Professional Documents
Culture Documents
42 s c i e n t i f i c a m e r i c a n m i n d S e p te m b e r/O c to b e r 201 3
tends to the realm of science. When more than a third of the pop- the habit of overestimating the intentionality behind the ac-
ulation doubts the veracity of climate scientists conclusions, as tions of others.
the Public Policy Polling numbers showed, the repercussions for A likely function of this cognitive bias is to help people make
society can be grave. In a paper published last May, psychologist sense of the world by offering simple explanations for complex
Stephan Lewandowsky of the University of Western Australia events. A number of studies have shown that belief in conspir-
and his colleagues investigated the relation between acceptance acy theories is associated with feelings of powerlessness and un-
of science and conspiracist thinking patterns. They recruited certainty. For example, a large 2008 study by Jennifer Whitson
their participants from climate blogs and focused their research of the University of Texas at Austin and Adam Galinsky of
on the belief systems of this subpopulation. Their results sug- Northwestern University showed that participants who lacked
gest that buying into multiple conspiracy theories predicts the control were more likely to perceive illusory patterns, including
rejection of important scientific conclusions, not only about cli- conspiracies. The authors note that observing patterns where
mate science but also about such well-established facts as that there are none fills a need for structure and organization. In oth-
smoking can cause lung cancer and that HIV leads to AIDS. er words, adopting conspiracy beliefs recasts the world as a
In addition to sowing doubts about scientific principles, be- more predictable place. A tangible enemy absorbs the blame for
lief in conspiracy theories can lead individuals to become dis- problems that otherwise may seem too abstract.
engaged from topics of social and political importance. In a A good example is climate change. A 2013 analysis of peer-
L e f t t o R i g h t: C o u r t e s y o f A la n B e a n N A S A ; HENNY R AY A B R A M S G e t t y I m a g e s ; Rac h i d Da h n o u n C o r b i s
2013 publication Douglas and University of Kent graduate stu- reviewed literature on the topic estimated the scientific consen-
dent Daniel Jolley presented statements to their study partici- sus at 97 percent in favor of the view that anthropogenic global
pants that supported various conspiracy theories, including warming is occurring. Of course, coping with the implications
one on climate skepticism. They found that people who re- of climate change may entail tremendous upheaval. Discount-
ceived information affirming the idea that global warming is a ing the entire phenomenon as a hoax is much more convenient
hoax were less willing to engage politically and to implement psychologically than making the difficult trade-offs that abat-
behavioral changes, such as reducing their carbon footprint. ing it would require. Yet as Al Gore famously pointed out, the
This result is alarming because it suggests that even cursory truth is not always convenient. M
defenses of conspiracy theories can sow mistrust and divert at-
tention from critical scientific, political and social issues. High- (Further Reading)
ly visible books such as Oklahoma senator James Inhofes re-
The Empire of Conspiracy: The Culture of Paranoia in
cent The Greatest Hoax: How the Global Warming Conspira-
Postwar America. Timothy Melley. Cornell University
cy Threatens Your Future may subtly erode public support for Press, 2000.
interventions that would slow climate change even without Dead and Alive: Beliefs in Contradictory Conspiracy
being read. Indeed, conspiracy theories are fiendishly difficult Theories. Michael J. Wood, Karen M. Douglas and Robbie
to unseat because any effort to rebut them has the unfortunate M. Sutton in Social Psychological and Personality Science,
Vol. 3, No. 6, pages 767773; November 2012.
side effect of legitimizing them at the same time. The solution
The Social Consequences of Conspiracism: Exposure to
may simply be to disseminate rigorous scientific evidence as Conspiracy Theories Decreases Intentions to Engage in
widely as possible in the hope that eventually the public be- Politics and to Reduce Ones Carbon Footprint. Karen M.
comes less susceptible to implausible worldviews. Douglas and Daniel Jolley in British Journal of Psychology.
Philosopher Karl Popper argued that the fallacy of conspir- Published online January 4, 2013.
NASA Faked the Moon LandingTherefore, (Climate)
acy theories lies in their tendency to describe striking events as
Science Is a Hoax: An Anatomy of the Motivated Rejec-
planned, thereby grossly underestimating the random nature tion of Science. Stephan Lewandowsky, Klaus Oberauer
and unintended consequences of many political and social ac- and Gilles E. Gignac in Psychological Science, Vol. 24,
tions. Popper was describing a cognitive bias that psychologists No. 5, pages 622633; May 2013.
now commonly refer to as the fundamental attribution error:
M in d . S c i e nti f i c A m e r i c an .c o m s c i e n t i f i c am e r i c a n m i n d 43