Professional Documents
Culture Documents
helicopter operations in
the oil & gas industry
1998
Global experience
The International Association of Oil & Gas Producers (formerly the E&P Forum) has
access to a wealth of technical knowledge and experience with its members operating
around the world in many different terrains. We collate and distil this valuable knowl-
edge for the industry to use as guidelines for good practice by individual members.
Our overall aim is to ensure a consistent approach to training, management and best
practice throughout the world.
The oil and gas exploration and production industry recognises the need to develop
consistent databases and records in certain fields. The OGPs members are encouraged
to use the guidelines as a starting point for their operations or to supplement their own
policies and regulations which may apply locally.
Many of our guidelines have been recognised and used by international authorities and
safety and environmental bodies. Requests come from governments and non-government
organisations around the world as well as from non-member companies.
Disclaimer
Whilst every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained in this
publication, neither the OGP nor any of its members will assume liability for any use made
thereof.
Copyright OGP
The International Association of Oil & Gas Producers is the international association of oil com-
panies and petroleum organisations formed in 1974. It was established to represent its members
interests at the International Maritime Organisation and other specialist agencies of the United
Nations, and to governmental and other international bodies concerned with regulating explora-
tion and production of oil and gas. While maintaining this activity, OGP now concerns itself with
all aspects of exploration and production operations, with particular emphasis on safety of person-
nel and protection of the environment, and seeks to establish industry positions with regard to
such matters.
As of the end of 1999, OGP has 58 members made up of 48 oil companies and 10 international oil
industry associations operating in more than 60 different countries. The Safety, Health & Person-
nel Competence Committee (SHAPCC) of OGP has observers from IADC, IAGC and IMCA in
its membership.
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
Preface
This is the first International Association of Oil and Gas Producers (OGP) oil industry helicopter
report that has been formally published. The OGPs Aviation Subcommittee has been collecting
this data since 1994, but has previously published only a Subcommittee report.
The principal purposes of this report are to record the safety performance of helicopter operations
in the oil and gas industry in 1998, to compare 1998 results to previous years, and to provide OGP
members and others with data that can be used to benchmark their aviation performance against
the global industry.
OGP report 6.80/295 Safety performance of the global E&P industry is derived from survey
returns provided by OGP member companies and it reports fatalities and Lost Time Injuries
(LTIs) for a11 industry activities including aviation; whilst the report provides overall safety
trends within the industry, aviation safety and operational performance are not comprehensively
covered.
This OGP world wide review of safety performance of helicopter operations in the oil & gas indus-
try is complementary to the above referenced report and provides a comprehensive survey, covering
helicopter accident and fatality rates, and analyses accident causes by region and type. Accidents to
fixed wing aircraft are also addressed. Because of its detail and scope, it is the preferred document
for use in aviation risk assessment work and in the classification and analysis of aviation accidents.
It does not cover LTIs, as this data would be difficult to collect on a global scale.
In comparing exposure rates between different forms of activity, it should be noted that the fatality
rate in this document is related to flight time exposure, whereas in Report 6.80/295 such rates are
based on working shift exposure.
The key indicators for analysis of aviation operations safety performance are numbers of fatalities
and accidents recorded, hours flown, passengers carried, and flights performed. The report presents
worldwide results against these indicators, and presents the rates of exposure by helicopter activity
performed, type of helicopter flown, and by country.
The method used in this report for measuring safety performance relative to exposure is the same
as that typically used by aviation regulatory authorities such as the UK CAA, US FAA, the insur-
ance industry, and the oil industry.
The definition of an aviation accident is the same as that used by the regulatory authority for
the country for which the data is gathered.
As such, some incidents may be reported as accidents by some countries, but not by others.
We do our best to report those serious incidents in the document narrative, but not in the
statistical analysis. Since incidents are not necessarily reported, it would be difficult to track
all occurrences and differences. Therefore, only confirmed accidents are reported statistically.
All countries do however, count a fatal occurrence as an accident, so comparison of fatality
rates is highly relevant.
Beginning with the 1997 report, the Aviation Subcommittee began collecting and expanding its
safety database to include the factors indicated below.
Helicopter categories, based on numbers of engines and numbers of seats (single engine, light
twin, medium twin, and heavy twin - see definitions.)
The relative exposure and risk of fatality for each 100,000 occupants carried. This factor had
not previously been considered and has allowed the Subcommittee to analyze the relative risk
of the different helicopter categories.
This 1998 report is the Aviation Subcommittees first attempt to gather activity for all oil and gas
aviation related activity, as only Offshore helicopter activity had been gathered previously.
2000 OGP i
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Data added for 1998 includes helicopter operational and safety data for seismic, geophysical,
pipeline, and other support operations. Also added were known industry aeroplane accidents
without statistical details.
The data for the offshore segment is the most complete, and believed to be most accurate
statistically.
There are countries for which the operations data accumulated is incomplete, but the accidents
for those areas have been included, so the accident rates are likely overstated.
Support from the OGP membership, and responses from a number of OGP member companies
and 136 helicopter operators worldwide for this safety and operations review, is not only appreci-
ated, but also vital in establishing a meaningful report. Continued support is encouraged for the
future.
It is anticipated that by sharing this information with all operators, global participation in the
annual review will be encouraged, and safety initiatives can then be focused on reducing accidents
where trends are apparent.
This is the first Aviation Subcommittee report in which specific initiatives are made for
member companies to consider that are focused on impacting accident causal factors.
