Professional Documents
Culture Documents
HISTORY/ DEVELOPMENT
-no excused absences Land Registration Act lasted for 75/77 years
until repealed by P.D. No. 1529 which is the law
-duty: to learn, to study, to pray, to pass! now in force and in effect.
o Persons go to other places Private land ownership did not come from
nowhere.
Thus, there is only temporary control because it
is impossible to physically possess or control There could be a source: who>/ from whom did
large tracts of land. you acquire your land?
1
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
The Government said that the Boracay Island is a When Spain entered the Treaty
forest and timberland and remained to be forest of Paris, Spain did not cede the
and timberland, so not agricultural land. lands of the churches; they
continued to be property of the
SC: the lands are inalienable public land; until the RC Church.
government reclassified Boracay Island, it is still
forest and timberland; thus, it cant be acquired Ohcho v. Director of Lands (75 Phils. 89) . . . All
by private persons. lands that were not acquired from the Government,
either by purchase or by grant, belong to the public
Basis: Regalian doctrine (all of public domains domain. An exception to the rule would be any land
belong to the State; State reserves such right that should have been in the possession of an
over such lands. occupant and of his predecessors in interest since
time immemorial, for such possession would justify
The 1935, 1973 & 1987 Constitution applies this the presumption that the land had never been part of
doctrine. the public domain even before the Spanish conquest.
(Cario vs. Insular Government, 212 U.S., 449; 53
All lands not acquired from the government Law. ed., 594.) 20 The applicant does not come under
belong to the State. the exception, for the earliest possession of the lot by
his first predecessor in interest began in 1880.
The state can consider what is alienable or not.
Laws of Indies Land- is the solid part of the surface of the Earth.
2
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
3
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
Public- not segregated from mass of We are concerned with transaction involving
lands. lands;
i. The Constitution classifies Ownership: how transferred? How lost? Who has
4 classes: better right? Page | 4
1. Forest and 3 DIFFERENT SYSTEMS
timberlands
OF TRANSFERRING LAND TITLE
2. Mineral
1. Production and delivery of conveyance and
3. Agricultural order of grantor to grantee (complete in itself)
Navigable sea
1. For Registered Lands:
INALIENABLE= NON-REGISTRABLE
PD 1529 (Codified Act; Cadastral Act)
4
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
-to put a stop forever to any question to the In all cases of registration procured by fraud,
the owner may pursue all his legal and
legality of the title except claims which are duly equitable remedies against the parties to such
noticed at the time of the registration (that claims fraud without prejudice, however, to the rights
should be duly recorded in the title) of any innocent holder for value of a certificate
of title. After the entry of the decree of
registration on the original petition or
application, any subsequent registration
procured by the presentation of a forged
Corollary to this is the next: duplicate certificate of title, or a forged deed or
other instrument, shall be null and void.
5
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
Page | 7
-presumed to know facts
Supposing, a registered land subject of sale; the
sale is not registered, who are bound?
-good faith is not a valid defense Only the parties (estoppels by deed)
Heirs, assigns, successors-in-interest (based on
SEC. 32 Review of decree of registration; Relativity)
Innocent purchaser for value. The decree of
registration shall not be reopened or revised Are third persons bound?
by reason of absence, minority, or other
disability of any person adversely affected It depends
thereby, nor by any proceeding in any court
for reversing judgments, subject, however, to
the right of any person, including the o If with actual knowledge of the
government and the branches thereof, conractshe is bound
deprived of land or of any estate or interest
therein by such adjudication or confirmation of
title obtained by actual fraud, to file in the
o K v. Veluz (41 Phil. 604) &
proper Court of First Instance a petition for Consolidated Rural Bank v. CA (448
reopening and review of the decree of SCRA 34)
registration not later than one year from and
after the date of the entry of such decree of
registration, but in no case shall such petition
Third persons are bound
be entertained by the court where an innocent because actual knowledge of the
purchaser for value has acquired the land or transaction is equivalent to
an interest therein, whose rights may be registration.
prejudiced. Whenever the phrase "innocent
purchaser for value" or an equivalent phrase
occurs in this Decree, it shall be deemed to Are there secret girlfriends?
include an innocent lessee, mortgagee, or
other encumbrancer for value. How? To let her know to notify actual
knowledge=registration
Upon the expiration of said period of one year,
the decree of registration and the certificate of 7. To provide stability to land titles
title issued shall become incontrovertible. Any
person aggrieved by such decree of
registration in any case may pursue his
remedy by action for damages against the
applicant or any other persons responsible for
the fraud.
