Yo u t h Paper Awards

EFFECT OF THIRD-PARTY PARTICIPATION IN URBAN PLANNING: A CASE STUDY ON

ENNING ROAD IN GUANGZHOU

WU Zuquan

KEYWORDS: third-party; urban planning; public

participation; Enning Road

1

62

2014 38 2

CITY PLANNING REVIEW

VOL.38 NO.2 FEB. 2014

2008

ABSTRACT: Based on interviews and materials
collected from media, this paper took the Enning
Road renovation project in Guangzhou as an
example, and illustrated the predicament faced by
the public in their participation in Chinas urban
planning, as well as the behavior of third-party
and its effects when participating in Chinas urban PX
planning. The research revealed that the existing
public participation framework failed in coordinating
different stakeholders interests no matter in the
active participation from the top to the bottom or in
1002-1329 the passive involvement from the bottom to the top.
(2014)02-0062-07
A competent third-party could effectively facilitate
TU984 the public to have their words heard and promote
A the effects of public participation in urban planning
doi10.11819/cpr20140212a by acting as a bridge connecting the public with
the entrepreneurial government. Whats more,
(1986-) under the condition that the government lays more
emphasis on economic interests and the public lacks
due social consciousness, the role of third-party in (2005)
2013-12-11 protecting public interests is particularly significant.
 (2003)(
(2008 1)
2012) ()


2.1.2

2090





2.1.3


2

()
2.1 ()

63
(Advocacy Planning)

(20002000)
(Communicative Planning)(1999
2012)
2.1.1

1960 2.2

(Davidoff P)
(NGO)(2012)


NGO
(2)
(Davidoff1965)
1990
(Community Planner)

1 2
Fig.1 Framework of public participation in Taiwan Fig.2 Improvement to existing framework of public
participation in China



Yo u t h Paper Awards

3

3.1




(3)






64 2007

2014 38 2

CITY PLANNING REVIEW

(4)
3
Fig.3 Location of Enning Road Block 3.2
VOL.38 NO.2 FEB. 2014

3.2.1







2006

3.2.2
2008
201091950
4 1506444
Fig.4 Site of Enning Road Project






(5)

4
5
Fig.5 Process of Enning Road renovation project

1
Tab.1 Public participation guided by the government


2007.3-2007.8


2008.4-2008.11


2009


2009.12-2010.1

4.2
4.1

65
2008-2010

(2)





(1)


28.6%

4.3
(6)

6 ()
Fig.6 Reasons for local residents dissatisfaction with related resettlement and compensation

policies for Enning Road project



Yo u t h Paper Awards

() 4.3.1












2
4.3.2

Tab.2 Process of active participation by local residents

(

3)

2008.5

20109

66 2009.11 7982011


2014 38 2

CITY PLANNING REVIEW

183

2010.1



2010.1
VOL.38 NO.2 FEB. 2014

4.3.3



220100
2010.4


2010.7

3
Tab.3 Primary activities organized by Enning Road Academic Group

2010.3
2010.9 798
2011.9.
2011.9
2011.10
2010.4
2010.5

2010.8
2010.9

2010.10


2012.9




4.4
(
20108 )
2012
20129



201010

15

20116 5.3
(7)

(
130 2006) 67

5.3.1

5

5.1

5.2

7
Fig.7 The new version of planning of Enning Road Block



Yo u t h Paper Awards

NGO



(




(Notes)
(Xi Guan)
5.3.2






2010


Arnstein S833

(2002)

68
3

2014 38 2

CITY PLANNING REVIEW

(References)
1 Arnstein S R. Ladder of Citizen Participation[J]. Journal
of the American Institute of Planners, 1969,35(4):233-
5.4 239.
VOL.38 NO.2 FEB. 2014

2 Davidoff P. Advocacy and Pluralism in Planning[J]. Journal

of the American Institute of Planning, 1965.

3 , .

[N].2011-06-29(9).
Chen Wen, HE Shan. Residents of Enning Road Support
the Self Renewal[N].Xinkuai Daily, 2011-06-29 (9).
4 .
[J]. 2008(1)50-55.
Hao Juan. Improving the Ability of Public Participation

in Urban Planning[J]. Urban Development Studies,
2008(1):50-55.
5 . [J].
2002(5): 79-83.
Jiao Yixue. Non-Government Organization in British
Heritage Conservation[J]. Planners, 2002(5):79-83.
6 .

[C]//
2012. 2012.
Lin Dongyang, Zhou Kebin, Wang Shifu. Urban
6 Regeneration and Public Participation in Guangzhou:
Discussion from Enning Road Event[C]//Proceedings
of the Annual National Planning Conference: Diversity and

Inclusion. 2012.

