Professional Documents
Culture Documents
4, 2015
Peter W. Macfarlane, DSC,* Charles Antzelevitch, PHD,y Michel Haissaguerre, MD,z Heikki V. Huikuri, MD, PHD,x
Mark Potse, PHD,k Raphael Rosso, MD,{ Frederic Sacher, MD,z Jani T. Tikkanen, MD, PHD,x Hein Wellens, MD,#
Gan-Xin Yan, MD, PHD**
ABSTRACT
The term early repolarization has been in use for more than 50 years. This electrocardiographic pattern was considered
benign until 2008, when it was linked to sudden cardiac arrest due to idiopathic ventricular brillation. Much confusion
over the denition of early repolarization followed. Thus, the objective of this paper was to prepare an agreed denition
to facilitate future research in this area. The different denitions of the early repolarization pattern were reviewed to
delineate the electrocardiographic measures to be used when dening this pattern. An agreed denition has been
established, which requires the peak of an end-QRS notch and/or the onset of an end-QRS slur as a measure, denoted Jp,
to be determined when an interpretation of early repolarization is being considered. One condition for early repolarization
to be present is Jp $0.1 mV, while ST-segment elevation is not a required criterion. (J Am Coll Cardiol 2015;66:4707)
2015 by the American College of Cardiology Foundation.
From the *Institute of Cardiovascular and Medical Sciences, Electrocardiology Section, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, United
Kingdom; yCardiovascular Research Program, Lankenau Institute for Medical Research, Wynnewood, Pennsylvania; zBordeaux
University Hospital, LIRYC Institute, INSERM 1045, Bordeaux University, Bordeaux, France; xMedical Research Center Oulu, Oulu
University Central Hospital, and University of Oulu, Oulu, Finland; kInria Bordeaux Sud-Ouest, 33405 Talence cedex, France;
{Tel Aviv Sourasky Medical Center, Tel Aviv, Israel; #Department of Cardiology, University of Maastricht, the Netherlands; and
the **Lankenau Institute for Medical Research, Wynnewood, Pennsylvania. The authors have reported that they have no re-
lationships relevant to the contents of this paper to disclose.
Listen to this manuscripts audio summary by JACC Editor-in-Chief Dr. Valentin Fuster.
Manuscript received February 5, 2015; revised manuscript received April 21, 2015, accepted May 18, 2015.
JACC VOL. 66, NO. 4, 2015 Macfarlane et al. 471
JULY 28, 2015:4707 The Early Repolarization Pattern
T-wave. However, many cardiologists have reported the onset of the ST-segment (13), which may ABBREVIATIONS
the presence of ST-segment elevation alone, most equate with the termination of an end-QRS AND ACRONYMS
commonly in the inferior and lateral leads in younger notch, whereas others use the term for the
ECG = electrocardiography
persons, as being consistent with early repolarization. peak (13) or the onset (C. Antzelevitch, per-
Jo = J onset
This view can be found in respected textbooks on sonal communication, March 28, 2014) of an
Jp = J peak
ECG (8). end-QRS notch. It is proposed that the
In the seminal study of Haissaguerre et al. (1), the following terminology be used: 1) J onset (Jo) Jt = J termination
investigators dened early repolarization as an should denote the onset of a notch; 2) J peak (Jp)
elevation of the QRS-ST-segment junction (J-point) in should denote the peak of a notch or onset of a slur;
at least 2 leads (within the same territory; e.g., infe- and 3) J termination (Jt) should denote the end of a
rior or lateral leads) as being a sign of early repolari- notch or slur.