Corollary to this is the MIRROR DOCTRINE (all you
have to do is to rely on the title; It was envisaged REGISTRATION DOES NOT VEST TITLE TO
that a person who was considering purchasing an REGISTRANT
interest in land could find all the information
Ex. OFW went abroad; he left documents to friend;
necessary to make a decision by inspection of the
then the friend registered.
register. That is, the register would be a `mirror' of the
actual state of the proprietor's title, and disclose any
Registration does not vest title, OFW can ask
benefits or encumbrances associated with the title
for reconveyance
Mirror principle - the register (Certificate of Title)
reflects (mirrors) accurately and completely the REGISTRATION MERELY CONFIRMS
current facts about a person's title. This means that, if TITLE
7
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
1. Occupation Page | 8
-registration is not a mode of acquiring ownership
2. Intellectual creation the only one not
-it does not cure defect in the contract
applicable to real property
-it does not validate an illegal contract
3. Donation/succession
4. In consequence of contract by
REGISTRATION SHOULD BE ACCOMPLISHED IN tradition/delivery
THE CORRECT SYSTEM OF REGISTRATION
5. Prescription
Ex. Land already registered; Tax Declaration is
unregistered land; land sold to A; A registered it to RECOGNIZED MODES
registration of unregistered land by attachment
creditor; 2nd buyer bought the land from registered 1. Government grant
owner.
2. Adverse possession
2nd buyer has better right because it was
wrong system of registration: invalid/legally 3. Prescription
ineffective registration
4. Reclamation
ORIGINAL REGISTRATION- if first time to be
registered in public record, it is original registration
5. Voluntary transfer
(Original Certificate Of Title)
OBJECT OF REGISTRATION: real rights and real There must be a law justifying express or implied
property and interests in the land (e.g. mortgage, grant.
attachment, etc.)
Example:
8
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
9
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
4. RECLAMATION
Alluvium
Reclamation- method of filling, dredging, or other
Avulsion means.
o No, technical description of the PD 1084 gave PEA authority to reclaim land; to
property does not include the develop, improve, acquire or sell land. PEA started to
additional area. Therefore, the dispose property. This was questioned.
additional area is unregistered.
Issues:
o The remedy is to apply for
registration under P.D. No. 1529 1. That submerged area of Manila Bay remains
inalienable natural resources of public domain it
10
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
cant be transferred to other party beyond the 1935 Constitution: private corporations can own
commerce of men public domains they remain owners of land;
they have vested rights of property; if we apply
2. When can it be subject to transfer? The filling of the current Constitution retroactively, it will be a Page |
the submerged areas through the reclamation deprivation of property without due process of
project, in order to be alienable, the government
11
law.
should issue a proclamation that the land is now
alienable.
5. VOLUNTARY TRANSFER
inalienable lands of public domain Can be made by the owner or his agent
o Seizure
Private Corporations not legally qualified to own land
o Levy on attachment
of public domains
o Levy on execution
1973, 1987 Constitution
11
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
4. ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEEDINGS
Real Property Act of 1857/1858 (?) (d) Exercise executive supervision over all clerks of court and
personnel of the Courts of First Instance throughout the
Philippines with respect to the discharge of their duties and
functions in relation to the registration of lands;
Advantages of Torrens System (e) Implement all orders, decisions, and decrees promulgated
relative to the registration of lands and issue, subject to the
approval of the Secretary of Justice, all needful rules and
Refer to book/s; read and learn regulations therefor;
Refer to book; read and learn (2) The Land Registration Commission shall have the following
functions:
LAND REGISTRATION AUTHORITY (EO 292) (b) Extend assistance to courts in ordinary and cadastral land
registration proceedings;
Headed by: Administrator assisted by 2 deputy
administrator (c) Be the central repository of records relative to
original registration of lands titled under the
Torrens system, including subdivision and
Under DOJ
consolidation plans of titled lands.
