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
1 Industrial Development Leasing Company of Bangladesh Ltd. (IDLC) 126.22 162.55 273.96 22.12 5.05
Growth (%) 22.02 28.78 68.54 (91.57) (77.17)
2 Bay Leasing & Investment Ltd. (BLIL) 77.31 44.14 76.78 11.2 2.77
Growth (%) 84.55 (42.91) 73.95 (85.41) (75.26)
International Leasing & Financial Services Ltd.(ILFSL) 59.25 44.68 70.49 6.74 (0.56)
Growth (%) 4.89 (35.39) (12.96) (90.43) (108.31)
3
4 United Leasing Company Ltd. (ULCL) 68.63 66.25 61.41 7.16 2.31
Growth (%) 16.95 (15.99) 5.93 (88.34) (67.73)
5 Peoples Leasing & Financial Services Ltd. (PLFSL) 40.33 35.53 4.94 7.47 2.76
Growth (%) (8.05) (22.07) 38.95 51.21 (63.05)
6 First Lease International Ltd. (FLIL) 59 53.38 45.3 3.45 1.64
Table 11 shows the earnings per share of the fluctuating trend. Only IDLC shows a consistent
leasing corporations of Bangladesh. It is observed pattern of their EPS and their EPS shows an
from the table there is no consistent pattern of increasing trend during 2007 to 2011. In 2009
EPS of all the selected leasing companies except IDLC has achieved highest growth rate of 68.59%
for IDLC. In most of the time during 2007 to 2011 for their EPS.
the EPS of all the leasing companies shows a
The beta coefficient as mentioned in Table15 also (and therefore the independent variables can be
justifies that all of the explanatory variable correlated). The other column under collinearity
becomes significant. relates to VIF variance inflation factor. It is
calculated as 1 /tolerance. As a rule of thumb, a
Having concluded that all our independent VIF of greater than 10 indicates a strong chance
variables have an impact on our dependent of collinearity.
variable, we need to understand if our
independent variables are correlated with each From the table, we can notice the variables
other. When independent variables are related DEPOSIT and LOAN both have a tolerance level
with each other, it represents multi-collinearity. below 0.10 and a VIF of greater than 10. For
In table 15, the last two columns relate to DEPOSIT, a tolerance value of 0.04 indicates that
collinearity. The first column defines tolerance. only 4% of the variation in DEPOSIT cannot be
Tolerance is measured as 1 R2 (where R2 explained by the other independent variables in
measures the amount of variance in the the model. Similarly for the variable LOAN, a
independent variable in the multiple regression tolerance value of 0.07 indicates that only 7%
explained by a combination of all the other variation in LOAN cannot be explained by the
independent variables). Therefore, a small value other independent variables. Hence, DEPOSIT
of tolerance (normally below 0.10) is a cause of and LOAN needs further investigation since they
concern since it signifies that a large part of the represent multi-collinearity.
variance in the independent variable can be
explained by the other independent variables
a
Colline arity Diagnos tics
Normally, any correlation coefficient more than retention packages of most of the firm under
0.7 or less than -0.7 is a cause of concern. As study (except IDLC) are not so attractive
mentioned above, we can see, there is correlation compared to banks. Skilled and trained human
between DEPOSIT and LOAN as well as resource is considered as an important component
correlation of OPEXP with DEPOSIT and LOAN for the development of any institution. Due to the
(however, to the contrary the table shows weak recent growth of leasing corporations, availability
correlation between OPINC with DEPOSIT and of experienced manpower is a challenge for this
LOAN). DEPOSIT and LOAN have a negative industry.
correlation of -0.837 (naturally, more loans, less
deposits and vice versa) while the correlation The supply shortage of efficient resource
between OPEXP with LOAN is 0.814 (more loans, personnel has been leading to a significant
more operating expenditure and vice versa) while increase in the compensation package, which is
with DEPOSIT the correlation coefficient is -0.764 also a cause of concern for leasing corporations.
(more deposit, less operating expenditure). All of The industry experts believe that although there
these variables are used to measure net income. remains enormous growth opportunity the market
However, because of multi collinearity, we cannot is still quite small and scope of work for skilled
measure the correct impact of changes in these personnel is very limited compared to that of
variables on net income that we could measure if banks. This makes the competent personnel to
we consider these variables individually to asses switch from leasing corporations to other
each of these variables impact on net income. institutions after a certain period implying low
retention rate of skilled human resource. If the
Findings and Conclusion
leasing firms can create systems which will
It is reflected from the analysis that almost every attract more talented and skilled workforce, then
year most of the companies under study have this industry can grow faster.
opened new branches. IDLC had the highest
number of branches in the year 2011, which were From the analysis it is reflected that the deposits
15. However, all the companies should open up of all the leasing companies under study has not
more new branches to provide more shown a steady growth rate. They are allowed to
comprehensive services to the entrepreneurs of take deposits directly from the public, as well as
Bangladesh. The leasing companies have created from institutions. According to the central bank
employment opportunities. However, from the regulation, leasing companies have the restriction
analysis we have found that both the leasing to collect public deposits for less than one year,
companies are still not able to attract the labor which creates uneven competition with banks as
pool that they supposed to. This is because still banks are also exploring the business
now peoples in Bangladesh are more familiarize opportunities created by leasing companies with
with traditional financial institutions like banks their lower cost of fund. In this study, we have
and a significant portion of fresh graduates prefer observed that BLIL and ILFSL had faced negative
to do jobs in banks compared to leasing growth rate under the period of study, but FLIL
companies. Another reason is their employee had faced a growth rate of 131% in the year 2011.