zation. The amplitude of the J-point elevation had to Figure 2A claries these points for an end-QRS
be at least 0.1 mV above the baseline level, as either notch. In the case of a slur (Figure 2B), Jo and Jp are
QRS slurring or notching. The amplitude and slope of electrocardiographically the same point. However, for
the ST-segment were not part of the denition. consistency of measurement, it is proposed that the
In subsequent papers, Tikkanen et al. (3,4) fol- slur onset be regarded as Jp, rather than Jo, because
lowed this denition but also measured the degree this allows Jp to be used to denote both the peak notch
of so-called J-point elevation, which was stratied and slur amplitude (Figure 2B). This means that in
at levels of 0.1 and 0.2 mV. These investigators publications, such as those of Haissaguerre et al. (1),
also introduced the concept of the ST-segment slope Rosso et al. (2), and Tikkanen et al. (3,4), the term J
having signicance in the presence of early repolari- amplitude or J-point elevation equates with Jp ampli-
zation, showing that a horizontal or downward- tude, as conrmed by these investigators in contrib-
sloping ST-segment is associated with greater uting to this consensus paper. Antzelevitch has used
arrhythmic risk (4). Jo to denote the J point when describing early repo-
Thus, there has been considerable variation in the larization (personal communication, March 28, 2014).
denition of early repolarization, as well as some It also means that in publications such as the Third
controversy regarding the term itself. Spodick (9), for Universal Denition of Myocardial Infarction (14),
example, regarded the term as a misnomer, while Jt equates with ST-segment amplitude in relation to
others believed that it was inappropriate and the denition of ST-segment elevation myocardial
confusing (10), a view which was challenged (11). infarction. The new terminology should clarify what is
The aim of this paper is essentially to present a being measured in future studies and is recommended
unied denition of early repolarization to assist future for use henceforth.
studies in the eld by recommending measurements
that should be made to facilitate sharing of data, with MEASUREMENT RECOMMENDATIONS
the ultimate aim of having a greater understanding of
the ECG pattern of early repolarization. A major aim of this paper is to set out recommenda-
tions with respect to measurements relating to
TERMINOLOGY the early repolarization pattern. To this end, the
following denitions are presented.
So that doubt can be avoided, an end-QRS notch is a
NOTCHING AND SLURRING. To facilitate future
notch that occurs on the nal 50% of the downslope
studies, the following measurements should be made
of an R-wave occurring as the nal segment of the
(Figure 2). All amplitude measurements are made
QRS complex; that is, it links with the ST-segment
with reference to QRS onset.
of the waveform (Figure 1A). It should be distin-
Notched QRS complex.
guished from a notch midway on the downslope of
1. The amplitude Jo at the onset of the notch
an R-wave (Figure 1B), because this may be due to
2. The amplitude Jp at the peak of the notch
fragmentation (12). Similarly, an end-QRS slur is an
3. The amplitude Jt at the end of the notch
apparent slowing of the inscription of the waveform
4. The duration D1 from Jo to Jp
at the end of the QRS complex that merges with the
5. The duration D 2 from Jo to Jt
ST-segment of the complex (Figure 1A). Likewise, in
the context of this paper, a slur should occur in the Slurred QRS complex.
nal 50% of the R-wave downslope. 1. The amplitude Jp at the onset of the slur
There is considerable variation in the use of the 2. The amplitude Jt at end of the slur
term J point. For many cardiologists, this is taken as 3. The duration D 2 from Jp to Jt
472 Macfarlane et al. JACC VOL. 66, NO. 4, 2015
(A) Electrocardiographic leads showing end-QRS notching in lead V4 progressing to end-QRS slurring in lead V6. End-QRS slurring is also
present in leads I and aVL. The arrows localize the notching or slurring. (B) Leads III and aVF show notching. In lead III, the notch peak is >50%
of the R-wave amplitude and could be regarded as fragmentation. In lead II, appearances on the R-wave downslope take the form of a slur, and
there is also a notch in lead aVF. They are most probably due to the same underlying physiological process. The arrows indicate the location of
the notches and slur.
ST-SEGMENT SLOPE. The following measurements NEW DEFINITION OF THE EARLY REPOLARIZATION
should be recorded when specifying slope (4). (END-QRS NOTCHING/SLURRING) PATTERN. A new
ST-segment slope. denition of the early repolarization pattern on the
1. ST-segment slope should be measured from Jt. basis of current knowledge is urgently needed. It is
2. The ST segment should be regarded as horizontal entirely feasible that another denition will emerge
or downward sloping if the amplitude of the ST- in the future, when further studies adopting the
segment 100 ms after Jt (interval M) is less than measurement recommendations of this paper are
or equal to the amplitude at Jt (Figure 3). The ST- available.
segment should be regarded as upward sloping if The majority of publications at the present time
the amplitude of the ST-segment 100 ms after Jt (e.g., refs. 14) adopt the amplitude of Jp in Figure 2 as
(interval M) is greater than the amplitude at Jt. the reference point for measuring J-point elevation.
