Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1. B.Tech Third Year Student, Civil Engineering Department, VIT University, Vellore, Vellore, Tamil Nadu, India
2 .Senior Professor, Structural and Geotechnical Engineering Division, VIT University, Vellore, Tamil Nadu, India
The expansive soils of India fall under A7 group of By free swell method, swell pressure (p s) is the pressure
USPRA classification system in which the sub groups required to bring back or compress a swollen specimen
are given by group index method [19]. to its initial void ratio. The swell pressure has also been
defined by different surcharges method and constant
III. METHODS FOR IDENTIFICATION OF volume method.
EXPANSIVE SOILS
3) Mineralogical Study: For the proper categorization
1) Subsurface Exploration: For identification of soils, of soil, different tests are conducted. The simple field
the most common method include subsurface tests include free swell test, load expansion test and
exploration which further includes preliminary dehydration test. Mineralogical study is also done by
exploration and detailed exploration. This provides an XRD [X-Ray Diffraction] method and Electron
idea of soil classification. Recently remote sensing Microscope Resolution [EMR]. The use of EMR is not
technique has come into picture. at field level due to its high cost of use.
1.1)Visual Exploration: The process is carried out 3.1)Simple lab test
based on color, texture and observations made at the
field. The field identification of expansive soils can be 3.1.1)Differential free swell test: In this method, soil
done by observing the cracking pattern of the surface of fraction passing 425um sieve is oven dried at a
the soil in summer seasons but in other seasons detailed temperature of 105 degrees centigrade. Then 10 grams
study is required. of this soil is poured separately into two graduated
cylindrical glass jars of 100 ml capacity. One contains
1.2)Remote Sensing Techniques:Presence of expansive distilled water while other kerosene. Both the cylinders
soil increases cost and time for many civil engineering are left for 24 hours and the final volumes are noted.
construction projects. Identification of the expansive The FSI is calculated (HOLTS & Gibbs 1956) as
soils and rocks using remote sensing, which involves
less ground visits, should be useful. The identification of FSI = (VwVk) / Vk100 - (2)
a few training samples is the first phase of remote
sensing investigation. Then a signature is developed Where Vw and Vk= volume of the soil in water and
which can represent the training samples. Identification kerosene respectively.
of expansive soils is thereafter tried using the supervised
3.1.2)Load expansion test:This test is done to measure
classification technique, following the maximum
the change in volume from remolded condition to the air
likelihood decision rule. Success and applicability of
dried and saturated condition.
one or the other of the methods depends upon the nature
of data structure, uniqueness of the signature, statistical Two identical specimens (undisturbed or remolded) are
distances between the signatures, nature of information taken in the "fixed ring type consolidometer", at desired
class being sought, spectral bands used etc. All the three density and water content. The specimens are allowed to
groups of spectral bands - visual, infra-red and dry in air till shrinkage limit. Volume of one of the
microwave- have been applied for the investigation. The specimens is measured by immersing it in mercury
final result of classification appears in the form of a while other is loaded in the consolidometer. The change
classified map. in volume is recorded.
2) Swelling Characteristics: Since the expansive soils 3.2) Specialized test: Under Differential Thermal
have the unique property of swelling, they exhibit the Analysis (DTA) the soil is heated for the chemical
characteristics of swell pressure and swell potential. reactions to occur. The reaction at different
Swell potential is defined as the ratio of increase in temperatures, depending on characteristics of mineral,
thickness to the initial thickness of the clay specimen, provides the idea of level of expansive nature of soil.
written as
The X-Ray Diffraction(XRD) method is used to
S% = (H/H)*100 - (1) determine the rough idea of thickness of minerals
present and thickness of molecular water layers on the
2) Moisture Barriers: Installation of vertical moisture swelling pressure and swelling potential decreases
barriers is one of the successful methods for minimizing significantly.
differential movement of a road pavement constructed
on an expansive clay subgrade. This method is already The use of GGBS (eco-cement) in expansive soil
being used across the United States, Australia (Victoria) stabilization is a new process in geotechnical field
and in other countries too. In most cases, replacement is (AniculaesiMircea et al). The laboratory tests report that
considered to be cost effective, but in case of rail and the replacement of expansive soil with cement and
road construction, replacement method is cost GGBS in the ratio of 1:1 improves the shear strength
prohibitive too. and decrease in compressibility will be noticed.For
practical implications, this technique requires high cost
The experiment results of TxDOT (instrument) for input.
various methods of minimizing damage by
encapsulating clay with impermeable fabric suggests 4) Fly Ash:Fly ash is a waste material, obtained from
that vertical moisture barrier proves to be successful burning of coal in Thermal Power Plants. The disposal
method, when installed in the shoulder of the pavement. of fly ash is a major challenge for power plant
For this experiment, both horizontal and vertical barriers authorities. It is a hazardous material for atmosphere
were used. [13] because of its low specific gravity and is non-plastic in
nature. One of the disposal techniques includes the
However this technique of moisture barriers is highly stabilization of expansive soils using fly ash [8].
expensive therefore it is reserved for major highways.
