Professional Documents
Culture Documents
STUK-B-VALO 59
K-H. Hellmuth
Surveillance department
H. Wehner
Federal Institute forGeosciences and Natural Resources
Hannover, FRG
Sold by:
The Finnish Government Printing Centre
P.O.BOX 516 SF-00101 HELSINKI
Tel. +358 0 56601
FINNISH CENTRE FOR RADIATION
STUKBVAL059 ANI) NUCLEAR SAFETY
HELLMUTH, K-H. The long-urm stability of natural bitumen - A case study at the bitumen-impregnated
limestone deposit near Holzen/Lower Saxony, RFC STUK-B-VALO 59, Helsinki 1989,69 pp.
ISBN 5-47-2989-7
ISSN 0781-2868
ABSTRACT
Natural bitumen can be an aid in the assessment of die long-term behaviour of technical bitumen in the
geosphere in general, and under die specific conditions at sites of nuclear waste repositories in particular.
Natural occurrences of bitumen usually have die drawback that die original material before alteration or
degradation began is not known.
The present work applies an alternative approach: on die basis of die geology and stratigraphy at a site where
bitumen samples have been taken, die existence of a gradient in die parameters of subaerial and microbial
degradation processes may be assumed. Therefore relative variations in properties, composition and structure
(bitumen content, volatile fraction, elemental composition, chromatographic fractions, saturated hydro-
carbons, trace metals, humic substances) at different locations widiin the deposit have been analysed.
The bitumen impregnates a bed of porous Jurassic limestone which crops out at die surface and dips under
sediments of various permeability. The quality of the bitumen is in compliance with standards for soft
technical bitumen, although it can be characterized as highly biodegraded. It has probably not been affected
to any marked degree by degradation since die Quartemary or possibly even late Tertiary, however, as
observable variations in compositon and properties are only minor and seem to exhibit no clear relation to
die present geological setting. Minor nuances may be caused by surface influences near fractures and faults
but could not be assessed from die few samples taken. Only near die present outcrop do diere seem to be
signs of increased oxidation. Direct exposure to die weadier at die surface leads to destruction of die bitumen
within a very thin surface layer. Traces of humic substances probably originating from die decomposition of
bitumen were found The rate of bitumen degradation at outzrops seems to coincide with the rate of
weadiering and erosion of die host rock.
Taking into account die limited number of samples and die preliminary nature of this work, it can be
concluded from the results that die time scales necessary to achieve significant alteration of bitumen under
the given conditions far exceed die time scales dictated by die half-lives of radionuclides in low- and
medium-level radioactive waste.
A
CONTENTS
ABSTRACT 1
CONTENTS 3
PREFACE 5
1 INTRODUCTION 7
3 EXPERIMENTAL 24
(samples, methods)
5 CONCLUSIONS 56
REFERENCES 60
APPENDIX 63
PLATES 68
o
PREFACE
1 INTRODUCTION
-30OO-\
i*SR_ELFR|EC ~ , ^ _
Mittlerer
^jas-sch/chten
-200 Himmeridge
- - __ _ ^ l ^ ^ W r n m e p T d g - e
Mi'ttlerer ~~'
Kimmer/'dge
-100
enoolith
Fig. 3. Cross section through Stollen Gustav mine (the profile does not
exactly transsect the open pit).
Cross Section through the ancient mine HERZOG WILHELM
scale 1:2000
wo 200 m (D) sample locality
WNW ESEl
m .s.l
SOO A
<8> H /
anc. pit
anc. quarry Herzog Wilhelm Hil
s-Sandstein
Wintjenberg
Neokom ~jQn
-^J^JVmmendge "^MS^srn^^~2J-\
200 H
Korallenooiith
Fig. 4. Cross section through the ancient mine Herzog Wilhelm (1)
15
Slratigraphischc Cbersichl
Neokom
I vvsalden
Portland
Kimmendge
Oford
calfovien
O Bathonien
| Bajocien
l Aaltnitn
TRIAS
fS i * . J
5
^*"*-"--i6 |w^w 7 | ^ |
Limestone and the Lower Munden marl series, may have been
more than 100 m thick, if a comparison is made with thick-
nesses observable at sites where they are not eroded
(1). On the basis of currently observable erosion rates
from plane to mountainous zones (10 to 200 m/Ma (9)),
the time scales for the exposure of the asphalt to surface
influences are up to millions of years.
ng areas
CJ1
Fig. 7. Plan of the Stollen Gustav mine. Lager Elfriede Stollen Gustav (Oberbank)
27
Stollen Gustav
A= e
x= c
-f"= open pit
TOC(%) = Herzog Vilhelm
lO
*"
/
/
BITUMEN (%)
io
Fig. 8. Correlation between total organic carbon and
extractable bitumen (CH2 Cl2 ).
