Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10.5368/aedj.2017.9.2.3.2
A POTENT REGIMEN FOR ORAL LICHEN PLANUS: A REVIEW
1 1
Tejaswi Katne Post graduate student
2 2
Anantha Venkata Srikar Muppirala Post graduate student
3 3
Rama Raju Devaraju Professor and Head
4 4
Ramlal Gantala Professor
1-4
Department of Oral Medicine and Radiology S.V.S Institute of Dental Sciences Telangana India
ABSTRACT: Background:Oral lichen planus (OLP) is a chronic inflammatory disease that affects oral mucosa. Substantial fluctuation is
seen between the patients in response to various treatments posing difficulty for the physician in management of the disease.
Aim: To assess efficacy of any form of intervention used to manage oral lichen planus.
Materials and methods: All the published randomised control trials from 2000 to 2016 in the management of OLP, comparing active
interventions with or without placebo irrespective of age, gender were selected from Cochrane central register of controlled trials,
CENTRAL, EMBASE and MEDLINE were included in the study, and SWOT analysis was performed.
Results and conclusion: Thirty two randomised control trials using different drug interventions were included in this systematic review.
The superiority of corticosteroids in remission of clinical signs of OLP is evident, though with few side effects. Future research with
consistent parameters and newer formulations, directed towards personalised medicine are required in a quest of the potent regime to treat
this condition.
INTRODUCTION
Oral lichen planus is a chronic inflammatory T-cell per study. All the studies included were performed in a
1
mediated autoimmune disease with unclear aetiology. secondary care except for one (yoke 2006), which was a
The conception in pathogenesis of Oral lichen planus has multi-centre study. Diagnosis of oral lichen planus was
been continuously changing from earlier era to recent confirmed clinically and histopathologically in all except in
times from initial concept of inflammation to immunological one study (Malhotra 2008).
mediated reaction then followed by the idea of
autoimmune mediated reaction to present genetic concept. Results and discussion
Accordingly the treatment strategies have been
2
continuously kept on changing to the present day. A randomised cross over study on 48 subjects was
Various treatment regimens have been tried to improve done by Buajeeb (2000) to compare the efficacy of
the lesions and to reduce the pain but a cure for OLP has Flucinolone acetonide gel 0.1% in two base forms (
not been found because of lack of an apparent cause and carbopol 1% and 0.5%) and Flucinolone acetonide in oral
its recalcitrant nature. Purpose of the present systematic base 0.5% for 4 weeks and concluded that both drugs
review was to evaluate the efficacy and safety of provided similar efficacy in the treatment but there was no
3
interventions in the treatment of OLP. statistical significance.
Effectiveness of Clobetasol (0.025%) and cyclosporine Study on 49 subjects was done to evaluate the efficacy
(1.5%) was compared on 40 subjects by Conrotto (2006) and safety of betamethasone (5 mg) oral mini pulse
in terms of long term remission of symptoms and cost therapy with triamcinolone acetonide 0.1% paste for 6
effectiveness for 2 months and stated that Clobetasol is months by Malhotra (2008) and concluded that both are
more effective than cyclosporine in inducing clinical equally effective but response is earlier with
improvement and gives less stable results with higher betamethasone oral mini pulse therapy and relapse of the
incidence of side effects in a follow up of 2 months. treatment was seen in half of the patients with more side
15
Cyclosporine is cost effective (five times higher than that effects.
6
of Clobetasol).
In a study conducted by Radfar (2008), the
A study on 139 subjects was done by Yoke (2006) to effectiveness of Clobetasol (0.05%) and tacrolimus (0.1%)
compare the effectiveness of cyclosporine solution with was evaluated. Regimen was used for 6 weeks on 30
triamcinolone acetonide in oral base for 8 weeks. Pain, subjects divided in 2 groups and summarized that the
16
burning sensation, area of reticulation erythema, ulceration latter is superior and is more effective than Clobetasol.
