Professional Documents
Culture Documents
www.elsevier.com/locate/microc
Abstract
The aim of our study was the evaluation of personal exposure to chemical pollutants in workers employed in a plant for the production of
terephtalic acid dimethyl ester. Chemical agents have been included in the monitoring program on the basis of the industrial process. In the
plant, the oxidation of p-xylene is performed by air and the resulting acid is esterified with methyl alcohol. Purified terephtalic acid dimethyl
ester is then utilized for the production of polyethylene terephtalate. The environmental monitoring included terephtalic acid dimethyl ester,
p-toluic acid methyl ester, terephtalic acid, p-xylene, methylacetate, methylbenzoate, formic acid, acetic acid, methanol, and the catalysts
cobalt acetate and manganese (II) acetate tetrahydrate. Personal exposure to the cited airborne substances was performed in the breathing
zone of six workers. Air samplings were carried out by drawing air through glass fibre filters (terephtalic acid dimethyl ester, p-toluic acid
methyl ester and terephtalic acid aerosols), by active adsorption (methanol, formic and acetic acids vapours). p-Xylene, methylacetate and
methylbenzoate vapours were collected by passive sampling. Cellulose nitrate filters were used for cobalt and manganese salts samplings.
Analyses were performed by UV detection high-performance liquid chromatography (terephtalic acid dimethyl ester, p-toluic acid methyl
ester and terephtalic acid), flame ionization detection gas chromatography ( p-xylene, acetic acid methyl ester and benzoic acid methyl ester),
ion chromatography (formic and acetic acids) and inductively coupled plasma-mass spectrometry (cobalt and manganese). The results were
evaluated according to the threshold limit values (TLVs) of the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) and
indicated that the environmental levels of the workplace pollutants were well below the threshold limit values-time weighed average (TLV-
TWA) adopted by the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists for 2002, although for three substances the TLVs were
not available.
D 2004 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
2.2.2. Foreman timetable extended from 8:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., with an
Controls the furnaces, compressors and centrifuges and hour for lunch.
carries out all the actions to guarantee their correct Terephtalic acid dimethyl ester, p-toluic acid methyl ester
functioning; intervenes in all parts of the plant on request and terephtalic acid were collected on binder-free, type AE,
of the shift manager; informs the shift manager of the need 25 mm diameter, cat. no. 225-702 (SKC, Pittsburgh, PA,
to stock up on raw and secondary materials. USA) glass fibre membrane, at the flow rate of 2 L/min with
AirChek 52 (SKC) pump. p-Xylene, methylacetate, meth-
2.2.3. External oxidation workers (2) ylbenzoate were sampled through a cat. no. 575-002 (SKC)
Control (intervening when necessary) oxidation, ester- active carbon passive sampler. Methanol was collected on
ification, methanol distillation, raw ester distillation, meth- cat. no. 226-82 (SKC) Anasorb 747 CSC vial at the flow
anolysis, terephtalic acid dimethyl ester rectification, rate of 50 mL/min, while formic and acetic acids were
catalyst recovery and distillation filtrate sections. sampled with cat. no. 226-09 active carbon vial at the flow
rate of 100 mL/min. These three pollutants were sampled
2.2.4. External crystallization worker with a PocketPump (SKC) fitted with cat. no. 224-26-01
Controls and intervenes in the crystallization and (SKC) double-adjustable low flow holders. Cobalt acetate
intermediate storage areas. and manganese acetate were collected by filtering air
through 25-mm, 0.8-Am pore size, cat. no. 600-60121
2.2.5. Technological worker (day worker) (SKC) mixed cellulose esters at the flow rate of 2 L/min. For
Provides the maintenance staff with practical assistance the linear velocity of sample flow of polluting airborne
to eliminate loss of steam and assists workers responsible particulates, we adhered to current Italian legislation [8].
