Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mechanical
Science and
Technology
Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology 23 (2009) 2964~2972
www.springerlink.com/content/1738-494x
DOI 10.1007/s12206-009-0814-5
(Manuscript Received March 26, 2008; Revised June 19, 2009; Accepted July 26, 2009)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Abstract
A finite element (FE) model, which is based on a transfer matrix analysis and local flexibility theorem, is introduced
for crack identification of a static (non-rotating) rotor with an open crack. Through numerical simulation, the effects of
crack location and crack depth on the mode shapes and the changes in the eigenfrequencies of the cracked rotor are
investigated. A crack identification algorithm that makes use of the translations of the first mode at two symmetric
points and the contour diagram of crack location versus crack depth for the first two given normalized eigenfrequencies
is proposed to estimate the crack location and depth in the rotor. Two illustrative examples are demonstrated and com-
pared for availability and validity of the proposed algorithm.
Keywords: Cracked rotor; Eigenfrequency; Finite element analysis; Local flexibility; Mode shape; Transfer matrix
analysis
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
crack depth and location in a cracked Timoshenko cracked element, and the FE model for the cantilever
shaft to the changes in the natural frequencies. Its beam is presented. The present study uses an FE
numerical simulation showed that knowledge of the model simplified from the model by Ref. [21-23] to
changes in the first three natural frequencies relative investigate the flexural vibration characteristics of a
to the uncracked shaft is sufficient in estimating the cracked rotor.
crack location and depth in the shaft [19]. By pertur- A non-rotating rotor with a single open crack with
bation theory and transfer matrix analysis, Gudmund- depth ad and location Z1 can be discretized into
son calculated the variation of eigenfrequencies due n beam elements or subsystems. The schematic
to a crack on a cantilever beam [20, 21]. Following diagram is shown in Fig. 1, where each element has
Gudmundson, Gounaris proposed a finite element one translational and one rotational degree of freedom
model using the transfer matrix method and local (DOF) for flexural vibration at each node. A crack on
flexibility theorem. To consider the discontinuity a beam element results in local flexibility due to the
deformation due to the crack on the beam, he adopted strain energy concentration near the crack tip under
two different shape functions for the two segments the load. According to the principle of Saint-Venant,
separated by the crack [22]. Based on the research of the stress field is affected only in the region adjacent
Gudmundson and Gounaris, Nikolakopoulos pre- to the crack; the element stiffness matrix, except for
sented the dependency of the structural eigenfrequen- the cracked element, may be regarded as unchanged
cies on crack depth and location in contour graph under a certain limitation of element size [8]. For the
form. To identify the location and depth of a crack, uncracked beam element shown in Fig. 2, the corre-
the intersection points of the superposed contours that sponding stiffness and consistent mass matrices are
correspond to the measured eigenfrequency variations given as follows:
and caused by the presence of the crack should be
determined [23]. With the model from Nikolakopou- 12 6l 12 6l
los, Suh presented a detection method that uses the 2
EI 6l 4l 6l 2l 2
hybrid neuro-genetic technique to identify the loca- K e = 3 (1)
l 12 6l 12 6l
tion and depth of a crack on a structure [24]. Hu and
6l 2l 2 6l 4l 2
Liang proposed a two-step procedure to identify
cracks in beam structures. They used the effective
stress concept coupled with Hamiltons principle to
Z1
derive a formulation relating the changes in the natu-
D ad
ral frequencies to the changes in member stiffness.
While using the formulation, the elements containing l
the cracks could be identified. The spring damage L
model was used to quantify the location and depth of
the crack in each damaged element [25]. Fig. 1. Diagram of a rotor with a single open crack.
