Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Facultad de Qumica
Grupo 66
Anlisis de Artculo
1
Instalox Metal Tower Packing
2
Height Equivalent to a Theoretical Plate
transferencia de masa para empaques estructurados el desempeo ha sido igual o
mejor que las correlaciones de transferencia de masa examinadas.
La figura 11 es una comparacin de datos del reflujo binario total (HETP) para los
anillos Pall de metal con los resultados de la simulacin para una seleccin de
distintas mezclas binarias y tamaos de empaque. En cada caso el coeficiente de
correlacin de la transferencia de masa desarrollado para la investigacin tiene un
desempeo indudablemente mejor que los otros coeficientes de transferencia
estudiados; esta mejora en el desempeo es un patrn que se repita en cada caso
estudiado a lo largo de la investigacin.
Conclusiones a las que llegaron
General Comments
Ayala Bueno Sabrina Valeria
Personally I feel with the freedom to admit that the article has engaged me since I
read the first word. Its clear how committed the investigators are and their intentions
are simple to understand. It seems important to not only evaluate the weight of the
work done here but also the way they express themselves, this article is not only
interesting but also easy to read thanks to its inherent order. The introduction is
pretty neat as the development and results obtained. The only problem that the
paper presents is the fact that in order to understand it completely is necessary to
check many other documents.
After clearing all of the points above I need to emphasize also the investigation; for
anyone with experience in any industry is easy to conclude the importance of packed
towers and how difficult it is to understand them or at least when the main purpose
is to predict the flow and the general behavior of the fluid inside, for this reason I can
say that regardless to all the amounts of information that can be found about the
theme it is never too much, it is always a good idea to search for more as it is well
known the complexity driven with this subject.
This article offers a perspective that not many articles have touching a considerable
number of subjects going through many mathematical models with the main purpose
of comparing the calculated and experimental data. Evaluating the article brings up
a flashback of theoretical lessons. As a conclusion is necessary to emphasize how
complete the article is, it not only has information regarding to the actual project but
also touches general cases and therefore its value cannot be measured.
I believe that this article is very complete, we can see how a lot of subjects that we
use in the school are mixed here. First I want to highlight the importance to know
how to use a software, all the time when a read an article always talk about a
software that was used to determinate the results, what I want to say is the fact that
technology plays a very important role in the investigation and that something we
can see in this article.
We can observe that the main theme of the article is to find new correlations for the
mass transfer, so first of all they prove the old correlations and as I mentioned with
the help of a software they determinate new correlations, that correlations helps to
know the HEPT of the tower, so is important to say how field of study we have in this
subject, in this case the article talk only about a few types of packings, but we others
types, so this theme is really extensive and its really important for a chemical
engineering because the package towers are one of the most common and useful
equipment in the industry, we are going to face them all the time.
I think that the article is really easy to understand, use tools like graphics to compare
the results, the ones that obtained with old correlations and the ones that they
obtained in the new. In all the cases they observed that the new correlations are
better than the others.
Knowing the importance of what is stated above the main concern of any student is
at least worth acquiring the skill, although for the most advisable resource is
possibly experience and practice however it is no mystery that frequently the
impossibility of This is presented to us so we look for other resources to achieve
the goal is no small thing and in short is something that the article offers.
Knowing the importance of what is stated above the main concern of any student is
at least worth acquiring the skill, although for the most advisable resource is
possibly experience and practice however it is no mystery that frequently the
impossibility of This is presented to us so we look for other resources to achieve
the goal is no small thing and in short is something that the article offers.