Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AbstractThis paper presents an approximate formula for recently, Zhang et al. [8] proposed a LIV peak-value formula
the peak value of the lightning-induced voltages in an aerial line considering stratified ground and Rizk et al. [9] proposed a
over high resistivity soils. In its derivation, it is considered the LIV peak-value formula for high-resistivity ground which is
transmission line return stroke model (TL) and a trapezoidal based on a number of correction coefficients.
current waveform. The formula is an improved version of a
previously expression presented by the authors, whereas its The peak value formula from Paulino et al. [7] was limited
validity range is extended from 1000 Ohmsm to 10000 Ohmsm. to soil resistivities up to 1000 m. However, many areas
The paper also illustrates the formula application in the experiencing high lightning-related problems have soil
assessment of the indirect lightning performance of overhead resistivities higher than 1000 m. Therefore, the aim of this
distribution lines. paper is to expand the LIV peak value formula presented in [7]
to soil resistivity values up to 10000 m.
Keywordscomponent; formatting; style; styling; insert (key
words) This paper is organized as follows. Initially, Section II
extends and validates the computer code TIDA for high-
I. INTRODUCTION resistivity soils. Section III derives the new peak value formula
The calculation of lightning-induced voltages (LIVs) in an and validates it against TIDA results. Section IV illustrates the
overhead conductor is relevant in order to develop cost- new formula application in the assessment of a power
effective protective methods for power distribution lines and distribution line flashover rate. Section V discusses some
telecommunication lines. For instance, the theoretical relevant aspects of the approximations considered and
assessment of the lightning flashover rate of a power Section VI draws the main conclusions.
distribution line allows the specification of the relevant line II. EXTENSION OF THE COMPUTER CODE TIDA FOR HIGH
components in order to achieve a desired performance. Are
RESISTIVITY SOILS
examples of these components the supporting structure
(including clearances), type of insulators, grounding scheme The computer simulations presented in [7] were carried out
and resistance, and installation of surge arresters. with the TIDA code [10] that uses the time-domain formulation
proposed in [11]. References [12]-[13] show that this
New modeling techniques and powerful computers allow formulation has a limitation at close range, especially for poor
the calculation of the LIVs considering realistic line topologies, conducting earth. In [14], the authors analyze the impact of this
which include complex line configurations, presence of surge limitation on the lightning induced voltages in aerial
arresters, and the shielding effect provided by nearby structures distribution lines at close range (50 m) and show that it is
[1]-[3]. Although these techniques are very useful to significant only for very poor conducting earth. Therefore,
investigate the effect of realistic lines, they have the drawback = 1000 m is considered as an upper limit for the earth
of requiring sophisticated software and large computational resistivity for using the formulation proposed in [11] for LIVs
resources. The latter is particularly relevant when it is calculation at close range (50 m). Up to such resistivity value
necessary to compute the indirect flashover rate, when and aerial distribution lines, the errors can be neglected.
hundreds thousands of simulations are required.
Considering the electric field component originated in the
On the other hand, the assessment of the indirect flashover current flowing in the ground near the point of impact of the
rate through the LIV peak value, although approximate, can stroke, a new formulation for the horizontal electric field was
yield fast and sufficiently accurate results for many proposed for the close range in [12]. This new formulation is
applications. A LIV peak-value formula was originally derived now incorporated into TIDA code.
by Rusck [4], considering perfectly conducting soils. This
formula was lately expanded by Darveniza [5] to take into The TIDA code was already validated for soils with
account lossy soils. An improved formula was proposed by resistivity up to 1000 m [10]. Recently Rizk et al. [15]
Paulino et al. [6] considering a step current waveform, which presented some LIV calculations for high-resistivity soils using
was lately expanded to a more general version [7]. More the 3-D FDTD method. The LIV were calculated in an aerial
T;
150 v r
y
T is the return stroke current front-time in s and h is the line
height, I0 is the peak value of the stroke current, is the soil
resistivity, y is the closest distance between the lightning
striking point and the line, vr is the relative velocity of the
return stroke (vr = v/c), v is the return stroke velocity and c is
the light velocity. The factor k=0.915 is needed to account for
the delay between the voltages VR and VS, as discussed in [6].
