Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Meghan Birdsey
Post University
2017
PREVENTION OF HIGH ATTRITION RATES AT ONLINE COLLEGES 2
Abstract
Online higher education is well known for its high attrition rates when compared to
traditional universities. While online education has provided many students with the ability to
pursue and further their education while maintaining their busy schedule, many students do not
complete their degrees. Through the review of literature the various causes of high attrition rates
among online students were determined as well as possible solutions to this problem. Among
these causes were lack of student support, lack of community feeling, lack of preparedness, and
unclear understanding of an online classroom environment. This research assisted in the creation
of the deliverable for this capstone project. In order to collect data on preparedness of students a
webinar and presentation were created to be administered during the admissions process. This
webinar process would determine whether clearly set expectations helped to lowers attrition rates
Problem Statement
2015). With the growth and development of online education it is evident that there are many
challenges that still need to be addressed in order to lower attrition rates. Although many efforts
have been made to assist students in being successful in online programs, studies continue to
show that student attrition rates are between 3% and 5% higher than attrition rates at traditional
universities (Shaw et al, 2016). High attrition rates show that many students enroll in a degree
program but do not complete their degree. This causes students to accrue debt from a degree that
they did not finish and universities to have low graduation rates and a poor reputation from this
data. High attrition rates can be caused by lack of support offered to online students as well as
lack of preparedness.
High attrition rates can be caused by many factors in online education. According to
Boton & Gregory (2015) these factors include motivation, culture, and online pedagogies. Online
universities are working hard to lower their attrition rates based on data that has been collected.
The online student experience begins during the admissions process. Little focus has been placed
on the very beginning of a students experience but is rather pointed towards the support while
students are in classes. There is a strong relationship between the beginning of the process (i.e.
admissions) and the continuation of the college process (i.e. retention and advising). If all
than many positive changes can be made to this data. For example, if a week trial of a course is
implemented to better prepare students this could help lower student attrition rates. Throughout
this project, a focus will be placed on how the admissions and retention processes at online
universities can better prepare students and support students in order to lower attrition rates.
PREVENTION OF HIGH ATTRITION RATES AT ONLINE COLLEGES 4
Literature Review
Introduction
The world of higher education has taken a huge turn over the past twenty years. As
technology has advanced and changed, higher education has moved forward as well. Online
education or distance learning has grown in popularity during this time. Higher education has
become more accessible to all students because of this growth. Unfortunately, as online
education has become increasingly popular, it has also developed a bad reputation. Online
universities are well known for their high attrition rates. High attrition rates in these programs are
caused by many factors, some that can be controlled and others that cannot be controlled. The
question that comes to mind when talking about high attrition rates is how it relates to the
admissions and retention process and what can be done to change this trend among online
institutions. Those who work in the Admissions field in higher education take keen interest in
how to set students up for success and engage them so that they persist throughout their entire
degree. If students do not continue, they may not try a second time in earning their degree. There
are three main areas that have a direct correlation with high attrition rates: admissions, advising
and retention, and different methods for success. The admissions process is step one for all
students; this is where the tone is set for their entire time enrolled as students. Once enrolled in a
university, students should be working closely with advising to stay on track and most
importantly have a point-person that has their back. Students should also have access to different
services through Student Affairs to help create a cohesive and encouraging environment for
students. The literature that will be discussed details the causes of high attrition rates in each area
Admissions
When students decide they would like to pursue their education, the first step they take is
researching and applying to different institutions. The research process is the area in which
Admissions Counselors specialize in. When working with prospective students, Admissions
Counselors encounter students from all walks of life; this includes both traditional and non-
traditional students. These students have different educational, work, and personal backgrounds.