3. If the researcher has not used Jt when measuring The following criteria are therefore proposed until
slope, any report must clearly state whether further research claries the situation.
100-ms intervals such as K, L, and M (Figure 3) have Early repolarization is present if all of the following
been used. criteria are met (Central Illustration):
JACC VOL. 66, NO. 4, 2015 Macfarlane et al. 473
JULY 28, 2015:4707 The Early Repolarization Pattern
A B
D1
D2 D2
Jo Jp Jt Jp Jt
(A) Illustration of the amplitudes J onset (Jo), J peak (Jp), and J termination (Jt), as well as durations D1 and D2, in relation to an end-QRS notch,
as dened in the text. (B) Illustration of Jp and Jt, as well as D2, in relation to an end-QRS slur.
1. There is an end-QRS notch or slur on the down- If the ST-segment is upward sloping and fol-
slope of a prominent R-wave. If there is a notch, it lowed by an upright T-wave, the pattern should be
should lie entirely above the baseline. The onset of described as early repolarization with an ascending
a slur must also be above the baseline. ST segment.
2. Jp is $0.1 mV in 2 or more contiguous leads of the If the ST-segment is horizontal or downward sloping,
12-lead ECG, excluding leads V1 to V3 . the pattern should be described as early repolariza-
3. QRS duration is <120 ms. tion with a horizontal or descending ST segment.
A B
L L
Jo Jp Jt Jp Jt
M
(A) Illustration of duration measurements K, L, and M, each 100 ms, that could be used in the measurement of ST-segment slope in the
presence of a notch with reference amplitudes J onset (Jo), J peak (Jp) and J termination (Jt) also shown. (B) Illustration of duration
measurements L and M, each 100 ms, used in the presence of an end-QRS slur with onset Jp and termination Jt to measure slope.
474 Macfarlane et al. JACC VOL. 66, NO. 4, 2015
SUMMARY RECOMMENDATIONS.
It is recommended that researchers reporting end-
QRS notching and slurring quote their criteria in
terms of Jo, Jp, and Jt. In Figure 2, Jt represents ST-
segment onset from an ECG standpoint and should
be used when reporting ST-segment elevation.
Whether a researcher uses all of these measure-
ments or not, it is recommended that they be made
available for any cooperative study or international
registry.
With respect to the denition of ST-segment slope,
the recommendation is to use the time interval M.
If this is not used, researchers must state whether
they are using K or L (Figure 3). The onset of M, that
is, the location of Jt, is best determined from
An illustration of an electrocardiogram showing moderate ST-segment elevation in leads I,
analysis of all 12 leads displayed in a time-aligned
II, and aVF and more marked ST-segment elevation in leads V4 to V6, in the absence of any
fashion, such that ST-segment onset can be deter- end-QRS notching or slurring. It is recommended that this nding should be described as
mined across all 12 leads. If any other method of early repolarization. The arrows indicate the points of ST-segment elevation.
determining ST-segment slope were used, it would
need to be dened in detail.
substrate that may pre-dispose to development of
DISCUSSION life-threatening ventricular arrhythmias. Their de-
nition of the pattern included the presence of prom-
In 2000, Gussak and Antzelevitch (19) presented inent J waves, or QRS notching or slurring, together
evidence in support of the hypothesis that the early with ST-segment elevation. It was 8 years later when
repolarization pattern denoted the presence of a idiopathic ventricular brillation was rst linked with
476 Macfarlane et al. JACC VOL. 66, NO. 4, 2015
One possible method of determining the presence of an end-QRS AUTOMATED DETECTION OF THE EARLY REPOLARIZATION
slur. If the angle between the initial downslope of the R-wave PATTERN. Some of the problems in detecting slurs
and the end-QRS inscription exceeds 10 , a slur is dened as
discussed earlier apply equally well to automated
present.