The peak value is calculated at the closest point along the
Fig. 1. LIV calculated by TIDA code and Rizk et al. [15] for a 10 m height, line with respect to the flash, as the maximum induced voltage
3400 m long line, and 2/100 s stroke current waveform. Soils resistivities occurs at this point [6].
varying from 0 to 2 km.
Paulino et al. [16] showed that the use of the median value
for the stroke current front time (T = 5.63 s) and the relative
return stroke velocity vr = 0.4 s lead to flashover rates very
close to those computed using the probabilistic variation of
these parameters in the Monte Carlo method. Therefore, the
values above will be assumed in this paper, which leads to a
simplification in (2):
VR 0.0568 I 0 h ln
1 1 2 ,
2
(4)
1 1 2
2
where = 337.8 / y.
VI. CONCLUSIONS
A simple formula is proposed to calculate the LIV peak
value in aerial wires over soils with resistivities values in the
range 100 10000 m. This formula is useful for the fast
assessment of the indirect flashover rate of power distribution
lines in regions where the soil resistivity main attain high
Fig. 7. Variation of the inverse attenuation constant (1/) as a function of values.
frequency for three ground resistivities values (r =10), adapted from [20].
The application of this formula shows that indirect
lightning is the major concern for the 100 kV CFO lines, as the
flashover rate for indirect flashes outnumber those from direct
flashes for ground resistivity values above 200 m. On the
2017 International Symposium on Lightning Protection (XIV SIPDA), Natal, Brazil, 2nd 6th October 2017.
other hand, for the 170 kV CFO lines, the indirect lightning comparison with the IEEE STD. 1410 Method, IEEE Trans. Power
flashes become the main cause of lightning-related flashover Delivery, vol. 22, no. 1, pp. 684692, Jan. 2007.
[18] IEEE Guide for Improving the Lightning Performance of Electric Power
only for relatively poor conducting ground (above 1000 m). Overhead Distribution lines. Approved 28 January 2011, IEEE
Finally, for the special design lines (CFO = 300 kV), the Standards Board. IEEE Std 1410TM- 2010.
indirect lightning flashes outnumber those from direct flashes [19] J. O. S. Paulino, C. F. Barbosa, I. J. S. Lopes, W. C. Boaventura,
only for very high resistivity soils (above 3500 m). G. C. Miranda, Indirect lightning performance of aerial distribution
lines considering the induced-voltage waveform, IEEE Trans. on
Electromag. Comp., vol. 57, no. 5, pp. 1123-1131, Oct. 2015.
[20] F. Rachidi, C.A. Nucci, M. Ianoz, and C. Mazzetti, "Influence of a lossy
VII. REFERENCES ground on lightning-induced voltages on overhead lines," IEEE Trans.
Electromagn. Compat., vol. 38, no. 3, pp.250-264, Aug.1996.
[1] A. Borghetti, F. Napolitano, C. A. Nucci, and F. Tossani, [21] H.K. Hidalen; Analytical formulation of lightning-induced voltages on
"Advancements in insulation coordination for improving lightning multiconductor overhead lines above lossy ground; IEEE Transactions
performance of distribution lines," Int. Symp. on Lightning Protection on Electromagnetic Compatibility, vol. 45, no 1, pp. 92-100, 2003.
(XIII SIPDA), Balnerio Cambori, Brazil, Sept.-Oct., 2015. [22] J.R. Wait, "Transient fields of a vertical dipole over homogeneous
[2] A. Borghetti, F. Napolitano, C.A. Nucci, and F. Tossani, "Influence of curved ground", Can. J. Phys., vol. 34, pp. 27-35, 1956.
the return stroke current waveform on the lightning performance of [23] A. Greenwood, "Electrical Transients in Power SystemsSection 2.6:
distribution lines", IEEE Trans. on Power Delvery, in print. Duhamels IntegralResponse of a Circuit to an Arbitrary Stimulus,"
[3] F. Tossani, A. Borghetti, F. Napolitano, A. Piantini, and C.A. Nucci, Hoboken, NJ: Wiley, 1971, pp. 2731.