The job of a college admissions department is to ensure that each student is qualified before
admitting them to the program, this involves a throughout interview and examination of the
previous transcript.
university has a different enrollment process that a student must complete to be considered for
admissions into their desired degree program. Online colleges have lower expectations than what
is found at on campus institutions. This is due to the demographic of student that enrolls in an
online program. Admissions Counselors for online programs must take great care in assessing
each and every student's background and qualifications during this process to make sure they
will be a successful candidate. Studies have shown that evaluating a student's online readiness
utilizing a survey can help to enroll students who will persist (Doe et al, 2017). This type of
survey addresses retention factors such as can the student work individually, has the student
taken online courses before, how motivated is the student to earn their degree. According to Carr
(2014), online students are successful when they feel comfortable in an online environment. The
survey studied by Doe (2017) addressed questions that ensured students were comfortable in this
environment. Doe (2017) concluded that an online student's readiness is directly correlated to
their motivation and self-efficacy. A student that has not taken online courses compared to a
PREVENTION OF HIGH ATTRITION RATES AT ONLINE COLLEGES 6
student who has taken online courses before is much less prepared to be successful in their
chosen program (Doe et al, 2017). This is where setting expectations throughout the admissions
Once a student is admitted, Admissions Counselors must continue their relationship with
their students to make sure they are fully prepared for their classes. Preparing students for their
courses begin with setting the right expectations. Robichaud (2016) explains to readers that
students need to be guided to know exactly what will be expected of them. Robichaud (2016)
also suggests that these expectations need to be made clear in several different areas or locations
to get the point across. Regarding admissions, setting expectations includes explaining in detail
the course set up, deadlines, and time commitment associated with enrolling in online courses.
Online courses require students to be able to organize their time wisely, work on their own, and
stay motivated. According to Carr (2014) online students must be comfortable within the online
classroom environment. Carr (2014) also suggests that online training for students is essential to
preventing future problems and frustrations that may be encountered once the student is in class.
on their own. Proper preparation and training within the online classroom may make a significant
difference with many students. While setting expectations for students, Admissions Counselors
must also keep their students motivated while they wait to begin their classes. "The affective
dimension that affects motivation has been neglected in some eLearning developments, and
without it, it is difficult to create a good connection between learners and their online courses
(Boton, 2015, 64)." It is clear that a university's admissions department plays a clear role in
setting the tone for new students. This is where their journey begins, and they must have a full
PREVENTION OF HIGH ATTRITION RATES AT ONLINE COLLEGES 7
understanding of expectations to succeed in their courses. However, this is just the start, once
students enroll in and begin their classes they then work with faculty and staff.
Once students begin their classes, they are assigned an advisor to work with throughout
their entire time. Each university's advising department works in different ways but the main gist
of it is to provide students with support and direction during their degree program. Besides
advising, there are some different programs and services that are offered to students in order to
encourage persistence and success. With online degree programs, it is more of a challenge to
offer effective student support services because faculty and staff are not dealing with the students
in person. These areas directly affect students and their decision to continue with their courses.
Based on a study conducted by Wilging and Johnson (2009) there are several program-
related reasons for students who have dropped out of online degree programs. These reasons
include "too many low-level assignments, too difficult working on the group assignments, lack
of one-to-one interaction with the instructors and students, the academic program was too
difficult/demanding, and a lack of interested in the material or the program did not meet
expectations (Wilging and Johnson, 2009, 10)." Schroeder et al (2016) made similar conclusions
and stated that student retention rates are negatively affected by a lack of institutional support,
little to no connection made between the student, and their university, and the feeling of being
isolated. It is not only the onus of the faculty that are teaching students to maintain a connection
with students; it is also a responsibility of the student support services and advising to do so as
well. The admissions office makes a connection during the beginning of the process and this
connection must be maintained. Online students have little to no connection to their professors
PREVENTION OF HIGH ATTRITION RATES AT ONLINE COLLEGES 8
and peers because they present themselves through a computer rather than in a classroom. For
some students, this is a more inviting environment that allows more students to have a voice and
participate in class discussions, for others it is not as challenged as expected. Properly engaging
students "enables meaningful interactions between the student and internal and external factors
of learning, such as student participation, attention, and desire (Lee, 2015, 54)." Engagement also
allows students to be dependent on their studies. A student's autonomy is essential to the success
of an online student. (Lee, 2015) "Research has shown that students perceive autonomy in their
learning when the instructor supports their interests, preferences, values, and psychological needs
(Lee et al, 2015, 55)." Online students overall have a much different experience than on-campus
students would. Online students are often isolated from their peers and do not experience the
type of support that one would experience at your local university. Understanding and evaluating
this type of problem is essential to determining how to better serve online students and offer
more support. In this case, utilizing retention and advising to further engage students creates a
more welcoming and supportive environment for online students and rids them of the feeling of
isolation.
