Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Correspondence
ragreen@jhmi.edu (R.G.),
ingolia@berkeley.edu (N.T.I.)
In Brief
Maturing mammalian platelets and red
blood cells lack nuclei but continue
protein synthesis during terminal
differentiation. Using ribosome profiling,
Mills et al. report abundant 30 UTR
ribosomes in these lineages and show
how interplay between the ribosome
rescue/recycling factors PELO and
ABCE1 may promote translation of
critical mRNAs during differentiation.
Report
SUMMARY period of at least several days (Ault, 1993; Ault et al., 1992),
and, during this time, they direct protein synthesis (Booyse and
Protein synthesis continues in platelets and maturing Rafelson, 1967; Weyrich et al., 1998).
reticulocytes, although these blood cells lack nuclei Ribosome homeostasis, which refers broadly to the regula-
and do not make new mRNA or ribosomes. Here, tion of ribosome levels in cells, plays an essential role in deter-
we analyze translation in primary human cells from mining which mRNAs are translated (Ludwig et al., 2014; Signer
anucleate lineages by ribosome profiling and un- et al., 2014). Haploinsufficiencies of specific ribosomal proteins
and defects in ribosome biogenesis perturb ribosome homeo-
cover a dramatic accumulation of post-termination
stasis and disproportionately result in hematopoietic dysfunc-
unrecycled ribosomes in the 30 UTRs of mRNAs.
tion (Barlow et al., 2010; Buchanan et al., 1981; Draptchinskaia
We demonstrate that these ribosomes accumulate et al., 1999; Ebert et al., 2008; Neuwirtova et al., 2013; Ricciardi
as a result of the natural loss of the ribosome recy- et al., 2015). Additionally, disrupted ribosome biogenesis in-
cling factor ABCE1 during terminal differentiation. In- creases free ribosomal proteins, which can activate p53 (Zhang
duction of the ribosome rescue factors PELO and and Lu, 2009), further modulating these phenotypes (Barlow
HBS1L is required to support protein synthesis et al., 2010). It is not well understood why these defects lead
when ABCE1 levels fall and for hemoglobin produc- to hematopoietic tissue-specific phenotypes. Moreover, mech-
tion during blood cell development. Our observa- anisms that regulate ribosome availability in anucleate blood
tions suggest that this distinctive loss of ABCE1 in lineages have not been identified, although autophagy (Kundu
anucleate blood lineages could sensitize them to de- et al., 2008), ubiquitin-dependent degradation (Etlinger and
Goldberg, 1977; Wefes et al., 1995), as well as specific ribonu-
fects in ribosome homeostasis, perhaps explaining
cleases (Pisareva et al., 2015; Valentine et al., 1974) have been
in part why genetic defects in the fundamental pro- proposed to degrade ribosomes in reticulocytes. Delayed ribo-
cess of ribosome production (ribosomopathies) some clearance is associated with abnormal erythroid matura-
often affect hematopoiesis specifically. tion (Kundu et al., 2008; Valentine et al., 1974) and platelet
dysfunction in humans (Fletcher et al., 2015; Marconi et al.,
INTRODUCTION 2016).