35
Stollen Gustav
open pit, 0-1 cm 4.9 1.7 4.4 16
open pit. 1-5 cm 5.2 1.9 4.7 17
adit, A, 1 m 4.2 4.2 3.3 16
(upper 2.5 m 2.5 2.9 2.6 18
deposit) 5 m 2.4 2.7 2.6 9
B, 1 m 2.3 2.6 2.3 10
(upper 2.5 m 3.3 2.6 2.5 32
deposit) 5 m 1.0 2.0 2.1 21
B, 1 m 0.7 0.8 1.0 20
(lower 2.5 m 1.8 2.1 2.0 16
deposit 5 m 3.0 3.2 3.1 (46)
c, 1 m 0.8 1.0 1.1 24
(lower 2.5 m 2.1 1.8 1.9 23
deposit) 5 m 0.9 1.0 1.3 21
Herzog Wilhelm
Germania 8.3 9.6 7.6 10
seep 98 100 5
Archaeol. sample
bulk 100 2.5
weather, rind 100 3.0
sample H N remarks
Stallen Gustav
Herzog Wilhelm
Germania deposit 83.2 10.3 0.3 1.6 4.6
fracture seep 85.5 10.3 0.4 1.8 6.3 1.2% ash
Habuba Kabira, bulk 76.8 8.5 0.4 10.6 3.6 1.7% ash
(archaeol.) rind 75.1 8.1 0.3 9.9 6.6 2.1% ash
Mohenjo Daro, India 79.0 6.3 0.7 7.5 6.8
(archaeol.)
Stollen Gustav
H/C . Ragusa
Lobs aim
+ = open pit
= A
A = B
X = C
O = Herzog Wilhelm
= Herzog Wilhelm,
fracture seep
Q Siirt
(Turkey)
Hohenjo Daro
(India) archaeol.
1
0.02 0.06 QIC O/C
Fig. 9. H/C and 0/C ratios of various bitumens.
Pathway of degradation.
39
The results are shown in Fig. 10. Note that the "HET"
fraction in the diagram includes asphaltenes and residue.
The material can be classified on the basis of the soluble
fraction and the hydrocarbon contents (saturated and
aromatic hydrocarbons) as asphalt. Exceptions are samples
from the outcrop. The archaeological sample lies between
asphalt and gilsonite (Fig. 11).
40
Stollen Gustav
open pit,, 0-1 cm 9.8 10.6 23.2 39.1
n
II
1-5 cm 14.6 15.4 23.5 26.8
adit. A, 1 m level 17.8 14.7 28.9 17.8
(upper 2.5 m 21.5 17.3 30.0 14.0
dep.) 5 m 20.5 18.2 29.9 13.8
STOLLEN GUSTAV
c f?
A B 0 A100
V c
+ T
X HW
0 V-2
100 0
20 40 60 80 100
% ARO
Gilsonit
Wurtzilit Grahamit
i i I I I I >
10 l
101 10'
% Extr.
100
%org.C
r
Signal
Retention time
Signal
Retention time
.'Uflnal
27
21 23 m 2S M
Retention time
Tiiiiiiiiiiiiiiirr
8 12 16 28 24 28 32 36 48 44 48 52 56 68 64 68 72 76
T i i i i i i i i i i i i i r T i r
8 12 16 28 24 28 32 3* 48 44 48 S2 St 68 t4 68 72 76
Fig. 16. Mass fragment m/z 71, adit, B, 2.5 m level,
lower deposit, saturated hydrocarbons.
89 ?3
T . n i i r T 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
12 16 28 24 28 32 36 48 44 48 52 56 68 64 68 72 76
Fig. 17, Mass fragment m/z 71, open pit, 1-5 cm, satu-
rated hydrocarbons.
47
MINOR MAJOR
BI0OE0RADATI0N
Stolien Gustav
open pit. 0--1 cm 32.3 1.78
open pit, 1--5 cm 26.9 1.98
adit, A 25.1 1.28
B 27.3 2.27
C 30.1 1.70
Stollen Gustav
open pit, 0-1 cm 16 31
open pit, 1-5 cm <1 5
adit, A, B, C <1 <l
(mixed sample)
The combined sample from below ground also gives the back-
ground level in the sediment. The possibility that the
humic substances isolated from the upper layers at the
outcrop resulted from contamination by soil material
some metres above had to be excluded. Elemental analysis
and examination by infrared- and nuclear magnetic reso-
nance spectrometry gave evidence that there is no simi-
larity between the humic acid fraction extracted and
common terrestrial humic acids.
52
The fulvic acids are very similar to each other and resem-
ble common terrestrial fulvic acids. They can be described
structurally as aliphatic, carbohydrate-type fulvic acids.
The sample extracted from the surface layer exhibits a
more polyhydroxylic character (hydroxylic C-0 signal at
1075 stronger than 1175 cnr1 ) than the sample from 1 to
5 cm depth, which is also reflected by the higher oxygen
content in the former (Table 8 ) .
ui
i. 0
!