The admissions and retention processes at online universities are constantly developing.
Studies are being conducted, and data is being examined to determine where online universities
are missing when it comes to preparing and supporting their students. Many universities have
implemented different programs and procedures in hopes of lowering attrition rates and setting
students up for success. Studies suggest that there are several methods that will help institutions
in lowering attrition rates. These methods include expanding support systems offered to students,
giving an outlet for students to acclimate to their program and join the community, and
PREVENTION OF HIGH ATTRITION RATES AT ONLINE COLLEGES 9
strengthening the quality of communication between students, faculty, and staff (Carr, 2014).
Within the admissions processes, Doe et al (2017) suggest the use of a student readiness survey
based on a study conducted. This study utilized an online assessment survey that evaluated the
readiness of students to take on the responsibility of an online degree program. Along with this
survey, a widely popular online university currently utilizes an online mock trial of a class to
prepare students for their actual courses. This is something that Carr (2014) refers to in their
research. "The orientation must be easy to use, must be offered at the right time, and must be
specific to the learning management system being used. Some important factors to include are a
clear communication of the expectations of the student, clear instructions on using the LMS, a
chance to work out technology barriers, and how the course and its material are organized (Lee,
2014, 61-62)." Moody (2004) also suggests that connecting with students and walking them
through the technology needed prior to beginning classes would prevent issues in the future
when they are in class. Mannay and Wilcock (2015) conducted a study on student success and
what online students want. Based on their findings, online students have a busy schedule outside
of their school responsibilities. In order to better support these students, the authors suggest
providing students with an introductory packet of information that details what to expect once
they begin classes. This packet details a breakdown of course setup, resources, and different
ways to reach out for assistance (i.e. social media groups with other students, tutoring, advisors,
etc) These types of methods for success during the admissions process ensures that students
are qualified and fully prepared for their courses before they begin.
Within the retention processes, there are also many suggestions for how to lower attrition
rates and best serve students. Moody (2004) suggests requiring students to work in small groups
to further encourage participation and a higher level of thinking. This would also create more of
PREVENTION OF HIGH ATTRITION RATES AT ONLINE COLLEGES 10
a community environment while ridding students of the feeling of being isolated. Thorngren et al
(2013) studied the success of a yearlong mentoring program for their students. They experienced
overall positive feedback from their students and mentors however the program did have some
limitations in collecting data to reflect the success of this program. Matching students with
mentors online can be done in a video chat, phone call, or email format. Simply having someone
to support students and bounce ideas off of creates a more engaging environment, and again gets
rid of that feeling of isolation. If students begin their time in a degree program with a positive
experience, and that experience is upheld throughout their time in the program, then they will
continue to be successful. With online programs, in particular, starting off by qualifying student
and preparing them properly makes major contributions to their success later on in the program.
Conclusion
With the growth of online education, more and more universities are rushing to meet the
demands. Online programs are evolving as time goes on and establishing themselves to compete
with traditional universities. In this evolution, they are working to lower the attrition rates that
have plagued online programs from the beginning. Enrollment management departments are
made up of admissions and retention. These departments need to work together to establish a
positive, engaging experience for all students. From the information collected, there is a vast
amount of room for improvement within both areas. Admissions need to focus on better
qualifying and preparing students while retention needs to focus on keeping students engaged
and motivated.