The technological investigations in Northern Victoria Fly ash can be used as a stabilizer for soil due to its
pozzolanic effect or due to self-hardening property
(Australia) have resulted in cost-efficient moisture
under favorable conditions of moisture and compaction
barrier which can be adopted in local roads (Evans et al, (Rollings, 1996). Studies have been carried out by
2004).The vertical barriers stop the seasonal lateral Phanikumar and Sharma (2004) on the effect of fly ash
moisture migration through the subgrade, beneath the on engineering properties of expansive soil [23].The
pavement (Picornell & Lytton, 1986). The barrier must samples of ash-blended expansive soil with fly ash
extend at least till active zone (depth of cracking) for contents of 0,5,10, 15 and 20% were used. The
effective reduction in moisture migration. penetration resistance of the soil mixed with fly ash was
determined from penetration tests (ASTM 1999,
The use of latest technologies and devices like Troxler D1558). The index properties of the test sample are
mentioned below.
Sentry 200-AP, could be installed to evaluate the
moisture measurement inside and outside of vertical The result was reduction in plasticity characteristics and
moisture barriers for more reliable data [13]. FSI by 50% on addition of 20% fly ash. The hydraulic
conductivity (k) decreased with increase in fly ash
3) Cement:The replacement of certain percentage of content. Swell potential and swell pressure decreased to
expansive soil with Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) 50% on 20% addition of fly ash, but above 20% no
shows astonishing results. The percentage of soil considerable change has been observed. Compaction
removed could be 8%, 10% or 20% depending on behavior, penetration resistance, undrained shear
strength were examined.
various physical and geotechnical factors at the site. FSI,
Table 1 : Properties of index of expansive soils and fly ash
;.
Table 2 : Effect of Fly Ash on Index Properties, Swelling, Compaction Behavior and Hydraulic Conductivity.
Undrained cohesion (cu) was calculated using Sanglerat 5) Use Of Lime:Expansive clay stabilization with
(1972) relation between the penetration resistance and chemicals has been found to reduce swelling and
cu; influence Free Swell Index FSI, swelling pressure and
swell potential. Among all additives, lime is one of the
Qc =Nk cu + Po - (3)
economical and effective additives. It reduces swell
potential meanwhile increases workability and strength.
where Qc = penetration resistance; cu = undrained
Lime content of 4% can be added to expansive soil as
cohesion; Po = total overburden pressure; and Nk=
beyond 4% results in increased swell potential and
penetration constant. The graph between measured cu
swelling pressure (Phanikumar). Experimental study on
with percentage of fly ash and watercontent is drawn.
effect of lime on Index (FSI), swell potential, swelling
pressure, consolidation characteristics, compaction
characteristics and strength behavior [14,8].
Fig 2: Variation of measured cu with percentage
As experimental authentication, tests have been
conducted (Phanikumar) on the sample of expansive soil
1.2m depth, having FSI of 165% and using unslaked
lime as additive. The other details of the sample include
Table 3: Index properties
The initial water content (wi %) and the dry unit weight
of the soil were kept constant at 0% and 13 KN/m3
respectively. Lime concentration (by dry weight of
expansive soil) was varied as 0%, 2%, 4% and 6%.
Evaluation of two test samples was done and the
average was reported.
Decrease in PI takes place due to increase in PL and swelling pressure could not be measured at a lime
decrease in LL with increase in lime content. At a lime content of 6%.
content of 4%, a maximum reduction in PI of 36% was
obtained. No further change in PI was observed when
the lime content was increased beyond 4%.
VI. BEST PAVEMENT PRACTICE - RESULTS Clays classification using various methods.
AND DISCUSSION
The use of polymer modified seals on
The use of mechanical alterations seems to be infeasible stabilized pavements to minimize reflective
for large highway or rail project. The only way is cracking.
chemical alteration done using cement, lime, fly ash or
other material; depending upon the use. The technique VIII. CONCLUSION
of fly ash uses the waste materials and hence it is
Investigation of expansive soil is not only necessary for
environmentally friendly too.
exploring the engineering properties of expensive soils
As this paper focuses on road and rail construction on and discussing the expansion mechanism but also
expansive soil, the latest trend has been discussed in this indispensable as to the improvement and reinforcement
topic. Currently, the use of geo-synthetics is considered of expansive soils and the discussion of new soil
to be most effective way of achieving a variety of research techniques and methods. As the Indian
outcomes. The main reason behind this includes government aims for smart cities and development of
availability of a variety of geo-synthetic with specific villages, the enhancement in transportation systems is an
material properties. indispensable part of this program. During the
application of expansive soils in the construction and
Tutumuler and Kwon (2005) found that geotextiles and employment of embankment, the peculiarity is
geo-grids are extensively being used in U.S.A as a influenced by both the nature of the denudation and
subgrade restraint. The study on tri-axial geo-grid deliquescence of expansive soils.
performance (Qian et al, 2010) reports that tri-axial geo-
grid provide more uniform resistance to material IX. ABOUT THE AUTHORS
movement, reduced pavement displacement and vertical
stresses rather than uniaxial and biaxial grids. The Dr. B R Phanikumar -PhD, Senior Professor, Civil
limitation includes that most geo-grids do not provide Engineering, VIT University, Vellore Division of
moisture barrier, drainage or particle separation. Structural and Geotechnical Engineering. 31
publications, 1.55 k reads and 225 citations has been
The use of rigid pavements has proven unsuccessful on observed as per research gate on his various papers.
expansive soils; so flexible pavement comes into role.