Wherever practicable, results are presented graphically. The data underlying the main body of this
report are tabulated in the Appendices.
ii 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
Table of Contents
Appendixes
A Operational data ........................................................................................................................... 41
B Helicopter accident data ................................................................................................................ 43
C Helicopter data by country ............................................................................................................ 57
D Aeroplane accident data................................................................................................................. 61
E Glossary of terms........................................................................................................................... 63
F Contributing companies................................................................................................................ 65
iv 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
1.1 Fatalities
Total fatalities Total fatal accidents by aircraft
There were a total of 133 aviation fatalities Helicopters had 9 fatal accidents and aeroplanes 4,
reported. totaling 13 fatal accidents.
There were 47 fatalities in helicopters and 86 in Aeroplane operations had far fewer accidents (6)
aeroplanes. reported than helicopters (22).
Industry wide, 46% of all aviation accidents were Aeroplane operations had much higher percentages
fatal. of the total fatalities (65%) and accidents with fatal-
ities (67%).
Together, these amount on average to over 2.5
deaths per week for the industry. 41% of the 22 helicopter accidents were fatal and
67% of the 6 aeroplane accidents were fatal.
28 Accidents 13 Fatal accidents
2000 OGP 1
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Worst accidents
The worst helicopter accident was a mid-air colli- It should be noted that it is unusual for the oil and gas
sion between two offshore helicopters in the Gulf industry to have a fatal aviation accident involving such a
of Campeche, Mexico and resulted in 22 fatalities. large number of people. More typical would be 20 or less
for a single event.
The worst aeroplane accident, caused by apparent
engine malfunction, was in Peru and resulted in 74
fatalities.
1.2 Injuries
2 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
28 Accidents
150 Aeroplanes
133
Helicopters
All aircraft
120
# reported
86
90
69 67
60
46 47
41
31
28
30 22
13
9
4 6
Accident causes
The most common causes of the 28 industry aircraft
accidents were flying into terrain, water or obstacles
(FITWO) and engine related, each accounting for
7 accidents (50% of the total).
Helicopters had 5 of the 7 engine related accidents
and 5 of the 7 FITWO accidents.
Accident causes, all aircraft (28 total)
The third most common cause of helicopter acci- Landing gear
dents was control malfunction, which involved 3 1 (4%) Unknown
Hard landing 1 (4%)
accidents (10%). 1 (4%)
Aircraft overload Engine related
The fourth most common cause of accidents was 1 (4%) 7 (24%)
midair collisions, which accounted for 2 accidents Refuel
involving 4 Offshore helicopters and 23 fatalities. procedure
1 (4%)
Of the 6 aeroplane accidents, 2 each were engine
Mid air
related and FITWO, 1 was landing gear related 2 (7%)
and 1 unknown.
Lightning
Half (3) of the aeroplane accidents were in multi- 1 (4%)
engine turbine, and 1 each single turbine, single Control
piston and multi-engine piston. malfunction
3 (10%)
External load
procedure Flight into terrain,
Tie down proceedure
2 (7%) water, obstacle
1 (4%)
7 (24%)
2000 OGP 3
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Single turbine
1 (17%)
Unknown Landing gear Multi turbine
1 (33%) 1 (33%) 3 (49%)
60
# fatalities
50
40
30
22 23 23
20
13
9 9 9
10
2 2 3 3
0 Engine related Flight into terrain, External load Control malfunction Mid air Unknown
weather, obstacle procedure
4 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
86 aeroplane fatalities
Single turbine
0
Multi turbine
76 (89%)
7
Helicopters
6 Airplanes
6
Total
13 fatal accidents
5
# fatalities
4
4
2 2 2 2 2
2
1 1 1 1 1 1
1
0 Engine related Flight into terrain, External load Control malfunction Mid air Unknown
weather, obstacle procedure
2000 OGP 5
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
1.4 Database
Participation Global representation
A number of oil and gas industry companies con- Operations in 50 countires are covered in the data-
tributed data and 136 helicopter operators submit- base
ted information.
Helicopters: see section 2.6.
It is estimated that the operators supplied 90% of
Aeroplanes: for aeroplanes, only accident data was
the detailed information
gathered.
The oil and gas industry companies generally do
not do a good job of tracking aircraft flying hours,
passengers carried, fatalities, injuries, etc. for world-
wide operations.
1.5 Highlights
Fatal accident causes Data gathering
The leading causes of fatal aviation accidents are Those OGP member companies that are not sub-
flying into terrain, water, or obstacles (FITWO) mitting the aviation safety statistics and operational
and midair collision. data to the Aviation Subcommittee are encouraged
to do so for company operated aircraft.
A significant number of FITWO accidents occur at
night. Similarly, those companies should collect and submit
data for their contracted aviation operations.
No helicopter fatalities were related to engine fail-
ure. Non-members are also encouraged to submit data
for the OGP industry report.
Fatalities versus injuries
The fatal risk versus injury risk is very high for avia- Helicopter detailed analysis
tion operations when compared to all oil and gas A detailed analysis of all helicopter safety and oper-
activities ational performance is attached in the remainder of
this report.
There was 1 fatality to 19 injured for all activites
and 7.8 fatalities for 1 injury in aviation.
