1 No.

1
2008 1 BO IL ER MANUFACTUR IN G Jan. 2008

: CN23 - 1249 (2008) 01 - 0065 - 05

AutoPSA CAESAR

, ,

( , 410013 )

: , AutoPSA CAESAR

, AutoPSA

, AutoPSA , Au2

toPSA
,

AutoPSA CAESAR
,
: ; ; ; ; ; ;
: TU4 : B

P ipe Stress Ana lysis Com par ison Bet ween

AutoPSA and CAESAR
Z hang S hu jun, L i Guobin, Chen B a ilian

(UESoft Corp. , Changsha 410013, China )

Abstract: The results of AutoPSA and CAESAR is compared combining som e actual engineering
examp les. The paper also p rovide the comparison result about nonlinear analysis such as single 2di2
rectional restraints and buried p ipe modeling. Considering the modal analysis, harmonic analysis,
spectrum analysis and tim e history analysis in p ipe stress analysis, suitable technique was app lied to
increase the efficiency and stability of dynam ic analysis. AutoPSA is accurate and universal, thus
suitable for engineering app lication in power, oil and gas, chem ical industry, et. The results of e2
valuated examp les demonstrate that AutoPSA is comparable w ith CAESAR , and exceed the latter
in some dom ain.
Key words: p ipe stress analysis; single 2directional restraint; buried p ipe; modal analysis; harmonic a2
nalysis; spectrum analysis; tim e history analysis

, ,
0 AutoPSA7. 0 AutoPSA7. 0 CAESAR
2002 12 21
AutoPSA1. 0 , AutoPSA7. 0

: 2007 - 05 - 17
: ( 1976 - ) , , 2007 , , CAE
 66 207

CAESAR GL IF , ,
AutoPSA7. 0
AutoPSA , UESoft 2007 8 17 ,
CAESAR , ASM E B31
AutoPSA7. 0 ,
, ASM E B31. 1 - 2001
, CAESAR ANSYS 1. 1
, AutoPSA7. 0 1 ,
10CrM o910, 540 , 13. 632
1 M Pa, 3 , [ 3 ] Au2
toPSA CAESAR ,

(W ) (W +D1 + T1 + P1 ) , GL IF GL IF
AutoPSA7. 0 , ,
, 15
[3] 38 mm
AutoPSA7. 0 (
) (
,
)
AutoPSA7. 0 ,

,


,
,
, 1

1. 2
AutoPSA7. 0
, 10 270
,
3 mm , Y

,
,
,
( OPE ) , AutoPSA

CAESAR 1 , ,
, CAESAR
1

X (mm ) Y (mm ) Z (mm )

AutoPSA CAESAR AutoPSA CAESAR AutoPSA CAESAR

3 16. 526 16. 489 - 51. 370 - 51. 384 - 51. 488 - 51. 502

5 - 18. 239 - 18. 294 - 74. 744 - 74. 740 - 118. 994 - 118. 992

6 - 20. 594 - 20. 573 - 22. 009 - 22. 010 - 132. 530 - 132. 459

7 - 19. 277 - 19. 205 - 176. 999 - 176. 999 - 133. 776 - 133. 656

8 - 14. 651 - 14. 675 - 150. 602 - 150. 612 - 132. 470 - 132. 418

1 000 - 44. 908 - 45. 003 - 32. 395 - 32. 450 - 107. 135 - 107. 366

10 080 - 17. 802 - 17. 864 - 82. 279 - 82. 274 - 115. 555 - 115. 559

10 270 - 19. 415 - 19. 342 3. 000 3. 000 - 133. 781 - 133. 661

10 280 - 56. 043 - 56. 057 - 30. 493 - 30. 541 - 128. 563 - 128. 796
 1 , : AutoPSA CAESAR 6 7

,
,
2
, , ,
, ,
, 0. 24 mm
1. 3 , ,
AutoPSA7. 0 ,
, CAESAR , Lanczos
, ,
2 , 10 - 11 AutoPSA7. 0 ,
, , 3. 657 6 m ( 12ft) , Lanczos ,
[ 4 ] , ,
[5]
, , Lanczos
0. 68%
,
AutoPSA7. 0
,

1
, 8 CAESAR
2 ,
2
0. 27% ,
2 ( Hz)
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

AutoPSA 0. 645 0. 754 1. 366 1. 644 2. 089 2. 334 2. 581 3. 038

CAESAR 0. 645 0. 756 1. 367 1. 645 2. 092 2. 336 2. 585 3. 042

120 Hz , [ 6 ]
3 120 Hz 115 Hz
137 Hz ,
AutoPSA7. 0
AutoPSA CAESAR
, ,
, 3 CAESAR
, , 0. 13%
3
3 , 8 13
( kPa) ( kPa)
AutoPSA CAESAR AutoPSA CAESAR