were all worse in patients receiving cyclosporine by the Thirty two subjects were evaluated by Corrocher (2008) to
th
end of 4 week and concluded that topical cyclosporine is compare the efficacy of tacrolimus 0.1% and Clobetasol
7
no more effective than steroid. 0.05% for 4 weeks and result was in favour of tacrolimus
with low symptom scores and is more effective than
17
Topical tacrolimus (0.1%) was compared with Clobetasol.
triamcinolone acetonide (0.1%)in hypromellose 20%
ointment by Laeijendecker(2006) on 40 subjects (20 in Efficacy of Aloe Vera with placebo for 8 weeks on 54
each group) for 6 weeks and results were in favour of subjects was carried out by Choonhakaran (2008) which
topical tacrolimus(0.1%) which induced a better initial stated that Aloe Vera is more effective than placebo and
therapeutic response than triamcinolone but relapses can be considered as a safe alternative treatment with no
8 18
occurred within 3-9 weeks of cessation of treatment. side effects.
Effectiveness of isotretinoin 0.18% with most frequently Efficacy of pimecrolimus 1% cream (Elidel) with vehicle
used isotretinoin 0.05% concentration was evaluated on for 30 days on 20 subjects was evaluated by Volz (2008)
70 subjects for 3 months by Scardina (2006) and drawing to a conclusion that pimecrolimus is more
concluded that isotretinoin 0.18% was superior and effective and no severe adverse reactions were reported in
19
effective in disappearance of dysplastic phenomena than one month follow up.
9
0.05%.
Thirty subjects were evaluated to know the efficacy of
Study was conducted on 13 subjects by Thongprasom Ignatia with placebo for 4 months by Mousavi (2009) which
20
(2007) to compare the effectiveness of cyclosporine stated that Ignatia has beneficial effects.
solution with triamcinolone acetonide 0.1% in orabase for
8 weeks and concluded that topical cyclosporine was not One hundred and twenty four subjects were included
effective than triamcinolone acetonide and more side in a study by Nolan (2009) to evaluate the efficacy of 0.2%
10
effects were noticed in patients receiving cyclosporine. hyaluronic acid and placebo for 28 days and concluded
that 0.2% hyaluronic acid was effective in reducing size of
Efficacy of curcuminoids capsules (2000mg/day) for 7 the lesion and providing efficacy for up to 4 hrs after
st
weeks and prednisone 60mg/day for 1 week on 33 administration and can be useful addition to the treatment
21
subjects were evaluated by Chainani Wu (2007) which option for oral lichen planus.
stated that curcuminoids at this dose were well tolerated
11
but this study ended early for futility. Carbone (2009) conducted a randomized, double-
blind, placebo-controlled trial to compare the efficacy and
Efficacy of 1% pimecrolimus for 4 weeks on 12 safety of two different formulations of Clobetasol, in the
subjects was done by Passeron (2007) and concluded that topical management of OLP and to evaluate the remission
pimecrolimus seems to be effective and well tolerated from signs and symptoms. Thirty-five patients were divided
treatment but with minimal side effects and relapse of the into two groups: the first received clobetasol propionate
12
treatment was seen in 1 month follow up. 0.025% and the second was given clobetasol propionate
0.05%. In all, 14 of the 15 clobetasol 0.025% patients
Forty subjects were evaluated to compare the efficacy (93%) and 13 of the 15 clobetasol 0.05% patients (87%),
and safety of pimecrolimus 1% cream with triamcinolone had symptoms improvement after 2 months of therapy (P
acetonide 0.1% for 2 months by Gorouhi (2007) drawing to = 0.001 in both groups). Also, 13 of the 15 clobetasol
a conclusion that both the drugs were effective in the 0.025% patients (87%) and 11 of the 15 clobetasol 0.05%
management but with minimal side effects noticed with patients (73%) had clinical improvement after 2 months of
13
pimecrolimus in 2 months of follow up. therapy (P < 0.05 in both groups). No statistical
differences were found in comparing the two different
22
Effect of Clobetasol propionate with and without topical formulations.
anti-fungal drug for 6 weeks on 35 subjects was carried by
Lodi (2007) which stated that addition of miconazole