6 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
Medium twin
Offshore 482 (33%)
1,209 (84%) Light twin
125 (9%)
2000 OGP 7
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Seismic
78,553 (7%)
Medium twin
433,153 (37%)
Offshore
1,209,503 (87%) Light twin
71,027 (6%)
Average flight duration, minutes Average annual flight hours per helicopter
100 1000
86 852
818
80 800
686 703
60 600
440
395
40 400
20 20 21 19
20 200
11
0 0
Offshore Geophysical Other support Offshore Geophysical Other support
Seismic Pipeline World-wide Seismic Pipeline World-wide
8 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
Passengers flown:
10,284,263 passengers represented
Passengers (pax) per type of helicopter
Single engine Light twin Medium twin Heavy twin Total fleet
Offshore 2,442,448 361,797 4,598,209 2,362,044 9,764,538
Seismic 145,609 7,705 55,219 4,200 212,733
Geophysical 1,000 0 0 0 1,000
Pipeline 10,011 212 12,852 245 23,320
Other support 72,448 7,804 194,700 7,720 282,672
Pipeline Geophysical
23,320 (1%) 1,000 (1%)
Other support Heavy twin
282,672 (4%) 2,374,209 (17%) Single engine
Seismic 2,672,556 (40%)
212,733 (7%)
Light twin
377,518 (6%)
Medium twin
Offshore 4,860,980 (37%)
9,764,538 (87%)
Average no. passengers flown per year Average no. pax flown per day/5 day week
35,000
8,077
8000
7,162 30,000
6000 25,000
4,545 20,000
4000
15,000
10,000
2000 1,860
897 5,000
818 1,087
35 4 90
0 0
Offshore Geophysical Other support Offshore Geophysical Other support
Seismic Pipeline World-wide Seismic Pipeline World-wide
2000 OGP 9
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Flights flown:
3,699,876 flights represented
Number of flights per type of helicopter
Single engine Light twin Medium twin Heavy twin Total fleet
Offshore 1,404,852 213,711 1,204,177 269,503 3,092,243
Seismic 404,479 828 28,410 6,965 440,682
Geophysical 7,896 0 0 0 7,896
Pipeline 11,919 204 21,704 1,188 35,015
Other support 63,334 2,864 41,606 16,236 124,040
Medium twin
1,295,897 (37%)
Average # flights per day Average # flights per helicopter per year
10,137 3,500
10000
3,000
8,299
8000 2,506 2,577
2,500
1,994
6000 2,000
1,500 1,347
4000
1,000
2000
1,207 500
277
96 340
22
0 0
Offshore Geophysical Other support Offshore Geophysical Other support
Seismic Pipeline World-wide Seismic Pipeline World-wide
10 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
2.2 Fatalities
Total fatalities
There were a total of 47 helicopter fatalities reported Together, these amount on average to over 0.91
in 1998 for the oil and gas industry. deaths per week for helicopters.
9 (41%) of the reported 22 helicopter accidents
were fatal.
50 47
# accidents
# fatal accidents
# fatalities
40
# reported
30 27
22
20
11
10 9
10 8 8
5
3
2 2 2 1 2
0 Single engine Light twin Medium twin Heavy twin 1998 totals
2000 OGP 11
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
20
15
11
10
7
6 6
5 4
2 2
0 1 1 1 1 1
0
0 Offshore Seismic Pipeline Geophysical Other support
Geophysical
Pipeline
8.88
8.74
Seismic
0
12 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
5
4.22
3 2.31
2.82
1.85 1.87
2
1.03
0.77
1 0.42
0.52
0 Single engine Light twin Medium twin Heavy twin 1998 totals
Occupant risk
1997 was the first year that the OGP Aviation Subcom- The lowest overall rates were 0 for seismic activity
mittee began recording the relative risk to the occupants for and 0.24 for offshore activity.
the helicopter based on the type of helicopter and 1998 is
The helicopter types with the lowest fatal occupant
the first year that the OGP began looking at the same data
rates were heavy twins at 0.07 and single engine at
for types of activity.
0.18.
Occupant risk in the oil and gas helicopter industry
The helicopters with the highest fatal occupant
is calculated based on the number of fatalities per
rates were medium twins at 0.36 and light twins at
100,000 occupants carried.
0.60.
The overall rate for all activities was 0.30 fatalities
This data indicates that light twins had the high-
per 100,000 occupants carried.
est risk to the occupant although they had a lower
The highest number of fatalities per 100,000 occu- fatal rate accident rate than medium twins.
pants carried was in geophysical operations at
22.48.
# fatalities/100,000 occupants by activity All helicopter fatal occupant rate
Other support Offshore
0.24 Heavy twin
1.29 0.07 Single engine
Pipeline 0.18
4.92
Medium twin
0.36
Seismic
0
Light twin
Geophysical
0.6
22.48
2000 OGP 13
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Industry Fatal Accident Rate (IFAR) per 100 Industry Fatal Incident Rate (IFIR)
million exposure hours The industry fatal incident rate (IFIR) or number
The industry fatal accident rate or number of fatali- of fatal accidents per 100 million hours of flying
ties per 100 million hours of flying exposure was exposure was 197 for helicopters versus 6.1 for the
928 for helicopters versus 6.8 for the overall OGP oil and gas industry rate for all activities (exclusive
IFAR for all activities (exclusive of aviation). of aviation).
The IFAR rate for helicopters is 136 times higher The industry helicopter rate is 33 times higher that
than that reported for non-aviation activities in the that reported for non-aviation activities in the oil
oil and gas industry. and gas industry.
The seismic rate was 0 and the offshore rate 709.