However flexible pavement requires effective Vijay Kumar Singh- Third year Civil Engineering
impervious base, subbase or a membrane below the B.Tech student from VIT University, Vellore campus,
surface (Haliburton,1972). For flexible pavement to be India. no 9629343964
achieved, documented empirical or mechanistic
S V Dinesh Babu Bommireddy- Third year Civil
materials is suggested.
Engineering B.Tech student from VIT University,
VII. FUTURE SCOPE Vellore campus, India. no:9566561948
To determine the active depth of expansive [3] Satyanarayana.B (1966).Swelling pressure and related mechanical
properties of black cotton soils, PhD Thesis, I. I. Sc., Bangalore.
soils.
[4] Katti, R.K. (1978). Search for solutions to problems in black
Advantages of performance based testing over cotton soils, First I.G.S Annual Lecture, Indian Geotech. Society at
I.I.T., Delhi.
traditional testing.
[5] Ranganatham B.V. and Satyanarayana, B. (1965).A rational [15]Damage mechanism of expansive soils Hussein Elarabi Building
method of predicting swelling potential for compacted expansive and Road Research Institute, University of Khartoum.
clays, Proc. 6th Int. Conf. S.M. & F.E., Canada, Vol.1, pp. 92-96.
[16] E.A.Sorochan, Construction of buildings on expansive soils,
[6] Phanikumar, B.R., Malini, C.A. and Karthika, R. (2012). Swell Moscow (1999).
consolidation characteristics of artificial sand clay mixes, Jrl. of
Geomechanics and Geoengineering: An international journal, Vol.7, [17] International Journal of Engineering and Innovative Technology
Issue 1. pp. 69-74. (IJEIT) Volume 2, Issue 3, September 2012; Effect of Fly Ash on an
Expansive Soil for Flexible Pavement Design Lakshmi Keshav,
[7] Sharma, D., Jain, M. P. and Prakash, C. (1978). Handbook on Mangaiarkarasi.V
underreamed and bored compaction pile foundations, Roorkee, India,
Central Building Research Institute. [18] Expanssive soils Problems and Remedies, B.R. Phanikumar
Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, VIT University, Vellore
[8] Phanikumar, B.R. (2009). Effect of lime and fly ash on swell 632 014, India.
consolidation and shear strength characteristics of expansive clays: A
comparative study, Jrl. of Geomechanics and Geoengineering: An [19]BLACK COTTON SOILS OF INDIA A review of engineering
international journal, Vol.4, Issue 2, pp. 175-181. properties and Construction Techniques. U.G. Project report submitted
by A.M. Patankar, D.M. Mukewar and S.L. Khankhoje Final Year B.E
[9] Rollings, R. S., Burkes, J. P. and Rollings, M. P. (1999). Sulfate .Students of Vishveshvarayya Regional College of Engineering
attack on cement-stabilised sand, Journal of Geotechnical and Nagpur.
Geoenvironmental Engineering, 125 (5), 364-372.
[20] Analysis of the railway heave induced by soil swelling at a site in
[10] Acosta, H., Edil, T. and Benson, C. (2003). Soil stabilization and southern France Anh-Minh Tang1, Yu-Jun Cui1, Viet-Nam Trinh1,
drying using fly ash, Geo Engineering Rep No. 03-03, Dept. of Civil Yahel Szerman2, Gilles Marchadier2.
and Environmental Engg., Univ. of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison,
Wis. 21. Holtz, W.G. and Gibbs, H.J.(1956),Engineering properties of
expansive clays, Trans. ASCE, Vol. 121, 1956.
[11] Suri, S., Adhikari, R. and Phanikumar, B. R. (2013). Free swell
index of an expansive soil blended with limeand fly ash, A Research 21. Katti, R.K. et el Report on research on B.C. Soils with and
Report submitted to VIT University, India. without inorganic additives, IIT Mumbai.
[12] Effective Road Pavement Design for Expansive Soils in Ipswich 22. Physical, mineralogical and micromorphologicalproperities of
by Catherine May Caunce,Submitted: November, 2010. expansive soil treated at different temperature. Jian HYPERLINK
"http://www.hindawi.com/20587498/" Li,1 Xiyong Wu,1 and Long
[13] Kieren A. Walters on Investigation of Construction Practices and Hou2.
Test Procedures for Road Pavements on Expansive Subgrades. 23. Effects of fly ash on engineering properties of expansive soils.
B.R. Phani Kumar1 and Radhey S. Sharma, M.ASCE
[14] Effect of lime on engineering behaviour of expansive Clays,
B.R. Phanikumar Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, VIT 24. SSRG online portal
University, Vellore632 014.