We show here that the active dissociation of the ribosomal
In mammals, immature red blood cells (reticulocytes) and plate- subunits, a distinct step in the translation cycle termed ribosome
lets lack nuclei and, therefore, cannot transcribe new RNA. recycling (Pisarev et al., 2010; Shoemaker et al., 2010), regulates
Despite this, retained ribosomes and pre-synthesized mRNAs ribosome homeostasis in reticulocytes and platelets. Our data
permit continued protein synthesis during terminal differentiation suggest that loss of the ribosome recycling factor ABCE1
in these cells (Heynen, 1990; Ji et al., 2011). Reticulocytes are (Rli1p in S. cerevisiae), limits ribosome availability during terminal
highly translationally active and circulate for 23 days before differentiation of these anucleate blood lineages, leading to the
completely losing ribosomes, organelles, and mRNA; these latter accumulation of post-termination, unrecycled ribosomes in the
events define their transition to mature erythrocytes (Heynen, 30 UTRs of mRNAs. These 30 UTR ribosomes are cleared by in-
1990; Wiczling and Krzyzanski, 2008). Translation by reticulo- duction of the ribosome rescue factors PELO and HBS1L
cytes is prolificas much as one-third of the final hemoglobin (Dom34p and Hbs1p in S. cerevisiae), which return ribosomes
content of an erythrocyte is synthesized after enucleation (Hey- to the active cellular pool. These factors act as a heteroduplex
nen and Verwilghen, 1982; Heynen, 1990). Similarly, nascent to release stalled and unrecycled ribosomes (Guydosh and
platelets are released from the bone marrow containing ribo- Green, 2014) and compensate for RLI1 defects in yeast (Young
somes, organelles, and mRNA derived from the precursor mega- et al., 2015). We propose that enhanced ribosome rescue com-
karyocyte (Bray et al., 2013; Kissopoulou et al., 2013; Rowley pensates for the loss of ABCE1-mediated recycling in anucleate
et al., 2011). Platelet mRNA and ribosomes are stable for a blood lineages. Our results delineate the functional significance
Cell Reports 17, 110, September 27, 2016 2016 The Author(s). 1
This is an open access article under the CC BY license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Figure 1. Platelet and Reticulocyte Ribo-
A B some Profiling Show Abundant 30 UTR RPFs
105
106
Primary Platelets B2M Primary Reticulocytes (A) Scatterplots of RPF counts per mRNA coding
PPBP
sequence for replicates from a single healthy hu-
104
105
TMSB4X HBB () man donor of primary platelets. Known platelet
F13A1
HBA1 (1) proteins are highlighted in blue. PTPRC (CD45) is a
RPFs (rep 1)
RPFs (rep 1)
ITGA2B PF4 HBA2 (2)
104
103
103
102
GP1BA
HBG1 ()
HbA= 22
102
HbF= 22
(D) Ribosome profile of the EEF2 mRNA from
PTPRC (CD45)
101
100
10 1
102 103 104 105 106
precursor Meg01 cells (bottom).
100 101 102 103 104 105
(E) Accumulation of 30 UTR RPFs during erythroid-
RPFs (rep 2) RPFs (rep 2)
like differentiation.
C D (F and G) Cumulative histograms of relative 30 UTR
50
Primary Platelets PLPs culture models and (G) primary reticulocytes and
RPFs
RPFs
RESULTS
80
Meg01
50
Meg01
RPFs
Ribosomes
0
0 500 1500 2500 3500 0 500 1500 2500 human anucleate blood lineages by
ribosome profiling, which relies on the
nt of HMGB1 mRNA nt of EEF2 mRNA deep sequencing of ribosome-pro-
tected fragments (RPFs) (Ingolia et al.,
E F
2009, 2011). Analysis of these data
K562
revealed 6,700 ribosome-occupied
1.0
120
Meg01
PLPs
Platelets mRNAs in platelets using a cutoff of
0.75
Uninduced
0.3 reads per kilobase of coding
80
RPFs
ECDF
Hemin 2 days
Kissopoulou et al., 2013; Rowley et al.,
RPFs
15
15 10 5 0 5
Relative 3UTR occupancy [log2]
2011) and proteome (Burkhart et al.,
2012; Kim et al., 2014; Martens
G
0
K562
40
ECDF