The remaining activities had significantly higher
levels ranging from 15,783 for geophysical to 3,646
for other support.
IFAR rate by activity - all helicopters per 100 IFIR rate per 100 million exposure hours
million exposure hours
Offshore
Other support
709 Other support Offshore
3,646
608 122
Pipeline
4,308
Geophysical
Pipeline
15,783
17,237 Seismic
0 Geophysical
7,881
Seismic
0
2.3 Injuries
Total injuries: Injuries by type aircraft:
The aviation relationship for injuries to fatalities is The reported helicopter injuries were 4 in single-
the opposite reported for the oil and gas industry engine helicopters and 9 in medium twin-engine
for non-aviation activities helicopters.
Helicopters reported 13 injuries, with a relationship Two injuries were attributed to engine malfunc-
of 3.6 fatalities for every injury reported (injuries tion on single engine helicopters, activity being per-
28 percent of reported fatalities). formed was seismic.
For all activities, the oil and gas industry reported
19 injuries for each fatality whereas helicopters
reported 3.6 fatalities for each injury.
Injury rates such as TRIR, LTIF, etc. are not reported for
aviation flight operations, nor were non-injured occupants
reported.
14 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
Seismic
7 (32%)
Light twin
3 (13%)
Pipeline Geophysical
17.48 Geophysical
8.88
12.66
2000 OGP 15
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
25
# fatal accidents/100k hours
# accidents/100k hours
20
# fatalities /100k occupants
# accidents/100k flights
15
10
0 Single engine Light twin Medium twin Heavy twin 1998 totals
16 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
External load
Control procedure
malfunction 2 (4%)
2 (22%)
2000 OGP 17
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
2.6 Database
The database is believed to be highly representa- A number of OGP industry companies contributed
tive for the offshore helicopter activity function, as data and 136 helicopter operators submitted infor-
activity has been gathered for several years. mation.
For the other helicopter functions (seismic, geo- It is estimated that the operators supplied 90% of
physical, pipeline, and other industry support) the the detailed information.
activity levels in the database may be understated.
The oil and gas industry companies generally do
However, for all these helicopter activities it is
not do a good job of tracking aircraft flying hours,
believed that the number of accidents reported is
passenger carried, fatalities, injuries, etc. for world-
reasonably accurate.
wide operations.
Thus, for non-offshore helicopter activities, acci-
dent rates may be overstated.
2.7 Highlights
This is the first year that data other than for offshore opera- The helicopter types with the lowest fatal occupant
tions has been collected and since activity data may not rates were heavy twins at 0.07 and single engine at
be complete, accident rates for other than offshore may be 0.18.
overstated.
The helicopters with the highest fatal occupant
Fatal risk industry comparison rates were medium twins at 0.36 and light twins at
0.60.
The fatal risk to occupants is high for helicopters
with 136 times for IFAR risk and 33 times for IFIR Accident causes
when compared to OGP non-aviation fatal risk.
The leading causes of helicopter fatal accidents are
The fatal risk versus injury risk is high for helicop- flying into terrain, water, or obstacle (FITWO) and
ter operations (1 fatal to 19 injured for all activities midair collision.
and 4 fatal for 1 injured in helicopters).
A high percentage of FITWO accidents occured in
Fatal accident rates night flights, and 2/3 involved industry supported
night training flights.
Geophysical helicopters had the highest number of
fatal accidents per 100,000 hours at 8.88, followed No helicopter fatalities were related to engine fail-
by pipeline at 8.74. ures. The last engine related fatalities occured in
1997 involving a Puma.
Seismic helicopters had the lowest fatal rate per
100,000 hours at 0, followed by offshore at 0.58. Seismic activity had 0 fatalities in 1998.
Medium twins had the highest overall fatal rate at Data gathering
7.04 fatal accidents per 100,000 hours.
Those OGP member companies that are not sub-
Single engine helicopters had the lowest overall fatal mitting the aviation safety statistics and operational
rate at 0.42, followed by heavy twins at 0.52. data to the Aviation Subcommittee are encouraged
to do so for company operated aircraft.
Occupant risk
Similarly, those companies should collect and submit
The highest number of fatalities per 100,000 occu-
data for their contracted aviation operations.
pants carried was in geophysical operations at
22.48. Non-members are also encouraged to submit data
for the OGP industry report.
The lowest overall rates were 0 for seismic activity
and 0.24 for offshore activity.
18 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
588
600
North Sea Total fleet 1,209
Gulf of Mexico
500 Others 470
392
400
299
300
200
151
89 94 100
100 73 69
51
21
13
0 Single engine Light twin Medium twin Heavy twin Total fleet
2000 OGP 19
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Others
Heavy twin 411,118 (40%) Gulf of Mexico
184,605 (18%) Single engine 454,280 (44%)
372,688 (36%)
Medium twin
404,058 (39%) Light twin North Sea
68,152 (7%) 164,105 (16%)
250,000
200,000
150,000
100,000
50,000
20 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
The average number of flights per helicopter world- This discussion on single versus twin engine helicop-
wide was 2,506. ters will be analysed further in section 3.2, Occupant
Risk.
The numbers of flights based on types of helicop-
ters mirrored the changes in the numbers of type Offshore helicopter flights by location
helicopters.
Others
The numbers of flights for the single and light- 1,448,201 (47%) Gulf of Mexico
1,390,773 (46%)
twin helicopters decreased, while the numbers for
medium and heavy twin increased. Since the smaller
helicopters perform more flights per helicopter, even
though the total number of helicopters increased
slightly, the numbers of flights decreased slightly.