Its arms (under it) are: various Register of Deeds
in provinces and cities
13
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
The Secretary of Justice shall define the official station and Section 10. General functions of Registers of Deeds. The office of
territorial jurisdiction of each Registry upon the recommendation of the Register of Deeds constitutes a public repository of records of
the Commissioner of Land Registration, with the end in view of instruments affecting registered or unregistered lands and chattel
making every registry easily accessible to the people of the mortgages in the province or city wherein such office is situated.
neighboring municipalities.
14
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
2. Judicial
15
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
Where to appeal?
JUDICIAL CONFIRMATION OF INCOMPLETE OR
IMPERFECT TITLE
Court of Appeals Land Registration &
Cadastral Cases
NATURE OF PROCEEDINGS
Judicial
1. What kinds of lands are covered? Sec. 48 (b), Chapter VIII, of CA 141, as amended
(Public Land Act), provides:
- Alienable and disposable land of public
domain
Sec. 48. The following described
2. Period of possession and occupation of land citizens of the Philippines, occupying lands of
the public domain or claiming to own any such
- Since June 12, 1945 or earlier lands or an interest therein, but whose titles
have not been perfected or completed, may
apply to the Regional Trial Court of the
3. When should application be filed? province or city where the land is located for
confirmation of their claims and the issuance
16
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
APPLICANTS
By law and jurisprudence, the following may therefore The burden of proof lies with the applicant to prove
apply for judicial confirmation of their imperfect or his positive averments.
incomplete title:
17
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
2. alienable and disposable lands of the public government grant, without the necessity of a
domain certificate of title being issued.
Page |
Possession The land perforce ceases to be of the public domain,
and beyond the authority of the Director of Land 18
- Broader than occupation because it includes Management to dispose of. The application for
constructive possession confirmation is then a mere formality, the lack of
which does not affect the sufficiency of the title as
- When the law adds the word occupation, it would be evidenced by the patent and the
seeks to delimit the all-encompassing effect corresponding Torrens title issued pursuant to such
of constructive possession. patent.
DISTINCTIONS BETWEEN OLR AND JCT 3. Setting of the date for the initial hearing of
the application by the Court;
(by Judge Serrano)
4. Transmittal of the publication and the date of
ORDINARY LAND JUDICIAL initial hearing with all the documents or other
REGISTRATION CONFIRMATION OF evidences attached thereto by the Clerk of
PROCEEDINGS TITLE Court to the Land Registration Authority
(LRA);
Title to land exist subject Presumption is that the
to confirmation land applied for pertains 5. Publication of a notice of the filing of the
to the State, and that the application and date and place of the hearing
occupants and in the Official Gazette;
possessors only claim an
interest in the same by 6. Service of notice upon contiguous owners,
virtue of their imperfect occupants and those known to have interests
title or continuous, open, in the property by the sheriff;
and notorious possession
7. Filing of answer to the application by any
May be dismissed with or Dismissal is always with person whether named in the court or not;
without prejudice prejudice (res judicata)
8. Hearing of the case by the Court;
(Applicant may re-file
case) 9. Promulgation of judgment by the Court;
If without prejudice, If applicant fails to prove 10. Issuance of the decree by the Court
applicant will not lose the grant as basis of declaring the decision final and instructing
ownership to the confirmation, property is the LRA to issue a decree of confirmation
property declared land of public and registration;
domain and loses
property 11. Entry of the decree of registration in the LRA;
20
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
SURVEY
(by Judge Serrano) Where the land is owned in common, all the
co-owners shall file the application jointly.
Prepares survey plan
Where the land has been sold under pacto de
Technical description (purpose: to identify retro, the vendor a retro may file an
and describe the landJ) application for the original registration of the
land, provided, however, that should the
period for redemption expire during the
pendency of the registration proceedings and
ownership to the property consolidated in the
Submitted to the Land Management Bureau vendee a retro, the latter shall be substituted
for approval by the Director for the applicant and may continue the
proceedings.
PREPARATION
1. Natural persons
2. Juridical persons
(1) Those who by themselves or through their 3. Corporations (under the Constitution must
predecessors-in-interest have been in open, continuous, be 60% owned by Filipinos)
exclusive and notorious possession and occupation of
alienable and disposable lands of the public domain
under a bona fide claim of ownership since June 12,
1945, or earlier.
Sec. 14 (1)
21
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
Requires that the property sought to be registered as Ex. Lands registered under the Spanish Mortgage
already alienable and disposable at the time of the Law which are not yet covered by a certificate of title
application for registration and not at the time/before by the time of the issuance of PD 1529 on June 11,
applicants possession 1978 and considered as unregistered land: these
lands may be acquired by a person by prescription by
adverse possession against the original grantee.