for cleaning the chemical plant. He is in charge of filling
cisterns with terephtalic acid dimethyl ester for sale outlet. 2.4. Analysis
2.3. Sampling Terephtalic acid dimethyl ester, p-toluic acid methyl ester
and terephtalic acid were extracted from the fibre glass filter
The aim of the environmental survey, which had a in 5 ml acetonitrile (HPLC grade, Carlo Erba Reagenti,
duration of four consecutive days in January 2003, was to Rodano, Italy), under sonication for 15 min. Recovery was
measure individual exposure to the substances listed in measured by spiking five filters with 100 Al of an
Table 1. For each of these, we have indicated the physical acetonitrile solution containing 97.1 Ag terephtalic acid
state (s, solid or v, vapour), CAS registry number and risk dimethyl ester (TCI, Tokyo, Japan) and 118.3 Ag p-toluic
and safety phrases. acid methyl ester (TCI), and 50 Al of an aqueous solution
During the survey, climatic data were obtained from a containing 111 Ag terephtalic acid (ChemService, West
meteorological station situated a few hundred meters from Chester, PA, USA). The filters were dried in a silica gel
the plant. Air was sampled in the breathing zone of the dryer overnight. Five clean filters were extracted to
workers. For shift workers, sampling took place over a determine limits of detection (LoDs). Terephtalic acid
continuous 77.5 h period, while for day worker the dimethyl ester and p-toluic acid methyl ester standards
duration was similar, but samplings were suspended were prepared in acetonitrile at 3.88 and 4.73 mg/l,
during the lunch break and were resumed immediately respectively, while terephtalic acid standard was prepared
afterwards. The 6:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m shift (the first in water at 111 mg/l. Blanks, standards, spikes and samples
shift) was chosen for the samplings. A day workers (20 Al) were analysed by HPLC, using a mixture of water/
Table 1
Air pollutants, physical state, CAS registry number, risk and safety phrasesa
Substance Physical state solid/vapour (S/V) CAS registry number Risk phrases Safety phrases
Terephtalic acid dimethyl ester S 120-61-6
p-Toluic acid methyl ester S 99-75-2
Terephtalic acid S 100-21-0
p-Xylene V 106-42-3 10-20/21-38 (2)-25
Methylacetate V 79-20-9 11-36-66-67 (2)-16-26-29-33
Methylbenzoate V 93-58-3
Formic acid V 64-18-6 35 (1/2)-23-26-45
Acetic acid V 64-19-7 10-35 23-26-45
Methanol V 67-56-1 11-23/24/25-39/23/23/24/25 1/2-7-16-36/37-45
Cobalt acetate trihydrate S 71-48-7
Manganese (II) acetate tetrahydrate S 6156-78-1
a
Ministry of Health. Decree 14th June 2002. Adoption of 2001/59/EC Council Directive with XXVIII adapting to technical progress the 67/548/EEC
Council Directive concerning the classification, packaging and labeling of dangerous substances. Gazzetta Ufficiale N. 244 17th October 2002.
402 I. Iavicoli et al. / Microchemical Journal 79 (2005) 399404
acetonitrile as the mobile phase at the flow rate of 1.5 ml/ 3. Results
min; programme: time 0 min, H2O/acetonitrile=100%:0%;
time 2 min, H2O/acetonitrile=100%:0%; time 10 min, H2O/ The results of environmental measurements of pollutants
acetonitrile=0%:100%; time 12 min, H2O/acetonitrile= are shown in Table 2 and are expressed as means and
100%:0%; time 20 min, H2O/acetonitrile=100%: 0%. concentration range. To calculate mean values, the LoD/2
Quantification was obtained by the external standard value were used in cases where some levels were below the
method. Analyses were performed using a mod. Vista LoD. Relative detection limits were deduced from LoDs,
(Varian, Walnut Creek, CA, USA) liquid chromatograph extraction parameters and the volume of air sampled. These
fitted with an Ultra C18 5 Am, 2504.6 mm (Supelco, are indicated in Table 2 for all substances as bb Q, except for
Bellefonte; PA, USA) column and a Polychrom mod. 9060 terephtalic acid dimethyl ester and methylbenzoate whose
(Varian) detector operating at 240 nm. Samples, standards, LoDs were found to be 0.0003 and 0.1 mg/m3, respectively.
blanks and spikes were injected into the liquid chromato- Relative data for each substance that has an established
graph after filtering through a 0.2-Am GyroDisk membrane threshold limit value-time weighted average (TLV-TWA)
(Orange Scientific, Waterloo, Belgium). have also been reported by referring to the American
p-Xylene, methyl acetate and methylbenzoate were Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH)
analysed by flame ionization detection gas chromatography. standards for the year 2002.