The North Sea, while using only medium and heavy
twin helicopters, has significantly fewer flights per
helicopter than the remainder of the world, due to
long distances flown from shore.
The landing and takeoff phases of a flight profile are
often considered the most hazardous.
Since the North Sea averages 36% fewer flights per
North Sea
aircraft (1,682 versus 2,506 globally), it could be 253,269 (8%)
assumed that the risk to the occupants should be
reduced by some factor relative to that reduced expo-
sure.
800
600
380
400
212 213
183 167
200
31 42 15
0 Single engine Light twin Medium twin Heavy twin
2000 OGP 21
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Passengers flown:
9,764,538 down 6,721 from 1997
Passengers flown in the North Sea total 1.9 million Passengers flown in other locations were 5.1 million
(20% of the total), averaging 7,344 passengers per (52% of the total), averaging 19,729 passengers per
day per 5 day workweek. day per 5 day workweek.
Passengers flown in Gulf of Mexico were 2.7 mil-
lion (28% of the total), averaging 10,483 passen-
gers per day per 5 day workweek.
Offshore passengers by type of helicopter
6
North Sea
Gulf of Mexico 5.1
5 Others
4
3.4
3 2.7
1.9
2
1.6
1.5
0.9 0.8
1 0.8
0.5
0.3
0.1 0.1
0 Single engine Light twin Medium twin Heavy twin Total fleet
22 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
3.2 Fatalities
35
35
# accidents *
# fatal accidents
30
# fatalities
11 total accidents
25 23
# reported
20
15
11
10
10
6
5
5 4
3 3
2 2 2
1
0 Single engine Light twin Medium twin Heavy twin 1998 totals
2000 OGP 23
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
6 # fatalities/100k hours
# accidents/100k hours
5 # accidents/100k flights
# reported
0 Single engine Light twin Medium twin Heavy twin 1998 overall
Fatal accident rates for offshore helicopter by area Gulf of Mexico offshore accidents
of activity
Data is shown only for the Gulf of Mexico (GOM) 3.0 # accidents
and the North Sea, as these are the most concen- # fatal accidents
trated areas of activity. 2.5 # fatalities
The GOM had 3 accidents with one fatality from
a mid air collision. A total of four aircraft were 2.0
# reported
24 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
The overall GOM accident rate was 0.66 and the For 1997, the North Sea had 3 accidents, with 2
fatal rate 0.22. For 1997 the rates were 1.27 and fatal accidents, and 13 fatalities. 1998 was a signifi-
0.21 respectively. cant improvement with only 1/3 the number of acci-
dents and no fatalities.
The overall GoM accident rates for medium and
heavy twins was zero. The North Sea flight rate was 2.42 for heavy twins,
0.38 overall (versus 1.08 for 1997).
While the overall GoM accident rate for singles was
0.99 (no fatalities) and for light twin was 1.83 for
both accident and fatal rate (the only light twin
accident was fatal). Gulf of Mexico offshore accident rates
The rate based on flights for GoM was 0.29 for sin- 2.0 # fatal accidents
gles, 0.55 for light twins, 0 for medium and heavy
# accidents
twins, and 0.22 overall (0.35 overall for 1997).
# flights
The North Sea had only one accident reported
1.5
(lightening strike), involving a heavy twin with no
fatalities. They had no reported single or light twin
activity.
The North Sea activity level is about 36% of the 1.0
annual activity of the GOM relative to flight hours.
For a realistic comparison, the two operations must
be compared over time, and that will be shown in
the next section of this report. 0.5
The North Sea accident rate for 1998 was 0.85 for
the heavy twin and 0.61 overall. For 1997 the rates
had been 1.78 for accidents and 1.19 for fatal acci- 0.0 Single engine Medium twin 1998 totals
dents. Light twin Heavy twin
0.9
0.70 0.70
0.57
0.6
0.43
0.31
0.3 0.24 0.22
0.12 0.10
0.0 # accidents/100k hours # fatal accidents/100k hours # fatalities /100k occupants # accidents/100k flights
2000 OGP 25
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
The GOM and North Sea have nearly identical The global accident rate for 1998 per 100,000 hours
5 year average rates for number of fatalities per flown is at the lowest rate since 1995 at 1.07. Over-
100,000 occupants flown at 0.12 and 0.10 respec- all rate since 1995 is 1.35.
tively. Both are nearly half the global rate of 0.22.
The number of global fatal accidents per 100,000
The North Sea 5 year accident rate for number of hours is up slightly in 1998 at 0.58 from the 1997
accidents per 100,000 flights flown (0.70) is higher rate of 0.53.
than the global rate of 0.43 and more than double
The global accident rate per 100,000 flights flown
the GOM rate of 0.29. This is partially explained
is nearly flat at 0.36 for 1998 versus 0.35 for 1997.
by the longer flight duration in the North Sea, but
the other areas should have a higher risk based on The fatal occupant rate per 100,000 occupants
takeoffs and landings performed. flown was down slightly in 1998 at 0.24 versus 0.29
for 1997.
World wide accident rates/4 years
1.16
1.07
0.70
0.59 0.58
0.53
0.41 0.43
0.5 0.35 0.36
0.21 0.22
0.12 0.29
0.24
Occupant risk
Beginning in 1997, the OGP began analyzing the Conceptually occupants should be afforded the
relative risk to the occupants of the offshore heli- same relative safety regardless of the type helicop-
copters by considering the number of fatalities to ter, and a standard measurement did not exist pre-
the occupants (crew and passengers) per 100,000 viously.
occupants transported.