detection techniques. It is therefore important
that the developers of software for the detection of
large numbers of individuals having the early repo- notching and slurring adhere to the guidelines
larization pattern (1). In addition, there have been presented. Even then, there are still likely to be
many papers (e.g., refs. 19,20) examining the experi- subtle differences, particularly in the detection of
mental basis for notching and slurring. Not all in- slur onset.
vestigators are in complete agreement about the
CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS. It is worth reiterating that
electrophysiological basis of early repolarization, but
the original denition of early repolarization referred
there is a consensus that the pattern of end-QRS
to a combination of end-QRS notching or slurring
notching and slurring may, on occasion, be due to
together with ST-segment elevation and a tall
late depolarization (9,21) rather than early repolari-
T-wave. The more recent association between the
zation (22). Some investigators take the view that the
newer denition of early repolarization, as outlined
mechanism responsible for end-QRS notching or
here, and life-threatening cardiac arrhythmias was
slurring has not yet been established (23). Indeed,
independent of increased Jt amplitude (13). The
they suggest (23) that the term early repolarization
work of Tikkanen et al. (4) and Rosso et al. (26) sug-
should be replaced by J waves. There is not space in
gests that an upward-sloping ST-segment, followed
this paper, which deals with measurement recom-
by an upright T-wave in the presence of end-QRS
mendations, to recount all of these discussions.
notching or slurring, is benign, whereas early repo-
Leads V 1 to V3 have been excluded from the new
larization with a horizontal or downward-sloping ST-
denition of early repolarization set out in this paper
segment is potentially more serious. The ascending
to avoid confusion with the Brugada pattern (24),
ST-segment has not predicted mortality or sudden
which may occur in leads V 1 to V3 and is regarded by
death in any of the general population samples.
some as a form of early repolarization.
However, in the series of Rosso et al. (26), the ma-
It is important that in future studies aimed at risk
jority of emergency department cases with idiopathic
stratication and/or prevalence estimations of early
ventricular brillation were associated with horizon-
repolarization, investigators all use the same termi-
tal or downward-sloping ST-segments, while the
nology and make the same measurements to describe
ascending type was less common in the patients with
their ndings. It is disconcerting that the prevalence
early repolarization syndrome resuscitated from
of early repolarization has been described as ranging
ventricular brillation. Further research clearly needs
from 2% to 31% (5). This could be ascribed to mis-
to be undertaken using the measures described in
understandings in what to measure, differences in
this paper.
ECG recording equipment (e.g., lter settings), and,
Finally, in 1 study (27), notching or slurring plus
perhaps, racial variation (25).
Jt elevation with Jt $0.1 mV occurred in 2.1% of
None of this should preclude new measurements
1,496 apparently healthy, white adults (mean age
from being introduced, but they should be presented
37.4 12.6 years), whereas the prevalence was 29.3%
alongside the measurements recommended in the
if only notching or slurring was present without Jt
preceding text.
elevation. This suggests that considerable caution
VISUAL RECOGNITION OF THE EARLY REPOLARIZATION must be exercised in interpreting the early repolari-
PATTERN. Although this paper focuses principally zation pattern, as dened earlier.
JACC VOL. 66, NO. 4, 2015 Macfarlane et al. 477
JULY 28, 2015:4707 The Early Repolarization Pattern
REFERENCES
1. Haissaguerre M, Derval N, Sacher F, et al. Sud- 11. Antzelevitch C, Yan GX, Viskin S. Rationale for 20. Antzelevitch C, Yan GX. J wave syndromes.
den cardiac arrest associated with early repolari- the use of the terms J-wave syndromes and early Heart Rhythm 2010;7:54958.
zation. N Engl J Med 2008;358:201623. repolarization. J Am Coll Cardiol 2011;7:158790.
21. Wellens H. Early repolarization revisited.
2. Rosso R, Kogan E, Belhassen B, et al. J-point 12. Das MK, Saha C, El Masry H, et al. Fragmented N Engl J Med 2008;358:20635.
elevation in survivors of primary ventricular QRS on a 12-lead ECG: a predictor of mortality and 22. Ghosh S, Cooper DH, Vijayakumar R, et al.
brillation and matched control subjects: inci- cardiac events in patients with coronary artery Early repolarization associated with sudden death:
dence and clinical signicance. J Am Coll Cardiol disease. Heart Rhythm 2007;4:138592. insights from noninvasive electrocardiographic
2008;52:12318.