In this paper, a finite element (FE) model is intro- i j
duced for crack identification in a static (non-rotating)
rotor with an open crack. The effects of the location xi , i x j , j
156 22l 2 54 13l Due to the crack, the point transfer matrix Tc ,
which relates the state vectors on the left and right
Al 22l 4l 2 13l 3l 2
Me = (2) sides of the crack, is
420 54 13l 156 22l
13l 3l 2 22l 4l 2 1 0 c11 0
0 1 0 c22
Tc = (5c)
A cracked beam finite element with a crack depth 0 0 1 0
ad at location lc from its left endpoint is depicted
0 0 0 1
in Fig. 3. Suppose that the crack only affects the stiff-
ness, and the element mass matrix is invariant. Due to With regard to the cross section of a cracked rotor
the discontinuity of deformation in the cracked ele- shown in Fig. 4, the local flexibility c11 , c22 can be
ment, it is very difficult to determine an appropriate calculated as
shape function to express approximately the kinetic
energy and elastic potential energy. To derive the +b / R
2 z z z
R F ( h )d R
2
c11 = d II (6a)
stiffness matrix of the cracked element, the transfer b / R R
matrix analysis that transfers the state variables (gen- +b / R
32 z z z z
R
2 2
c22 = d [1 ( ) ] F ( )d (6b)
eralized displacements and forces) from one node to b / R
2
R R h R
2
The transfer matrix Tec of the cracked element is crack depth ad = ad / R . The cracked rotor is discre-
written in the following form: tized into 10 beam elements. The variations of the
first three normalized eigenfrequencies ci / ni
T T12 ( i = 1, 2,3 ) with the relative crack depth are shown in
Tec = T2TcT1 = 11 , (9)
T21 T22 Fig. 6. For a given crack location, it can be seen from
Fig. 6 that for a given crack location, the changes in
and the stiffness matrix of the cracked element can be eigenfrequencies of the cracked rotor monotonically
readily computed [23], [24] as increase with the increment of the crack depth, such
that if the crack location is known in advance, the
T121T11 T121 crack depth can be read out from the changes in ei-
K ce = 1 1
. (10)
T21 T22T12 T11 T22T12 genfrequencies. It can also be seen from Fig. 6 that
the change in the first eigenfrequency with a crack
Assembling the element stiffness and consistent present is significant because the crack is close to the
mass matrices to obtain the global stiffness and mass antinodal point of the first mode. In contrast, the
matrices, the model of the cracked rotor in bending is change in the second eigenfrequency is quite small
set up in the following form: because the crack is near the nodal point of that mode.
In addition, a large drop in the eigenfrequencies re-
( 2M + K )x = {0} . (11) sults from the increment of crack depth for a given
crack location in the rotor. Thus, it can be concluded
Based on the above equation, the eigenvalue analy- from Fig.6 that if the crack location is known in ad-
sis is carried out and used to investigate the vibration vance, the crack depth can be read out from the
characteristics of a rotor with a single open crack. changes in eigenfrequencies.
First two Calculate possible Table 1. Comparison between the predicted and actual results
normalized crack locations of the first example.
eigenfrequencies of and crack depths
the cracked rotor using FEM model Predicted results Actual results Errors
Z1 / L 0.243 0.25 2.8%
Draw contour ad 0.2105 0.2 5.25%
Determine the diagram of crack
actual crack location versus crack
parameters depth to obtain two Table 2. Comparison between the predicted and actual results
possible symmetric of the second example.
candidates
First mode Predicted results Actual results Errors
shape of the
cracked rotor Z1 / L 0.3464 0.35 1%
ad 0.7951 0.8 0.6%
Fig. 9. Flow chart of the crack identification algorithm.