Offshore #fatal/100,000 occupants carried
0.8 Gulf of Mexico
North Sea
0.7 World wide
0.6
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0.0 Single engine Light twin Medium twin Heavy twin 1997 overall 1998 overall
26 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
The overall offshore risk of a fatality to occupants As noted in the chart below, covering a five-year
for every 100,000 transported in 1997 was 0.29 period, the relative risk over time for the entire off-
and for 1998 0.24, a slight improvement. shore industry is 0.22. Note years 94-96 were all
estimated based on fatalities, flight hours, etc.
For the GOM, the risk for the last two years has
been 0.02, and for the North Sea 0.49 for 1997 and Although the industry average for offshore opera-
0 for 1998. tions is 0.22 over time, both the GOM and North
Sea have rates approximately 50% lower at 0.12 and
For single engine for 1998, the occupant risk has
0.10 respectively.
been 0 and for 1997 was 0.03.
Although the North Sea and the Gulf of Mexico
For light twin engine for 1998, the risk in the GOM
are two very differing operations, the data does
was 0.22 and worldwide 0.64 (almost three times).
support the position that small single engine heli-
For medium and heavy twins, the only occupant copters can be used with low risk in non-hostile
risk was outside of the GOM and North Sea, where environments where the chances of a successful
the relative risk was 0.33, and 0.07 respectively. autorotation are good, where the occupants can be
The data indicates that for offshore operations in par- protected from the elements, and where the occu-
ticular, engine malfunction in single engine operations pants can be rescued within the limits of expected
does result in some ditchings (6 in the Gulf of Mexico survival times.
in 1998), but the occupants are usually not seriously Likewise, it also supports the position that multi-
injured in these ditching incidents. engine high performance helicopters with full
In non-hostile offshore environments where single instrument capabilities are warranted for hostile
engine helicopters are commonly used and when the climates where the chances of a successful ditch-
occupants can be rescued in a timely manner, the rela- ing are reduced, where the occupants may not
tive risk to the occupants is nearly the same as that be fully protected from the elements, or where
in hostile environments such as theNorth Sea where rescue may not be achieved within expected sur-
multi-engine operations are mandated. vival times.
0.49
0.5 Gulf of Mexico
North Sea
World wide
0.4
0.29
0.3
0.24
0.21 0.21 0.22
0.19
0.2
0.14
0.12
0.12
0.1 0.10
0.02 0.02
0 0 0 0
0.0 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 5 year average
2000 OGP 27
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Industry fatal accident rate (IFAR) Industry fatal incident rate (IFIR)
The IFAR rate for offshore helicopters or number of The industry fatal incident rate (IFIR) or number
fatalities per 100 million hours of exposure is 102 of fatal accidents per 100 million hours exposure
times higher than that reported for non-aviation was 122 for offshore helicopters versus 6.1 for the
activities in the OGP industry. OGP industry rate for all activities (exclusive of
third party incidents).
The industry helicopter rate is 20 times higher that
that reported for non-aviation activities in the OGP
industry.
Offshore exposure rates (IFAR & IFIR) per 100 million exposure hours for five years
963
1000 IFAR (fatalities)
IFIR (incidents)
Trend
800
709 694
671
600
432
400
189
168 149
200 112
115
3.3 Injuries
Total injuries:
There were a total of 6 injuries reported for off-
shore helicopter operations in support of oil and gas
activities.
Overall for all offshore helicopters, injuries had a
relationship of 5.9 fatalities for every injury reported
(injuries average 17% of reported fatalities).
28 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
Control
malfunction
1 (9%)
2000 OGP 29
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
3.5 Database
Participation: Global Representation:
A number of OGP industry companies contributed Operations in 50 countries are covered in the data-
data and 79 helicopter operators submitted infor- base.
mation.
It is estimated that the operators supplied 90% of
the detailed information.
The oil and gas industry companies generally do
not do a good job of tracking aircraft flying hours,
passenger carried, fatalities, injuries, etc. for world-
wide operations.
3.6 Highlights
Fatal accident causes: Medium twin-engine helicopters had the worst fatal
rate at 5.87 fatalities per 100,000 hours.
The leading cause of fatalities was mid air collision
in two accidents involving 4 helicopters Occupant risk
The leading causes of offshore fatal aviation acci- For the GOM, the risk for the last two years has
dents are flying into terrain, water, or obstacle been 0.02, and for the North Sea 0.49 for 1997 and
(FITWO) and midair collision. 0 for 1998.
During 1998 all FITWO accidents occurred at For single engine helicopters for 1998, the occupant
night, all with medium twin helicopters with 2 risk has been 0.
of the 3 accidents on industry supported training
flights. Data gathering
Those OGP member companies that are not sub-
No helicopter fatalities were related to engine fail-
mitting the aviation safety statistics and operational
ures.
data to the Aviation Subcommittee are encouraged
to do so for company operated aircraft.
Similarly, those companies should collect and submit
data for their contracted aviation operations.
Non-members are also encouraged to submit data
for the OGP industry report.
30 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
Light twin
1,517 (2%)
2000 OGP 31
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
The typical seismic flight duration is 11 minutes, Seismic helicopters carried 212,733 passengers, with
the shortest average in the industry as a result of the largest bulk in single engine helicopters (68%),
most activity being short haul sling loads. and medium twins carrying 26%, with light and
heavy twins accounting for 4% and 2% respec-
tively.