Sec. 14 (2)
Article 1137 of the Civil Code For accretion and alluvion to be registrable, requisites
provides that ownership and other must concur:
real rights over immovables also
prescribe through uninterrupted
adverse possession thereof for thirty 1. That the deposit be gradual and
years, without need of title or of good imperceptible;
faith. 2. That it be made through the effects of the
current of the water;
3. That the land where the accretion takes
place is adjacent to the banks of rivers.
4. That it must be exclusive work of nature and
Rules for 30-year period: not caused by human intervention.
22
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
24
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
(a) Mailing of notice to persons named in the The court may also cause notice to be served
application. The Commissioner of Land to such other persons and in such manner as
Registration shall also, within seven days after it may deem proper.
publication of said notice in the Official
Gazette, as hereinbefore provided, cause a
copy of the notice of initial hearing to be
mailed to every person named in the notice
whose address is known. (Caption and Title)
(b) Mailing of notice to the Secretary of Public To (here insert the names of all persons
Highways, the Provincial Governor and the appearing to have an interest and the
Mayor. If the applicant requests to have the adjoining owners so far as known, and to all
line of a public way or road determined, the whom it may concern):
Commissioner of Land Registration shall
cause a copy of said notice of initial hearing to
be mailed to the Secretary of Public
Highways, to the Provincial Governor, and to
the Mayor of the municipality or city, as the An application (or petition) having been filed in
case may be, in which the land lies. the above-entitled case by (full name and
address) praying for the registration and
confirmation (or for the settlement and
adjudication, in case of petition in cadastral
proceedings) of title to the following described
(c) Mailing of notice to the Secretary of lands:
Agrarian Reform, the Solicitor General, the
Director of Lands, the Director of Public
Works, the Director of Forest Development,
the Director of Mines and the Director of
Fisheries and Aquatic Resources. If the land (Insert description)
borders on a river, navigable stream or shore,
or on an arm of the sea where a river or
harbor line has been established, or on a lake,
or if it otherwise appears from the application
or the proceedings that a tenant-farmer or the You are hereby served this notice to appear
national government may have a claim before this Court at its session to be held at
26
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
Witness, the Hon. -the duty to set it lies with the court
________________________ Judge of the
Court of First Instance of _______ this
_______ day of _________________, in the -it is beyond the power of the applicant
year 19______.
-it is unfair to punish the applicant because
Attest: he has no control to set the date for initial
hearing.
Commissioner of Land Registration
PUBLICATION
-O.G. often delayed, notice does not reach By sheriff or his deputy
interested party on time
Certification of Administrator
If the court does not acquire jurisdiction: (because he is the one who caused the
all proceedings by the court are null and void. publication)
o Probative value/ conclusive proof;
Section 24. Proof of publication and
notice. The certification of the Commissioner of Land
Issue of O.G. released after initial hearing Registration and of the sheriff concerned to the effect
that the notice of initial hearing, as required by law, has
been complied with shall be filed in the case before the
Register of Deeds of Malabon v. RTC, date of initial hearing, and shall be conclusive proof of
Malabon, Metro Manila such fact.
Copy of the Official Gazette
-tardiness of publication: court did not Copy of the Newspaper
acquire jurisdiction Affidavit of publication issued by the
publisher or duly authorized person of the
Republic v. CA (236 SCRA 442, 449) newspaper.