"Lightning performance of overhead power distribution lines in urban [24] F. Heidler, Analitische blitzstromfunktion zur LEMP-berechnung,
areas", IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, in print. presented at the 18th Int. Conf. Lightning Protection, Munich,
[4] S. Rusck, Induced lightning over-voltages on power transmission lines Germany,1985.
with special reference to the over-voltage protection of low-voltage [25] V. Cooray, Propagation effects due to finitely conducting ground on
networks, Ph.D. dissertation, Royal Inst. Technol., Stockholm, Sweden, lightning-generated magnetic fields evaluated using Sommerfelds
1957. integrals. IEEE Trans. Electromagn. Comp., vol. 51, no. 3, pp. 526-531
[5] M. Darveniza, A practical extension of Ruscks formula for maximum Aug. 2009.
lightning-induced voltages that accounts for ground resistivity, IEEE
Trans. Power Delivery., vol. 22, no. 1, pp. 605612, Jan. 2007.
[6] J. O. S. Paulino, C. F. Barbosa, C.; I. J. S. Lopes, W. C. Boaventura; An
Approximate formula for the peak value of lightning-induced voltages in
overhead lines. IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, vol. 25, no.2, April
2010, pp. 843-851.
[7] J.O.S. Paulino, C.F. Barbosa, C.; I.J.S. Lopes, W.C. Boaventura.; The
peak value of lightning-induced voltages in overhead lines considering
the ground resistivity and typical return stroke parameters," IEEE Trans.
on Power Delivery, vol. 26, no.2, pp. 920-927, April 2011.
[8] Qilin Zhang, Liang Zhang, Xiao Tang, and Jinge Gao, "An approximate
formula for estimating the peak value of lightning-induced overvoltage
considering the stratified conducting ground," IEEE Trans. on Power
Delivery, vol. 29, no. 2, April 2014.
[9] M. E. M. Rizk, F. Mahmood, M. Lehtonen, E. A. Badran, and
M. H. Abdel-Rahman, "Computation of peak lightning-induced voltages
due to the typical first and subsequent return strokes considering high
ground resistivity," IEEE Trans. on Power Delivery, in print.
[10] J. O. S. Paulino, C. F. Barbosa, I. J. S. Lopes, and G. C. Miranda,
"Time-domain analysis of rocket-triggered lightning-induced surges on
an overhead line", IEEE Trans. on EMC, vol. 51, no. 3, Part II,
Aug.2009.
[11] C. F. Barbosa; J. O. S. Paulino, "An approximate time domain formula
for the calculation of the horizontal electric field from lightning," IEEE
Trans. on Electromag. Comp. vol.49, pp. 593-601, Aug. 2007.
[12] C. F. Barbosa and J. O. S. Paulino, "A time-domain formula for the
horizontal electric field at the earth surface in the vicinity of lightning,"
IEEE Trans. EMC, vol. 52, no. 3, pp. 640-645, Aug. 2010.
[13] V. Cooray, Horizontal electric field above and underground produced
by lightning flashes, IEEE Trans. Electromagn. Compat., vol. 52, no. 4,
pp. 936943, Nov. 2010.
[14] J. O. S. Paulino, C. F. Barbosa, W. C. Boaventura, "Effect of the surface
impedance on the induced voltages in overhead lines from nearby
lightning", IEEE Trans. on Electromag. Comp., vol. 53, no. 3, pp. 749-
754, Aug. 2011.
[15] M. E. M. Rizk, F. Mahmood, M. Lehtonen, E. A. Badran, M. H. Abdel-
Rahman, "Influence of highly resistive ground parameters on lightning-
induced overvoltages using 3-D FDTD method," IEEE Trans. on
Electromag. Comp., vol 58, no. 3, June 2016.
[16] J.O.S. Paulino, C.F. Barbosa, I.J.S. Lopes, and W.C. Boaventura,
"Assessment and analysis of indirect lightning performance of overhead
lines," Electric Power Systems Research, vol. 118, pp. 55-61, 2014.
[17] A. Borghetti, C. A. Nucci, and M. Paolone, An improved procedure for
the assessment of overhead line indirect lightning performance and its