7 .
[J].2012(4)
79-85.
Mo Wenjing, Xia Nankai. Planning Participation
Approaches and Public Political Maturity[J]. Urban Planning

(75)
 ,2007(12):135-138. 14 ()..[M].,
Yang Yuzhen. Discussion about Lu Zuofus Practice and .:,2010.
Ideology of Urban Construction: A Study Briefing About Howard E.Garden Cities of To morrow[M].Translated by
Historical Personality in Modern City History[J]. Huazhong Jin Jingyuan. Beijing: The Commercial Press, 2010.
Architecture, 2007(12):135-138. 15 (),().
11 .[M].: [M].,.:
,2000. ,2009.
Zheng Dahua. Rural Reconstruction Movement in Republic Hall P, Ward C. Sociable Cities: The Legacy of Ebenezer
of China[M].Beijing: Social Sciences Academic Press, Howard[M].Translated by Huang Yi.Beijing: China Building
2000. Industry Press, 2009.
12 . 16 .2012[M].:
[M].:,2001. ,2012.
Wu Xiangxiang. Biography of James Yen: Striving for the Niu Wenyuan. The 2012 Annual Report of New
Global Rural Reconstruction of Sixty Years[M]. Changsha: Urbanization in China[M]. Beijing: Science Press, 2012.
Yuelu Press, 2001. 17 .
13 .(3) [M].:,2013.
[M].,1985. Wu Tinghai, Zhang Neng, Xu Bin. Sharing Space: Neo-
Education Science Institute of Central China Normal Marxism and Chinas Urbanization[M]. Beijing: The
University. Collected Works of Tao Xingzhi(Volume 3)[M]. Commercial Press, 2014.
Changsha: Hunan Education Press, 1985.

(68)
Forum,2012(4):79-85. Yin Jie, Luo Xiaolong. Thinking of the Development of 75
8 . NGO in Chinese Urban Planning[J].Planners, 2003(1):74-

[J]. 77.

2005(7)52-56. 15 .
Qi Dongjin, Zhou Jianyun. Public Participation in Urban PX
Planning: Two Cases in Mainland China and Hong Kong[J]. [J]. , 2010(3): 81-86.
City Planning Review, 2005(7):52-56. Zhao Min, Liu Jing. Social Claims and Institutional
9 . Guarantee in Public Participation of Urban Planning
[J]. 2012(6) Discussion from Xiamen PX ProjectEvent[J].Urban
82-90. Planning Forum,2010(3):81-86.
Wang Fenglong, Chen Qianmin, Xu Yanyan, et al. 16 .
Communicative Planning Theory: Introduction, Criticism and
Inspiration[J]. Urban Planning International, 2012(6):82- [J].1999(6)33-36.
90. Zhang Tingwei.FromSpeaking Truth to Power
10 . to Communicative Planning[J]. City Planning Review,
[N]. , 2010-08-27(9) 1999(6):33-36.
Wu Xuanjian, Chen Wen. The Government Acknowledge 17 .
Plan of Enning Road was Wrong[N].Xinkuai Daily, 2010- [J].
08-29(9). 2005(4)41-48.
11 ,,. Zhou Jiangping, Sun Mingjie. Public Participation in Urban
[C]//2012 Planning and Development Decision-making: Literature in
. 2012. the West and Its Implications[J]. Urban Planning Overseas,
Xie Shixiong, Zhou Yueyun, Li Hao. Fair and Efficiency 2005(4):41-48.
Construction of the Third-party Planning[C].//Proceedings 18 .
of the Annual National Planning Conference: Diversity and [J]..2009(4):112-
Inclusion. 2012. 116.
12 . Davidoff[J]. Zhang Wangfeng, Zhang Xiangde, Xu Jia. The Research
2000(1)30-32. on Public Participation in the Urban Planning Process[J].
Yu Hong. Davidoffs Advocacy Theory[J].Urban Planning Urban Studies, 2009(4):112-116.
Overseas, 2001(1):30-32. 19
13 . [J].
[J]. 2005(5):62-65 2006(4):1-6.
Yang Fan. Let More to Participate in Urban Planning[J]. Zhang Jingxiang, Yin Jie, Luo Xiaolong. Research of
Planners, 2005(5):62-65. Urban Spatial Development Under the Circumstances of
14 . NGO Local Governments Entrepreneuralization[J]. Human
[J].2003(1)74-77. Geography, 2006(4):1-6.