2017 7 28 7

1 1
2 2017-01-18
2017-06-13

1 299 430072
2 299 430072

DOI 1011946 / cjstp201701180044

SC
Shotton1 HTML
8
Elsevier
WileyPLoS
910
Article of the
Future 11 Smart Article 12

23 Anywhere Article 13



4 PDF
NanoPublicaiton

MircoPublication 5 Semantic

Evidence 6

eLife
DF
Lens14 CDF 15Utopia16

1
Enhanced Publication 11
2009

OCID 0000000156011487 E-mail songny_whu@ 126com
OCID 0000000312847164 E-mail whu_wxg@ 126com

http wwwcjstpcn 28 7 587592 587

2017
 2017 7 28 7

SUF


17 18
Hunter Kircz
19
Modular Model
Scientific Publication Package


Digital
Object
20
Breure ich
Internet Publication
Semantic 1
Metadata Image-Driven
Linear and Nonlinear
eading Shotton 21
PLoS Neglected Tropical Disease

Scientific Workflow
22
Journal 30
Enriched Content
Linked Mash-up Discovery
Open Collaborative Communication



2014 Bardi 2324

2

3
12

588
2017
28 7 http w w w cjstpcn


Utopia
2
Biochemical Journal

eLife LensUtopiaCDF
1
APS eLife Lens
1

2012 Elsevier https wwwelseviercom / connect / designing-the-article-of-the-future
eLife Lens 2015 Ivan Grubisic http lenselifesciencesorg / about / #figures / all
2014 Wiley http onlinelibrarywileycom / doi /101111 / nph12453 / full
Utopia 2010 Attwood T K http getutopiacom
CDF 2014 Wolfram http wwwwolframcom / cdf / html

12

UL

21
CDF

CDF Wolfram Utopia Annotators
Wolfram DoCO PDF

Utopia
25
CDF
22
CDF


CDF
eLife Lens



Utopia CDF
Visualizers




eLife Lens
GenBank ProteinData Bank

eLife Lens Utopia

http wwwcjstpcn
2017
28 7 589
 2017 7 28 7

Utopia
23


UtopiaeLife
Lens


Utopia
CDF
HTML
JavaScript
eLife PDF
Lens 2

2
CDF elife Lens Utopia
Y Y N Y Y
Y N N Y N
Y N N N N
Y Y Y Y Y
N N N Y Y

Y N N Y Y
Y Y Y Y Y
Y Y Y Y Y

CDF ich HTML HTML ich HTML Enhanced PDF

/ / / / / / /

1
HTML JavaScript
HTML


eLife LensUtopia 3
XML
DTD


2

590
2017
28 7 http w w w cjstpcn


Utopia DoCO


3


31



Liu26
CDF

4







32
PDF




1 Shotton D Semantic publishing The coming revolution in
scientific journal publishingJ Learned Publishing200922

2 8594
2 J

2011 11 5458
3
J 20 4 7380
2012
4
Nanopublication J 2013
39 4 102109

5 Clark TCiccarese P NGoble C A Micropublications A

semantic model for claimsevidencearguments and annotations in
biomedical communications J Journal of Biomedical
CDF Semantics
2014
5 28
6 Blling CWeidlich MHolzhtter H G SEE Structured

representation of scientific evidence in the biomedical domain

using Semantic Web techniques J Journal of Biomedical

Semantics 5 S1 S1
2014
7 Schmidt N Tackling complexity in an interdisciplinary scholarly
33 network equirements for semantic publishing J First
Monday
2016
21 5

http wwwcjstpcn
2017
28 7 591
 2017 7 28 7

8
SC Press
2009
J 201324 5 18 Hunter J Scientific publication packagesa selective approach to
825829 the communication and archival of scientific outputJ
9 Elsevier J International Journal of Digital Curation 1 1 3352
2006
25 10 12561261
2014 19 Kircz J G Modularity The next form of scientific information
10 Allen L Creative ways to semantically enrich an Open Access presentation J Journal of Documentation199854 2
PLoS research articleZ / OL 20090427 2017 05 08 210235
http / / blogs plos org / everyone /2009 /04 /27 / creative-ways-to- 20 Breure LVoorbij HHoogerwerf M ich internet publications
semanticallyenrich-an-open-access-plos-research-article Show what you tellJ Journal of Digital Information201112
11 Aalbersberg I JHeeman F
Koers H
et al Elsevier's aticle of the 1 http / / journalstdlorg / jodi / article / view /1606 /1738
future enhancing the user experience and integrating data through 21 Shotton DPortwin KKlyne Get al Adventures in semantic
applicationsJ Insights The UKSG journal 25 1 3343
2012 publishing Exemplar semantic enhancements of a research article
12 Smart ArticleEB / OL 2017 02 22 2017 05 08 J PLoS Comput Biol 5 4 e1000361
2009
http / / aswileycom / WileyCDA / Section / id817760html 22 J
13 Anywhere ArticleEB / OL 2017 02 21 2017 05 08 37 5 412
2011
http / / exchangeswileycom / blog / tag / anywhere-article 23 Bardi AManghi P Enhanced publications Data models and
14 eLife LensEB / OL 20160217 201705 08 http / / information systemsJ LIBE Quarterly 23 4 240273
2014
lenselifesciencesorg / about / #figures / all 24 Bardi AManghi P A framework supporting the shift from
15 EB / OL 2016 02 17 2017 05 08 traditional digital publications to enhanced publicationsJ D-
http / / wwwwolframcom / cdf / compare-cdf Lib Magazine 21 1 /2 17201722
2015
16 Attwood T KKell D BMcDermott Pet al Utopia documents 25 Constantin APeroni SPettifer Set al The document
Linking scholarly literature with research data J components ontology DoCO J Semantic Web20167 2
Bioinformatics 26 18 i568i574
2010 167181
17 Woutersen-Windhouwer SBrandsma Hogenaar Aet al 26 Liu Z eading behavior in the digital environment changes in
Enhanced publications Linking publications and research data in reading behavior over the past ten years J Journal of
digital repositories M Amsterdam Amsterdam University Documentation 61 6 700712
2005

Comparisonand analysis of enhanced publication models

SONG Ningyuan 1 WANG Xiaoguang 12

1 School of Information M anagement Wuhan University299 Bayi oad Wuchang DistrictWuhan 430072China
2 Center for Studiesof Information esearchesWuhan University299 Bayi oad Wuchang DistrictWuhan 430072China

Abstract Purposes The innovation of publication model is the core of semantic publishing The enhanced publication models are
compared and analyzedw hich is the basement for developing new publication model and has reference significance for the future
development of semantic publishing Methods Based on the review of semantic publishing researchesfive enhanced publication
models w ere selected as the research objectsand w ere comparatively analyzed through three w aysi econtent expression
external resource integration and reading environment FindingsThe features of enhanced publications are summarizedincluding
the resembled model architectureimbalanced semantic enhancement and less publication ontology Conclusions The enhanced
publications have magnificent meanings in know ledge servicescreen reading and science communicationsand deserve further
development
Keywords Semanticpublishing Enhanced publication Semantic enhancement Comparative analysis

592
2017
28 7 http w w w cjstpcn