Meg01
PLP PLPs
0.3
1.0
1.0
10
3UTR:
RPFs (x106)
RPFs (x104)
PLP
0.6
6.0
0.6
0.1
2.0
0.2
0.2
0
0 1 2 0 1 2 0 1 2
21 24 27 30 33 36 frame frame frame
5 10 15
PLPs
RPFs
250
EPA
0
0
PLPs + salt wash Post-termination
5 10 30
PLPs + salt wash
5ends of RPFs
ribosome release
500
RPFs
250
0
0
0 500 1000 1500 2000
CDS
Nucleotides of HNRNPA1 mRNA
ribosome footprints in other cell types, we quantified an approx- to precursor Meg01 cells (Figures 1D and 1F). Next, we induced
imately 30-fold increase in RPFs in platelets and reticulocytes K562 cells toward erythroid differentiation by supplementing the
compared with nucleated peripheral blood mononuclear cells growth media with hemin (Rutherford et al., 1979). These cells
(PBMCs) (Figures 1F and 1G; Figure S2A), neutrophils (Guo also exhibited a global, differentiation-dependent increase in
et al., 2010), or macrophages (Su et al., 2015). The increased 30 UTR RPF density (Figure 1E), consistent with observations
density of 30 UTR RPFs is a global rather than a transcript- from primary reticulocytes (Figure 1G). Together, these data
specific effect. In platelets, 30 UTR RPFs represented 30% of establish that the striking increase in 30 UTR RPF density we
all RPFs mapped to mRNA transcripts, whereas in reticulocytes observed in primary platelets and reticulocytes also occurs in
(which have a far less complex transcriptome), 4% of all RPFs cell models for these lineages.
were mapped to 30 UTRs. We next set out to verify that these 30 UTR RPFs are derived
To explore the mechanisms underlying the 30 UTR ribosome from bona fide ribosomes and test whether these ribosomes
accumulation in primary human cells, we tested whether these are actively engaged in translation. Because previous work has
effects could be recapitulated by in vitro systems of blood cell shown that genetic reduction of ribosome rescue and recycling
differentiation. We purified in vitro platelet-like particles (PLPs) factors in yeast generates an accumulation of 30 UTR ribosomes
from megakaryoblast (Meg01) precursor cells that generate (Young et al., 2015), we focused on the possibility that a failure of
these particles in tissue culture (Clarke et al., 2003; Takeuchi ribosome recycling may explain the abundance of 30 UTR RPFs
et al., 1991, 1998) and showed that they are translationally active observed in platelets and reticulocytes. The distribution of frag-
(Figures S1FS1J; Supplemental Experimental Procedures). ment sizes that mapped to 30 UTRs was nearly indistinguishable
Ribosome profiling in PLPs showed that, like primary human from those that mapped to the coding sequence (CDS) (Fig-
platelets, PLPs display increased 30 UTR RPF density relative ure 2A), suggesting that they are authentic RPFs and not the
D E F
PELO/HBS1L Regulate Ribosome Homeostasis mRNA abundance and saw that TE of the individual a and g
We propose that induction of the ribosome rescue factor PELO mRNAs encoding the HbF (a2g2) tetramer rises dramatically in
during platelet and reticulocyte maturation plays a critical role the first 2 days of differentiation (75-fold for a-globin mRNA
in rescuing ribosomes to maintain translational homeostasis and 8-fold for g-globin mRNA) and drops off rapidly thereafter
and support the synthesis of critical proteins as ABCE1 levels (Figures 5B and 5C; Figure S4). The time course of hemoglobin
decline. Reticulocytes synthesize large quantities of hemoglobin production closely matches that of PELO expression (Figures
subunit proteins, as do K562 cells differentiating in response to 3B and 5A), suggesting that PELO/HBS1L induction may be crit-
hemin treatment (Rutherford et al., 1979), and we observed ical in providing available ribosome subunits for its translation.