15 1 1 258. 648 1 257 - 1 258. 648 - 1257

7 8 - 543. 303 - 543 543. 303 543

10 11 - 892. 392 - 892 892. 392 892

16 2 1 258. 853 1 258 - 1 258. 853 - 1 258

4
3


 68 207

5
,

,
,
, , ,
,
, , ,
, ,
[7]

AutoPSA7. 0
,
, ,
,
, AutoP2
SA7. 0 , , ,
( SRSS) ( DSRSS)

(AB S) ( GROUP )
[5]

( 10% ) Newmark ,
4 , 65 AutoPSA7. 0
, [ 6 ] Au2 HHT , ,
toPSA CAESAR Newmark
4 ,
[8]
CAESAR
, ANSYS
, ANSYS
, 2
, ANSYS
,
1040 , 1130
20 ,
5 6
, AutoPSA ANSYS ,
CAESAR
, CAESAR , Au2
toPSA , CAE2
4 SAR
5
4
(m sec) 0 5. 0 26 31
( kPa) ( kPa)
(N ) 0 76 853 76 853 0
AutoPSA CAESAR AutoPSA CAESAR

5 6 9 007. 5 9 056 8 743. 5 8 788 6

6 10 15 286 14 580 14 982. 5 14 281 X (mm ) Z (mm )

11 15 20 023 19 076 20 115. 5 19 166 AutoPSA ANSYS CAESAR AutoPSA ANSYS CAESAR

16 20 17 968. 5 17 130 17 242 16 442 11 - 0. 019 - 0. 019 - 0. 019 - 0. 107 - 0. 107 - 0. 083

40 50 27 752 27 703 23 799. 5 23 704 20 12. 082 12. 082 11. 644 0. 836 0. 836 0. 727

65 70 21 230 21 135 23 001. 5 22 967 30 10. 130 10. 130 10. 534 - 0. 023 - 0. 023 - 0. 018
 1 , : AutoPSA CAESAR 6 9

[ 2 ] . ( 2)
6 [ J ]. , 2005, 4: 66 - 70.
[ 3 ] CAE .
AutoPSA , AutoPSA7. 0 [M ]. :
, , , 2006.
[ 4 ] ASM E Code for Pressure Pip ing, B31. 1, Power Pip ing.
, [ 5 ] . [M ]. :
1 ) AutoPSA , , 2003.

[ 6 ] CAESAR App lications Guide. COADE Engineering

2 ) AutoPSA Softw are Inc.

[ 7 ] , . [M ]. :

, 1990.
3 ) AutoPSA ,
[ 8 ] Chung J. , Hulbert G. M. A Tim e Integration A lgo2

rithm for Structural Dynam ics w ith Imp roved Numerical
4 ) AutoPSA , , D issipation: The Generalized - M ethod [ J ]. Journal
of App lied M echanics, 1993, 60: 371.
[ 9 ] , , , .

[M ]. : , 1983
[ 1 ] . ( 1 )
( : )
[ J ]. , 2005, 3: 57 - 62.

[ 58 ] , ,
, ,
,
, :
1 )
, , ,

2 )
, ,
,
4
3 )
300 mm ,
< 3 100 < 3 500 ,

4
, ,
,
, ,

5 , ,
3. 4 m , ,

( : )
http://free.paperyy.com
3http://www.ixueshu.com
http://www.paperyy.com/reduce_repetition
PPThttp://ppt.ixueshu.com

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1. CAESAR

2.

3.

4. CAESARFPSO

5. CAESAR

6.

7. CAESAR II

8. AutoPSACAESAR

9. CAESAR

10. Caesar salad, smoked salmon

11. CAESAR

12. ,

13. CAESAR

14. 350MW

15.

16.
17. CAESAR

18. 300MW

19. CAESAR

20. AutoPSACAESAR

21. CAESAR

22. JULIUS CAESAR ACT 3, SCENE 2

23. CAESAR

24.

25.

26.

27. CAESAR

28. CAESAR

29. CAESAR

30. Caesar

31. CAESAR

32.

33. CAESAR GLIF

34. CaesarANSYS

35. CAESAR

36.

37. CAESAR II

38.

39. CAESAR IIANSI

40.

41.

42. CAESAR

43.

44. CAESAR

45. CAESAR II

46. CAESAR

47. CAESAR II

48.

49.

50. 1000MWCAESAR