13. Perez MV, Friday K, Froelicher V. Semantic imaging. Heart Rhythm 2010;7:5347.
3. Tikkanen JT, Anttonen O, Junttila MJ, et al. confusion: the case of early repolarization and the 23. Hoogendijk MG, Potse M, Coronel R. Critical
Long-term outcome associated with early repo- J point. Am J Med 2012;125:8434. appraisal of the mechanism underlying J waves.
larization and electrocardiography. N Engl J Med
14. Thygesen K, Alpert JS, Jaffe AS, et al., for the J Electrocardiol 2013;46:3904.
2009;361:252937.
Writing Group on Behalf of the Joint ESC/ACCF/ 24. Brugada P, Brugada J. Right bundle branch
4. Tikkanen JT, Junttila MJ, Anttonen O, et al. AHA/WHF Task Force for the Universal Denition block, persistent ST elevation and sudden cardiac
Early repolarization. Electrocardiographic pheno- of Myocardial Infarction. Third universal denition death: a distinct clinical and electrocardiographic
types associated with favorable long-term of myocardial infarction. Circulation 2012;126: syndrome. A multicenter report. J Am Coll Cardiol
outcome. Circulation 2011;123:266673. 202035. 1992;20:13916.
5. Maury P, Rollin A. Prevalence of early repolari- 15. Appendix 1: adult normal limits and appendix 25. Clark EN, Macfarlane PW. Ethnic variation in
zation/J wave patterns in the normal population. 2: paediatric normal limits. In: Macfarlane PW, van prevalence of end QRS notching and slurring in
J Electrocardiol 2013;46:4116. Oosterom A, Pahlm O, et al., editors. Specialized apparently healthy populations. Presented at:
6. Kambara H, Phillips J. Long-term evaluation Aspects of ECG. London, UK: Springer-Verlag, Computing in Cardiology Conference (CinC);
of early repolarization syndrome (normal variant 2012:639778. September 710, 2014; Cambridge, MA.
RST-T segment elevation). Am J Cardiol 1976;38: 16. Mason JW, Ramseth DJ, Chanter DO, et al. 26. Rosso R, Glikson E, Belhassen B, et al.
15761. Electrocardiographic reference ranges derived Distinguishing benign from malignant early
7. Wasserburger RH, Alt WJ. The normal RS-T from 79,743 ambulatory subjects. J Electrocardiol repolarization: the value of the ST-segment
segment elevation variant. Am J Cardiol 1961;8: 2007;40:22834. morphology. Heart Rhythm 2012;9:2259.
18492. 17. Macfarlane PW, Clark EN. ECG measurements 27. Heng SJH, Clark EN, Macfarlane PW. End QRS
8. Chung EK. Electrocardiography: Practical in end QRS notching and slurring. J Electrocardiol notching or slurring in the electrocardiogram: in-
Applications With Vectorial Principles. 2nd edition. 2013;46:3859. uence on the denition of early repolarization.
Hagerstown, MD: Harper & Row, 1980. J Am Coll Cardiol 2012;60:9478.
18. Clark EN, Katibi I, Macfarlane PW. Auto-
9. Spodick D. Early repolarization: an under- matic detection of end QRS notching or slurring.
investigated misnomer. Clin Cardiol 1997;20:9134. J Electrocardiol 2014;47:1514.
10. Surawicz B, Macfarlane PW. Inappropriate 19. Gussak I, Antzelevitch C. Early repolarization KEY WORDS cardiac arrhythmias,
and confusing electrocardiographic terms: J-wave syndrome: clinical characteristics and possible electrocardiography, end-QRS notching/
syndromes and early repolarization. J Am Coll cellular and ionic mechanisms. J Electrocardiol slurring, heart conduction system,
Cardiol 2011;7:15846. 2000;33:299309. sudden cardiac death, ventricular brillation