PREVENTION OF HIGH ATTRITION RATES AT ONLINE COLLEGES 11
This capstone project focused on how to better prepare students for their academic career
during the admissions process. The end goal of this project was to collect data that further
supported the notion that preparedness of students helps to lower attrition rates at online
universities. For this capstone project, the population sample tested consisted of a group of
Admissions Counselors from an online university. These Admissions Counselors created a panel
of experts that reviewed the provided material to determine whether it will assist online students
in being successful. For this project, a mixed method approach will be used; this means that both
The first step in the development of this project was to determine the important points
that needed to be covered during the webinar. This webinar would be used to give prospective
students a brief walkthrough of the online classroom before their classes begin. The goal was to
create a ten minute long recorded video for Admissions Counselors to show their students. This
webinar was a walkthrough of the online classroom, examples of deadlines and assignments, and
resources available to students in the online classroom. The software used for this webinar was
Cisco Webex that is readily available to all Post University students. The focus of this program
was to introduce students to the online classroom before their first week of classes. This program
would allow students to see what they will experience on a week to week basis and also help to
set clear expectations from the beginning of the program to prevent drop outs and unearned
failures. In addition, students will also work with their Admissions Counselor during this process
even further to build a relationship and know that they have this additional type of support. As
evidenced below, students are shown resources such as Postone Portal, Office 365, Blackboard,
Once the webinar was in development, it was determined that a presentation would
accompany the webinar as part of the admissions process. This presentation overviews important
points for prospective students, information about Post University, and the next steps once a
student is able to register for their courses. As shown below, this presentation walks students
through important points to consider when researching colleges/universities, the steps for
prospective Post University students, and how to move forward once a student is registered in
their course and has completed the webinar with their Admissions Counselor.
PREVENTION OF HIGH ATTRITION RATES AT ONLINE COLLEGES 14
When a prospective student shows interest in the university and begins speaking with an
Admissions Counselor they will view the presentation. This presentation is geared towards
reviewing important information covered in the students Professional College Advisory Session.
Once the student is registered for their courses they will participate in the online webinar. The
webinar will review the online classroom and the other online resources for Post University
students. Coupled together, the presentation and webinar will set online students up for success
in their program by setting clear expectations and strict deadlines from the beginning.
PREVENTION OF HIGH ATTRITION RATES AT ONLINE COLLEGES 15
Introduction
While developing this capstone project, after some time it became clear that this is not
something I would be able to implement and use with my students. There are few reasons as to
why, but most importantly I would not be able to implement this project because of the many
factors that go into meeting compliance in higher education. For this reason, a self-assessment
rubric was created to help determine the effectiveness of this capstone project. Since the project
was not be implemented, it was be reviewed by a panel of experts from the higher education
field.
Self-Evaluation
Once this capstone project was completed, the researcher completed a grading rubric that
was based on the EDU 699 Capstone grading rubric. This allowed the researcher to determine if
their project met the requirements for this project including demonstrating the program learning
objectives, presenting the deliverable findings clearly, as well as ensuring that the contact of this
Overall this project was well thought out and had a lot of effort put into it to ensure that it
was held to high standards of academic integrity. A strength of this project was the amount of
research found to support the initial problem statement. The high attrition rates among online
universities have been researched and written about by many scholars and will continue to be
researched in the future. Within the field of education there will always be progress and changes
that require academics to follow suit and adapt to meet the needs of their students. Another
strength of this project was the opportunity to have it reviewed by admissions professional in the
online education field. Their feedback allowed the researcher to hone in on the areas that needed
to be focused on in the webinar itself. Their feedback was also essential in determining the
It is believed by the researcher that a weakness of this project is that it could not be
implemented and studied on prospective students. While professional feedback has many
benefits, seeing the results of how this webinar could potentially help students would have
potentially further supported the problem statement. It also would have been beneficial to have a
larger group of experts participate in the panel for this project. This would have provided the
researcher with a larger, possibly more varied amount of feedback on the webinar itself. Another
weakness of this project was in the implementation of the deliverable. While recording, the
researcher faced many technology errors that caused setbacks in the finalization of the