The analytes were desorbed for 4 h at room temperature with On account of the low solubility of terephtalic acid in
2 ml of carbon sulfide (J.T. Baker, Instra-Analyzed, Deventer, acetonitrile, the standard solutions had to be prepared in
Holland). Extraction efficiency was measured by adding to water, but recovery (98,0F1.8%) with acetonitrile of small
the adsorbent 2 ml of carbon sulfide containing p-xylene (RS amounts, such as those collected during air samplings, was
grade, Carlo Erba Reagenti), methylacetate (ChemService) not affected. Recoveries of terephtalic acid dimethyl ester
and methylbenzoate (RPE grade, Carlo Erba Reagenti) at and p-toluic ester were 101.8F2.0% and 97.7F2.3%,
concentrations of 0.43, 0.47 and 0.38 mg/l, respectively. Five respectively. Relative detection levels were b0.0005 mg/m3
clean adsorbents were also extracted to determine LoDs. (terephtalic acid dimethyl ester), b0.0001 mg/m3 ( p-toluic
Analyses were performed using a mod 3400 (Varian) gas acid methyl ester) and b0.0008 mg/m3 (terephtalic acid).
chromatograph and a mod. 8100 (Varian) autosampler.
Quantification was calculated by external standard method
with correction for extraction efficiency. A 60 m, i.d. 0.53 4. Discussion and conclusion
mm, Rtx-VMS (Restek, Bellefonte, PA, USA) column was
used with flame ionization detection. An isotherm pro- The sampling strategy took into account the remarkable
gramme was used: 40 8C for 4 min (step 1); programmed differences of the physico-chemical properties of the
temperature (step 2): up to 180 8C at 4 8C/min; programmed substances examined. In fact, while some of them, such as
temperature (step 3): up to 240 8C at 10 8C/min. The carrier terephtalic acid dimethyl ester, p-toluic acid methyl ester
and makeup gas was nitrogen at flows of 4 and 26 ml/min, and terephtalic acid dimethyl ester are solid, others, such as
respectively. p-xylene, methylacetate, methylbenzoate, formic acid,
Formic and acetic acids were analyzed by ion chroma- acetic acid and methyl alcohol, were present in the work-
tography using the OSHA-ID168SG method with a mod. places as vapours. This made it necessary not only to adopt
2100iSP ion chromatograph fitted with P580 (Dionex, different sampling systems for airborne particulates and
Sunnyvale, CA, USA) pump. Formic and acetic acid vapours, but also compelled us to use different vapour
standards were supplied by ChemService. sorbents.
Methanol was determined by flame ionization gas In order to reduce the number of sampling devices worn
chromatography using the OSHA 91 method. Standards by workers, we opted for a passive sampling system for the
and instruments were supplied by ChemService and Varian collection of p-xylene, methylacetate and methylbenzoate,
(see above), respectively. and an active sampling system for formic and acetic acids,
Cobalt acetate and manganese acetate were analysed by and methyl alcohol. To sample formic and acetic acids and
ICP-MS, using the OSHA ID125G method after digestion methyl alcohol, the double-adjustable low flow holders was
of the filters in an MDS-2000 microwave oven (CEM, particularly useful since it enabled us to use a single pump
Matthews, NC, USA) with ultra pure concentrated HNO3 to sample formic and acetic acids with two vials.
(6970% J.T. Baker Instra-Analyzed) and dilution to 5 ml With regard to sampling of cobalt and manganese
with deionized water (Nuovo RD 30 Elettracqua, Genova, acetate-based catalyst, on account of the very limited
Italy and Milli-Q, Millipore, Bedford, MA, USA). Calibra- duration of the three loading operations, 3.33, 2.93 and
tion was performed by using working standards of cobalt 2.83 min, respectively, we decided to perform extra
and manganese obtained by serial dilutions of 1000 mg/L samplings during the second shift.