that the induction of PELO and HBS1L coincides closely with he-
moglobin production (Figures 5A and 3B). We note that K562 PELO/HBS1L Is Required for Hemin-Induced HbF
cells primarily synthesize embryonic and fetal hemoglobin tetra- Accumulation
mers (a2g2 and a22) (Rutherford et al., 1979) rather than the adult In light of the tight coincidence between PELO induction and
hemoglobin (a2b2) that is made in primary reticulocytes from hemoglobin expression, we next asked whether PELO/HBS1L
adults. Through analysis of our ribosome profiling and RNA- induction is required to promote hemoglobin accumulation. De-
seq data, we see that hemoglobin accumulation is primarily fects in ribosome rescue (Figure 5E), either by knockdown of
driven by increased translation (Figure 5B). We calculated the HBS1L alone (Figure 5F) or with PELO (Figure 5G), abrogated he-
translational efficiency (TE) as the ratio of RPFs relative to moglobin production. The levels of the control proteins eIF1A
200
600
shABCE1 shABCE1 ribosomes
150
post-Nfx day: - 2 6 6 - 2 6 6
5ends of RPFs
5ends of RPFs
400
+Hemin day: - - - 3 - - - 3
ABCE1
GFP control
100
PELO over-
200
PELO post-termination
expressed ribosomes
50
eIF1A
0
100 50 0 50 100 100 50 0 50 100
nt from stop codon nt from stop codon
D terminating E F
ribosome queue
Meg01 PLPs K562
l
tro
LO
l
tro
on
LO
tro
LO
PE
on
C
on
PE
PE
C
C
GFP control
PELO
PELO PELO
G H I
25
Control
Meg01/PLPs K562 cells (+Hemin)
1.0
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
RPFs
Meg01-Control
Control (0 days)
Meg01-PELO
0.8
PELO (0 days)
ECDF
Control (6 days)
ECDF
0.6
PELO
0.4
PLP-PELO
RPFs
0.2
0
0.0
Relative 3UTR ribosome occupancy [log2] Relative 3UTR ribosome occupancy [log2]
nt of HSP90AA1 mRNA
and actin remained unchanged, indicating that these changes do compensate for the natural loss of ABCE1 to maintain ribosome
not reflect a loss of cell viability. These data instead argue that availability. We propose that this release of unrecycled ribo-
PELO/HBS1L induction is required for translation of a group of somes by PELO/HBS1L allows for the translation of critical
mRNAs that includes hemoglobin in K562 cells, where they mRNAs, such as those encoding hemoglobin (Lodish, 1974).
Hours: 0 6 12 18 24
15
100 HBA1 100 HBZ1
TE Fold Change
2 days post-hemin induction
80 80
HbF HBA1
HBZ1 60 60
10
HBE1
HBG1 40 40
20 20
PELO
0 0
0 2 6 0 2 6
5
6.0 6.0
5 0 5 10 15 4.0 4.0
Translational Efficiency (TE) [log2] 2.0 2.0
eIF1A 0 days post-hemin induction 0 0
0 2 6 0 2 6
Days Days
D E F
shHBS1L-1/ shHBS1L-2/
shPELO-1 shPELO-2 2d
-1
1L
BS
+ - + -
trl
sh Ctrl
H
C
sh
sh
2 days post-hemin
sh HBS1L - + - + kDa
- + - +
0.4 0.5
sh PELO 160
day 0 TE
Fraction of mRNAs
160
PELO vs GFP
1.5
Fraction of mRNAs
0.3
HBA1
1.0
0.2
HBG1 76 HBS1L
0.5
0.1
76
0.0
HBS1L
PELO
0.0
2 0 2
6 4 2 0 2 4 6 Fold Change TE [log2]
PELO HbF
Fold Change TE [log2]
eIF1A Actin
G H I
2d
sh Ctrl + - - GFP + + over-
Available ribosomes Translating ribosomes
-
sh HBS1L-1 - + - PELO - - + expression initiation
sh PELO-1 - + - shCtrl + - -
knockdown
sh HBS1L-2 - - + shRPS19-1 - + +
Loss of ABCE1
sh PELO-2 - - +
HbF
HbF
X
recycling
eIF1A RPS19
High PELO/ 3UTR
HBS1L (nontranslating)
ribosomes
eIF1A