Seismic flights - 440,682 Seismic helicopter passengers - 212,733
Heavy twin
Medium twin Heavy twin 4,200 (2%)
28,410 (6%) Medium twin
6,965 (2%) 55,219 (26%) Single engine
Single engine 145,609 (68%)
Light twin 404,479 (91%)
828 (1%)
Light twin
7,705 (4%)
Light twin 0
Medium twin
3.52
Light twin 0
32 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
2000 OGP 33
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Light twin
204 (1%)
Medium twin
Light twin 21,704 (62%)
212 (1%)
34 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
8.88 22.48
8.88 12.66
2000 OGP 35
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Single engine helicopters recorded the highest The largest number of passengers 194,700 (69%)
number of flights at 63,334 (51%) of the total, and was flown with medium twins, followed by single
light twins had the lowest number at 2,864 (3%). engine with 72,448 (26%).
Other support flights flown - 124,040 total Other support passengers flown - 282,672
total
Heavy twin
Heavy twin
16,236 (13%)
Single engine 7,720 (2%)
Medium twin
63,334 (51%) 194,700 (69%) Single engine
72,448 (26%)
Light twin
7,804 (3%)
Medium twin
41,606 (33%)
Light twin
2,864 (3%)
36 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
Database
Data was provided by 24 helicopter operators rep-
2.29 0.81 resenting 16 countries.
# accidents/100,000 hours # accidents/100,000 flights
Pipeline activity had the highest accident rate per The only oil and gas injuries in 1998 due to engine mal-
100K hours at 17.48 (double the geophysical and function were in seismic operations in single engine heli-
seismic rates). copters.
2000 OGP 37
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
38 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
5.2 Reduce accidents caused by flying into terrain, water or obstacles (FITWO)
Aircraft equipment Operations
Installation of additional equipment in the aircraft Emphasise customer support of operational proce-
that could provide additional alert to the pilot dures that may reduce risk, such as: enforcement of
when operating in close proximity to the ground or weather minima.
water.
Development of adverse weather criteria to provide
Items that could be considered include radio altim- guidance on when flying operations should be
eters with visual and audio alerts and ground prox- restricted.
imity warning systems.
Conduct offshore night flights to full IFR stand-
Training ards.
Where reasonably available, instrument training in
flight simulators for aircrews.
Recurring instrument and night training programs
and maintenance of night currency at periodic inter-
vals.
2000 OGP 39
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
40 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
2000 OGP 41
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
42 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
Injury classification
Injuries Severity
pax crew minor serious fatal
Single engine 6 6 3 1 8
Light twin 7 3 0 0 10
Medium twin 24 12 1 8 27
Heavy twin 0 2 0 0 2
1998 totals 37 23 4 9 47
2000 OGP 43
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Injury classification
Pax Crew Minor Serious Fatal
Offshore 25 16 2 4 35
Seismic 3 4 2 5 0
Geophysical 1 1 0 0 2
Pipeline 3 1 0 0 4
Other support 5 1 0 0 6
1998 total 37 23 4 9 47
44 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
2000 OGP 45
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Injury classification
Injuries Severity
pax crew minor serious fatal
Single engine 0 1 1 0 0
Light twin 7 3 0 0 10
Medium twin 18 10 1 4 23
Heavy twin 0 2 0 0 2
1998 totals 25 16 2 4 35
1997 totals 41 13 7 5 42
Aircraft damages
Minor Major Total loss
Single engine 0 1 2
Light twin 0 0 3
Medium twin 0 0 5
Heavy twin 0 1 1
1998 totals 0 2* 11 *
1997 totals 1 3 8
46 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
Injury classification
Injuries Severity
pax crew minor serious fatal
Single engine 0 1 1 0 0
Light twin 0 1 0 0 1
Medium twin 0 0 0 0 0
Heavy twin 0 0 0 0 0
1998 totals 0 2 1 0 1
1997 totals 6 6 7 4 1
* One mid-air collision resulted in damages to two aircraft, one fatality, reported as one accident
2000 OGP 47
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Injury classification
Injuries Severity
pax crew minor serious fatal
Single engine 0 0 0 0 0
Light twin 0 0 0 0 0
Medium twin 0 0 0 0 0
Heavy twin 0 0 0 0 0
1998 totals 0 0 0 0 0
1997 totals 11 2 0 0 13
* One mid-air collision resulted in damages to two aircraft, one fatality, reported as one accident
48 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
Injury classification
Injuries Severity
pax crew minor serious fatal
1995 35 8 19 0 24
1996 8 8 0 0 16
1997 41 13 7 5 42
1998 25 16 2 4 35
4 year average 27.3 11.3 7.0 2.3 29.3
Industry fatality rates per 100M exposure hours, passengers & crew
Accidents (IFAR) Incidents (IFIR)
1995 671 168
1996 432 189
1997 963 115
1998 709 122
4 year average 694 149
2000 OGP 49
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Injury classification
Injuries Severity
pax crew minor serious fatal
1994 9 2 0 1 10
1995 7 3 1 1 8
1996 7 4 0 0 11
1997 6 6 7 4 1
1998 0 2 1 0 1
5 year average 5.8 3.4 1.8 1.2 6.2
50 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
Injury classification
Injuries Severity
pax crew minor serious fatal
1994 0 0 0 0 0
1995 0 0 0 0 0
1996 0 0 0 0 0
1997 11 2 0 0 13
1998 0 0 0 0 0
5 year average 2.2 0.4 0 0 2.6
2000 OGP 51
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
52 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