tained using transfer matrix analysis and local flexi- Ke : Stiffness matrix of uncracked element
bility theorem. K ce : Stiffness matrix of cracked element
The changes in eigenfrequencies monotonically in- M : Global mass matrix
crease with the increment of the crack depth for a Me : Element consistent mass matrix
given crack location in a cracked rotor. Because of T1 , T2 : Transfer matrices
the symmetry of the rotor, the changes in eigenfre- Tc : Point transfer matrix due to the crack
quencies with different crack locations show a sym- Tec : Transfer matrix of cracked element
metric property, and their changes depend on how Vi , V j , VL , VR : State vectors at positions i ,
close the crack is to one of the mode shape nodes. If j , CL , CR
the first two eigenfrequencies are known in advance, xi , x j , xL , xR : Translations at positions i ,
two possible cracks can be predicted at the symmetric j , CL , CR
locations on the rotor, but the first mode shape can be i , j , L , R : Rrotations at positions i , j ,
used to select the true crack location from the two CL , CR
possible cracks. : Eigenfrequency of the rotor
A crack identification algorithm that makes use of c1 , c2 , c3 : First three eigenfrequencies
the translations of the first mode at two symmetric of cracked rotor
points and contour diagram of crack location versus n1 , n2 , n3 : First three eigenfrequencies
crack depth for first two given normalized eigenfre- of uncracked rotor
quencies is proposed to estimate the crack location
and depth in the rotor. Two illustrative examples are References
demonstrated and compared for the availability and
validity of the proposed algorithm. [1] J. Wauer, On the dynamics of cracked rotors: a
literature survey, Applied Mechanics Review, 43 (1)
(1990) 13-17.
Acknowledgment
[2] R. Gasch, A survey of the dynamic behavior of a
We gratefully acknowledge the support from the simple rotating shaft with a transverse crack, Jour-
National Natural Science Foundation (Approved nal of Sound and Vibration, 160 (2) (1993) 313-332.
Grant: 50875162) and the China Postdoctoral Science [3] A. D. Dimarogonas, Vibration of cracked struc-
Foundation funded project (Approved Grant: 20070- tures: a state of the art review, Engineering Frac-
420655). ture Mechanics, 55 (5) (1996) 831-857.
[4] Y. P. Pu, J. Chen and J. Zou, Quasi-periodic vibra-
tion of cracked rotor on flexible bearings, Journal
Nomenclature-----------------------------------------------------------
of Sound and Vibration, 215 (5) (2002) 875-890.
ad : Crack depth [5] Y. P. Pu, J. Chen and J. Zou, The research on non-
ad : Relative crack depth linear characteristics of a cracked rotor and recon-
Z1 : Crack location of the rotor struction of the crack forces, Proceedings of IM-
A : Cross-sectional area echE, Part C, Journal of Mechanical Engineering
L : Length of the rotor Science, 216 (11) (2002) 1099-1108.
R : Radius of the rotor [6] J. Zou, J. Chen and Y. P. Pu, On the wavelet time-
D : Diameter of the rotor frequency analysis algorithm in identification of a
E : Youngs modulus cracked rotor, Journal of Strain Analysis for Engi-
v : Poisson ratio neering Design, 37 (3) (2002) 239-246.
: Material density [7] C. A. Papadopoulos and A. D. Dimarogonas, Cou-
I : Moment of inertia pled longitudinal and bending vibrations of a rotat-
l : Length of the element ing shaft with an open crack, Journal of Sound and
lc : Crack location from the left endpoint Vibration, 117, (1) (1987) 81-93.
on an element [8] A. S. Sekhar, Vibration characteristics of a cracked
c11 , c22 : Local flexibility rotor with two open cracks, Journal of Sound and
c11 , c22 : Dimensionless flexibility Vibration, 223, (4) (1999) 497-512.
K : Global stiffness matrix [9] H. Baruh and S. Ratan, Damage detection in flexi-
G. M. Dong and J. Chen / Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology 23 (2009) 2964~2972 2971
ble structures, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 166 vibrations of a general cracked-rotor bearing system,
(1) (1993) 21-30. Transactions of the ASME, Journal of Mechanical
[10] S. Ratan, H. Baruh and J. Rodriguez, On-line iden- Design, 104 (2) (1982) 345-355.
tification and location of rotor cracks, Journal of [19] M. D. Rajab and A. A. Sabeeh, Vibrational char-
Sound and Vibration, 194, (1) (1996) 67-82. acteristics of cracked shafts, Journal of Sound and
[11] M. Krawczuk and W. M. Ostachowicz, Transverse Vibration, 147 (3) (1991) 465-473.
natural vibrations of a cracked beam loaded with a [20] P. Gudmundson, Eigenfrequency changes of struc-
constant axial force, Transactions of the ASME, tures due to cracks, notches or other geometrical
Journal of Vibration and Acoustics, 115 (4) (1993) changes, J Mech. Phys. Solids, 30, (5) (1982) 339-
524-528. 353.