4UCJ0 3600 32UU ^UUO ?'i rjfj ?UUU IfiO 1 ?OL' 8UU Ji
WHvENLIMbER
Hfl 1
/"K^
\
l5 IG'iO 14 80 :32O
1 i RO 1000 84~ 680 s;;
Wn'/L: NUMBER
Fig. 20. IR-spectrum of humic acids. Stollen Gustav,
open pit, 0 - 1 cm.
56
5 CONCLUSIONS
REFERENCES
APPENDIX 1
Zttultrr
T
SyM--m Abrrtlun* Stnlc
(Formition) tund Knrcnrnrnlalli* auch l'nt?rat'ifc)
- IE|
B. Holoiln
II. Q u a r t l r (aleht T a b . I I )
A. Pletatozan
<l.i-D-
AMI
E. P l l o i l n PlMYBlln
Pont ( - Panoon)
(T)
Sarmat Obtrc
Torton SO>a*
D. X l o z l n Hclvct Obere
BurrllgAl I MccmmolMM
1
AqulUn Inure
<2> SBBwMfrrTnoUw*
Owl!
C. O I l K o i l n } SUmp t'ntcrc
Rupcl
Mccmmolane
Utiort
( 3 7 - 3)
Barton
3
Auvera
Lulet
JEi
Z i Vptrn
(53 - i n
S pa mar
A Palloxan ThaneC
Mont
(.>)
M.m*tr.rhl
('umpu n i Scnon .
Sanion I GOMU
Turon
rrnomxn
Alh
Apt
Barrrmc
A. I ' n t r r r
Maillrrlv-
Krrlrtr
Val^ndil
Infraviilcnrfi* (
Portland <;>
( Malm
(WiB,r Kimni'rMg* 1y & * e\
J ur Qiforrl (a I)
64
APPENDIX 1 , c o n t .
Z.UAIK,
l 1 Formal wn Alrftiktnc
OIW>
(ml m c v ^ n m l a l f a * VntcrUvfe)
(i((..T.)+0
B. D | ( r r
{Bfiunrr lifcnini i (x.T.)
Uftin IfHtiliT.])
lUlmn (+f.Lu>([i.T.D
10. J u ra
Tanai (.C(.T.|)
(S<li*iriff FlicfiibMji>tn (* + )
J'a) S""" (. + )
lomlkum
i 1 Url Karnitckr
M.rlr.rpi J ,,
M n J V f t f n j Alprn
trrrocriKfc t>i* ntann | nurin martn
1-
Allrr-Sctir(ZIV)
c
_5
Ltmt V n t l Z III)
1 Tatar
B<rllrropkn
SdiMhu-i
StalWiirlk-SmlZII)
ci
E 3 K a i an
9
M
-ra-SrriclZI)
m 9. P e r m
(Dyii) Krruinadirr
8 e
E G
(Ufa) + Grdrnfr
Wjjfriwr S(hditra
Stvrrrnrr Sdtiditrn
(rnit VuHani-trn:
1 Tamba- *
l
Kwn-gwf
.Grtmilafrr*)
-3
e
Thoiryrr MiHhtro
ObrrftorV j
I Miidltrn
1
5 G*Ml>v-
e LcbjArr Siid-ten trrncr
<
3 MlIK
ba<hrr RjttfnAffrr
K w l > r 5tJ.rdti.rfl Sih m t f i 5Ar Ktrn
Ctthtrnrr
!!
[ SaarNahf [ [ TWing | Stril. Gr<tixfl nur i nnah-rmd parallel
_ (MO)
3
^ - A
"TOPOGRAPHISCHE
UBERSICHTSKARTE
DES
HILSGEBIETES
(N.ich d*r- H o h t n w i h K . h t e n U d f f a vc
n \
. ^ ^ ^ , v --- X . . - ,. .ttT>Ali
. - . . - U ! J .
::vli
'.;<'>.'-
J.
>. '(. .
'. . *--<'' . T T -
>
a
P:
z
D
-Brunsen
r>
lorphological map of t h e H i l s a r e a , x = s o l i e n Gustav.
Mllm
Dogger
List
Tnas
OtoritirbontWittWi
Abn*hm9dsbrtckiuhii Emfhiislt
f Frmmimfttmnfund a
W1 Wttldin 1
I Hwptbecktn
II Uilflbtcktn
III Oilbtcktn
APPENDIX
t to .
'iL-*rt
Hils trough
w
T h e NW-German W e a l d e n b a s i n ( 2 9 ) .
Interrelationship of three chromatographic observations (occurence of n-hydrocarbons
in pyrograms and chromatograms, and the presence of a baseline "hump") with two
geochemical prosesses, thermal maturation and biodegradation (30):
PLATES
PLATES
>*M&
ISBN 951-47-2989-7
ISSN 0781-2868
VMton prinMMhwtaJt