Injury classification
Injuries Severity
pax crew minor serious fatal
Single engine 0 3 2 1 0
Light twin 0 0 0 0 0
Medium twin 3 1 0 4 0
Heavy twin 0 0 0 0 0
1998 totals 3 4 2 5 0
2000 OGP 53
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Injury classification
Injuries Severity
pax crew minor serious fatal
Single engine 1 1 0 0 2
Light twin 0 0 0 0 0
Medium twin 0 0 0 0 0
Heavy twin 0 0 0 0 0
1998 totals 1 1 0 0 2
54 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
Injury classification
Injuries Severity
pax crew minor serious fatal
Single engine 0 0 0 0 0
Light twin 0 0 0 0 0
Medium twin 3 1 0 0 4
Heavy twin 0 0 0 0 0
1998 totals 3 1 0 0 4
2000 OGP 55
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
Injury classification
Injuries Severity
pax crew minor serious fatal
Single engine 5 1 0 0 6
Light twin 0 0 0 0 0
Medium twin 0 0 0 0 0
Heavy twin 0 0 0 0 0
1998 totals 5 1 0 0 6
56 2000 OGP
World wide oil industry helicopter accidents
Severity # fatal Injuries Aircraft damages
Acivity Country minor serious fatal accidents passengers crew minor major total aircraft type date description night ditched
Geophys Indonesia 2 1 1 1 1 AS315B SE 2 Feb hit power lines
Offshore UK 1 AS332L HT 28 Jan lightening strike
SE single engine
LT light twin
MT medium twin
HT heavy twin
57
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
58 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
2000 OGP 59
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
60 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
Summary data
Date Activity Model Type Location Narrative
20 Mar Crew change AN-32 Multi turbine Peru Eng. failed, unable to maintain altitude
08 Apr Management BE 200 Multi turbine Nigeria Landing gear collapsed
12 Oct Crew change C402 Multi piston Norway
16 Nov Crew change C206 Single piston Garoka Failed to go around
25 Nov Crew change C208 Single turbine Nigeria Engine failure
17 Nov Management BE 200 Multi turbine Gabon 3 add. fatal on gnd, cause unknown
1998 total 6 accidents
Injury classification
Injuries Severity
Date passengers crew minor serious fatal
20 Mar 68 6 74
08 Apr
12 Oct 8 1 9
16 Nov 1 2 2 1
25 Nov 1 1 2
17 Nov 2 2
1998 total 78 12 2 2 86
Note: this data was gathered informally. No other aeroplane flying data or other statistics are available.
Geophysical mineral survey statistics are available through IAGSA.
2000 OGP 61
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
62 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
HUET
Helicopter underwater escape training device or dunker
IFAR
The industry fatal accident rate (IFAR) or fatalities per 100 million hours of flying exposure for
passengers and pilots.
IFIR
The industry fatal incident rate (IFIR) or fatal accidents per 100 million hours of flying exposure
for passengers and pilots.
Light Twin
Small twin engine helicopter capable of carrying up to 9 passengers
Medium Twin
Medium Twin engine helicopter capable of carrying up to 13 passengers
Non-Hostile Environment
An environment in which:
aa safe forced landing can be accomplished; and
bthe helicopter occupants can be protected from the elements; and
csearch and rescure response/capability is provided consistent with anticipated exposure.
Occupant Risk
The number of fatalities that occur for every 100,000 passengers or crew members carried.
Pax
Abbreviation for passenger
Single Engine
Single Engine helicopter
2000 OGP 63
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
64 2000 OGP
Oil industry helicopter operations and safety review
2000 OGP 65
International Association of Oil & Gas Producers
66 2000 OGP
What is OGP?
e International Association of Oil & Gas Producers encompasses the worlds leading
private and state-owned oil & gas companies, their national and regional associations, and
major upstream contractors and suppliers.
Vision
To work on behalf of all the worlds upstream companies to promote responsible and
profitable operations.
Mission
To represent the interests of the upstream industry to international regulatory and
legislative bodies.
To achieve continuous improvement in safety, health and environmental performance
and in the engineering and operation of upstream ventures.
To promote awareness of Corporate Social Responsibility issues within the industry
and among stakeholders.
Objectives
To improve understanding of the upstream oil and gas industry, its achievements and
challenges and its views on pertinent issues.
To encourage international regulators and other parties to take account of the
industrys views in developing proposals that are effective and workable.
To become a more visible, accessible and effective source of information about the
global industry, both externally and within member organisations.
To develop and disseminate best practices in safety, health and environmental
performance and the engineering and operation of upstream ventures.
To improve the collection, analysis and dissemination of safety, health and
environmental performance data.
To provide a forum for sharing experience and debating emerging issues.
To enhance the industrys ability to influence by increasing the size and diversity of
the membership.
To liaise with other industry associations to ensure consistent and effective approaches
to common issues.
209-215 Blackfriars Road
London SE1 8NL
United Kingdom
Telephone: +44 (0)20 7633 0272
Fax: +44 (0)20 7633 2350
165 Bd du Souverain
4th Floor
B-1160 Brussels, Belgium
Telephone: +32 (0)2 566 9150
Fax: +32 (0)2 566 9159