[12] D. Armon, Y. B. Haim and S. Braun, Crack detec- [21] P. Gudmundson, The dynamic behavior of slender
tion in beams by rank-ordering of eigenfrequency structures with cross-sectional cracks, J Mech. Phys.
shifts, Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, Solids, 31 (4) (1983) 329-345.
8 (1) (1994) 81-91. [22] G. Gounaris and A. D. Dimarogonas, A finite
[13] Y. S. Lee and M. J. Chung, A study on crack de- element of a cracked prismatic beam for structural
tection using eignenfrequency test data, Computers analysis, Computers and Structures, 28 (3) (1988)
and Structures, 77 (3) (2000) 327-342. 309-313.
[14] R. D. Adams, P. Cawley, C. J. Pye, et al., A vibra- [23] P. G. Nikolakopoulos, D. E. Katsareas, and C. A.
tion technique for non-destructively assessing the Papadopoulos, Crack identification in frame struc-
integrity of structures, Journal of Mechanical Engi- tures, Computers and Structures, 64 (1) (1997) 389-
neering Science, 20 (2) (1978) 93-100. 406.
[15] P. Cawley and R. D. Adams, The location of de- [24] M. W. Suh, M. B. Shim, and M. Y. Kim, Crack
fects in structures from measurements of natural identification using hybrid neuro-genetic technique,
frequencies, Journal of Strain Analysis for Engi- Journal of Sound and Vibration, 238 (4) (2000)
neering Design, 14 (2) (1979) 49-57. 617-635.
[16] T. G. Chondros and A. D. Dimarogonas, Identifi- [25] J. L Hu and R. Y Liang, An integrated approach to
cation of cracks in welded joints of complex struc- detection of cracks using vibration characteristics,
tures, Journal of Sound and Vibration, 69 (4) Journal of the Franklin Institute, 330 (5) (1993)
(1980) 531-538. 841-853.
[17] P. F. Rizos, N. Aspragathos and A. D. Dimarogo- [26] A. D. Dimarogonas, Vibration Engineering, St
nas, Identification of crack location and magnitude Paul, West Publishing Cooperation, (1976).
in a cantilever beam from the vibration modes, [27] G. M. Dong, J. Chen and J. Zou, Parameter identi-
Journal of Sound and Vibration, 138 (3) (1990) fication of a rotor with an open crack, European
381-388. Journal of Mechanics A/Solids. 23 (1) (2004) 325-
[18] T. Inagaki, H. Hanki and K. Shiraki, Transverse 333
2972 G. M. Dong and J. Chen / Journal of Mechanical Science and Technology 23 (2009) 2964~2972
Guang Ming Dong received Jin Chen received his B.S. and
his B.S. and M.S. degrees in M.S. degrees in Mechanical
Mechanical Engineering from Engineering from Shanghai Jiao
Xian Jiao Tong University, Tong University (SJTU), China,
China, in 1999 and 2002, re- and his Ph.D. degree from To-
spectively. He then received his kyo Institute of Technology,
Ph.D. degree in Mechanical Japan. He is currently a profes-
Engineering from Shanghai sor and Ph.D. supervisor in Shanghai Jiao Tong Uni-
Jiao Tong University, China, in 2007. Dr. Dong is versity, the Director of the SJTU Library, and vice
currently a postdoctoral research fellow at the State director of State Key Laboratory of Mechanical Sys-
Key Laboratory of Mechanical System and Vibration tem and Vibration. Dr. Chen is also a member of the
in Shanghai Jiao Tong University, China. Dr. Dongs Standing Committee of the Chinese Society of Vibra-
research interest is on damage identification and tion Engineering, president of the Fault Diagnosis
health monitoring of structural and mechanical sys- Society of China, Editor of the Journal of Mechanical
tems using global methods, specifically, vibration- System and Signal Processing, Standing Editor of the
based damage detection. Journal of Vibration, Testing, and Diagnostics, and
Chairman of the Alumni Association of Tokyo Insti-
tute of Technology in Shanghai.