standards (HPS, Charleston, SC, USA). Analyses were It should be remembered that the melting point of p-
carried out by means of mod. Elan 6000 (Sciex-Perki- toluic acid methyl ester is 33 8C and that during our
nElmer, Norwalk, UK) ICP-MS. environmental survey the air temperature never exceeded
I. Iavicoli et al. / Microchemical Journal 79 (2005) 399404 403
200 Ag/m3*
this value (maximum temperature=13 8C), and the temper-
b0.112.5
Mn ature in the control room, where monitored workers was
always below 21 8C. This confirms that the sampling device
4.2
20 Ag/m3 (i.e. fibre filter) used for collecting p-toluic acid methyl ester
was adequate. It should be noted that during other periods of
0.351.4
the year, when air temperature is above the melting point of
1.1
Co
b0.050.29
b0.050.60
b0.050.51
b0.050.50
0.070.33
Acetic acid
0.22
0.30
0.24
0.11
b0.12.7
b0.11.8
b0.11.4
0.10.6
0.43
1.0
0.3
b0.0020.130
b0.0020.026
0.0030.044
b0.0020.013
Airborne organic (mg/mg3) and inorganic (Ag/m3) pollutant levels (mean, range) in the breathing zone of six workers; n= number of measurements
Formic acid
acid dimethyl ester and p-toluic acid methyl ester were close
0.036
0.022
0.008
0.007
0.006
0.22.2
0.36.9
0.43.5
0.33.4
2.3
1.6
1.4
b0.10.7
b0.10.4
b0.10.9
b0.10.3
b0.10.6
0.4
0.1
0.3
b0.11.7
b0.14.3
b0.10.4
b0.10.3
0.10.4
0.2
0.2
0.2
b0.00080.004
b0.00080.006
0.0010.014
0.0010.013
10 mg/m3
0.002
0.002
0.003
acid
b0.00010.013
b0.00010.022
0.0010.030
0.0030.020
p-Toluic acid
methyl ester
0.009
0.008
0.009
0.0010.007
0.0030.020
0.0020.010
0.0070.106
0.009
0.005
0.039
(crystallization)
External worker
workera
acetate, in the absence of a short-term exposure level [2] ATSDR (Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry),
(STEL) and on the basis of the duration of the exposure, we Toxicological Profiles for Xylenes, Public Health Service, Atlanta,
GA, 1995.
can estimate a mean weighted exposure for 8 h of 0.0064 [3] ACGIH, Documentation of the Threshold Limit Values and Biological
and 0.025 Ag/m3 (as a metal), respectively. These values are Exposure Indices, 7th ed., ACGIH, Cincinnati, OH, USA, 2001.
several orders of magnitude below the TLV-TWA estab- [4] ATSDR (Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry),
lished for these two metals. American Family Physician (1993) 163.
[5] NIOSH (National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health),
In conclusion, even if it is difficult to make a hygiene
Criteria Document for Methyl Alcohol, NIOSH, Cincinnati, OH,
assessment of the three substances that do not have an 1976.
established TLV-TWA, all the other substances investigated [6] K. Humperdink, Archiv Fqr Gewerbepathologie Und Gewerbehy-
were well below their respective ACGIH levels. To the best giene 10 (1941) 569.
of our knowledge, this is the first study that investigates [7] V.K. Rowe, S.B. McCollister, in: G.D. Clayton, F.E. Clayton (Eds.),
occupational exposure in workers employed in a plant for Pattys Industrial Hygiene and Toxicology, Toxicology, vol. 2C, John
Wiley & Sons, New York, p. 4528, 3rd rev. ed.
the synthesis of terephtalic acid dimethyl ester This fact [8] Decreto Legislativo 2 febbraio 2002, no. 25. Supplemento ordinario
makes our findings of particular interest in the field of alla Gazzetta Ufficiale, Serie Generale n. 57 dell8 marzo 2002.
prevention and in that of Industrial Hygiene. [9] Council Directive 98/24/EC of 7 April 1998 on the protection of the
health and safety of workers from the risks related to chemical agents
at work (fourteenth individual Directive within the meaning of Article
16(1) of Directive 89/391/EEC) [Official Journal L 131 of
References 05.05.1998].
[10] Ullmanns Encyclopedia of Industrial Chemistry (1954), vol. 5, p. 845.
[1] ACGIH, TLVs and BEIs Based on the Documentation for Threshold Urban and Schwarzenberg, MunichBerlin.
Limit Values for Chemical Substances and Physical Agents: Bio-
logical Exposure Indices, ACGIH, Cincinnati, OH, USA, 2002.