28
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
- all the objections to the application and 1. a homesteader who had not yet been issued
his title but who had fulfilled all the conditions
- shall set forth the interest claimed by the party required by law to entitle him to a patent;
filing the same and
2. a purchaser of friar land before the issuance
- apply for the remedy desired, and
of the patent to him;
- shall be signed and sworn to by him or by
some other duly authorized person. 3. Persons who claim to be in possession of a
tract of public land and have applied with the
Bureau of Land Management for its purchase
The oppositors: need not be named in the notice of When the land is inalienable (e.g. timberland, forest
initial hearing. land)
- He must claim an interest to the property applied Ground: the court has no jurisdiction over the case
for, based on a right of dominion or some other because the land is inalienable
29
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
1. Fraud
A default order is entered against the whole
2. Accident
world, so that all persons are bound by said
3. Mistake
order. A person who has not challenged the
4. Excusable negligence
application for registration of land, even if the
5. Meritorious defense
appeal he afterwards interposed is based on the
right of dominion over the same land, cannot
allege damage or error against the judgment
granting the registration inasmuch as he did not
allege to have any right to such land. If there has already been judgment by
The applicant is allowed to present evidence ex default and applicant has already
parte presented evidence: motion for new trial
(ground: fame-m)
30
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
31
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
33
SUMMARY TABLE OF PIECES OF EVIDENCE APPLICANT SHOULD PROVE IN LAND REGISTRATION
CASES
1. That the land applied for has a. Presidential proclamation a. Survey plan
been declassified, and is a public b. Executive order b. Conversion of land into fishpond
agricultural land, is alienable and c. Administrative order c. mere fact that the area in which the
disposable d. BFD Land Classification Map land involved is located has become
e. Certification by the Director of Forestry highly developed residential or
and reports of District Forester commercial land and actually no longer
f. Investigation reports of Bureau of forest land
Lands
g. Legislative act, by statute
2. Identity of the land a. Survey plan
b. Tracing cloth plan and blue print copies
of the plan
c. Technical description of the land
applied for, duly signed by a geodetic
engineer
d. Tax declarations
e. Boundaries and area
it is an effect, a writ of execution, commanding the a complement of the writ of possession, without
sheriff to enter the land and give possession thereof which the latter would be ineffective
to the person entitled under the judgment.
not appealable where there is no allegation that it
Persons entitled: has varied the tenor of the judgment
1. Adjudged owner
2. Any subsequent purchaser of the property
DECREE OF CONFIRMATION AND
REGISTRATION
2
Dismissal without prejudice the judgment is not conclusive Decree of registration
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
condensed form of the courts judgment such conclusiveness does not cease to exist when
the title is transferred to a successor
Sec. 31. Decree of registration.
Contents:
Sec. 39. Preparation of decree and 1. Full names of all persons whose interest
certificate of title. make up the full ownership in the whole land
2. Civil status
After the judgment directing the registration of
3. Names of respective spouses, if married
title to land has become final, the court shall,
within 15 days from entry of judgment, issue If the property covered belongs to the
an order directing the Commissioner to issue conjugal properties, the certificate is issued
the corresponding decree of registration and in the name of both spouses.
certificate of title. The clerk of court shall send, 4. Citizenship
within 15 days from entry of judgment, 5. Residence
certified copies of the judgment and of the 6. Postal address
order of the court directing the Commissioner
to issue the corresponding decree of
registration and certificate of title and a
In determining whether a property belongs to
certificate stating that the decision has not
been amended, reconsidered, nor appealed,
the conjugal partnership or paraphernal property
and has become final. Thereupon, the of one of the spouses, it is important to note in
Commissioner shall cause to be prepared the whose name or names the title is registered. This
decree of registration as well as the original is so because the certificate of title does not
and duplicate of the corresponding original establish the time of the acquisition of the
certificate of title. The original certificate of title property. It only confirms a pre-existing title.
shall be a true copy of the decree of
registration. The decree of registration shall
be signed by the Commissioner, entered and Owners duplicate certificate of title
filed in the Land Registration Commission.
The original of the original certificate of title Sec. 41: Owners duplicate certificate of
shall also be signed by the Commissioner and title
shall be sent, together with the owner's
duplicate certificate, to the Register of Deeds The owners duplicate certificate of
of the city or province where the property is title shall be delivered to the registered owner
situated for entry in his registration book. or to his duly authorized representative. If two
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
3
Art. 1441: Trusts are either express or implied. Express trusts are
5. ACTION FOR RECONVEYANCE
created by the intention of the trustor or of the parties. Implied
trusts come into being by operation of law.
LTD LECTURE NOTES & REVIEWER
Art. 477: The plaintiff must have a legal or equitable title to,
or interest in the real property which is the subject-matter of GOD BLESS!
the action. He need not be in possession of said property.
Art. 479: The plaintiff must return to the defendant all the
benefits he may have received from the latter or reimburse
him for expenses that may have redounded to the plaintiffs
benefit.
Art. 481: The procedure for the quieting of title or the removal
of a cloud therefrom shall be governed by such rules of court
as the Supreme Court shall promulgate.
Note:
Before Now