deliverable. With technology there is always a risk for possible hiccups and this project had
many of them. Along with the technical issues there also became the issue of content. The
webinar came out to be a nine minute presentation on how to navigate through the online
classroom however the researcher determined that this was not enough to prepare prospective
PREVENTION OF HIGH ATTRITION RATES AT ONLINE COLLEGES 18
students. A powerpoint was then created to accompany the steps of the admissions process that
Panel of Experts
A panel of experts was used to determine the effectiveness of this capstone project. This
panel consisted of five professionals from the higher education field. These experts have worked
in the college admissions field for more than two years. Over this time they have enrolled many
non-traditional and traditional college students into online degree programs. With their high level
of experience it was expected that their feedback would help to strengthen this project and also
collect honest and constructive feedback. After viewing this project, the panel was asked to
complete a questionnaire with specific questions on the effectiveness of the project. They also
were asked to provide open feedback. The questionnaire and feedback from the panel is included
below:
The results of this questionnaire determined that this project would be successful in
assisting prospective online students in preparing for their courses to come. The Panel of Experts
agreed that this webinar and presentation would prepare students for their degree program, build
a stronger relationship between the student and the school, and set the correct expectations for
incoming students. Based on the open feedback from the experts it was also determined that this
webinar would also help to familiarize Admissions Counselors with the online classroom,
allowing them to better assist their students in the long run. Overall the panel of experts agreed
PREVENTION OF HIGH ATTRITION RATES AT ONLINE COLLEGES 21
that this webinar is the type of progress that needs to be made in the online university admissions
This project has helped the researcher to learn more about student success methods being
used in higher education to help lower attrition rates. Online education is unfortunately plagued
with high attrition rates often due to the fact that students are not prepared enough when they
begin their courses. The amount of literature supporting the causes of high attrition rates at
online universities was great, just as the amount of information on how to prevent high attrition
rates was even greater. When this project began, the researcher was a member of an online
admissions team at Post University. The researcher was passionate about helping students
achieve their academic success, but more often than not their students did not retain past their
second or third module of courses. This is how this project came to fruition. The researcher has
since left Post University for a traditional on campus university and it is very apparent the
differences between online admissions and on campus admissions. Speaking to students over the
phone puts a barrier between the connection of the university and its students, which in turn
makes it more difficult to feel a sense of community. This webinar process would further connect
the admissions counselor with their students to emphasize support and community within Post
University.
Throughout this Masters of Education program, the researcher learned a great deal about
higher education and how to effectively support adult learners. During this capstone project, the
researcher met many of the program outcomes as well as the higher education concentration
outcomes. This researcher was able to evaluate and implement and research based practice
within the higher education field. During the creation of this project the researcher demonstrated
a great deal of creativity and critical thinking in application to the higher education admissions
process. The higher education field of study proved to be interesting and helped to the
PREVENTION OF HIGH ATTRITION RATES AT ONLINE COLLEGES 23
researchers professional career. Throughout the program and this capstone project the researcher
was able to study the demographic and social trends to determine where problems may lie within
the online university admissions process. Overall, this researcher has learned a lot in the manner
of helping their students and setting their students up for success in their degree program.
PREVENTION OF HIGH ATTRITION RATES AT ONLINE COLLEGES 24
References
Ary, D., Jacobs, L., Sorensen, C., & Walker, D. (2013). Introduction to research in education.
Cengage Learning.
Boton, E., Gregory, S. (2015) Minimizing Attrition in Online Degree Courses. Journal of
Carr, M. (2014). The Online University Classroom: One Perspective for Effective Student
14(1), 99-110.
Doe, R., Castillo, M., Muskoya, M. (2017). Assessing Online Readiness of Students. Online
Heyman, Errin. "Overcoming Student Retention Issues in Higher Education Online Programs".
Kentnor, H.E. (2015). Distance Education and the Evolution of Online Learning in the United
Lee, E., Pate, J., & Cozart, D. (2015). Autonomy Support for Online Students. Techtrends:
Mannay, D. & Wilcock, C. (2015). What Students Want? Exploring the Role of the Institution in
Moody, J. (2004). Distance Education: Why are the Attrition Rates so High? Quarterly Review
Parker, Kelly. "A Study of Variables the Predict Dropout from Distance Education".
Schroeder, S., Baker, M., Terras, K., Mahar, P., & CHiasson, K. (2016). Students' Desired and
Shaw, M., Burrus, S., & Ferguson, K. (2016). Factors that Influence Student Attrition in Online
Thorngren, J.M., Nelson, M. D., Baker, L. J., Zuck, B., & Koltz, R. L., (2013). On Track: A
Wilging, P. & Johnson, S. (2009). Factors That Influence Students' Decision to Drop out of
Appendix